‘Privatisation premium’: billions from UK energy bills paid to shareholders
A quarter of the average UK energy bill was funding corporate profits last year, according to analysis that reveals the hidden cost of privatising some of the UK’s key industries.The study – part of a wider Who Owns Britain project by the Common Wealth thinktank – found that a sum equal to 24.2% of the average energy bill went to the pre-tax profits of the major electricity generators, networks and household suppliers in 2024.In addition, the analysis reveals the scale of wealth extracted from bill payers since the privatisation of Britain’s energy system.It found that shareholders of Britain’s privatised energy companies have taken at least £70.
7bn in dividend payouts between 2010 and 2025, rather than reinvesting that money or reducing bills.Mathew Lawrence, director of Common Wealth, said the public was paying a high price for the “privatisation premium”.“They are lumped with higher energy bills that fund billions of pounds of shareholder payouts.That money should be invested to build homegrown clean power and help reduce costs.”The analysis found that £416 of the average bill of £1,719 was taken as pre-tax profits by the major electricity generators, networks and household suppliers last year.
It also calculated that the energy networks that distribute gas and electricity to the UK’s homes and businesses had a profit margin of 55% between 2020 and 24, compared with a FTSE 350 average of 14%.Chris Hayes, the Common Wealth chief economist, said the UK’s energy system was unfit for the challenges the country faced amid an escalating climate emergency and cost of living crisis.“Networks running natural monopolies have systematically underinvested in maintenance and expansion.A splintered retail sector has allowed generators to capture windfall profits.Meanwhile, our clean energy investment regime has been blown apart by the last few years of economic uncertainty.
Public investment and vertical reintegration are desperately needed to overcome these challenges.”The study calculates that in the era of public ownership, investment in the energy system was twice as high relative to GDP as under the privatised era, helping deliver what the report describes as a period of “innovation and ambition, when Britain led the world in new nuclear power, rapidly rolled out the modernised ‘Supergrid’ and built the world’s first ocean-receiving LNG terminal at Canvey Island”.The privatisation of the energy sector was a key plank of the Tory government’s broader policy of reducing state involvement in the economy during the 1980s and 1990s.Supporters argued it increased efficiency, improved choice and attracted private investment – therefore reducing the burden on the state.However, the Common Wealth report found that investment and innovation have stalled, bills have gone up and tens of billions of pounds have been taken from hard-pressed consumers and given to shareholders and corporations.
Sandy Hager, from the University of London, said energy was not a luxury but “the lifeblood of our economy and daily lives”.“Households face soaring bills, over a quarter of which now goes to company profits, while investment has withered.If we’re serious about energy security and decarbonisation, the model is indefensible.We need an energy system organised around the public good, not shareholder dividends, which means bringing our networks and generation into public hands.”The analysis found that the nine largest electricity generators that account for two-thirds of total UK electricity generation, and the energy networks which transport electricity and gas from generators to homes and businesses, made £17.
8bn in operating profits in 2023 – £10.4bn for generation; £7.4bn for networks.The analysis found that much of this profit was going to servicing company debt and shareholder payments rather than investment.In 2023, the last fully reported financial year for the companies analysed, they spent a total of £8.
02bn on dividends, buybacks, and interest payments, of which £3.8bn came from the generation companies and £4.2bn came from the networks.This amounted to 9% of the typical 2023 energy bill.The report argues that money from bills – which leaks out of the energy system as dividends and expensive debt servicing – should be reinvested to build clean and affordable homegrown power.
A spokesperson for the energy regulator, Ofgem, said it regulated the energy market to “ensure that any costs passed on to consumers are fair and accurate, and that the sector isn’t making excessive profits”.They added: “We also work hard to bear down on costs while attracting the investment needed to upgrade the system and move away from volatile international markets that drive the fluctuations in energy bills we’ve seen in recent years.”They said Ofgem had collected almost £500m “in payments from energy companies for not meeting our rules”.Lawrence Slade, the CEO of ENA, which represents the UK’s electricity network operators, said: “The £100bn of private investment made by network operators into the future of the UK’s energy grid to deliver the government’s clean power 2030 targets comes with regulated returns of 5% per year.This investment ensures the UK has the clean, secure and affordable energy it requires in the years ahead, money that UK taxpayers would otherwise need to find, whilst also maintaining one of the most safe, stable and resilient energy grids anywhere.
“Cherrypicking figures from annual accounts of major long-term UK infrastructure spending risks giving a misleading picture of investment that is essential to the UK’s clean energy future,”In the UK, domestic prices were among the highest in Europe in the first half of 2024 and industrial users face some of the highest electricity prices in the world,Average household energy bills are now 63% higher than before the energy crisis,A recent YouGov survey found 71% of the electorate backed public ownership of energy companies,There are signs that the political consensus around privatisation is breaking down.
The Labour government has established the publicly owned GB Energy and has completed the renationalisation of the grid, with the creation of the National Energy System Operator.The new Green party leadership and the new Your party vehicle have both made public ownership of energy central to their agendas, and even rightwing Reform UK has called for the renationalisation of privatised utilities like water.Mathew Lawrence said support for publicly owned power was “not about nostalgia”.“It is a proven and effective tool – from our own past and in comparator economies today – to deliver a more affordable and effective clean energy future.As the consensus on the status quo fragments, just like in the past, whoever seizes the mantle of change will reap the rewards.
”Sophie Flinders, senior data analyst at Common Wealth, said the politics of energy was at “an inflection point”.“Attacks on the cost of the transition are increasing,” she said.“But higher bills are the result of private economic power not renewable power.The best response is to deliver new era of public power based on more coherent, certain, and cost-effective investment.The political prize is great: reducing a key driver of the cost of living crisis, delivering more homegrown clean power, and renewing consent for an ambitious transition.
