AI could make it harder to establish blame for medical failings, experts say
The use of artificial intelligence in healthcare could create a legally complex blame game when it comes to establishing liability for medical failings, experts have warned.The development of AI for clinical use has boomed, with researchers creating a host of tools, from algorithms to help interpret scans to systems that can aid with diagnoses.AI is also being developed to help manage hospitals, from optimising bed capacity to tackling supply chains.But while experts say the technology could bring myriad benefits for healthcare, they say there is also cause for concern, from a lack of testing of the effectiveness of AI tools to questions over who is responsible should a patient have a negative outcome.Prof Derek Angus, of the University of Pittsburgh, said: “There’s definitely going to be instances where there’s the perception that something went wrong and people will look around to blame someone.
”The Jama summit on Artificial Intelligence, hosted last year by the Journal of the American Medical Association, brought together a panoply of experts including clinicians, technology companies, regulatory bodies, insurers, ethicists, lawyers and economists.The resulting report, of which Angus is first author, not only looks at the nature of AI tools and the areas of healthcare where they are being used, but also examines the challenges they present, including legal concerns.Prof Glenn Cohen from Harvard law school, a co-author of the report, said patients could face difficulties showing fault in the use or design of an artificial intelligence product.There could be barriers to gaining information about its inner workings, while it could also be challenging to propose a reasonable alternative design for the product or prove a poor outcome was caused by the AI system.He said: “The interplay between the parties may also present challenges for bringing a lawsuit – they may point to one another as the party at fault, and they may have existing agreement contractually reallocating liability or have indemnification lawsuits.
”Prof Michelle Mello, another author of the report, from Stanford law school, said courts were well equipped to resolve legal issues,“The problem is that it takes time and will involve inconsistencies in the early days, and this uncertainty elevates costs for everyone in the AI innovation and adoption ecosystem,” she said,The report also raises concerns about how AI tools are evaluated, noting many are outside the oversight of regulators such as the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA),Angus said: “For clinicians, effectiveness usually means improved health outcomes, but there’s no guarantee that the regulatory authority will require proof [of that],Then once it’s out, AI tools can be deployed in so many unpredictable ways in different clinical settings, with different kinds of patients, by users who are of different levels of skills.
There is very little guarantee that what seems to be a good idea in the pre-approval package is actually what you get in practice.”The report outlines that at present there are many barriers to evaluating AI tools including that they often need to be in clinical use to be fully assessed, while current approaches to assessment are expensive and cumbersome.Angus said it was important that funding was made available for the performance of AI tools in healthcare to be properly assessed, with investment in digital infrastructure a key area.“One of the things that came up during the summit was [that] the tools that are best evaluated have been least adopted.The tools that are most adopted have been least evaluated.
”
UK economy at risk of ‘bumpy landing’; JP Morgan’s Dimon warns of ‘more cockroaches’ after collapse of First Brands and Tricolor – as it happened
Bank of England policymaker Alan Taylor has warned that the UK economy is at a growing risk of “a bumpy landing”.Speaking at King’s College, Cambridge (Taylor’s alma mater) today, he sticks to his reputation as a dovish member of the Bank’s monetary policy committee. He predicts that wage settlements will be pushed down in “an economy with rising unemployment and weak demand”, meaning little risk of an upward spiral in wage-led domestic inflation.Taylor argues that there are now three plausible scenarios in 2026, of varying pain for consumers and businesses:The first scenario is the “soft landing”, which Taylor fears is receding in terms of probability.He says:By maintaining what I think is a too restrictive path of interest rates, we may have braked too hard, such that inflation cannot smoothly return to target with the economy close to potential, as my votes have indicated
US raised concerns about Chinese boss of chipmaker before Dutch takeover
