Trussonomics still haunts parties’ economic promises in run-up to UK local elections | Phillip Inman
As local and regional elections across the UK loom into view, it is clear the spectre of Trussonomics lives on.The Greens, Reform UK, Your Party, Restore Britain, the Conservatives and even the Liberal Democrats cannot help making extravagant spending promises, often paid for by cutting something or borrowing more that, they argue, will have no negative economic consequences.Or if they do, the costs will be borne by people and businesses they do not care about.Only Keir Starmer and his cabinet colleagues seem to be immune to the hysterical demands for the UK government to somehow reconfigure the way the economy operates without any spillovers, unintended consequences or extra costs that nullify the supposed gains derived from the original policy.Liz Truss promised huge tax cuts worth £45bn paid for with extra borrowing and welfare “efficiencies”.
Directed mostly at richer people, the economic argument rested on unleashing an entrepreneurial spirit that would drag Britain out of a long period of low productivity and only incremental gains in average incomes.Heading into May’s local elections, there are many other magic bullet policies on offer.The Conservatives want to spend big after making savage cuts to welfare benefits.Among the headlines at the last Tory conference was the pledge to drive down the welfare bill by £23bn.“The culture of ‘something for nothing’ must end, now,” said the shadow chancellor, Mel Stride.
The Green party leader, Zack Polanski, has toned down some of the more radical elements of his party’s economic plans, although the agenda remains vague.If we examine what his colleagues proposed in the last election we can see free lunches littering every page.They proposed to increase taxes by more than £170bn a year by the end of the next parliament – including a £90bn a year tax on carbon emissions – to fund a similar-sized boost to day-to-day public spending.On the spending side of the ledger, they planned to top up the current £160bn capital spending budget by a whopping £90bn a year.Reform UK has embraced Trussonomics like no other party.
Its main general election pledge was to raise the threshold at which people start paying income tax from £12,570 to £20,000, at a cost to the exchequer of more than £40bn a year,Underlying many of these proposals is a sense that the UK can reverse more than 100 years of decline with a magician’s wand and, more than that, travel alone on this journey without needing to worry about the effect on financial markets or trading partners, and also while the old global order disintegrates,Donald Trump may be an extreme example of the desire among US citizens to maintain their standard of living inside a protective economic and military shield, yet there are plenty more like the current White House resident, both in the US and in other countries,In France, Marine Le Pen’s the National Rally trades blows with Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s France Unbowed (LFI) to gain the attention of those who believe economies and societies can be turned on their head in just a few weeks or months,They both touted dramatic policies that claimed to turn the French economic supertanker as if it were a skiff, targeting the rich, big business or immigrants for big savings and extra revenues.
Thankfully, the French electorate rejected gesture politics in last month’s local elections, preferring more centrist candidates.Not across the board, but in some key cities such as Paris and Marseille, it meant centre-left candidates who distanced themselves from both Mélenchon and Le Pen were victorious.There seemed to be a recognition that the reality of this decade – one characterised by two major wars costing trillions of dollars in lost output, a quantum technological shift and a rapidly changing climate – is that there are no easy answers.Labour’s route to riches, while staying within strict spending confines, was supposed to be extra economic growth.Rachel Reeves bet big that a spending splurge early in the parliament would spur the economy later on and at least in time for the next general election, if not the more imminent midterm verdict that is about to be delivered.
However, the damage done by the last government is still underestimated, leaving Labour with a much bigger hole in the public finances than even the £22bn Reeves publicised in her first months in office.There is still much that Labour could do with the money it has already set aside for investment if only ministers could make some decisions.Procrastination is the disease that infects Whitehall at the moment and Starmer must take a good deal of the blame for that.Once the government can show it achieves things with public money, it can justify taking more from the better off, knowing it won’t be wasted – at the moment there is only HS2 as a guide to how well ministers spend on new infrastructure.Yet the overarching theme must be that in an uncertain world, sensible, rational government is preferable to outlandish initiatives that create many outraged losers.
