Patients go to court to stop embryos being destroyed after admin error
A group of at least 15 fertility patients are taking legal action to prevent their frozen embryos being destroyed as a result of administrative errors that could deny them a chance to have children.The group, which includes people with cancer and fertility problems, froze gametes or embryos to improve their chances of conceiving later on, but were informed by their clinics that owing to administrative errors they had not renewed their consent in time and would not be able to access their embryos or extend their storage without a court order.In some cases, people only learned of the errors when they approached the clinic about their plans to have a child and for some it is their only hope of conceiving naturally.In other cases, clinics approached couples after internal audit processes and apologised for their errors but notified them that they could only extend storage through a court order.The errors relate to two changes in law.
One took place in 2022 and extended the maximum storage period for embryos and gametes (eggs and sperm) from 10 years to 55 years for personal use, provided the individual gives consent every 10 years, and the other was a temporary two-year extension granted during the coronavirus pandemic in 2020,In some cases, the clinics failed to contact clients about the need to fill in consent forms to extend storage, held the wrong expiry dates or medical details on file, or did not follow up on reminders,In others, patients missed emails because they said the urgency of the subject matter wasn’t clear enough,In several cases clinics continued to accept annual storage payments, leaving patients feeling that everything was in order,James Lawford Davies, a partner at LDMH Partners representing the group, said although the fertility law change had been “positive and well intentioned”, in practice “clinics and patients have found the new rules difficult to understand and apply”.
“The cases before the court have arisen as a result of errors, oversights and misunderstandings surrounding the new rules.The applications are hugely significant for all the patients involved and, for many, this represents their only chance of having their own genetic child.“We hope that, going forward, the guidance and process for storage consents can be clarified and simplified for patients and clinics alike,” he said.Appearing in the high court this week, Emma Sutton KC, representing the applicants, described how they felt “emotional” and “distressed” since they “would have given their consent had the process been put into effect in the way it should have”.Their frustrations had been exacerbated by waiting “in limbo” for nearly a year, with “time of the essence” for some couples because of age or health problems, she added.
She argued that destroying the embryos would be in conflict with article 8 of the Human Rights Act, which gives people the right to a family life uninterrupted by the state, and that permitting them to extend storage “would not undermine a fundamental objective of the statutory scheme – namely the requirement for consent”.Barristers representing the UK’s fertility regulator, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA), and the Department for Health and Social Care outlined their support for considering the applications on a case-by-case basis, and proposed that in the cases where clinics had failed to notify people of the need to extend consent, the patients be given a six-month window in which to now arrange consent.Jeremy Hyam KC for the Department of Health and Social Care expressed concern that UK fertility law’s emphasis on effective consent could be undermined if there were to be a “free for all”, which could lead to some clinics adopting a “default position of indefinite storage” for fear of being held liable for any miscommunication.He disagreed that the cases in which people had been notified but it had been the patient’s error – for example failing to open emails, update addresses or log into online portals – should be granted the opportunity to extend consent.Ravi Mehta, for the HFEA, noted the regulator’s “sympathy” for the patients involved, and commended the clinics for their “candour” and willingness to admit their mistakes.
He added that the UK’s fertility law made the clinic, not the patient, responsible for securing consent.“[The patient’s] wishes now are sufficient – no one is asking for open-ended relief, that takes consent now as opening the door to everything,” he said.Mrs Justice Morgan, who heard the case, will provide a written judgment in the coming months.