US authorities had raised concerns about the boss of a China-owned chipmaker before it was taken over by the Dutch government this week, according to court papers.The documents show US officials warned the Netherlands in June that Nexperia may not be able to export to the US if its Chinese chief executive, Zhang Xuezheng, remained in post.Late on Sunday the Dutch government said it had invoked a cold war-era law to effectively take control of the company, citing “major shortcomings that could jeopardise security of supply” of chips to European factories.By that point Zhang had been suspended from Nexperia, which is controlled by the Chinese company Wingtech.It has now emerged that the US had raised concerns about Nexperia’s management as far back as June
The gospel according to Peter Thiel: why the tech svengali is obsessed with the antichrist
Hello, and welcome to TechScape. For the past week, my brain has been marinating in billionaire Peter Thiel’s byzantine musings about the antichrist and Armageddon. At this point, I’m pickled.Why, you might ask, does it matter what a billionaire thinks about the antichrist? Good question!To help us understand, my colleagues Johana Bhuiyan, Dara Kerr and Nick Robins-Early have reported on a series of talks given by billionaire political svengali and tech investor Thiel:Over the past month, Thiel has hosted four lectures on the downtown waterfront of San Francisco philosophizing about who the antichrist could be and warning that Armageddon is coming. Thiel, who describes himself as a “small-o Orthodox Christian”, believes the harbinger of the end of the world could already be in our midst and that things such as international agencies, environmentalism and guardrails on technology could quicken its rise
Instagram to bring in version of PG-13 system to protect children, says Meta
Instagram is to adopt a version of the PG-13 cinema rating system to give parents stronger controls over their teenagers’ use of the social media platform.Instagram, which is run by Meta, will start applying rules similar to the US “parental guidance” movie rating – first introduced 41 years ago – to all material on Instagram’s teen accounts. It means users aged under 18 will automatically be placed into the 13+ setting. They will be able to opt out only with their parents’ permission.While the teen accounts already hide or prohibit the recommendation of sexually suggestive content, graphic or disturbing images, and adult content such as tobacco or alcohol, the new PG-13 version will tighten restrictions further
MPs warned over ‘shameful’ lack of funding for GB athletes at Deaflympics
It is shameful and discriminatory that deaf people are the only disabled community that does not receive any government funding to help them compete in elite sport, MPs have been told.While UK Sport will invest £330m of government and national lottery funding into British Olympic and Paralympic sport over the Los Angeles 2028 cycle, the GB team for next month’s Deaflympics in Tokyo is having to raise the majority of the £450,000 costs themselves.That is despite the Deaflympics having been established in 1924 and been recognised by the International Olympic Committee in 1955, over three decades before the Paralympics, the culture, media and sport select committee was told.Chris Ratcliffe, the CEO of UK Deaf Sport, told MPs: “When it comes to elite sport, we are the only disabled elite sports group that have no access to funding whatsoever. I think that’s shameful, speaking forthrightly
RFL close to selling stake in expanded Super League to private equity
The Rugby Football League is in advanced talks with several private equity firms about selling a stake in Super League.The Guardian has learned that the RFL has had multiple offers from funds interested in buying into the competition after the collapse of a proposed investment in Super League from Australia’s National Rugby League.One of the approaches is understood to be from LionCap Global, a US-based investment firm that incorporated a UK company in May as a precursor to investing in this country. Talks have also taken place with Oakwell Sports Advisory, the London-based firm that brokered CVC Capital Partners’ investments in rugby union’s Six Nations Championship and Premiership Rugby.A spokesperson for Rugby League Commerical, an offshoot of the RFL in charge of their commercial, sponsorship and broadcast rights negotiations, told the Guardian: “One of the workstreams emanating from the Strategic Review held earlier this year has been to explore recapitalisation of the sport, including the Super League
US shares risk ‘sharp correction’ but markets seem complacent, IMF warns
World economy resilient amid Trump tariffs but outlook looks ‘dim’, says IMF
Bose QuietComfort Ultra 2 review: the most comfortable noise cancelling headphones
What does the end of free support for Windows 10 mean for its users?
The Breakdown | South American rugby success stories propel men's World Cup qualifying
Beau Greaves stuns Luke Littler in PDC world youth championship thriller