Who are the key Labour rebels in the revolt against Starmer’s welfare bill?
Keir Starmer’s welfare reforms hang by a thread the day before a vote that could define his premiership.The prime minister was almost certainly heading for his first Commons defeat in government before a last-minute deal reached last week between government officials and leading rebels.However, the result remains uncertain, with Labour MPs warning on Monday that they could not back the bill in its current form.Many are angry about the fact that the controversial four-point system to qualify for personal independence payments (Pips) will take effect in November 2026, no matter the outcome of a government review into the system.With ministers still unsure of winning the vote, Labour whips were calling colleagues throughout Monday to gauge support levels.
One of the problems for party managers is that opposition is coming from a large and disparate group without one clear leader.But here are six of the Labour figures – inside and outside parliament – whose voices are being listened to particularly closely.MP for Hackney South and ShoreditchAs head of the cross-party Treasury select committee, Hillier’s parliamentary role is more usually that of impartial inquisitor rather than rabble-rousing rebel.So, her name as the first signatory on last week’s wrecking amendment gave the rebellion the momentum it needed to force the government into concessions.It was unsurprising, therefore, that Hillier was one of the small group of MPs who thrashed out a compromise deal last week.
Her support for that deal was vital in persuading the government they had done enough to sway other moderates.But her questions in the House of Commons on Monday over the details of the concessions reflected an unease about the details, which is shared by many of her colleagues.MP for Oldham East and SaddleworthAlong with Hillier, Abrahams, the chair of the work and pensions select committee, helped negotiate the compromise package struck last week.But also like Hillier, her comments in the Commons on Monday suggested she was still unconvinced that they go far enough.“The [Pip] review should determine both the new process, the new points and the new descriptors,” she said.
“We shouldn’t pre-determine it at four points at the moment.”Abrahams is understood to be more hardline in her opposition to the compromise she helped agree than Hillier, and whips will be working hard to talk her round.MP for Sheffield HeeleyHaving been sacked from the cabinet last November, Haigh has found a new lease of life as unofficial leader of the soft left on the Labour backbenches.Although she has not played the most visible role of the rebels, she has been acting as their unofficial whip, counting MPs’ votes and helping to decide the wording of the wrecking amendment.Haigh was thought to have been mollified by the government’s concessions last week, but on Monday her allies were criticising the government for the way they had handled the fallout.
MP for Penistone and StocksbridgeFor the last few weeks, Tidball has remained largely silent on the welfare bill, despite being one of parliament’s only visibly physically disabled MPs.Although she had not put her name to the rebel amendment, she played an important role trying to persuade the Treasury to make concessions, culminating in what is reported to have been an angry conversation between her and the chancellor, Rachel Reeves.Tidball broke her silence on Sunday, detailing her objections to the bill in a piece for the Guardian.She made an impassioned contribution to Monday’s debate in which she argued: “Having no public consultation of these plans excludes the voice of disabled people.”However, she has not yet said which way she intends to vote and her final decision will be keenly watched by Labour whips.
MP for York CentralA persistent thorn in Starmer’s side, Maskell has emerged as a softly spoken champion of the left of the party,From winter fuel payments, to overseas aid cuts, to compensation for Waspi women, Maskell has often been one of the government’s most eloquent left-wing opponents,Party managers expect the MP for York Central to line up against them on Tuesday,If they persuade her not to, they could peel off a large chunk of the remaining rebels,Mayor of Greater ManchesterWhen Keir Starmer is in trouble, Andy Burnham has a knack of making himself prominent.