Ofcom criticises O2 for going ‘against the spirit’ of new pricing rules
The UK telecoms regulator has criticised O2 for raising prices for millions of mobile phone customers by more than they were originally told.In an unusual intervention, Ofcom said it was “disappointed” by the phone network’s decision, which “goes against the spirit of our rules”.Up to 15 million O2 customers will see their monthly bills rise by more than they were told when they signed up to their contracts, after the company announced an additional 70p per month increase to its annual price rises from April 2026.The originally stated £1.80 monthly rise will now be almost 40% higher at £2
FTSE 100 winning streak ends as WPP shares hit lowest level since 1998; ECB holds rates at 2% - as it happened
Time to recap.Shares in advertising group WPP fell to their lowest level since 1998, after the FTSE 100 group slashed its revenue guidance for the year and its new chief executive Cindy Rose said its recent performance has been “unacceptable”.The former Microsoft executive has announced a review of the business, saying she was taking action to address the “unacceptable” performance at the company, which has struggled to stem a growing exodus of clients and compete with the AI and data capabilities of its rivals.Over in Frankfurt, the European Central Bank kept interest rates on hold on Thursday for the third meeting in a row despite concerns that a modest economic recovery across the eurozone would fuel inflation.The ECB kept its key deposit rate at 2% despite annual price growth rising to 2
Apple reports record iPhone sales as new lineup reignites worldwide demand
Apple reported its first quarterly earnings since the release of its new lineup of iPhones on Thursday, beating Wall Street analysts’ expectations. The company showed steady financial growth and a strong bottom line despite slow progress on artificial intelligence. The report comes just days after the company hit a $4tn market value for the first time.“Today, Apple is very proud to report a September quarter revenue record of $102.5 billion, including a September quarter revenue record for iPhone and an all-time revenue record for Services,” Apple’s CEO, Tim Cook, said in a statement
Amazon reports strongest cloud growth since 2022 after major outage
Amazon has made its first financial disclosures since the disastrous outage suffered by its cloud computing division that brought everything from smart beds to banks offline.In spite of the global outage, Amazon Web Services has continued to grow, and this quarter reported a 20% increase in revenue year over year. Wall Street estimated that AWS would bring in $32.42bn in net sales in the third quarter, with the company reporting actual revenue of $33bn.“AWS is growing at a pace we haven’t seen since 2022,” CEO Andy Jassy said in a statement accompanying the earnings report
Borthwick hopes England can emulate Bazball mentality for autumn series
England’s rugby players are seeking to emulate the Bazball ethos of their cricketing counterparts and strike a pre-emptive blow for the nation in the run-up to the forthcoming Ashes series. Steve Borthwick and members of his coaching staff have had discussions with Brendon McCullum and want their team to make a fast and furious start against Australia in the Quilter Nations Series on Saturday.There is a collective desire within the England camp to make a statement over the coming month and Borthwick and his defence coach, Richard Wigglesworth, have been picking McCullum’s brain on the best ways to encourage a positive mindset. “We met Brendon McCullum and his coaching staff a few weeks ago,” said Wigglesworth. “We had a sit down and a coffee in Manchester which was very enjoyable
Enhanced Games are dangerous and must be stopped, says Wada head
The head of the World Anti-Doping Agency (Wada) has called on the body’s American counterparts to act to stop the Enhanced Games, describing the new event – which allows athletes to take performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs) in competition – as “dangerous” and “irresponsible”.Witold Banka said the world’s anti-doping regimes had to be “very united” in their opposition to the Enhanced Games and said the United States Anti-Doping Agency (Usada) had a responsibility to push against it. Banka went on to criticise the anti-doping regime in the US, at a time when the government there has withheld crucial funding from Wada’s operations.“Sometimes we don’t know what to say about this ridiculous idea, because from the ethical point of view, from the moral point of view, how is it possible that people come to agree to compete, taking all these prohibited substances?” Banka said. “It’s completely against everything that we are doing
Thunder guard Nikola Topic, 20, undergoing treatment for testicular cancer
Breeders’ Cup 2025: all-conquering O’Brien arrives with sights on new record
England’s Ashes debacle and review was meant to change everything. Did it? | Raf Nicholson
England at risk of 2027 World Cup embarrassment and in need of ODI upswing
Trey Lance has cost $7m per start. Is there any hope of reclaiming a once hyped prospect?
‘Bats out for Benny’: teenager killed by cricket ball honoured amid debate over neck guards