New York City hospitals drop Palantir as controversial AI firm expands in UK
New York City’s public hospital system announced that it would not be renewing its contract with Palantir as controversy mounts in the UK over the data analytics and AI firm’s government contract.The president of the US’s largest municipal public healthcare system, Dr Mitchell Katz, testified last week before the New York city council that the agreement with Palantir would expire in October.He said at the hearing that the contract, which focused on recovering money for insurance claims, was always meant to be short-term, and that there was an “absolute firewall” preventing Palantir from sharing information with US Immigration and Customs Enforcement.He said that the agency had “not had any incidents”.The contract and related payment documents shared with the Guardian by the American Friends Service Committee and first reported by the Intercept, show that NYC Health + Hospitals has paid Palantir nearly $4m since November 2023.
The contract noted that Palantir would be able to review notes about patients’ health and help the hospital claim more money in public benefits through programs such as Medicaid.It also includes a line stating that with permission from the city agency, Palantir can “de-identify” patients’ protected health information and use it for “purposes other than research”.NYC Health + Hospitals said in an email to the Guardian that it will be transitioning to systems that were made entirely in-house, and there will be no data shared with Palantir or use of the company’s applications after the contract expires.“NYC Health + Hospitals’ use of Palantir technology is strictly limited to revenue cycle optimization, helping the public healthcare system close gaps between services delivered and charges captured, protect critical revenue, and reduce avoidable denials,” the agency said in an emailed statement.A Palantir spokesperson said in a statement: “Palantir, as a software company, does not own or have any rights to customer data – and each customer environment is individually protected against unauthorized access or misuse via robust security controls which can be fully administered and audited by the customer.
”As New York City’s hospital system prepares to part ways with Palantir, the company is facing similar scrutiny over privacy issues in its £330m agreement with the UK’s National Health Service (NHS),Health officials in the UK are concerned that the controversy surrounding Palantir may stop the nationwide rollout of the company’s data system, even though Keir Starmer is trying to speed up deployment,As of last summer, not even half of the country’s health authorities had started using Palantir’s technology amid concerns from the community and doctors,A 12 March briefing by Medact, a health justice charity, said Palantir’s software could enable “data-driven state abuses of power”, including US-style ICE raids,Palantir has denied that the data could be used in this way, noting that it would be illegal and a breach of contract.
Palantir, which also contracts with the British government’s Ministry of Defence, is expanding its influence in the country – despite backlash from activists and some lawmakers.The Guardian revealed last week that Palantir is trying to gain access to sensitive national financial regulation data.The Financial Conduct Authority, a watchdog for thousands of financial bodies from banks to hedge funds, awarded Palantir a contract to investigate internal intelligence data to help root out financial crime.That has sparked outcry from some MPs, who have urged the government to halt this agreement.Liberal Democrats called on Monday for a government investigation into the contract.
Starmer has dismissed suggestions that the UK has become “dangerously over-reliant” on American tech companies, including Palantir, but noted he preferred to have more domestic capability,Medact has raised privacy concerns in the UK about Palantir’s ability to access de-identified patient data,(De-identified data refers to data that has been stripped of characteristics that could indicate who an individual is, such as names and social security numbers,) In a 12 March briefing for health officials, Medact argued that the NHS’s data privacy protections are insufficient; NHS England has said that data is de-identified as it moves through its national software system, the NHS federated data platform (FDP),But Medact cited concerns that this data can be easily re-identified.
An NHS spokesperson said in an emailed statement to the Guardian that the supplier of the FDP “was appointed in line with public contract regulations and must only operate under the instruction of the NHS, with all access to data remaining under NHS control and strict contractual obligations protecting confidentiality”,Data privacy experts interviewed by the Guardian said that there are risks in Palantir accessing New Yorkers’ de-identified data for purposes other than research, especially given the company’s vast access to government records, willingness to cooperate with the federal government and ability to connect and analyze large datasets,“De-identification is not the guarantee it used to be, and it’s getting easier with AI capabilities to re-identify information,” said Sharona Hoffman, a law professor at Case Western Reserve University,Ari Ezra Waldman, a law professor at University of California, Irvine who has researched how governments and tech companies use data about individuals, says that we should be concerned “whenever a company like Palantir or a hostile government collects information on vulnerable populations”,He is particularly concerned about the contract’s provision to use the information for “purposes other than research”.
That tells him the government didn’t have enough power to push back on Palantir when negotiating the contract, or didn’t care or know the risk, he says,Despite the hospital system’s claims that the partnership had no real risks for patients, activists living in New York City, and beyond, are counting this as a win,Nurses, pro-Palestinian activists and social and climate justice groups applied pressure on the city government as part of a nationwide campaign known as Purge Palantir to stop the company from contracting with government agencies, universities and corporations,“We don’t think that the same AI systems that are targeting immigrants here in the United States for ICE, as well as choosing places to bomb in Iran, should be the same AI systems used in hospitals,” said Kenny Morris, an organizer with the American Friends Service Committee,The group obtained the NYC Health + Hospitals contract with Palantir through a public records request, and shared the document with the Intercept and the Guardian.
The national nurses union and the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement were also involved in the campaign.Groups with the “No Palantir in our NHS” campaign in the UK are hoping New York City’s public hospital system’s decision to let the Palantir contract expire fuels their own fight, too.Medact and Amnesty International UK told the Guardian in emailed statements that they are calling on the NHS to follow New York City’s example and terminate its £330m contract with Palantir.“As campaigners in New York have shown, workers and communities can hold our health institutions accountable and push them to make the right choice.We will do the same here, and force NHS England to cancel this contract,” Dr Rhiannon Mihranian Osborne, corporate campaigns lead at Medact, which is in touch with Purge Palantir.
