No 10 refuses to say if ethics adviser saw proof Reeves’s rental breach was ‘inadvertent’
Downing Street has refused to say whether Keir Starmer’s adviser on ministerial conduct has seen any evidence to support Rachel Reeves’s claim she made an “inadvertent” mistake in failing to get a licence to rent out her south London home.As pressure mounted on the chancellor, despite the prime minister saying an apology should end the matter, No 10 also declined to say whether Reeves contravened the ministerial code or had broken the law in breaching Southwark council rules.In an exchange of letters with Starmer late on Wednesday, Reeves said that when she rented out the house she had not been told by the lettings agency that homes in that area needed a £945 licence before they were rented out.In his reply, Starmer said that having consulted his independent adviser on ministerial interests, Laurie Magnus, he was satisfied the breach was “inadvertent” and that given her prompt action once she knew about the licence, an apology was sufficient.Pressed repeatedly at a media briefing whether Magnus had seen any evidence to back up Reeves’s case or had simply taken the chancellor at her word, a Downing Street spokesperson refused to say, noting that Magnus’s advice was always confidential.
“The chancellor rightly acted with urgency on this matter,” he said.“She has set out that it was an inadvertent mistake, and as soon as it was brought to her attention, took immediate action, applying for the licence and speaking to the independent adviser on ministerial standards.“She made the prime minister aware of this issue at the earliest opportunity, at which point he immediately sought advice from the independent adviser, who has advised that in the light of the chancellor’s prompt action to rectify the position, including her apology, that further investigation is not necessary.The ministerial code makes clear that in certain circumstances, an apology is a sufficient resolution.”Asked again what evidence Magnus had seen, the spokesperson repeated the same lines several more times.
Asked by one reporter whether Magnus had “done a stitch-up with the prime minister very quickly to avoid upsetting the markets”, the spokesperson replied: “I don’t accept the framing of that at all,” adding that Magnus’s role was an independent one,The spokesperson declined to say, when questioned, whether Reeves’s actions were considered a breach of the ministerial code, or if she might have broken the law,He did indicate, however, that if Reeves was found to have broken the law she would lose her job,Asked if Starmer stood by his argument following Boris Johnson’s fine for breaching Covid rules that “lawbreakers cannot be lawmakers”, he said: “Yes,”Reeves’s error is all the more uncomfortable given that 10 days ago she tweeted praise for Leeds council, where she has her constituency, for extending its selective landlord licensing policy, the same policy she fell foul of in Southwark.
Speaking earlier on Thursday, the Conservative leader, Kemi Badenoch, said it was up to Reeves to have been on top of the necessary paperwork and that she must be sacked if she had broken any laws.“I think that the more I hear about the story, the more questions there are to answer,” the Conservative leader told reporters after a speech on London’s South Bank.The rules about the licence originated in a 2004 law brought in by Labour, Badenoch said, adding that Reeves had “tweeted about how it should be extended, and yet she wasn’t following it herself”.Badenoch said: “It’s all very well blaming someone else – the lettings agent didn’t do this, or that she is the chancellor.She needs to be on top of her paperwork.
She was aware of this legislation.I think there should be an investigation.“But the bottom line is that Keir Starmer said again and again, that lawbreakers shouldn’t be lawmakers.So if she’s broken the law, then he should apply his own rules to her.”Reeves admitted having rented out her home after moving into Downing Street following the election without the licence required by Southwark after it was first disclosed by the Daily Mail.
A spokesperson said the chancellor had used a lettings agency to manage the process, and that while she should have been aware of the obligation to buy the licence, she had not been advised that she needed one.“She had not been made aware of the licensing requirement, but as soon as it was brought to her attention she took immediate action and has applied for the licence,” Reeves’s spokesperson said.The four-bedroom detached house had been advertised for rent at £3,200 a month last year, the Daily Mail and the BBC reported, and Reeves has noted rental income on her record of parliamentary interests since September 2024.The controversy could be a gift to Badenoch and other opposition politicians, who were already targeting Reeves before next month’s budget.Badenoch spoke to reporters in London, where she and the shadow chancellor, Mel Stride, said Reeves should be sacked if she tried to raise taxes at the budget, as is being considered.
