Judge cuts off Musk’s AI doomsday talk as his testimony ends in OpenAI case
Elon Musk’s court case against Sam Altman continued on Thursday, after a day of contentious exchanges during OpenAI’s cross-examination of the Tesla CEO.Musk faced more combative questioning throughout the morning, in a glimpse of what may await other prominent witnesses set to take the stand.Witness testimony and evidence has revealed formerly private emails, text messages and diary entries surrounding the formation of OpenAI, giving a behind-the-scenes look at how the tech behemoth was created.Many of the tech industry’s most powerful players are named as witnesses and will give their accounts on the origins of Musk and Altman’s bitter feud.Altman will testify later in the trial, which will last three weeks.
Musk, who co-founded OpenAI in 2015, is arguing that Altman, OpenAI and its president Greg Brockman broke a foundational agreement when they shifted the company from a non-profit intent on bettering humanity into a for-profit structure.Musk claims that Altman and Brockman unjustly enriched themselves and should be removed from the company.He is also seeking the undoing of the for-profit conversion and $134bn in damages to be redirected to OpenAI’s non-profit arm.OpenAI rejects Musk’s allegations and is attempting to show that Musk was always aware of plans for creating a for-profit entity.The AI firm’s attorneys have stated Musk is “motivated by jealousy” of OpenAI’s success after he left the company in 2018 after a failed attempt to take control.
OpenAI has emphasized that it is still overseen by a non-profit,OpenAI’s lead attorney, William Savitt, grilled Musk again on Thursday as the Tesla CEO bristled at his questions,As with the previous round of cross-examination, Savitt engaged in rapid-fire questioning about what Musk knew about OpenAI’s structure and forming a for-profit branch,In response to many of the questions, Musk took a defensive tone and repeated his go-to phrase in the trial that “you can’t just steal a charity”,At one point, Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers moved to strike Musk’s charity statement from the record, saying: “That portion is stricken, we’ve heard it many times.
”On Thursday, Savitt asked Musk several questions about the AI company he founded in 2023, xAI, and why he did not set it up as a non-profit.Musk, visibly rattled after Savitt cut him off if he responded at length, loudly said in a stern voice: “I started OpenAI as a non-profit.” He went on to explain that OpenAI converted into a for-profit only in the last few years.“That is the entire basis for this whole lawsuit,” Musk said.“Why would I start another non-profit when I already started a non-profit?”Musk’s lawyer, Steven Molo, redirected questions to his client after Savitt finished.
Molo asked Musk to reaffirm a point he had made earlier: that he was fine with OpenAI operating a for-profit entity, as long as it was in support of the non-profit,Molo then turned his questioning to Musk’s desire to create an AI army of robots and why he thinks this is necessary, something that came up in testimony the day before,“The worst-case situation is where it is a terminator situation,” Musk said, “where AI will kill us all,”Gonzalez Rogers cut in, saying it was time for the court to take a break,After the jury left the room, she spoke directly to Musk and his lawyers, telling them: “We are not going to talk much about extinction in this case.
They got it, that’s enough.”After Musk’s testimony wrapped, his longtime top lieutenant, Jared Birchall, took the stand.Birchall, who is CEO of Neuralink and runs Musk’s family office, said he started working for the billionaire in 2016 and got the job through a mutual acquaintance.He said he oversees Musk’s assets and resources.Birchall testified that he was in charge of sending Musk’s donations to OpenAI, but that all decision-making regarding those donations was done by Musk.
He said he sent approximately 60 contributions, amounting to roughly $38m, to OpenAI from Musk from 2016 to 2020,Much of OpenAI’s cross-examination of Birchall focused on documents detailing Musk’s donations to AI, which included paying rent for OpenAI at the Pioneer Building in San Francisco,The trial, which began on Monday with jury selection at a federal courthouse in Oakland, California, has already produced dramatic moments and bold accusations,Musk and Savitt spent most of Wednesday in a heated back-and-forth, with the world’s richest person becoming noticeably frustrated and saying that Savitt’s questions “are designed to trick me”,After court wrapped on Wednesday and the lawyers conferenced with the judge, Savitt groused about Musk being a difficult witness since he repeatedly refused to answer questions in a yes-and-no manner.
Gonzalez Rogers essentially told him to deal with it, saying that comes with litigation.Silicon Valley is intently watching the trial for both its blockbuster testimony and the potential effects it will have on the AI industry.OpenAI is intending to go public later this year at around a $1tn valuation, but if Musk succeeds in this case, it could greatly complicate that effort – an outcome that would also benefit Musk’s own xAI artificial intelligence firm.The nine-person jury will decide whether OpenAI is liable, but Judge Gonzalez Rogers will determine what, if any, remedies are necessary in the case.
