Can Nigel Farage emulate success enjoyed by Italy’s far-right Giorgia Meloni?
Reform’s leader may hope to tread a similar path to Italy’s prime minister, but she is an experienced parliamentarian open to collaboration and compromiseOne of the more striking images from June’s G7 summit showed a small group of world leaders engaged in an impromptu and informal evening chat at the venue’s restaurant.In the foreground of that photo was a familiar blond head: Giorgia Meloni.During her three years as the Italian prime minister, Meloni has moved beyond her hard-right populism, not to mention her fascism-adjacent origins, to earn at least the respect of other leaders – Keir Starmer among them – for her pragmatism and flexibility.Among those watching this transformation from the sidelines will be the man hoping to be Starmer’s replacement: Nigel Farage.If campaigning is, as the political truism goes, conducted in poetry while government is prose, this is doubly so for insurgents and outsiders, whose careers are built on promising rapid and straightforward solutions to seemingly intractable national troubles.
When this unstoppable force of rhetoric meets the immovable object of actual government, the results can be turbulent, as with the currency bailouts and increased poverty of Javier Milei’s Argentina, or the stability-shedding chaos of Donald Trump’s impetuous policymaking.Although Meloni arrived in power as the overtly far-right leader of a party, Brothers of Italy, with neofascist roots, she has tempered her ideology with realism and compromise, for example mixing plans to process asylum claims in Albania with a marked increase in work visas to address labour shortages.As shown by the G7 photo, she has also been able to work closely with a series of very different world leaders, among them Starmer, helped by a relaxed manner and proficiency in English, French and Spanish.So could Farage pull off a similar trick? In one sense he already has, also dragging a hard-right party from support once measured in the few percent to mainstream popularity.There are some ways in which Farage’s ideology has remained fairly consistent, not least – and this is one very clear difference from Meloni – his consistent refusal to ally with openly far-right groups, all the way from shunning the British National party in the early days of Ukip to his more recent distancing from Elon Musk and the far-right agitator Tommy Robinson.
“I don’t see Nigel’s principles as having changed one little jot,” said Gawain Towler, who was Farage’s press chief for years and is closely involved with Reform UK.This has not meant a never-changing worldview, Towler argued, saying the “blood and thunder Thatcherism” acquired by Farage during his period as a metals trader in the City during the 1980s was tempered by “25 years going around the poor parts of our country and realising that Thatcherism didn’t work well for everybody”.In a closer parallel to Meloni, Farage does very clearly shape his message to his audience.One example is the repeated airing of tropes and conspiracy theories associated with the far right and antisemitism in US interviews over several years, rhetoric now firmly abandoned and – Farage hopes – largely forgotten.He has also shown himself happy to junk policies which could hamper Reform’s rise, notably the recent move to drop £90bn in planned annual tax cuts, promised only last year.
There is, however, much more to running a government than ideological flexibility.It is also a question of personality and experience.And this is where the differences between Farage and Meloni become more stark.For all that she is still a relative newcomer to the world stage, Meloni has been a member of Italy’s parliament for nearly 20 years and first served as a minister in a Silvio Berlusconi-led coalition government in 2008.In contrast, while Farage is undoubtedly a political veteran – he was a founding member of Ukip more than three decades ago – almost all his experience, even in the European parliament, involved being the undisputed head of a relatively small group of outsiders.
Some former colleagues question how well he may adapt to the endless compromises and delegation involved in running a national government.“Nigel was not at all collegiate back in the day,” said someone who saw him operate as an MEP.“It was his way or the highway, and he’d consider genuine disagreement to be treachery.The question is, has he changed?”According to Robert Ford, a professor of political science at Manchester University, any comparison with Meloni “falls down if you actually look into her biography, because she had done time in government before she headed her own party”.He went on: “It’s important to remember that the question of how much Farage is willing to compromise to get into power is different from the question of whether or not he’ll be good at the compromises necessary.
“She has been in parliament for years and years,He has been in parliament for all of one year and has already managed to lose two of his MPs,“The problem that Farage has long had organisationally is the only kind of organisation he has ever been very effective at running is one where he basically is a sort of autocracy, where his word is holy writ,“Whenever his parties have had any kind of a more differentiated internal structure, he has ended up getting into massive arguments with everybody and marginalising people, and splits have happened,The Brexit party and Reform were explicitly set up with a goal of, essentially, if anyone disagrees with Nigel, Nigel wins.
In government that model doesn’t work.”Meloni, Ford noted, “has had a lot of experience at bargaining, compromise, negotiation – the more subtle arts of manoeuvring yourself into a position where you win and get what you want.None of this is necessarily familiar political terrain for Farage.”