Thunder guard Nikola Topic, 20, undergoing treatment for testicular cancer
Oklahoma City Thunder say their 2024 first-round draft pick, Nikola Topic, is undergoing chemotherapy to treat testicular cancer.Thunder’s general manager, Sam Presti, said on Thursday that doctors are “extremely positive” about Topic’s outlook.“Our only expectations for him are to focus on this,” Presti said. “This is his most important priority. He’ll be back playing basketball when he’s able to, but we’re not putting any time length or expectations on that obviously
Breeders’ Cup 2025: all-conquering O’Brien arrives with sights on new record
Aidan O’Brien’s gallop towards an extension of his record for Group One wins in a season has slowed a little in recent weeks, but there was still a shield-beating sense of theatre about the scene as his team for the 2025 Breeders’ Cup meeting at Del Mar this weekend made its way to the track for morning exercise on Wednesday.Unlike 2024, when City Of Troy was being aimed at the Classic, there is no obvious headliner in the O’Brien lineup, but plenty of the horses trotting past in a well-ordered single file have banked at least one Group One already this season and four are expected to set off as favourite.Minnie Hauk, the Arc runner-up and a three-time Group One winner over the summer, heads the market for the Turf on Saturday, while Gstaad (Juvenile Turf), Precise (Juvenile Fillies’ Turf) and True Love (Juvenile Turf Sprint) are also all likely favourites for the three turf events on Friday’s card for juveniles. Other runners from the yard at single-figure odds include The Lion In Winter (Mile) and Havana Anna (Juvenile Turf Sprint), and the Ballydoyle squadron is, as so often, at the heart of the European challenge at the meeting.O’Brien needs a single success this weekend to take sole control of the record for Breeders’ Cup with 21, one more than the late D Wayne Lukas, who died in June
England’s Ashes debacle and review was meant to change everything. Did it? | Raf Nicholson
England have been knocked out of a World Cup after losing a match they were expected to win, thanks to a one-off innings which nobody saw coming. Sound familiar? That’s because it describes two events involving England which took place almost exactly a year apart: on Wednesday, their 50-over semi-final exit at the hands of South Africa; a year ago, their loss in a must-win group stage match against West Indies in the 20-over version.In the interim, a 16-0 Ashes debacle and a post-series review which was meant to change everything. Did it? Time to delve a little more deeply into those two World Cup exits. In 2024, England fell to pieces, dropped five catches, and allowed a bish-bash-bosh innings from Qiana Joseph to win the day
England at risk of 2027 World Cup embarrassment and in need of ODI upswing
Harry Brook has admitted that he is flummoxed by England’s inability to get consistent results in recent one-day internationals, saying that some of the supposedly stellar talents in his squad – which includes up to seven batters he insists “would get into any team in the world” – “just haven’t performed well enough”.“It is disappointing, isn’t it?” England’s white-ball captain said, as he looked ahead to the third and inal fixture in an already-lost series against New Zealand. “You go round every single player there and you think: ‘Bloody hell, there isn’t many teams that they don’t get into in the world.’ It’s disappointing we haven’t performed as well as we could. Sometimes you’ve got to hold your hand up and say they’ve been the better team
Trey Lance has cost $7m per start. Is there any hope of reclaiming a once hyped prospect?
Quarterbacks such as Sam Darnold and Baker Mayfield have gone from busts to MVP candidates. The Chargers backup is in the ideal place to make a similar journeyThe development path for young NFL quarterbacks is brutal. They get lobbed in at the deep end as franchises try to figure out if their investment was worth it, before being tossed overboard if things go wrong. The league eats its young. The path from potential franchise starter to career backup – or out of the league – has never been shorter
‘Bats out for Benny’: teenager killed by cricket ball honoured amid debate over neck guards
Australia’s cricket community have begun to put their bats out in a gesture to remember teenage cricketer Ben Austin after he was killed by a ball hitting his neck in a practice session, in an incident in Melbourne on Tuesday described as similar to the death of former Test player Phillip Hughes in 2014.The 17-year-old was wearing a helmet but not a neck guard, and while the incident is likely to trigger calls to make such protection mandatory at the community level – as it already is among elite players – cricket officials said the priority must be around supporting Austin’s family and the boy who threw the ball with a training tool known as a sidearm or “wanger”.Austin’s cricket club, Ferntree Gully, posted on Facebook on Thursday calling on people to “put your bats out for Benny”, replicating the gesture that followed Hughes’ death. Dozens of other posts under the hashtag #batsoutforben have followed, highlighting the impact the incident has had on Australia’s cricket community.Cricket Victoria’s chief executive, Nick Cummins, was emotional in addressing media on Thursday
Almost all children in 73 areas of England live in low-income households
UK woman who booked Oslo flight but did not fly loses child benefit ‘because she emigrated’
Only full abolition of two-child benefit cap will substantially cut poverty, thinktank says
Patients go to court to stop embryos being destroyed after admin error
Robert Wilkinson obituary
Councils in England face clampdown on four-day working weeks