Unregulated chatbots are putting lives at risk | Letters
Your coverage of AI-associated delusions exposes a gap that training-level guardrails cannot close (Marriage over, €100,000 down the drain: the AI users whose lives were wrecked by delusion, 26 March).As someone who has worked in health systems across fragile and low-income contexts, I find it striking that AI companies have failed to adopt a safeguard that even the most underresourced clinic in the world already uses: screening patients before exposing them to risk.The Patient Health Questionnaire-9 for depression and the Columbia Suicide Severity Rating Scale are administered daily in settings with no electricity, limited staff, and patients who may never have seen a doctor.These tools take minutes.They are validated across dozens of languages and cultural contexts.
They create a human checkpoint between vulnerability and harm.Conversational AI platforms have no such checkpoint.A person experiencing suicidal ideation, psychotic symptoms or a manic episode can open a chatbot and receive hours of validating, sycophantic engagement with no interruption and no referral.The Lancet Psychiatry review by Morrin et al documents this pattern across more than 20 cases.The Aarhus study of 54,000 psychiatric records found chatbot use worsened delusions and self-harm in those already unwell.
AI companies argue that their models are trained to detect and deflect harmful conversations.But training is not screening.A model that sometimes recognises distress mid-conversation is not the same as a system that identifies risk before the conversation begins.The moral responsibility here is explicit, not implicit.Platforms serving hundreds of millions of users must implement validated, pre-use screening instruments that flag elevated risk and route vulnerable individuals to human support.
This is not innovation.It is a standard of care that the rest of the world adopted long ago.Dr Vladimir ChaddadBeirut, Lebanon I’m really disturbed by Anna Moore’s article, featuring Dennis Biesma’s description of how using a chatbot led to him becoming delusional and losing his marriage and €100,000.The sheer potency of AI’s capacity to derail humankind is frightening – but that alone is not the only reason I’m disturbed.Last year, while researching on a tourism website, I encountered a chatbot of extraordinary sophistication.
Its responses were incredibly pleasant, helpful and validating of my needs.I recall being really impressed, but there was something I felt I couldn’t put a finger on at the time.After reading this article, the penny has dropped.It is essentially the same engagement behaviour as child sexual abuse (CSA) survivors experience when being groomed.As a survivor of CSA, I recognise this behaviour.
The empathy, validation, making you feel understood and special, making you feel this is the only place you are seen – to the degree that you become isolated from others, and your choices and decisions become distorted and expose you to harm,Your self-worth and identity are insidiously compromised as you succumb to the perceived support and can’t reality-test,It becomes a shameful secret because you succumbed,The question needs to be asked, especially by those wanting to hold tech companies to account for their lack of a duty of care: what knowledge base did AI programmers use to teach it to engage in this way?Name and address supplied I found ChatGPT delusional the first time I used it,I asked it why, and it said that when in the possession of insufficient facts, it became delusional rather than admit it did not know.
So I asked it to adhere to a few simple rules,One, flag up if something is fact generally held to be true, and opinion not based on fact,Two, if it does not know, tell me,Three, do not try to be like a human,It was much more straightforward to communicate with after I did this.