Truss was a disaster and not only because she believed major industrialised economies such as the UK (as opposed to Ireland or Switzerland) can cut taxes as a route to sustainable growth,It was the idea that an escape hatch, or an ejector seat if you prefer, is available that will, Artemis-like, propel the economy to a higher plane,
Rising star ‘Wreck-It Will’ Sherman has roots in US rugby’s past and eyes on its future
Will Sherman may be the future of US rugby, but his roots are in the game’s American past. The 22-year-old standout second-row forward for Anthem Rugby Carolina in Major League Rugby is the son of Wade Sherman, a member of a champion Cal Berkeley team that included Mark Bingham, who on 11 September 2001 was one of the Flight 93 passengers who fought their hijackers and kept it from reaching Washington.“There was a super old photo that my dad pulled up, and the first time I heard that story was from him,” Sherman said. “He was like, ‘That guy standing to my left is an American hero.’”Sherman “loves telling the story” of how his dad found rugby – which after all is the reason he found it too
NCAA women’s Final Four: UCLA 51-44 Texas; South Carolina 62-48 UConn – as it happened
On paper, South Carolina would be favored in the final. They beat an unbeaten and nearly unbeatable team convincingly. But as we’ve seen tonight, when you get the very best teams together in a competitive cauldron, what bubbles to the surface remains to be seen.Until then …Last bit on Auriemma – in the postgame interviews, Auriemma said he doesn’t regret what he said in his in-game interview about the officials, noting that he had a player change her jersey after it was ripped. But that player, Sarah Strong, ripped her own shirt
Geno Auriemma and Dawn Staley have tense postgame exchange after South Carolina shock UConn in Final Four
UConn coach Geno Auriemma and South Carolina coach Dawn Staley had a heated exchange on the sideline after the Gamecocks beat the undefeated Huskies 62-48 in Friday night’s semi-final of the women’s NCAA Tournament.South Carolina ended UConn’s winning streak at 54 games and secured a return trip to the national championship game.As the two met in front of the scorer’s table with 0.1 seconds left, Auriemma appeared to go to shake Staley’s hand and began yelling in her direction. Staley responded with words of her own
County cricket: Gay makes hay on opening day to blast season’s first century
DIVISION ONESophia Gardens: Glamorgan 99-4 v YorkshireSouthampton: Hampshire v Essex 219-3Grace Road: Leicestershire 15-1 v Sussex 361Taunton: Somerset 292-6 v NottinghamshireEdgbaston: Warwickshire v Surrey 328DIVISION TWOThe County Ground: Derbyshire 391-4 v WorcestershireChester le Street: Durham 335 v Kent 50-2Lord’s: Middlesex 279-5 v GloucestershireWantage Road: Northamptonshire v Lancashire 346-7The spectre of the Ashes loomed over day one of a new Championship season, every innings, every wicket, a play in one act sent straight to the laptop of Brendon McCullum.England Lion Emilio Gay won the race to the first century of the season for Durham, a classy innings, fierce on the loose ball, and in tricky conditions at Chester-le-Street. When he was finally out, a fourth catch of the day to Kent’s Zak Crawley, he had pocketed 128 from just 140 balls.Crawley’s turn with the bat went about as well as Jamie Smith’s and Ollie Pope’s over at Edgbaston, two boundaries before falling lbw to Matthew Potts for nine.At Grace Road Tom Clark embroidered a stylish 101, as Sussex gave promoted Leicestershire a bloody nose in the morning session, racing to 155 for two by lunch
Foakes to the rescue for Surrey as County Championship makes its earliest start
The County Championship whirred back into life on Good Friday, with 3 April its earliest start in history. By extension, Rory Burns claimed the record for its earliest dismissal, with Surrey’s captain run out 10 minutes into the day’s play at Edgbaston in a scene usually reserved for the village green.Cricket really can be a sod sometimes. All that pre-season graft, all those hours dreaming big, only to plink a drive early on, think it has beaten mid-off, and set off for the run in good faith. The throw from Warwickshire’s Ed Barnard may have been wild but Kai Smith mopped up smartly at the stumps
Timeforshowcasing into Classic contention after Burradon success
Charlie Johnston picked up a decent bonus on top of the trainer’s share of the prize money after backing Timeforshowcasing for the Burradon Stakes at Newcastle on Friday at prices up to 25-1, and could now fast-track his filly into Classic company at either Newmarket or the Curragh next month.Timeforshowcasing was up against some promising colts and geldings in the Listed contest over a mile but travelled easily through the early stages before taking it up at the furlong pole and holding off the late challenge of Padraig Dawn by a neck.“All day I’ve been thinking, ‘what do people know that I don’t?’, because this filly worked last Thursday and I thought she was in phenomenal order,” Johnston said.“She was 6-1, went out to 10-1, then 16s and she’s won at 25-1. I hope my bookmaker gives best odds guaranteed
Fair Work Agency’s priorities criticised days before its launch
Waitrose employee sacked after stopping shoplifter from taking Easter eggs
An AI bot invited me to its party in Manchester. It was a pretty good night
Kurt Strauss obituary
County cricket day two: Anderson rolls back the years with five-fer for Lancashire
Henry Arundell inspires Bath to come-from-behind win over Saracens