Kemi’s experiment in kindness is a sorry sight to behold | John Crace

A picture


This was meant to be Kemi putting her best foot forward.Nice Kemi.Kind Kemi.Collaborative Kemi.All the Kemis that don’t usually see the light of day.

A press conference with Chris Philp and four parents and survivors of child sexual abuse exploitation gangs,A moment of calm,Of reflection,A time to put the victims back where they always should have been,Front and centre.

It was nice while it lasted.Maybe it was an act of partial atonement.During her reply to Yvette Cooper’s statement to the Commons on the Casey report on Monday, Kemi had turned the occasion into one that was all about her.Not a hint of apology for any failings for which she and previous Conservative governments might have made.The victims and survivors were just collateral damage in her fight with Labour.

Her sole focus Keir Starmer’s refusal to grant a national inquiry six months earlier,Her tone tin-eared at best,Many of her Conservative colleagues looked on in embarrassment,“This is not a time for party politics,” Kemi said in her opening remarks to a small group of journalists,Better late than never.

But we were still no closer to understanding why Monday had been exactly the right time for party politics and Tuesday wasn’t.Nor would we find out.If Kemi is capable of self-reflection she keeps her findings to herself.She is thoroughly old school with her emotions.Never explain.

Just keep going,After a few introductions, Kemi handed over to the families and survivors,Marlon, Fiona, Teresa and Lucia,Their testimony was both powerful and moving,And brave.

It takes guts to speak out,Their stories were all depressingly similar,Of boys and girls whose cries for help went unheard,Whose safety was ignored by police and social workers who didn’t want to rock the boat,Survivors who were blamed for their own exploitation.

Widespread cover-ups,For the first question from the media, Kemi more or less held it together,Held the line,Remember to be kind Kemi,Thank the families and survivors.

Maybe even look them in the eye.Make them think that they are the main focus of this presser.Yes, she would be happy for the inquiry to go wider into Westminster and Whitehall.It must go where the evidence leads.No one who was complicit should be exempt.

Then things began to unravel a little as a Sky reporter observed that the cover-ups had been going on for years, during most of which the Conservatives had been in power.So maybe some kind of apology was in order.Could she just maybe whisper a sorry? Or if that was too hard, then merely mouth the word? A sorryette.No.Hear that? No.

She wasn’t sorry for anything.None of this had been anything to do with her.Even though she had once been minister for children.Suella Braverman and Sajid Javid had been heroes throughout.The Tories had never put a foot wrong.

The families and survivors looked on in silence.“Er … You didn’t offer an apology,” said a BBC journalist.Now Kemi started to get notably brittle.She had said sorry sometime in the past.She couldn’t remember what it was for or who it was said to, but it would have to do.

She wasn’t going to say sorry again,Now wasn’t the time for politicians to apologise,She seemed to be unaware that she had spent most of the previous day angrily demanding that the Labour government apologise,I guess she doesn’t consider Starmer to be a proper politician,“Apologies are easy,” she snapped.

Though not for her.It didn’t get any better.ITV wondered if she was as keen to investigate the Tories as she was Labour.Kemi side-stepped that one.Why should she be? The Tories had done nothing wrong.

Did she regret her tone on Monday? Of course not,Elle ne regrette rien,Cue another pile-on to Labour for the imaginary crime of not voting for a Tory amendment that would have killed the child safety bill,For most of the press conference, the shadow home secretary, Chris Philp, had kept quiet,It was possible he also had his reservations about his party leader.

So he had just sat silently.Nodding with compassion.Trying to look decorative.Trying to look like a man who cared.But come the end, he just couldn’t help himself as the topic moved to his favourite subject.

Small boats crossings,“The lack of control at the border is fuelling the risk here,” he said,They should be locked up on sight,For an object lesson in personal responsibility, you had to look elsewhere,Specifically to a Westminster committee room, where Louise Casey, the author of the report, was giving evidence to the home affairs select committee.

Here was the humility of someone capable of not just asking other people the hard questions, but herself too,She wasn’t one to give herself a free ride,She didn’t take shit from other people and she didn’t take shit from herself,“I was surprised to be asked to re-engage with the child sexual exploitation scandal,” she said, having authored the original report into the Rotherham gangs,“But I soon came to see it was the right thing to do.

I found myself asking whether I had done a good enough job,Where had I been when the abuse continued? Did I do enough, given everything she had known? We know it’s still going on,”You won’t find that kind of integrity – that visceral, unsparing self-examination – from many others,In Westminster they prefer to shift the blame elsewhere,Further down the food chain.

Yet to realise that an apology can be an admission of strength.Not of defeat.Casey went on to list her demands.A thorough inquiry that was done quickly.One that didn’t duck the difficult questions.

