Government made ‘every effort’ to support China spying trial, says minister
The government made “every effort” to support the trial of two men accused of spying for China, a minister has said, as he accused the Tories of claiming the case was deliberately abandoned “without a shred of evidence”.Dan Jarvis, the security minister, issued a robust defence of Jonathan Powell in the Commons after reports that Keir Starmer’s national security adviser played a role in the collapse of the case.His intervention prolongs an extraordinary blame game between ministers and prosecutors over the abandonment of charges against two men, including a former parliamentary researcher, who were accused of spying for Beijing.Charges were dropped against Christopher Cash and Christopher Berry, who had always maintained their innocence, last month after the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) said it could no longer meet the evidential threshold needed to proceed.Jarvis said that since the charges against Cash and Berry were brought in April 2024, the deputy national security adviser, Matthew Collins, provided three witness statements to support the trial in December 2023, February 2025 and July 2025.
“All of the evidence provided by the deputy NSA was based on the law at the time of the offence and the policy position of the Conservatives at the time of the offence,” he told MPs.“Every effort was made to provide evidence in support of this case within these constraints.”But he said the CPS decided to pull the charges because it was “hamstrung by antiquated legislation that had not been updated by the Conservative government despite the evolving nature of the state threats that we face”.Jarvis told the Commons that “suggestions that the government concealed evidence, withdrew witnesses or restricted the ability of witnesses to draw on particular bits of evidence are all untrue”.Kemi Badenoch, the Conservative leader, said the government’s explanation “will not wash” and that it “looks like a deliberate decision to collapse the case and curry favour with the regime in China”.
She argued that the Conservatives repeatedly described China as a threat when they were in government and suggested Powell had a hand in the developments because he “has a very close relationship with China”.The Liberal Democrats called on Labour to publish correspondence between Collins and the CPS, saying the “buck for this fiasco ultimately stops with the prime minister”.Jarvis said that Powell “was not involved in any decisions about the substance of the evidence” and “made no decisions about the contents of any evidence”, and denied reports that Powell told a meeting of senior officials in September that the government would not be able to describe China as a threat in its evidence.“We fully recognise that China poses a series of threats to UK national security, yet we must also be alive to the fact that China does present us with opportunities,” Jarvis said.“If we were to follow the approach of the party opposite – to ignore China and to refuse to engage with China – that is what would undermine our national security.
”Stephen Parkinson, the director of public prosecutions and head of the CPS, wrote to MPs last week saying that “efforts were made over many months” to obtain a witness statement from the government stating that China posed a “threat to the national security of the UK”,He said that without it the case “could not succeed”,There have been accusations that the government deliberately declined to provide this evidence for fear of damaging trade relations with China, and claims that Powell was behind the decision,Downing Street insisted on Monday it was “entirely false” to suggest that the government was responsible for the collapse of the trial,The prime minister’s spokesperson said the “decision to drop the case was entirely a matter for the CPS” and that there had been “no role for any member of this government, no minister or special adviser” in making it.
Ministers appeared to harden their line towards China on Monday, with Jarvis, the Foreign Office minister Hamish Falconer and the Cabinet Office spokesperson in the Lords Ruth Anderson all saying the country posed a series of national security threats to the UK including through cyber-attacks and the transnational repression of Hongkongers.The Conservatives wrote to Parkinson on Monday night to ask whether the prosecution could be restarted if ministers now provided the evidence requested.Lindsay Hoyle, the Commons speaker, told MPs he was “angry and disappointed” that parliament was not receiving robust enough protection against foreign espionage.New MI5 guidance has been published warning politicians in the UK that they are “a target of long-term strategic foreign interference and espionage from elements of the Russian, Chinese and Iranian states”.The intelligence service warned that foreign agents operated by posing as diplomats, journalists, academics and lobbyists and employed techniques including blackmail and financial donations.