The Greater Manchester mayor does not have a vote in Tuesday’s debate, but his intervention over the weekend, telling MPs not to vote for a “50% U-turn”, will have been noticed in Downing Street and on the soft left of the party,Burnham’s position was echoed on Monday by his London counterpart, Sadiq Khan, pitting the country’s two most powerful Labour politicians outside Westminster against the prime minister,
NHS repeatedly failing in care of stroke patients, watchdog says
The NHS has repeatedly failed in its diagnosis and care of stroke patients, England’s health ombudsman has said.According to the World Stroke Association, more than 12 million people worldwide will have their first stroke this year and 6.5 million will die as a result. Strokes are one of the UK’s biggest killers, causing about 34,000 deaths a year, and the single biggest cause of severe disability.The NHS Fast campaign aims to raise awareness of the most common symptoms of stroke – facial drooping, arm weakness and slurred speech – and the need for prompt treatment, including transfer to a specialist stroke unit within four hours
Most women in England and Wales have seen abusive male behaviour in past year, says poll
A majority of women have direct experience of violence or harassment, or know someone who has suffered it, in the last year, a poll has found.The poll finds little faith in the police or government to stem the tide of male violence, and most believe the problem has got worse.The survey was presented to a private meeting attended by police chiefs and police and crime commissioners just under three weeks ago.It was conducted by Zencity and based on almost 1,800 female respondents aged over 16 across England and Wales.The large scale and high frequency of violence against and harassment of women is something law enforcement and the government are trying to get a grip on
Health inequality is linked to gross disparities in wealth | Letters
Your article on health inequality (Britain’s ‘medieval’ health inequality is devastating NHS, experts say, 29 June) describes the laudable efforts of NHS agencies to tackle some of the acute health problems in poorer areas. However, the real problem is that the reason we have such disparities in health is that they are directly related to the gross disparities in wealth and income in this country.As Prof Michael Marmot and many others have demonstrated, some of the most important factors in determining health are social and economic. It is all very well for the NHS to make efforts to actively address the effects of social and economic deprivation in poor areas, but this is managing symptoms rather than the cause.It is no coincidence that the UK has some of the worst health outcomes of developed countries and also among the worst levels of inequality
The Vivienne died from cardio-respiratory arrest due to ketamine use, inquest finds
The drag artist known as The Vivienne died from misadventure after suffering cardio-respiratory arrest after taking ketamine, a coroner has ruled.James Lee Williams, 32, was found in the bath by a neighbour at home in Chorlton-by-Backford, Cheshire, on Sunday 5 January. The last time anyone had contact with Williams was two days earlier, a court was told, when a friend said it was evident the entertainer had taken ketamine.Five drug snap bags were found in The Vivienne’s property, including in a bedroom drawer and a bin in the bathroom, an inquest at Warrington coroner’s court heard on Monday.Although the performer had struggled with drugs in the past, Williams’s family told the hearing they should not be remembered for their use of ketamine and that drugs did not define the person they were
People having IVF should get time off work for appointments, say UK campaigners
People undergoing fertility treatment should have the legal right to take time off for their appointments, according to research that finds over a third have considered leaving their job due to the physical and emotional strain.The campaign group Fertility Matters At Work is calling for IVF to be recategorised as a medical procedure, rather than an elective treatment equivalent to cosmetic surgery, in guidance for employers under the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) code of practice.This would mean employers are no longer able to refuse time off for appointments, and would help tackle the stigma and lack of support that exists in many workplaces, the group says.Fertility Matters at Work has published a report based on a survey of more than 1,000 UK-based employees who have undergone fertility treatment. It found that nearly all (99%) had experienced it as a major life event that affected their mental wellbeing, while 87% reported anxiety or depression directly related to it, and 38% had left or considered leaving their job
NHS will use AI in warning system to catch potential safety scandals early
The NHS is to become the first health system in the world to use AI to analyse hospital databases and catch potential safety scandals early, the government has said.The Department of Health and Social Care said the technology will provide an early warning system which could detect patterns or trends and trigger urgent inspections. The scheme is part of the 10-year plan for the NHS that is due to be published by Wes Streeting this week.The government acknowledged the concern surrounding standards of patient care after “a spate of scandals including in mental health and maternity services”.Last week a national investigation into NHS maternity and neonatal services was announced by Streeting
Downbeat Liz Kendall acts as if even she no longer believes in welfare reforms | John Crace
Starmer offers Labour MPs major welfare bill concession
People in the UK: what do you think of Labour’s first year in government?
Removing hereditary peers is not enough to reform Lords, poll suggests
Leading Labour rebel backs welfare bill amid sustained defiance
Who are the key Labour rebels in the revolt against Starmer’s welfare bill?