Starmer and Reeves promised honesty about public finances. Can they stay the course?
During the first televised debate in the run-up to last summer’s general election, Keir Starmer used a phrase that received enthusiastic – and unanticipated – applause from the Salford audience,“I don’t pretend there’s a magic wand that will fix everything overnight,” he told them,Labour strategists were surprised by the clapping, and encouraged him to deploy the line again in future,The prime minister, his aides said, entered office determined not to fall into the same trap as many leaders before him of making promises that were never going to be kept because of the state of the public finances,For her part, Rachel Reeves arrived at the Treasury intent on hammering home the message the Tories were to blame for the sorry state of the nation’s books.
Her downbeat statement to MPs last July, in which she slashed the winter fuel allowance, zeroed in on the immediate “black hole” left by Jeremy Hunt.“This level of overspend is not sustainable.Left unchecked, it is a risk to economic stability,” she warned.A month later, Starmer’s gloom-laden speech in the Downing Street garden underlined the government’s economic pessimism.“I have to be honest with you: things are worse than we ever imagined,” he said.
Somewhere along the way, the determination to be brutally honest with the public, come what may, has been knocked off course.Some inside government are worried that Starmer – in the face of slumping poll ratings – may have lost his nerve.Ministers argued that winter fuel payments were not sustainable, but then reversed cuts after poor local election results.They emphasised the fiscal advantages of disability benefit changes, and consequently lost the support of their own MPs.But as the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) made starkly clear this week, there are also intense pressures on the public finances over the longer term, including the inexorable rise in the cost of state pensions.
Richard Hughes, the OBR chair, stressed this was due to the design of the triple lock policy, as well as the UK’s ageing society.“The UK public finances are in an unsustainable position in the long run.The UK cannot afford the array of promises that it has made to the public,” he warned.In her Mansion House speech next week, the chancellor will address the OBR report and again point the finger of blame at the Tories, with national debt at a historic high – the UK spends more than £100bn a year on debt interest – and interest rates still recovering from Liz Truss’s mini-budget.She will argue that there is “nothing progressive” about having higher debt, Treasury sources said.
With more borrowing off the table, and the government opposed to further austerity, that leaves tax,The chancellor is widely expected to put up taxes in her autumn budget, potentially by freezing income tax thresholds once again,“All governments … come to each budget as an individual set of choices, almost forgetting what happened last year and without setting a direction for the future,” Paul Johnson, the outgoing director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, told the BBC’s Week in Westminster programme,“I slightly worry that we’re in the same sort of place with this government,It feels like we’re going to get another set of tactical decisions to respond to whatever this year’s fiscal situation is.
”Ruth Curtice, chief executive of the Resolution Foundation thinktank, said that despite the ferocity of the rows over tax and spending over the past 12 months, politicians had not confronted a fundamental question.“We’re not really having a big debate about the fact that the state’s got a lot bigger than it was before the pandemic.Does the country want to pay for that with higher taxes, or make it smaller again?”She said the trade-offs faced by Reeves and her predecessors had been exacerbated by the continued weakness of the UK economy after a series of shocks – the global financial crash, the pandemic and the energy crisis sparked by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.“Fundamentally, it comes from this lack of growth in the economy.Growth has been disappointing since 2010, and we haven’t really faced up to whether that just means that we’re poorer as a country.
”The latest growth figures, showing that Britain’s economy unexpectedly shrank in May, underline the point.It is felt most in people’s pockets: wages have stagnated for much of the last decade.“There’s a reason the electorate is concerned about this, which is that they’ve had 15 years without a pay rise effectively.This is the consequence,” Johnson said.“It’s a zero-sum game when you don’t have growth.
More money for one group of people means less money for another.The rhetoric of this government is right: growth, growth, growth.Without growth, we are stuck in that doom loop.”The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know.If you have something to share on this subject you can contact us confidentially using the following methods.
Secure Messaging in the Guardian appThe Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories.Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs.This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said.If you don't already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu.Select ‘Secure Messaging’.
SecureDrop, instant messengers, email, telephone and postSee our guide at theguardian,com/tips for alternative methods and the pros and cons of each,Rob Ford, a professor of political science at the University of Manchester, said: “Whenever you look at the polling on this, the immediate reaction is to become profoundly depressed and somewhat more sympathetic towards the plight of politicians,“Because what people will tell pollsters, over and over again, is that they want more money spent on the things they like and they don’t want their taxes to go up, and that someone they don’t like should pay for it,”Labour is still hoping for a bounce in growth that would ease the pressures on the public finances – but a year in, and with a crunch budget looming in the autumn, it has not materialised yet.
Neither have they taken either of the two potential pivot points – Donald Trump’s trade tariffs or increased defence spending – that would have allowed them to take a tougher message to the public on the economic realities.Government sources, however, defend the decision to stick to Reeves’s self-imposed fiscal rules.“They’re purposely designed to get the public finances on to a sustainable footing.They’re not self-imposed, they’re cold economic reality,” one said.“We’ve been honest that the public finances need to improve.