Helen Goh’s recipe for pear, chocolate and hazelnut torte | The sweet spot
Unlike lighter, flour-based cakes, tortes are traditionally rich and dense. Often made with ground nuts instead of flour, this gives them a fudgy, moist texture. Here, ripe pears sink gently into a dark chocolate and hazelnut batter, with the flavours of vanilla, almond and cardamom subtly enhancing the depth of the chocolate and teasing out the fruit’s perfume.Prep 10 min Cook 1 hr 15 min, plus cooling Serves 8-10150g blanched hazelnuts 200g dark chocolate (about 70% cocoa), roughly chopped150g unsalted butter, cubed150g soft brown sugar 1 tsp vanilla extract ½ tsp almond extract 4 large eggs, separated¼ tsp fine sea salt ¾ tsp ground cardamom (from the seeds of 12-18 pods)2 small ripe pears (conference, williams), peeled, quartered and cored To finishIcing sugar, for dusting Creme fraiche or ice-cream, to serveHeat the oven to 190C (170C fan)/375F/gas 5, and line the base and sides of a 23cm springform cake tin with baking paper.Put the hazelnuts on a small baking tray and toast in the oven for five to eight minutes, until light golden and fragrant
More than a third of whisky drinkers are female. Time for the industry to wake up to women
Why wait for International Women’s Day to celebrate women? A commemorative day is a good excuse, true, but we don’t need to wait to recognise the contributions of female and female-identifying individuals to the drinks industry. Right? Right.The Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more
Jimi Famurewa’s recipe for Marmite and leek homity pie
The first time I encountered homity pie was in a disused train carriage. It was Deptford market in the late 2000s: a reliably chaotic, noisy morass of jostling bodies, the wafted smell of sweating burger onions and a vast section where the “stalls” generally comprised gatherings of orphaned trainers, boxy VHS players and other random house-clearance items dumped on to lengths of tarpaulin. I was an eager but gastronomically green 25-year-old in my first proper flatshare and this ragtag locus of trade became an early site of core dining memories. I thoughtfully appraised very ordinary vegetables, channelling Rick Stein in Gascony; bought warm, hectically seeded granary loaves from the Percy Ingle bakery; ate average pub Thai, better kerbside rotisserie chicken; and generally tried, with limited success, to ignore the creeping sense that I had settled in a part of town that wanted for some structure or culinary vitality.It was this atmosphere of cultural nascence into which the Deptford Project trundled
$1.50 mangoes: Australia’s best-value fruit and veg for November
Kensington Pride, Calypso and Honey Gold mangoes are the juiciest of the crop right now – but avoid potatoes until prices come back downGet our weekend culture and lifestyle emailHot weather in the Northern Territory has been favourable for summer’s golden child.“Everyone should be eating mangoes right now,” says Josh Flamminio, co-owner of Galluzzo Fruiterers in Sydney.The mango abundance will continue throughout the month and will only get better as supply from Queensland increases. Flamminio is selling larger premium mangoes for $2.50 to $3 each, and smaller-sized ones for $1
How to turn the dregs of a tin of golden syrup into a delectable toffee sauce – recipe | Waste not
Lyle’s golden syrup comes in the most ornate and nostalgic of tins, but the syrup inside often proves almost impossible to extract entirely. Turn what might otherwise be wasted into this luxurious toffee sauce to savour on Bonfire Night, especially when drizzled generously over cinnamon baked apples with scoops of vanilla ice-cream.Apples transform beautifully when baked, turning this hyper-seasonal fruit into a super-simple yet decadent dessert. I prefer cox or braeburn varieties (ie, something not too large), so you can serve one apple per person.Gordon Ramsay’s recipes are my go-to for traditional techniques that deliver reliable results
Mirepoix kimchi and vegetarian umami chilli: Kenji Morimoto’s recipes for cooking with homemade ferments
Cooking with ferments brings a tremendous amount of flavour to whatever you’re making, and it’s a great way to showcase how an ingredient evolves through the application of heat. The idea of combining a Korean preservation method with a French technique is exactly what I love about creativity in the kitchen. This mirepoix kimchi is not just a fun ferment to dot on savoury oatmeal or eat alongside cheese, but it also acts as the backbone for a plant-based, umami-filled chilli.This versatile, umami-rich paste is a twist on the classic mirepoix and can be used to add a hit of flavour to everything from soups to marinades, or even enjoyed as is.Prep 10 min Ferment 2 weeks+ Makes 500ml jar150g carrot 150g white onion 150g celery 13½g salt (or 3% of the total weight of the first three ingredients)½ tbsp red miso, or fish sauce½ tbsp sugar 15g gochugaru chilli flakesRoughly chop the vegetables (there is no need to peel the carrots if they have been rinsed), then put them in a food processor
Die My Love to Rosalía’s Lux: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
Seth Meyers: ‘Trump has no idea what regular people are going through and he doesn’t care’
Seth Meyers on Mamdani’s win: ‘The kind of energy Democrats have been desperately seeking for years’
Garden shed of vaccine pioneer Edward Jenner added to heritage at risk register
Miss Piggy movie on way from Jennifer Lawrence, Emma Stone and Cole Escola
Colbert on Pelosi calling Trump a vile creature: ‘You know who agrees? Most Americans’