One that rooted out abuse in every city.Where the data was used professionally.To show no fear.It was a big ask.But someone has to step up.

So it might as well be her.
societySee all
A picture

US supreme court upholds Tennessee ban on youth gender-affirming care

A Tennessee state law banning gender-affirming care for minors can stand, the US supreme court has ruled, a devastating loss for trans rights supporters in a case that could set a precedent for dozens of other lawsuits involving the rights of transgender children.The case, United States v Skrmetti, was filed last year by three families of trans children and a provider of gender-affirming care. In oral arguments, the plaintiffs – as well as the US government, then helmed by Joe Biden – argued that Tennessee’s law constituted sex-based discrimination and thus violated the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment. Under Tennessee’s law, someone assigned female at birth could not be prescribed testosterone, but someone assigned male at birth could receive those drugs.Tennessee, meanwhile, has argued that the ban is necessary to protect children from what it termed “experimental” medical treatment

A picture

UK politicians propose ban on pimping websites

A ban on pimping websites has been proposed by MPs, as part of measures designed to rewrite legislation regulating the sexual exploitation of women.Campaigners say ordering a woman to be sexually exploited has become as straightforward as ordering a takeaway online, with the proliferation of websites that allow buyers to browse images and videos of women, and refine their search by postcode.A group of 59 cross-party MPs have signed an amendment to the crime and policing bill, to be debated on Wednesday, which would make it a criminal offence to “enable or profit from the prostitution of another person, including by operating a website hosting adverts for prostitution”.The all-party parliamentary group on commercial sexual exploitation has published research saying that the ease and speed with which pimps and traffickers can now advertise their victims to potential customers has “turbo-charged the sex trafficking trade”.The committee has warned that regulation of the sex trade has not kept pace with technological developments

A picture

Over half of English councils face insolvency under £5bn deficit, MPs warn

Councils in England face being overwhelmed by billions of pounds in debts and reforms that are divorced from reality, according to an influential committee of MPs.In its inquiry into local government finances, the public accounts committee (PAC) told the Treasury and other departments to urgently address the estimated £5bn deficit on high needs spending – mainly on special educational needs – that will hit council balance sheets at the end of the financial year, potentially driving many insolvent.Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, the PAC’s chair, said: “Our inquiry heard that the government is concerned about local authority finances. But the lack of urgent action to come forward with a plan to address the fast-approaching cliff edge for under-pressure authorities would seem to suggest it is comfortable with the current state of affairs as normalised background noise.“Alarmingly, scrutiny of council finances can now provoke a sense of deja vu, with the same unfixed issues seen over and over

A picture

Overseas-trained dentists working in McDonald’s as millions lack NHS care

Overseas-trained dentists are working in McDonald’s and other takeaways in the UK even though millions of patients are finding it impossible to get NHS dental care.The disclosure comes in a new report being sent to MPs on Wednesday, which urges ministers to slash bureaucracy stopping dentists from abroad plugging the huge gaps in NHS dental care.The main obstacle they face is securing a place to take the exams needed to work in the UK, a process so difficult some liken it to obtaining a ticket to see Taylor Swift.As a result fully qualified dentists from countries such as India, Egypt and Albania are spending months or even years at a time working in fast food cafes, according to the Association of Dental Groups (ADG).The ADG, which represents major dental providers, demanded an urgent overhaul of the two-part overseas registration examination (ORE) to avoid “an unacceptable waste” of foreign dentists’ skills

A picture

Cannabis use could double risk of heart deaths, study suggests

Cannabis use may double the risk of dying from heart disease and increase the risk of stroke by 20%, according to a global review of data.The number of people using cannabis and cannabinoids has soared over the past decade. While previous studies have linked cannabis use to cardiovascular problems, the scale of the risk has until now not been clear.This is an important gap in light of major changes in consumption, researchers at the University of Toulouse in France said.To strengthen the evidence base, they searched databases looking for large observational studies, published between 2016 and 2023, which explored cannabis use and cardiovascular outcomes

A picture

Two mothers denied ‘rape clause’ exception to benefit cap discriminated against, UK court told

Two mothers who conceived children while in physically abusive relationships have been discriminated against after being denied access to benefits, a court has been told.The women launched a challenge against the universal credit system after being denied an exception to the two-child cap.The cap typically has exceptions, one of which is the “rape clause”, which means that a child conceived through sexual assault will still be covered by benefits.On Tuesday, however, Leeds administrative court was told that this rule only applies to third or subsequent children, meaning that some woman are unable to claim an exception if their first two children were conceived non-consensually.Karon Monaghan KC, representing the women, who can be identified only as LMN and EFG, said the pair conceived their children when they were in their teens and vulnerable