We’ve taken some significant steps,Has that been pain-free? No,We’re having to get a grip on day-to-day spending, saying no,That’s not shirking away from the challenge, that’s grabbing it,”
Louis Vuitton says UK customer data stolen in cyber-attack
Louis Vuitton has said the data of some UK customers has been stolen, as it became the latest retailer targeted by cyber hackers.The retailer, the leading brand of the French luxury group LVMH, said an unauthorised third party had accessed its UK operation’s systems and obtained information such as names, contact details and purchase history.The brand, which last week said its Korean operation had suffered a similar cyber-attack, told customers that no financial data such as bank details had been compromised.“While we have no evidence that your data has been misused to date, phishing attempts, fraud attempts, or unauthorised use of your information may occur,” the email said.The company said it had notified the relevant authorities, including the Information Commissioner’s Office
The CEO who never was: how Linda Yaccarino was set up to fail at Elon Musk’s X
In May 2023, when Linda Yaccarino, an NBC advertising executive, joined what was then still known as Twitter, she was given a tall order: repair the company’s relationship with advertisers after a chaotic year of being owned by Elon Musk. But just weeks after she became CEO, Musk posted an antisemitic tweet that drove away major brands such as Disney, Paramount, NBCUniversal, Comcast, Lionsgate and Warner Bros Discovery to pause their advertising on the platform. Musk delivered an apology for the tweet later at a conference – which he called the worst post he’s ever done – but it came with a message to advertisers, specifically the Disney CEO Bob Iger: “Go fuck yourselves.” Yaccarino was in the audience of the conference.“I don’t want them to advertise,” he said
AI-generated child sexual abuse videos surging online, watchdog says
The number of videos online of child sexual abuse generated by artificial intelligence has surged as paedophiles have pounced on developments in the technology.The Internet Watch Foundation said AI videos of abuse had “crossed the threshold” of being near-indistinguishable from “real imagery” and had sharply increased in prevalence online this year.In the first six months of 2025, the UK-based internet safety watchdog verified 1,286 AI-made videos with child sexual abuse material (CSAM) that broke the law, compared with two in the same period last year.The IWF said just over 1,000 of the videos featured category A abuse, the classification for the most severe type of material.The organisation said the multibillion-dollar investment spree in AI was producing widely available video-generation models that were being manipulated by paedophiles
Children limiting own smartphone use to manage mental health, survey finds
Children are increasingly taking breaks from their smartphones to better manage their mental health, personal safety and concentration spans, research has revealed.They are reacting to growing concerns that spending too much time online can be harmful by taking control of their own social media and smartphone use rather than relying on parents to enforce limits, according to experts.The number of 12- to 15-year-olds who take breaks from smartphones, computers and iPads rose by 18% to 40% since 2022, according to the audience research company GWI, drawing on a survey of 20,000 young people and their parents across 18 countries.Prof Sonia Livingstone, the director of the LSE’s Digital Futures for Children centre, said these findings were echoed in soon to be published research, which has found that children and young people are trying various options to manage how their online lives affect their wellbeing, including taking a break from social media, distracting themselves from negativity online, seeking more positive experiences on the internet and in some cases quitting social media altogether.Livingstone said: “Children have got the message – from their parents, the media, their own experiences – that too much social media isn’t always good for them
UK government’s deal with Google ‘dangerously naive’, say campaigners
Google has agreed a sweeping deal with the UK government to provide free technology to the public sector from the NHS to local councils– a move campaigners have called “dangerously naive”.The US company will be asked to “upskill” tens of thousands of civil servants in technology, including in using artificial intelligence, as part of an agreement that will not require the government to pay. It is considered in Whitehall to be giving Google “a foot in the door” as the digitisation of public services accelerates.However, the agreement prompted concerns about the precariousness of UK public data potentially being held on US servers amid the unpredictable leadership of Donald Trump.The Department of Science, Innovation and Technology (DSIT) said Google Cloud, which provides databases, machine learning and computing power, had “agreed to work with the UK government in helping public services use advanced tech to shake off decades old ‘ball and chain’ legacy contracts which leave essential services vulnerable to cyber-attack”
Linda Yaccarino stepping down as CEO of Elon Musk’s X
The CEO of X, Elon Musk’s social network, announced on Wednesday she would resign.“After two incredible years, I’ve decided to step down as CEO of 𝕏,” Linda Yaccarino wrote.Musk replied to her tweet: “Thank you for your contributions.”The outgoing CEO said, “When @elonmusk and I first spoke of his vision for X, I knew it would be the opportunity of a lifetime to carry out the extraordinary mission of this company. I’m immensely grateful to him for entrusting me with the responsibility of protecting free speech, turning the company around, and transforming X into the Everything App
Reform wants to cut council diversity roles. The problem is there are already barely any
Unite attacks Angela Rayner over ‘abhorrent’ handling of Birmingham bin strikes
Starmer and Reeves promised honesty about public finances. Can they stay the course?
Zarah Sultana launches fundraising drive for new leftwing party
Nearly 60 Labour MPs call for UK to immediately recognise Palestinian state
MPs and political candidates face ‘industrial’ levels of abuse, minister says