Man who pocketed tiles from medieval priory as boy returns them 60 years later
Fragments of a priory’s medieval tiled floor that spent almost 60 years stashed in a toffee tin after being pocketed by a nine-year-old boy during a family outing have finally been handed back.The three pieces of decorative clay tiles, dating from the late 13th to early 14th century, were taken as a souvenir by Simon White during a family visit to Wenlock Priory in Shropshire in the late 1960s.White, now a 68-year-old retired chartered surveyor, found the fragments in an old toffee tin during a house move and owned up to English Heritage. He told officials he recalled his father encouraging him to take the pieces but had always felt a little uneasy and was delighted when he rediscovered them.“I can remember the day this all happened with my father standing guard,” he said
Seth Meyers on Trump’s ballroom push: ‘How is this their biggest priority?’
Late-night hosts responded to King Charles’s roasts of Donald Trump during his visit to the US Congress as Republicans try to force taxpayers to pay for Trump’s $400m gilded ballroom.“Donald Trump desperately wants to be a king,” said Seth Meyers on Wednesday evening. “We all know this. He loves pageantry and fanfare and putting his face and name on everything. His official store sells everything from Trump golf balls to Trump beer koozies to Trump pickleball paddles to Trump dog collars, which you could get in three sizes: poodle, doberman and JD Vance
The Festival of Britain opens – archive, May 1951
From our London staff 4 May 1951After an impressive service of dedication at St Paul’s this morning the king, in a broadcast speech from a dais outside the cathedral, proclaimed the Festival of Britain open. To-night he unveiled a tablet at the Royal Festival Hall before attending another service of dedication and hearing the first concert in the new hall.About 10,000 people were crowded into the semicircle of St Paul’s churchyard when the king stepped on to a dais at the top of the steps in front of the portico. The queen, Queen Mary, and other members of the royal family stood on his right as he made his broadcast speech. He referred to the contrast between the Victorian age and the hard experience of our own
Stephen Fry sues tech conference organisers for £100,000 over fall from stage
Stephen Fry is suing two companies that organised a tech conference where he was injured in 2023 after falling off the stage, high court documents show.The actor and presenter broke his hip and had multiple breaks in his right leg, pelvis and ribs when he attended the CogX festival at the O2 Arena, where he delivered a talk on artificial intelligence on 14 September 2023.Now, court documents show he is suing CogX Festival Ltd and Blonstein Events, bringing a claim for damages due to injuries sustained at the event.“The incident was caused by the negligence and/or breach of statutory duty of the defendants, its servants or agents, in failing to ensure that the stage and backstage area were safe, adequately lit and properly protected to prevent a fall from height,” the document reads.“The claimant claims damages for personal injuries and consequential losses up to £100,000, which includes an award for pain, suffering and loss of amenity exceeding £1,000, together with interest on damages … and costs
Jimmy Kimmel on the Trump administration: ‘They’ve hit peak ridiculous’
Late-night hosts roasted King Charles’s state visit and Donald Trump trying to push the cost of his $400m gilded ballroom on to taxpayers.Tuesday was “another weird day”, said Jimmy Kimmel on his most recent show. “There’s so much nonsense – and I mean that in a very literal sense of the word: non-sense happening. And at the same time, there are also so many awful and scary and flat-out unbelievable things going on. The world has been turned upside down, mostly for no good reason
Boom! A melodrama fit for Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton’s doomed love affair
“My very first memory is of pain.” More than a touch dramatic, the words could easily be lifted from the script of Boom! Instead, they are a real-life confession by its leading lady, Elizabeth Taylor.When it comes to pain, Taylor is the poster child-star. In her long life, the actor underwent more than 30 surgeries and was supposedly hospitalised on more than 100 occasions. After a bout of pneumonia almost took her out in 1961, it was the pain of nearly losing her that led to her best actress sympathy win at the Oscars
Solicitors report late flood of no-fault evictions before ban in England
Austerity to blame for the fall in healthy life expectancy | Letters
Why routine cancer tests have age limits | Brief letters
UK researchers develop tool to identify people most at risk of obesity-related diseases
Violence against women is at ‘breaking point’, says writer of John Worboys drama
Raise tax on alcohol and junk food to cut deaths from liver disease, experts say