Human rights experts raise concerns over Olympics transgender women athlete ban
Over 100 human rights, sports and scientific groups, including the United Nations, have criticised the International Olympic Committee’s new gender eligibility guidelines as “a blunt and discriminatory response that is not supported by science and violates international human rights law”,The IOC’s new guidelines, announced on Friday, mandate genetic sex tests for all athletes competing in its women’s categories, as well as blanket bans of people who identify as transgender, intersex or with sex differences,Athletes in these categories have been allowed to compete in Olympic events since the IOC scrapped mandatory sex testing in 1999, which was deemed arbitrary, inaccurate, expensive and discriminatory,New IOC president Kirsty Coventry reversed the organisation’s position and backflipped on its own 2021 Framework on Fairness, Inclusion, and Non-Discrimination, a policy informed by extensive consultation and research which recognised the need for evidence-based, sport-specific and rights-respecting rules,“Mandatory genetic sex testing and rigid biological criteria as a condition for participation in the women’s category violates fundamental and universal human rights … including the right to equality, non-discrimination, dignity, privacy, and bodily autonomy,” said Professor Paula Gerber, an international human rights lawyer at Monash University.
“As several UN independent experts have noted, binary definitions of sex reinforce harmful stereotypes and erode progress toward substantive gender equality,Any testing of athletes needs to be individualised and evidence-based, not arbitrary or degrading,”The new guidelines were developed by a committee which has not publicly shared the scientific data that the IOC claims informed their position,In a press conference on Friday, Coventry claimed all women athletes will be tested for the SRY gene, which multiple medical experts have stated is unreliable and reductive,“The IOC’s move to mandate sex testing across the female category risks undermining both evidence-based policy and athlete wellbeing, while diverting attention from the real priorities in women’s sport,” said Dr Ada Cheung, a professor of endocrinology at the University of Melbourne.
“The best available data … shows that transgender women receiving gender-affirming hormone therapy are not meaningfully different from cisgender women in key performance-related measures such as muscle mass, strength, body composition, or cardiorespiratory fitness, and in many aspects have a disadvantage.“This represents a return to practices that were abandoned decades ago for good reason.”Of the tens of thousands of athletes who have participated in Olympic events since 1999, just one has identified as a transgender woman – Laurel Hubbard of New Zealand.She did not place in her event.Athletes who are intersex or have differences of sex development, including cisgender women, will be overly affected by the new guidelines, with women of colour likely to be disproportionately targeted due to their appearance.
The guidelines do not affect community sport, but national governing bodies could follow the IOC’s lead in implementing similar tests and bans at grassroots level.“This isn’t just about transgender or intersex athletes; this impacts every girl playing Australian sport today,” said Nikki Dryden, a human rights lawyer and former Olympic swimmer.“If these rules are adopted, it could mean that when you sign your daughter up to play sport, she may be subjected to sex testing just to participate.“Worse, it creates a culture where someone like a coach, an official, or even another parent, feels entitled to question whether your daughter ‘looks female enough’ to belong.That is not protecting women’s sport.
That is policing girls’ bodies,And once sport starts deciding which women are ‘acceptable’, no woman or girl is truly safe,“The IOC’s new guidelines will be unlawful in Australia,Mandatory sex testing and blanket bans directly conflict with the Sex Discrimination Act, our sporting National Integrity Framework, and our safeguarding obligations to children,“Moving towards exclusionary, invasive rules is not only unnecessary, it is a step back over 25 years that exposes athletes and organisations to serious legal and integrity risks.
”Australian Olympic Committee president Ian Chesterman said he supported the new guidelines, and offered affected athletes counselling and support.“Without doubt, this is a challenging and complex subject and at the AOC we approach it with empathy and understanding,” Chesterman said.“This decision provides clarity for elite female athletes who compete at the highest level and demonstrates a commitment to fairness, safety and integrity in Olympic competition, all of which are fundamental principles of the Olympic movement.”Australia’s chef de mission for the 2028 Games in Los Angeles, Anna Meares, said she commended the IOC for “taking the lead” on the issue.“The IOC ruling today protects female athletes at the highest level of competition, ensuring it remains safe and fair,” said Meares.
