Who are the main threats to Keir Starmer’s Labour leadership?

A picture


Keir Starmer has long been dogged by leadership rivals – despite only having won a huge majority two years ago.He insists there is no vacancy, and that he will fight on in No 10, seeking a second five-year term and a decade in the job.However, the various contenders to replace him have been organising for some time.Many others may consider throwing their hats into the ring if the contest opened up – from the home secretary, Shabana Mahmood, and the education secretary, Bridget Phillipson, to the foreign secretary, Yvette Cooper, and the armed forces minister, Al Carns.But here are Starmer’s main threats:Health secretaryThe health secretary is widely thought to be the most ready for a leadership contest, and the one who stands to gain from a competition right now – given Andy Burnham is not an MP and Angela Rayner still has an unresolved tax problem.

Streeting is considered to be on the right of the party, formerly close to Peter Mandelson, and a leading light of the Blairite Progress wing,However, he has been veering to the left for some time, on the issues of Gaza and welfare, no doubt with an eye on the Labour membership who are likely to be the ones to decide the next leader of the party,As long ago as January, there were briefings from some supporters that he had 200 MPs lined up to back him in the parliamentary party – although some opponents say it is “complete nonsense” that half of the party are behind him,At the time of the Mandelson scandal, some support appeared to drift away from him given his friendship with the machiavellian former peer,However, he attempted to get on the front foot by releasing text messages, including one about him fearing he was “toast” at the next election, and others where he criticised the government for having “no growth strategy”.

Once close to No 10 and the former adviser Morgan McSweeney, Streeting appeared to drift away from Starmer as early as last autumn, as speculation about his own leadership ambitions began to heat up.He faces substantial hurdles to becoming the leader, with a soft-left choice potentially more favoured by the membership and some “Stop Wes” MPs determined to do everything possible to prevent his candidacy.Backbench MP and former deputy leaderThe former deputy leader has not confirmed she would definitely run.However, her allies say she is getting prepared, even though she is not dead set on becoming the candidate of the soft left – the middle-ground position between Labour’s right and the harder left.Having stepped down over an HMRC inquiry about her tax affairs, Rayner had hoped to have put the affair behind her by now.

The lack of conclusion makes it difficult but not impossible for her to throw her hat into the ring, and she sent out a lengthy statement with her prescription for turning the government around on Sunday – urging Labour to return to governing for the working class.She also made clear that she believes it was a mistake for Starmer to block Burnham from returning to parliament as an MP.Rayner’s chances of becoming leader are boosted by Burnham’s continued exclusion from parliament, but if there were to be a quick contest then she could benefit from his backing – and could offer to allow him to return in a top job.Rayner also has an impressive record in government to show Labour members who could decide any contest, from bringing in the employment rights bill to pushing for more housebuilding.Mayor of Greater ManchesterBurnham was obviously jostling for the leadership as early as autumn, when he set out criticisms of the government before the Labour conference and confirmed he would seek to stand against Starmer if there were to be a contest.

He subsequently pushed to return as a candidate in the Gorton and Denton byelection before being blocked by Labour’s national executive, which was loyal to Starmer.After that, the Greater Manchester mayor became quieter – but his ambitions have not gone away and he has built up substantial support on the soft left in parliament, as well as some centrists.Many of his backers have been calling on Starmer to name a date for his resignation in the last few days.However, this tactic appears to have massively backfired by creating the momentum for supporters of Streeting and other sitting MPs to push for a quicker contest that would exclude him.The alternative plan now is for Burnham backers to urge Starmer to set out an “orderly transition” rather than allow a contest that favours Streeting and other sitting MPs.

A former health secretary, Burnham is also a proponent of Manchesterism – fighting for place-based growth – and for proportional representation,He has not yet commented on the local election results and pulled out of a speech on Friday morning so as not to overshadow the event,However, he is a rare potential replacement for Starmer in being both popular with party members and the country at large,Seen as working class, authentic and the “king of the north”, Burnham would be seen by many as the strongest contender if he were allowed to run,Secretary of state for energy security and net zero“I can see how there is a path for Ed,” says one Labour figure from another camp.

Miliband has played the long game.He has not been caught up in scandals, and most MPs thought he was content to pitch himself as a future chancellor or kingmaker of the soft left.However, if a contest to replace Starmer takes place before Burnham has returned, there is a strong chance that MPs could turn to him rather than Rayner as their candidate.He has not confirmed he would run in any competition but is reported to have asked Starmer last week to name a timetable for his exit – a plan that the prime minister firmly rejects.Miliband’s biggest weakness, though, is that he has already been rejected once by the electorate against David Cameron in 2015.

