South East Water boss lasting weeks in post would be a surprise | Nils Pratley

A picture


Can David Hinton, the chief executive of South East Water, stay in his job long enough to bag a £400,000 bonus for turning up to work? With four and a half years to go, one can’t say his chances of landing the retention payment – or “service award” – are good,In fact, it will be surprising if he’s still infuriating the residents of Tunbridge Wells four and a half weeks from now,In the latest episode of this long-running double saga of outages that has left thousands of households in Kent and Sussex without running water for days, Ofwat has opened a first-of-its-kind investigation into whether South East complied with its obligation to provide “high standards of customer service and support”,That comes a day after Emma Reynolds, the environment secretary, called for the regulator to review the company’s operating licence,Meanwhile, even the company’s shareholders, who normally shun the spotlight on these occasions, are spluttering into their bottled water.

NatWest Group’s pension fund, a 25% owner, said it was “extremely concerned” by the impact on customers and said it would use its influence “to direct South East Water’s board to ensure these issues are fully resolved”.That wasn’t quite an instruction for heads to roll, but it wasn’t far off.One can understand its alarm.Shareholders sank £200m in fresh equity into South East as recently as May, on top of £75m in December 2024, to support an over-extended balance sheet.Yet the company’s last annual report was still full of scary lines about how it needed “a more balanced regulatory settlement” to be able to “fulfil its purpose as a provider of the public water service now and in the future”.

On that score, developments aren’t encouraging either: South East asked the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) for an 18% uplift on the bill increase granted by Ofwat.However, in its provisional finding (the final is still awaited), the appeals regulator allowed 4%.Against that strained financial background, it was vital that South East handled any operational crisis, such as two big outages in two months, slickly.We’ll see what Ofwat says but one doubts it will award the “eight out of 10” that Hinton gave himself when appearing before MPs this month.To outside eyes, he has served up a masterclass in how not to communicate during a crisis: he told MPs his reluctance to give interviews was in case he was asked distracting questions about his pay or shareholder dividends.

There’s a lot to ask about.Why did South East’s board feel Hinton needed a performance-free £400,000 incentive to stay in post for five years, as the Guardian reported on Thursday? It had simultaneously just awarded him a 30% increase in his annual salary to the same level and reintroduced a long-term incentive scheme (on top of the annual bonus scheme) worth 150% of salary, which is the normal way to encourage executives.How many carrots does he need? Actually, one more: a one-off £50,000 “cash allowance” for work on the CMA appeal.Separately, Ofwat is running an engineering-related investigation into whether South East “failed to develop and maintain an efficient water supply system”.That one dates from 2023 and the outcome is due within weeks.

The potential penalties are piling up,In the shareholders’ shoes, you’d get a new boss in there as soon as possible in the hope of saving your investment,
societySee all
A picture

Maternal death rate in UK rose by 20% over 14 years despite Tory pledge

The rate of women dying during or soon after pregnancy in the UK has increased by 20% over the last decade, despite the Conservatives having pledged to halve it, according to figures experts have described as “an absolute tragedy”.In 2015, the then Tory health secretary, Jeremy Hunt, vowed to reduce maternal deaths by 50% by 2030 and make the NHS “one of the safest places in the world to have a baby”. In 2017, he brought the date forward to 2025.However, figures from MBRRACE-UK, a research project led by the University of Oxford, show the rate of women dying during the Conservatives’ 14 years in government went up, not down.Health leaders and campaigners said the 20% increase between 2009-11 and 2022-24 was shocking and showed something had clearly “gone badly wrong”

A picture

ADHD care needs better regulation and fewer pills | Letters

As a UK-trained consultant psychiatrist, fully indemnified, appraised and regulated by the General Medical Council, with specialist expertise in adult attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) assessment and treatment, I read your article on rising ADHD care costs with concern and frustration (NHS ADHD spending over budget by £164m as unregulated clinics boom, 12 January).For the past eight months I have been navigating the opaque Care Quality Commission (CQC) registration process to provide high-quality, fully regulated ADHD assessments in an independent setting, alongside two similarly qualified colleagues. Until this process is complete, I am legally prohibited from seeing patients.It is therefore deeply troubling to learn from your article that multiple companies have been awarded NHS ADHD contracts despite not having CQC registration. In addition, some health professions fall outside the CQC remit and thus can set up a practice “diagnosing and treating” ADHD tomorrow – for example, a psychologist working with a prescribing pharmacist

A picture

Religious tradition, child safety and the law on circumcision | Letters

I would welcome criminalising circumcision if it was performed by an unqualified person – just as would be the case if someone unqualified conducted any other surgical operation (Circumcision classed as possible child abuse in draft CPS document, 10 January). But leaping from that to banning the practice altogether is not justified.Given that it is a longstanding and important tradition among Jews, Muslims and various other cultures, the best way forward is to only permit circumcision if it is practised by someone specifically qualified for it and who belongs to a nationally accredited scheme. This would involve compulsory training, monitoring all cases and producing annual reports.Such a step is vital if we value both the safety of children and the integrity of faith backgrounds, and should be implemented as soon as possible

A picture

Woman pulled out of UK ultramarathon after death threats over Afghanistan fundraising

A woman was pulled out of Britain’s most gruelling ultramarathon after receiving death threats over her fundraising for Afghan women and girls.Sarah Porter was nearly a third of the way through the 108-mile Montane Winter Spine Challenger South endurance race when organisers made the “difficult decision” to withdraw her due to threats to her life in relation to the foundation she runs helping women and girls in war zones.Speaking to the Guardian, Porter said she was disappointed. “My immediate feeling was just one of shame really.”“I was very emotional,” she said, “just born from the perspective that I really felt like I’d let down the girls that I was running for and I’d really kind of got this narrative in my head and psyched myself up that what I was doing was just so insignificant in comparison to what they’re enduring

A picture

Circumcision kits found on sale on Amazon UK as concerns grow over harm to baby boys

Circumcision kits have been found on sale on Amazon UK, highlighting lax regulation as concerns grow about deaths and serious harm to baby boys.In December, a UK coroner issued warnings about insufficient circumcision regulation after the death in 2023 of a six-month-old boy, Mohamed Abdisamad, from a streptococcus infection.In a prevention of future deaths report, Dr Anton van Dellen, assistant coroner for west London, highlighted how “any individual may conduct a non-therapeutic male circumcision (NTMC) without any prior training”, with “no requirement for any infection control measures [and] no requirements for any aftercare”, adding that “action should be taken to prevent future deaths”.The Department of Health and Social Care has until the end of February to respond.The Guardian found “Plastibell” kits, in various sizes, on sale for £200 on Amazon in January

A picture

One in four UK teenagers in care have attempted to end their lives, study says

One in four teenagers in care have attempted to end their own life, and are four times more likely to do so than their peers with no care experience, according to a landmark study.The research analysed data from the millennium cohort study, which follows the lives of 19,000 people born in the UK between 2000 and 2002, and considered how out of home care, including foster, residential and kinship care, affected the social and mental health outcomes of the participants.More than one in four (26%) 17-year-olds who have lived in foster or residential care have attempted to end their own lives, the analysis found, compared with only one in 14 (7%) of teenagers with no experience of being in care.Although previous research has found that about 7% of UK children have attempted suicide by the age of 17, this study, conducted by academics from the UCL Centre for Longitudinal Studies and funded by the Nuffield Foundation, is the first to calculate the elevated suicide risk teenagers with care experience have.Lisa Harker, the director of the Nuffield Family Justice Observatory, said the fact that one in four care-experienced children had attempted suicide was a “national emergency”