”
Tell us about the worst meal you have cooked
From an overambitious birthday cake to an adventurous would-be feast that ended up in the dustbin, we would like to hear about the worst meal you’ve ever cooked.We will feature a selection in an article of humorous (and non-lethal) anecdotes of culinary disaster for G2.You can tell us about the worst meal you've cooked by filling in the form below.Please include as much detail as possible.Please note, the maximum file size is 5
Thomasina Miers’ recipes for cod with courgettes, green olives and lemon, and a blackberry and almond slice
There is something so simple but so delicious about a parcel of fish. Like unwrapping an edible present, the smell hits you before anything else, which in this case is fennel, thyme and lemon. It is a delicate way to cook fish, so the sauce needs to have some character, and basil, olives and lemon with a slick of olive oil make a beautiful, late-summer seasoning. Round off the feast with a blackberry and crisp almond pastry slice that tastes all the better if you forage your own fruit.The sharp acidity of the lemon and olive herb salsa is stunning with the gently baked fish
Rukmini Iyer’s quick and easy recipe for bibimbap with miso-peanut sauce | Quick & easy
I love bibimbap, the Korean rice bowls – they’re a great way to use up bits and pieces in the fridge; arrange them beautifully on a bowl of rice and top with an egg and Korean chilli sauce. I don’t always have gochujang at home, so came up with this addictive miso-peanut chilli sauce instead. Roast the vegetables in some sesame oil in a tray, pop the rice in the microwave, boil or fry an egg, and that’s dinner sorted.Any leftovers are wonderful the next day – just heat through until piping hot.Prep 15 min Cook 30 min Serves 41 aubergine, trimmed and cut into 1
Chetna Makan’s recipes for corn on the cob curry and coriander mint chutney butter corn
Inspired by a corn curry from Maharashtra, today’s recipe has the perfect umami flavour: a bit of heat from the chillies, some gentle sweetness from the sugar and lots of sourness from the lime juice, along with the creamy coconut milk and juicy corn. The sharpness of a fresh, herby chutney with salty butter, meanwhile, makes the perfect topping for barbecued corn on the cob. I often cook the corn straight on the hob, which is a bit tricky, but it’s how we did it when I was growing up in India.Prep 10 min Cook 45 min Serves 4-6For the curry4 corn cobs, cut in half widthways2-3 tbsp peanut oil, or sunflower oil 1 tsp cumin seeds 4 garlic cloves, peeled and finely chopped20 curry leaves 400ml coconut milk 1 tsp saltFor the curry paste40g fresh coriander, leaves and stalks10g fresh mint, leaves only6 garlic cloves, peeled2½cm piece fresh ginger, peeled 4 green chillies, stalks discarded, flesh roughly chopped (remove the pith and seeds if you prefer less heat) 1 medium-sized red onion, peeled and roughly chopped1 tsp cumin seeds 1 tsp black pepper 2 tsp soft brown sugar ½ tsp ground turmeric 4 tbsp lime juicePut the corn pieces in a pan, cover with water and bring to a boil. Cook for 10 minutes, then drain
How to make fried tofu with chilli crisp – recipe | Felicity Cloake's Masterclass
The New York Times once described raw tofu as having “the texture and disposition of a particularly upbeat sponge” – sauteeing, the writer decreed, was the only way to render the stuff “acceptable”. As it happens, I often eat the creamy, wobbly silken variety straight from the packet, but I wouldn’t disagree: you don’t have to be vegetarian to enjoy a hot, crisp nugget of deep-fried beancurd.Prep 15 min Cook 15 min Serves 2About 280g firm or extra-firm tofu – if using silken, skip step 3Salt and black pepper 4 tbsp cornflour, or other starch (optional)Neutral oil, for deep-frying For the chilli crisp (if making)1½ tbsp Sichuan peppercorns 3-4 tbsp gochuharu, or other chilli flakes to taste 30g roasted salted peanuts, or soybeans, roughly chopped1 tbsp fermented black beans, finely chopped (optional)250ml neutral oil1 long shallot, or 2 round ones, peeled and thinly sliced 6 garlic cloves, peeled and thinly sliced1 tsp sugar (optional)¼ tsp MSG powder (optional)Firm or extra-firm tofu is the best choice for frying – silken will be creamy inside, and pressed tofu chewier and more meaty. For the neatest results, cut into bite-sized nuggets about 3cm x 2cm. If you value crunch over appearance, break it into bite-sized pieces instead; the rougher edges will crisp up better than perfectly flat surfaces
Tillingham, Peasmarsh, East Sussex: ‘Not much cooking was going on’ – restaurant review
The restaurant of this farm in breathtakingly beautiful countryside is missing its potentialTillingham is essentially a natural biodynamic wine production business working over 70 acres of gently rolling countryside, near Rye and the Romney Marshes in East Sussex. If only their main trouble was making bottles of chardonnay and pinot blanc, or selling pretty Tillingham tea towels at £36 a pop. But no, Tillingham has (quite literally) many other plates to juggle: it has a fancy restaurant and a vast barn from which they serve pizza, too.There’s also the option to stay over in bell tents, no less, if posh hen weekends or corporate bonding sessions are required. Or in bricks-and-mortar rooms with actual plumbing, if the tent’s compost toilet is not for you
Are the stars finally aligning for the ‘new golden age’ of nuclear? | Nils Pratley
Federal Reserve cuts interest rates by a quarter point, for first time in nearly a year – as it happened
What is new in UK-US tech deal and what will it mean for the British economy?
UK is going to be ‘AI superpower’, says Nvidia boss as he invests £500m
Millions tune in to athletics broadcasts as Gout Gout attracts huge viewing numbers
Eddie Hearn threatens to sue Chris Eubank Jr over ‘sabotage’ claim before Conor Benn rematch