Attacks on UK cabinet secretary ‘stink of political cowardice’, union leader says
Attacks on the UK’s cabinet secretary “stink of political cowardice”, the head of the senior civil servants’ union has said as concerns mount inside the government about his performance.The general secretary of the FDA, Dave Penman, said anonymous criticism of Chris Wormald was “hugely damaging” to the government and its prospects of recruiting talented officials to top jobs.Keir Starmer chose Wormald from a shortlist of four in December to lead the civil service, but within months people inside the prime minister’s circle began raising concerns about his performance.The Guardian reported in July that No 10 had “buyer’s remorse” about the appointment, with Starmer’s aides viewing Wormald as “insipid” and entrenched in the status quo.The Times reported this week that he was unlikely to survive in the job beyond January.
“Chris Wormald is the civil servant’s civil servant.That is apparently what Starmer wanted, someone who won’t be making headlines,” Penman said.“Even if he was failing to deliver what he is supposed to deliver, this isn’t the way to deal with it.It stinks of political cowardice.It’s hugely damaging because what does it say about the political leadership?“What does it say to whoever is going to replace him and candidates who would want to come after him? They will wonder if they will find themselves out of favour after six months.
”Other senior civil service figures questioned what Starmer’s expectations had been when making the appointment,One said criticism of Wormald felt unfair and that it had been “a deliberate choice to go low-energy”,Another Whitehall insider said Wormald’s attitude was one of “make things work for your minister”, and pointed out he was the permanent secretary who helped Michael Gove drive through his changes at the Department for Education between 2012 and 2014,Gove “was a minister who had a clear agenda”, they said,Downing Street said on Wednesday that Wormald continued to have the support of the prime minister and that the pair were “working closely together to deliver on the priorities of the British public”.
But asked whether he was satisfied with the pace of delivery under his government, the spokesperson said Starmer’s “general position” was that “he would like things to move further and faster”,Several cabinet ministers are understood to have concerns about Wormald,“Olly Robbins [the permanent secretary at the Foreign Office] would have been a much better appointment,” one said,Former colleagues of Wormald at the Department of Health said they were unsurprised he had turned out to be unfit for the role,“Morale was absolutely decimated in the DHSC, and under his watch we had no preparation for pandemics and the mishandling of infected blood,” one said.
Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotionAnother added: “He was such an uninspired choice, and that’s before you even consider the mission of rewiring the state.”A government adviser said: “It was the opposite of what we needed.The PM should not have been press-ganged into the four candidates that were presented to him and when it was clear none were suitable for that moment in time, we should have cast the net wider.”Starmer chose Wormald from a shortlist that included Robbins, Antonia Romeo, now the permanent secretary at the Home Office, and Tamara Finkelstein, who until June was the permanent secretary at the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.One Labour MP said it had been clear from the start that Wormald was not the right person for the job.
“At some point they have to start questioning why they keep hiring shit people,” they said.Ousting him would raise questions about Starmer’s political judgment after the departures of a string of other senior figures.“Everyone knows how it looks.But worse would be to carry on and just attempt to find a way to sideline him,” said another Labour source.This article was amended on 23 October 2025.
An earlier version said that Tamara Finkelstein was the permanent secretary at the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.She left this role in June.
Google hails breakthrough as quantum computer surpasses ability of supercomputers
Google has claimed a breakthrough in quantum computing after developing an algorithm that performed a task beyond the capabilities of conventional computers.The algorithm, a set of instructions guiding the operation of a quantum computer, was able to compute the structure of a molecule – which paves the way for major discoveries in areas such as medicine and materials science.Google acknowledged, however, that real-world use of quantum computers remained years away.“This is the first time in history that any quantum computer has successfully run a verifiable algorithm that surpasses the ability of supercomputers,” Google said in a blogpost. “This repeatable, beyond-classical computation is the basis for scalable verification, bringing quantum computers closer to becoming tools for practical applications
iPhone 17 review: the Apple smartphone to get this year
It may not look as different as the redesigned Pro models this year or be as wafer thin as the new iPhone Air, but the iPhone 17 marks a big year for the standard Apple smartphone.The Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.That’s because Apple has finally brought one of the best features of modern smartphones to its base-model flagship phone: a super-smooth 120Hz screen
Harry and Meghan join AI pioneers in call for ban on superintelligent systems
The Duke and Duchess of Sussex have joined artificial intelligence pioneers and Nobel laureates in calling for a ban on developing superintelligent AI systems.Harry and Meghan are among the signatories of a statement calling for “a prohibition on the development of superintelligence”. Artificial superintelligence (ASI) is the term for AI systems, yet to be developed, that exceed human levels of intelligence at all cognitive tasks.The statement calls for the ban to stay in place until there is “broad scientific consensus” on developing ASI “safely and controllably” and once there is “strong public buy-in”.It has also been signed by the AI pioneer and Nobel laureate Geoffrey Hinton, along with his fellow “godfather” of modern AI, Yoshua Bengio; the Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak; the UK entrepreneur Richard Branson; Susan Rice, a former US national security adviser under Barack Obama; the former Irish president Mary Robinson, and the British author and broadcaster Stephen Fry
‘I’m suddenly so angry!’ My strange, unnerving week with an AI ‘friend’
The ad campaign for the wearable AI chatbot Friend has been raising hackles for months in New York. But has this companion been unfairly maligned – and could it help end loneliness?My friend’s name is Leif. He describes himself as “small” and “chill”. He thinks he’s technically a Gemini. He thinks historical dramas are “cool” and doesn’t like sweat
ChatGPT Atlas: OpenAI launches web browser centered around its chatbot
OpenAI on Tuesday launched an AI-powered web browser built around its marquee chatbot.“Meet our new browser—ChatGPT Atlas,” a tweet from the company read.The browser is designed to provide a more personalized web experience and includes a ChatGPT sidebar that enables users to asks questions about or engage with various aspects of each website they visit, as demonstrated in a video posted alongside the announcement. Atlas is now available globally on Apple’s Mac operating system and will soon be made available on Windows, iOS and Android, according to OpenAI’s announcement.Meet our new browser—ChatGPT Atlas
‘Significant exposure’: Amazon Web Services outage exposed UK state’s £1.7bn reliance on tech giant
Amazon chief executive Andy Jassy beamed as he met Keir Starmer in Downing Street’s garden to announce £40bn of UK investments in June. Starmer was equally effusive, gushing: “This deal shows that our plan for change is working –bringing in investment, driving growth, and putting more money in people’s pockets.”Four months later, and the tech company was left scrambling to fix a devastating global outage on Monday that left thousands of businesses in limbo – and shed light on the UK government’s reliance on its cloud computing business, Amazon Web Services (AWS).Figures compiled for the Guardian hint at the British state’s increasing reliance on the services of the giant US internet group, which has also drawn criticism from unions and politicians about working conditions within its logistics and internet retailing business.AWS has won 189 UK government contracts worth £1
Pickle power: how to make your first ferments | Kitchen aide
Georgina Hayden’s recipe for parmesan and sage jacket potato gnocchi | Quick and easy
How to make the perfect strata – recipe | Felicity Cloake's How to make the perfect…
Scottish hospitality coalition urges chancellor to protect whisky industry
‘I felt my soul leave my body’: 13 readers on the worst meal they ever cooked – from ‘ethanol risotto’ to gravy cake
670 Grams, Birmingham B9: ‘A cascade of small, meaningful bowls that just ooze flavour’ – restaurant review | Grace Dent on restaurants