Labour MPs call on Rachel Reeves to scrap council tax
More than a dozen Labour MPs have written to Rachel Reeves calling on her to scrap council tax, as the chancellor faces mounting pressure to overhaul Great Britain’s property taxes in next month’s budget.Thirteen MPs, mainly from seats in northern England, wrote to Reeves last month asking her to abolish the tax and replace it with another system that better accounts for the steep rise in house prices in London and the south-east over the last 35 years.The chancellor is looking for ways to close what could be a £30bn shortfall in the public finances, with experts warning that doing so could require a shake-up of the entire tax system.The Labour MPs wrote: “If we are to succeed in our mission to transform Britain and fight back against Reform, we must be bold and embrace new ideas that put more money back into the pockets of working people.“One place we can start is by looking at ways we can abolish the outdated, deeply regressive, and increasingly indefensible council tax system
Muddle over semantics or pressure from China? Collapsed spying case remains baffling
There is a baffling contradiction at the heart of the efforts of Dan Jarvis, the security minister, to explain why the prosecution of two Britons accused of spying for China collapsed last month. The problem, he insisted in front of MPs on Monday, was that “it was not the policy of a Conservative government to classify China as a threat to national security”.Except there is plenty of evidence to suggest that China was recognised as a threat by the previous governments in documents and public statements by ministers and officials. All this makes the failure of the government witness – Matthew Collins, the deputy national security adviser – to set this out in three separate witness statements given to the prosecution even more surprising.The context here is the ongoing fallout from the collapse of the prosecution of Christopher Cash, a parliamentary researcher, who was working for the Conservative MP Alicia Kearns at the time of his arrest, and his friend Christopher Berry, a researcher based in China
Farage criticises ‘disgraceful’ rhetoric after alleged attack on Reform council leader
The Reform UK leader, Nigel Farage, has criticised “disgraceful” rhetoric from the Labour and Green parties after the UK’s youngest council leader was allegedly assaulted.George Finch, 19, the Reform leader of Warwickshire county council,said he was called a “racist” and a “fascist” before being allegedly assaulted on Friday.The alleged attacker “was wound up and sent into battle by the dangerous rhetoric of Labour and the Greens”, Finch told the Daily Mail. He said the attack didn’t cause any lasting injury.Farage said he was “deeply upset” about the incident and “the words used against him echo the prime minister’s disgraceful attack on Reform during Labour conference week and wholly irresponsible comments from the leader of the Green party”
Government made ‘every effort’ to support China spying trial, says minister
The government made “every effort” to support the trial of two men accused of spying for China, a minister has said, as he accused the Tories of claiming the case was deliberately abandoned “without a shred of evidence”.Dan Jarvis, the security minister, issued a robust defence of Jonathan Powell in the Commons after reports that Keir Starmer’s national security adviser played a role in the collapse of the case.His intervention prolongs an extraordinary blame game between ministers and prosecutors over the abandonment of charges against two men, including a former parliamentary researcher, who were accused of spying for Beijing.Charges were dropped against Christopher Cash and Christopher Berry, who had always maintained their innocence, last month after the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) said it could no longer meet the evidential threshold needed to proceed.Jarvis said that since the charges against Cash and Berry were brought in April 2024, the deputy national security adviser, Matthew Collins, provided three witness statements to support the trial in December 2023, February 2025 and July 2025
Badenoch accuses Labour of prioritising economic ties with China over national security – as it happened
At the Downing Street lobby briefing this morning the PM’s spokesperson took questions for about 45 minutes on the collapse of the China spying prosecution. The briefing did not provide answers to all the questions raised by Kemi Badenoch (see 10.20am) and others, but it did move things on a bit. Here are the main points.The PM’s spokesperson said it was “entirely false” to claim the government played a role in getting the CPS to drop the prosection
Why Britain’s climate and defence strategies need to be better integrated | Letter
Your article (National security threatened by climate crisis, UK intelligence chiefs due to warn, 8 October) exposed the dangerous disconnect between climate policy and defence. It raises vital questions about Britain’s – and the world’s – readiness to face the security threats posed by the climate crisis, none of which can be met if leaders keep treating climate and defence as separate issues.This summer, wildfires linked to climate change brought Europe to its knees, wreaking economic havoc, overwhelming health systems and draining military resources. All over the world, climate breakdown is fuelling instability, conflict and displacement. The EU’s failure to break free from Moscow’s pipelines is jeopardising its energy sovereignty
UK economy at risk of ‘bumpy landing’; JP Morgan’s Dimon warns of ‘more cockroaches’ after collapse of First Brands and Tricolor – as it happened
US raised concerns about Chinese boss of chipmaker before Dutch takeover
The gospel according to Peter Thiel: why the tech svengali is obsessed with the antichrist
Instagram to bring in version of PG-13 system to protect children, says Meta
MPs warned over ‘shameful’ lack of funding for GB athletes at Deaflympics
RFL close to selling stake in expanded Super League to private equity