“I also know the pain this decision will cause some athletes and I empathise with them,“This is about integrity on the Olympic field of play,Female athletes know that when they compete it will be fair, it will be safe,”The AOC said it will now take some time to work with the IOC and member sports to fully understand the workings of the new policy,
Jimmy Kimmel on Trump’s election integrity push: ‘Like Bill Cosby telling you he’ll watch your drink for you’
Late-night hosts mocked Donald Trump’s mail-in voting as he tries to end mail-in voting, ICE agents in US airports and a mysterious “gift” from Iran.On Tuesday’s Jimmy Kimmel Live!, the host checked in on Donald Trump’s efforts to pass the so-called Save America act. The sweeping restrictive voting bill would require proof of US citizenship for new voters and end mail-in voting, or what Trump called “mail-in cheating”.“That’s right, he prefers in-person cheating,” Kimmel quipped.“He keeps saying that it was brought to his attention today that we’re the only country that does mail-in voting – when is someone going to step in and tell him that’s not true?” he continued
Jon Stewart on Donald Trump’s Iran lies: ‘Our Supreme Misleader’
Late-night hosts reacted to Donald Trump’s tweet celebrating Robert Mueller’s death, his ICE intervention at chaotic airports and his bluffing on “talks” with Iran.Jon Stewart hoped you had a happy Monday, because “the dizzying, chaotic carnival ride that is Donald Trump’s America continues to careen down Shitshow Hill”, he said on The Daily Show. “It’s fucking madness out there: TSA lines longer than your actual trip, escalating threats in the Middle East, planes driving into trucks.”In fact, “the only thing giving me joy is looking forward to this season of The Bachelorette”, he joked, referring to the doomed season with The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star Taylor Frankie Paul, pulled three days before its premiere after video surfaced of a previously reported domestic violence incident from 2023. “I mean, they’ve got a strong Mormon woman
Punk masks, Walkmans and Choppers: Museum of Youth Culture to open in London
In the basement of a new-build housing block in Camden, the ventilation system is working flat out. The fans whir like a chainsaw orchestra bouncing around the concrete room as they attempt to deal with a slight damp problem. “This is what it’d sound like if there was a fire!” shouts Jon Swinstead, the driving force behind the Museum of Youth Culture, as he tries to make himself heard above the din.It’s hard to imagine but in a few weeks this empty, slightly soggy space will be transformed into an institution dedicated to all things teenage – a project Swinstead has been working on in one way or another for almost 30 years.Opening on 15 May, the museum has amassed a 100,000-item archive that tells the story of British youth subcultures from mods and rockers, to ravers and emo
‘Audiences told us we didn’t show enough teacher sex’: how we made Waterloo Road
‘In series one, it was bullying, drugs and alcohol. Twenty years on, it’s vapes, cyber-bullying and bloody energy drinks’I was working on women’s prison drama Bad Girls when the idea for Waterloo Road came up. Bad Girls creators Maureen Chadwick and Ann McManus had a fiery belief in social justice and did rigorous research. Those are often the foundations of successful serial drama. Ann had once taught in a Glasgow comprehensive and was passionate about education: she believed we write off young people too readily
What does loneliness smell like? Inside the strangely soothing world of fragrance TikTok
I was bestowed with a nickname throughout my younger years: Smellanor. When I decided to go by Elle, the nickname evolved with it: Smell. I’m always a sucker for a fun rhyme. But it did make me hypervigilant about maintaining what I actually smelled like, vowing that this moniker would never manifest itself into reality. Thus began my ongoing journey into the wild world of fragrances
Claire Hooper: ‘People have different forms of therapy. Songs for the Deaf by Queens of the Stone Age is mine’
The premise of your new standup show, Fun Show xx, is that you are not a fun person. What is the least fun thing about you?The minute my husband leaves the house, I turn the music off. I love silence. For my 40th birthday my husband, my two babies and I flew to Adelaide and hired a car to drive to the Barossa. My husband said, “It’s your birthday, you get to choose the playlist!” and I said, “Just complete silence please
Oil shrugs off Trump’s latest Iran extension; UK consumers feel ‘ripple of fear’ from the conflict – business live
US markets see biggest slump since start of US-Israel war on Iran
‘Accountability has arrived’: dual US court losses show shifting tide against Meta and co
New York City hospitals drop Palantir as controversial AI firm expands in UK
Chess: iconic Reykjavik Open sparks memory of Bobby Fischer from 1973
Aryna Sabalenka sinks Rybakina to set up Miami Open final showdown with Gauff