Rachel Reeves urged to raise taxes on companies profiting from war on Iran
Rachel Reeves is being urged to raise taxes on businesses generating “windfall” profits linked to the US-Israel war on Iran to fund emergency cost of living support for UK households.With the government under pressure to respond, a group of leading charities, campaigners and trade unions said the chancellor could raise billions by taxing “excess profits” linked to the conflict.In an open letter to Keir Starmer and Reeves, the organisations – including Greenpeace UK, the National Education Union and Tax Justice UK – said energy companies, banks, agricultural commodities businesses, defence companies and tech firms stood to financially benefit from the economic fallout.Urging Labour to strengthen its existing North Sea energy windfall tax and to introduce new levies for firms in these other sectors, the group said the extra revenue for the exchequer could be used for emergency cost-of-living support and to invest in the future resilience of the UK economy against energy shocks.“We urge you to make this crisis a turning point for the UK
PM rejects ‘far-fetched’ scepticism about Morgan McSweeney phone theft
Keir Starmer has said it is “far-fetched” to suggest that the theft of his former chief of staff’s mobile phone is somehow connected to a subsequent push for the release of documents relating to Peter Mandelson’s appointment as US ambassador.Downing Street has come under pressure to say whether key messages between Morgan McSweeney and the former ambassador were lost after it emerged that the government-issue phone was stolen last year.Kemi Badenoch had “raised an eyebrow” in relation to accounts about the theft, a spokesperson for the Conservative leader said on Wednesday. The Labour MP Karl Turner, who has clashed with the government over jury trial legislation and was a critic of McSweeney’s role, said on X on Wednesday night that he did not believe the phone was stolen.The prime minister responded to the claims on Thursday morning, saying: “The phone was stolen
David Winnick obituary
For much of his career, David Winnick, Labour MP for 42 years – representing Walsall North for 38 of them – was a dogged parliamentarian, originally of the Tribunite left and never aspiring to ministerial office. Yet he will be best remembered for an act of singular courage when he succeeded in defeating the plans of the Blair government in its Iraq war-era attempt to hold terrorist suspects for up to 90 days without charge.Winnick, who has died aged 92, had supported the invasion of Iraq in 2003, but took his stand on civil liberties grounds and, much to the aggravation of ministers, led the charge against the prolonged detention proposal in the Commons in 2005 – and then in the home affairs committee against a further attempt by the subsequent Brown administration to hold suspects for 42 days. Winnick’s successful amendment limited the term to 28 days; the vote against the terror bill was the first defeat for the Labour goverment, nine years after taking power.Winnick’s stand was of a piece with his concern for civil liberties – he also opposed the plans to introduce identity cards – but he was no pacifist
Trump describes UK aircraft carriers as ‘toys’ in latest anti-Nato jibe
Donald Trump has dismissed British warships as “toys” in his latest jibe at Nato countries for their lack of involvement in the joint US-Israeli strikes on Iran. Speaking at the White House on Thursday, he claimed he had told the UK: “Don’t bother, we don’t need it.”Trump has previously alleged that he requested two aircraft carriers from the UK that Keir Starmer had initially rejected and then offered to send. No 10 has denied that a request was made or denied.The prime minister has said he would not permit UK bases to be used for offensive strikes against the Iranian regime, but bases including Diego Garcia on the Chagos Islands can be used for defensive strikes to combat Iran’s retaliation
Reform busy firefighting in Scotland but may yet set Holyrood’s politics ablaze
Hope, change, progressive change, change with fairness at its heart – from a harbour north of Edinburgh to a hipster arts venue in Glasgow’s Barras Market, Scotland’s political parties spent the first official day of the Holyrood election campaign reaching for the phrase that best encapsulates what people will get if they vote for them on 7 May.Only one of the main parties did not hold an event to set out their stall on Thursday: possibly Reform UK was too busy firefighting after another of its Scottish parliament candidates quit, bringing to four the number who have stepped down or been suspended since they stood with the party leader, Nigel Farage, under a hail of turquoise confetti last week.But despite the bright spring sunshine, Farage was a shadow presence at the other launches, with the Scottish National party’s John Swinney and Scottish Labour’s Anas Sarwar in particular differentiated by their approach to him.At the newly renovated Citizens theatre in Glasgow, Swinney urged supporters to get out and campaign for a “historic” overall majority – as happened once before in 2011 under Alex Salmond – promising voters “a fresh start with independence”.An SNP majority would not only force another independence referendum, but also “lock Nigel Farage out of any influence” in Scotland, he said, speaking from a lectern emblazoned with the word “hope”
UK politics: Trump says UK’s aircraft carriers are just ‘toys’ – as it happened
Donald Trump has claimed that the UK’s two aircraft carriers, HMS Queen Elizabeth and HMS Prince of Wales, are little better than “toys”.The president hit out as he spoke on camera at the start of a cabinet meeting in the White House.In a rambling address, that covered a range of subjects, Trump revived his complaint about the UK not offering military help with the Iran war.He said that Nato had done “absolutely nothing” to support the US and he went on:double quotation markNow they all want to help. When they’re annihilated, the other side is annihilated, they said ‘we’d love to send ships’
Human rights groups cheer ‘watershed’ verdict in social media addiction trial
Brussels opens investigation into Snapchat amid concern over children’s safety
Google warns quantum computers could hack encrypted systems by 2029
Starmer vows to tackle social media’s ‘addictive features’ to protect children
Creator of AI actor Tilly Norwood says she received death threats over project
Charity Commission warns Alan Turing Institute of its legal duties after complaints