While one of the most popular members of the cabinet with Labour members, there is nervousness among MPs about how he would fare in an electoral contest with Nigel Farage.Former parliamentary under-secretary of state at the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development OfficeFew outside Westminster have heard of West.The former Foreign Office minister’s decision to say she would challenge Starmer for the leadership came out of the blue over the weekend.She is a very unlikely candidate to actually win any contest.But she told the New Statesman: “You know what sometimes happens to stalking horses? They become the candidate.

politicsSee all
A picture

The Tories are still on life support – so why is Badenoch in celebratory mood?

By any sane person’s reckoning, the Conservative party had a night to forget in Thursday’s local, mayoral and devolved elections. It lost about 500 councillors in England and ceded control of three local authorities to Nigel Farage’s Reform UK – losing to the rightwing upstarts in England, Wales and Scotland. Why, then, is Kemi Badenoch hailing these results as proof that “the Conservatives are coming back” – and why do many Tory MPs appear to agree with her?The Conservative leader was vocal on Friday about the eye-catching gains her party made in politically atypical London, where the Tories won back the totemic council of Westminster, took the most seats in Wandsworth council and saw off the threat from Reform in Bexley and Bromley.But it was hard to ignore the damage in her own back yard of Essex, where Badenoch and five other shadow cabinet ministers are MPs. Reform ended the party’s 25-year reign at the local authority, as well as taking the Tory-held Newcastle-under-Lyme and Suffolk, as well as making inroads in East and West Sussex

A picture

Angela Rayner calls blocking Andy Burnham’s return to parliament a mistake as pressure mounts on Keir Starmer – as it happened

Angela Rayner has just released a statement on the fallout from Thursday’s elections. The most significant passage is one in which she calls the decision to block Andy Burnham from parliament a mistake and says Keir Starmer ‘must now meet the moment’. Here is the key extract:double quotation markThis is bigger than personalities, but it is time to acknowledge that blocking Andy Burnham was a mistake. We must show we understand the scale of change the moment calls for - that means bringing our best players into Parliament - and embracing the type of agenda that has been successful at a local level, rather than reaching back to an agenda and politics that has failed people.These are the fights we need to have, and the change in direction we need to see

A picture

Plaid Cymru leader plans minority Welsh government built on cooperation

The leader of Plaid Cymru, Rhun ap Iorwerth, has vowed to form a stable minority government in the Senedd and said he would seek out mature cooperation from all opposition parties.Ap Iorwerth said his administration would press the UK government for extra powers over policy areas such as policing and justice and focus on results rather than engaging in political rows with Westminster.Asked if Plaid’s win meant the country had taken a step closer to independence – a key Plaid aspiration – ap Iorwerth replied that a “more confident” Wales felt closer.“The people of Wales didn’t begrudgingly decide to give us a go,” he said. “They said: ‘We believe in your belief in Wales

A picture

Give Starmer the chance to carry out his promises | Letters

As a local Labour activist, I understand the general wailing and gnashing of teeth that has beset the party after our drubbing in the local elections. But amid the panic about who should or shouldn’t resign, or what may or may not happen in three years’ time, I’d like to propose a philosophy that I’m calling “positive defeatism”.For only the fourth time in a century, a Labour prime minister has won a general election with a large majority – with a mandate that takes us to July 2029. What if we stop worrying about a second term and just get on with making consequential changes in this term?Here’s my list for starters: Locking in the great transition so that climate deniers can’t undo it; reducing the voting age to 16 so young people get a chance to vote for their future; and reforming party funding laws so that shadowy cryptocurrency barons can’t hijack our democracy. There are other priorities of course – cost of living, housing, inequality…So let’s make the most of the time we have now

A picture

PM must resign to save Britain’s future | Brief letters

Keir Starmer’s word salad of banal platitudes – “we will deliver the change that people are desperate for” (which change?) – exemplifies his inability to capture the imagination (These election results don’t mean tacking left or right…, 8 May). If he stays on as PM, it is extremely likely that Nigel Farage will succeed him. While I’m uninspired by any potential Labour successor, it is possible one of them might step up into the role and succeed. Starmer must resign to give us that chance for the future.Dr Kimon RoussopoulosCambridge If Keir Starmer is seeking to reassure voters that he is really the man to deliver change, it seems bizarre to bring in Gordon Brown and Harriet Harman (9 May)

A picture

What’s behind surge in support for Reform and Greens across England? Five key takeaways

Local elections have fundamentally reshaped the political landscape in England. Labour suffered heavy losses, losing ground to the Green party and Reform UK, while the Conservatives also sustained significant losses to Reform UK and the Liberal Democrats.Reform and the Green party made significant gains, in results that laid bare an increasingly fragmented political system. Reform gained 1,349 council seats and control of 14 councils, while the Green party won 376 council seats, control of five councils, and took two mayoralties.With both insurgent parties making inroads, what is behind the surge in their support?So far, Reform’s vote in English council seats has grown the most in areas with greater socioeconomic deprivation, early analysis shows