However, it had also told me that its algorithms were not based on truth-giving, but on other imperatives to do with the programmers’ views and the desire to make money.I moved to Le Chat, and found it more representative of a reasonable pseudo-consciousness.It says it does not give distortions and is happy to admit imperfection.I would strongly advise anyone using ChatGPT to be careful and consider regarding it as a rather manipulative, duplicitous “friend”, with proto-psychopathic tendencies.Patrick ElsdaleMusselburgh, East Lothian Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Tribe’s Lions heroics fuel Glamorgan’s belief on return to Championship elite
The daffodils were in suitable bloom in Cardiff, swathes of them, creeping from under the trees in Bute Park, yolky heads bobbing in the spring sunshine. A few hundred metres up the road, Glamorgan’s players were gathering at Sophia Gardens before their biggest season in years, back in Division One of the County Championship for the first time since 2005.Their campaign last year was a slow burner but blossomed, a close-knit side playing confidently. Alongside a thousand runs each from Colin Ingram and Kiran Carlson were eye-catching performances from two talented then 21-year-olds, Ben Kellaway and Asa Tribe, who went on to be picked for the Lions tours in the winter. In their shellacking by Australia A in the unofficial Test, Tribe hit an unbeaten 129, which was enough to get him a namecheck from the England managing director, Rob Key, in pre-season media musings – the only non-capped player to be mentioned
MCC rules out rescuing crisis club Middlesex after Gatting’s damning letter
The MCC has ruled out buying or investing in Middlesex as their tenants at Lord’s begin another season in a state of crisis.A group of distinguished former players, led by the ex-England captain Mike Gatting, has called on the chair, Richard Sykes, to stand down because of poor performances on the field and longstanding financial and governance problems, with an open letter claiming that Middlesex are “drifting towards irrelevance.”As Middlesex’s landlords since 1877 with annual revenues of around £70m an MCC takeover has long been mooted as a potential solution to the club’s problems, but it will not happen under their present leadership.While MCC remain committed to extending Middlesex’s lease at Lord’s and will provide further help where possible, there are no plans to offer them direct financial assistance or become more involved in the running of the club, as there is no business case to do so.The MCC’s membership secretary, Mahdi Choudhury, was seconded to Middlesex as interim chief operating officer this year after the suspension of the club’s chief executive, Andrew Cornish, but he will return to his employers this month
The Spin | ‘It keeps you young’: England Over-70s bask in glory of Ashes and World Cup wins
Late-age cricket leagues are growing fast and the national Over-70s thrived on their winter southern hemisphere tour“You could compare and contrast if you so desired,” says the England Over-70s manager, Chris Lowe, offering the straightest of bats to my shameless prod. “You’re the journalist, so you probably will.” It would be professional negligence not to so let us duly look at the fate that befell Brendon McCullum’s England team over the winter, alongside that of their Over-70s counterparts, whose itinerary bore a startling resemblance to their junior brethren.For both it began in Australia where Ben Stokes’s side succumbed to a bruising 4-1 Ashes defeat, weeks before the Over-70s swept to a 3-0 triumph in the wonderfully named Silver Ashes.Under pressure to keep his job, McCullum then reconvened his troops for the T20 World Cup, where their involvement ended at the semi-final stage against India, the eventual winners
Can Congress stop the ‘straight greed’ of US sports teams leaving their cities?
WWE star CM Punk called it “straight greed”. Illinois governor JB Pritzker called it a “slap in the face”. An overwhelming majority of fans say they will hold a grudge.This cacophony of disgust has been prompted by the real possibility that the Chicago Bears could relocate to Hammond, Indiana. The Bears’ owners bought a site in Arlington Heights, Illinois, for a new stadium, but negotiations over property taxes have stalled construction
ECB accused of allowing non-disabled players to take place of disabled cricketers in top domestic league
The England and Wales Cricket Board has been accused of allowing non‑disabled players to participate in its Disability Premier League, blocking the pathway to international cricket.The parents of Jai Charan and Alex Jervis – both former England players who have diagnosed learning disabilities – say their sons have been replaced in the DPL by players who do not meet the disability criteria under the ECB’s assessment process.The DPL is intended as the top of the pathway to the England Mixed Disability team but another parent, who requested to remain anonymous, estimates that 12 out of 64 players selected in the December draft are non-disabled.The ECB is a signatory to Virtus, the international sports federation for athletes with an intellectual impairment, meaning all players wanting to play internationally under the LD (learning disability) category must show they have an IQ of 75 or lower.Owen Jervis, who is also the volunteer manager of Yorkshire’s disability team, alleges the ECB has allowed several neurodiverse players to participate in the DPL, despite not meeting the criteria in the LD assessment process, carried out by an educational psychologist
From the Pocket: Voss has had every chance to succeed but Carlton backed the wrong coach
Michael Voss often speaks about standards and habits. Right now, the Carlton coach’s team are habitual dwindlers. It’s on the whiteboard of every opposition coach. It’s in the marrow of every Blues player and supporter. And it goes back a long way
Don’t blame AI for the Iran school bombing | Letters
Patrick McKeown obituary
Apple at 50 quiz: top sellers, turkeys and turtlenecks
MP rejects Palantir’s claims that criticism of NHS England deal is ‘ideologically motivated’
US tech firm Oracle cuts thousands of jobs as it steps up AI spending
I wore Meta’s smartglasses for a month – and it left me feeling like a creep