Role of Scotland’s top law officer questioned after ‘bombshell’ over Peter Murrell charges

A picture


Serious doubts have been raised about the dual role of Scotland’s top law officer after it emerged that the first minister was informed of criminal charges against Peter Murrell nearly a year before they were made public.The lord advocate, Dorothy Bain, who acts as Scotland’s chief prosecutor as well as the government’s principal legal adviser in cabinet, has faced calls to resign but the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service maintains she was acting in line with her duties.On Tuesday the office released a list of nearly 30 other cases the lord advocate had updated governments about over the last three decades.It emerged that on 20 March last year, Bain told John Swinney that Murrell, the former chief executive of the SNP, had appeared in court charged with embezzling more than £460,000 from the party.That detail did not emerge publicly until earlier this month.

Opposition parties described the revelation as a “bombshell”.The Scottish Labour deputy leader, Jackie Baillie, said the public “need to know that all criminal cases are handled impartially and without political interference”.The Scottish Conservative leader, Russell Findlay, said the row “surely sounds the death knell for the lord advocate’s dual role”.Senior legal figures are surprised that the Scottish government has not yet published an expert report on splitting the lord advocate’s dual roles, which it received more than a year ago.Concerns have been swirling since the SNP won power in 2007.

The prominent KC and former SNP MP Joanna Cherry proposed a private member’s bill at Westminster in 2024 on separating the lord advocate’s roles, citing “a perception of a conflict of interest” brought to the fore by the investigation into the former first minister Alex Salmond, among others.Legal experts point out that in England and Wales the cabinet role of attorney general and the post of director of public prosecutions are held by two different people.The delay in publishing the review by Malcolm McMillan, a former chief executive of the Scottish Law Commission, has raised suspicions that it may have been blocked or resisted within the government, even though the SNP promised voters before the 2021 Holyrood election that it would launch a consultation on the issue during this parliament.Legal figures say they are unhappy about the lack of transparency and the wasted opportunity to publicly debate the case for splitting the two roles.Angela Constance, the justice secretary, has been asked repeatedly by the Scottish Conservative MSP Liam Kerr about when McMillan’s report and the Scottish government’s response will be published.

She told Kerr in April last year that the report was being peer reviewed, but there is no sign that the Scottish government will launch the promised consultation before the current parliament finishes at the end of March, before May’s Scottish elections.A Scottish government spokesperson said: “While the Scottish government is considering whether any change might be desirable, it considers that the current position is appropriate.”Brian McConnachie, one of Scotland’s leading KCs, said the current situation was “ludicrous”.“I can’t see any logic in [dual roles] and it can only lead to issues like we saw last week,” he said.“It may be there are simple answers but from a legal perspective I do wonder why, if the lord advocate and solicitor general had recused themselves from this case, the lord advocate was then getting involved in telling the government about it? Why is there a need to remind the first minister of this country about the contempt of court laws? Why not remind everybody?”The dean of the faculty of advocates, Roddy Dunlop KC, has defended Bain, saying she had “always evinced the highest level of ethical conduct”.

He said: “Suggestions of corruption on her part are very serious and, on the evidence available, entirely baseless.”
cultureSee all
A picture

Maxi Shield, beloved Australian drag queen and Drag Race Down Under star, dies aged 51

One of Australia’s best-known and loved drag queens, Sydney’s Maxi Shield, has died after being diagnosed with throat cancer, prompting tributes from around the world.Kristopher Elliot, who performed drag under the name Maxi Shield, was 51. Shield was a mainstay of the Sydney drag scene and brought Australian drag to the world as contestant in season one of RuPaul’s Drag Race Down Under.Shield revealed she had throat cancer in September, which forced her to step down from performing in a Kath & Kim show at Edinburgh fringe with a fellow Drag Race Down Under season one alum, Art Simone.Sign up: AU Breaking News emailShe returned to performing at the Oxford Hotel and Palms on the gay strip of Oxford Street in Sydney this month, and was set to host a sold-out Mardi Gras viewing party at the Oxford Hotel on Saturday

A picture

Kenneth Williams and racist attitudes | Brief letters

While appreciating Kenneth Williams’ humour, I felt uneasy that your article (‘He loved showing his bum. Loved it’: the subversive genius of Kenneth Williams, 20 February) didn’t simply state he had racist attitudes. Referring to a dislike of Sid James and people of colour seems to water down unacceptable views.Catherine UtleyLondon When I can’t sleep because my brain is too busy, I have my own method of “cognitive shufflng” (I tried the latest sleep trick – and my husband and I were up all night, 18 February). I choose a subject and try to think of an example for each letter of the alphabet

A picture

Philippe Gaulier obituary

In 1980 the École Philippe Gaulier opened its doors in Paris to help performers find and celebrate their “inner idiot”. The school quickly became the prime destination for clown training, attracting theatre students, actors and curious others from around the world.Philippe, who has died aged 82 following a lung infection, made the concept of le jeu – play – central to his teaching. For him, comedy was not about jokes but about danger: the moment when a performer risks failure or ridicule in pursuit of delight. His clowns were not sentimental innocents but mischievous creatures who loved the audience and longed to be loved in return

A picture

‘Musicians drank too much and slept on my barn floor’: Andrew Bird on making cult album The Mysterious Production of Eggs

We had a family farm three hours west of Chicago, and when I was scoping out potential studio spaces I remembered some barns where my brother and I used to make forts out of hay bales when we were little. One was in rough shape and had racoons living in it, but I got a local carpenter to do the skilled jobs and I did the mundane stuff such as boards for the ceiling. Then I just moved in, but I hadn’t realised how isolating it would be. It was February and snowing and none of my friends had cars. I’d go for two weeks at a time without speaking to anyone

A picture

Is the UK’s golden era of free museum entry coming to an end?

For a quarter of a century, visitors to the UK’s national museums and galleries have enjoyed universal free entry to see permanent collections.The policy, introduced by the New Labour government in 2001, has been widely credited with improving access to culture and significantly increasing footfall to some of the country’s best-known attractions.But as funding pressures deepen across the sector, and running costs increase, a policy once treated as untouchable is now under renewed scrutiny.The tension was brought into focus this week, when the National Gallery announced it was to make significant cuts in the face of an £8.2m deficit in the coming year, which could mean fewer free exhibitions, reduced international borrowing of artworks and higher ticket prices

A picture

The Guide #231: ​How the ​hunt for the ​next James Bond ​became the ​franchise’s ​best ​marketing ​tool

Callum Turner’s turn as James Bond lasted at most a couple of weeks. No sooner had he been enshrined as frontrunner to succeed Daniel Craig, than he was nudged from the DB5 driver’s seat by the latest heir apparent, Jacob Elordi, installed as the new bookies’ favourite after his smouldering, highly profitable performance in Wuthering Heights. Smarting somewhere in the background is Aaron Taylor-Johnson, who seemed locked in for the job a couple of years ago, enjoying the backing of former 007s Pierce Brosnan and George Lazenby, but now seems to have fallen out of favour. And don’t forget the succession of other dead cert Bonds now banished to the back of the odds market: the long-rumoured likes of Tom Hardy and Idris Elba (both now likely to have aged out of the role); Theo James; James Norton; Josh O’Connor; Harris Dickinson; Bridgerton’s Rége-Jean Page; and approximately 5,000 other predominately British actors who have enjoyed box office success/led a successful TV drama/look good in a tuxedo.On and on the hunt goes