Ministers block Lords bid to make AI firms declare use of copyrighted content

A picture


Ministers have used an arcane parliamentary procedure to block an amendment to the data bill that would require artificial intelligence companies to disclose their use of copyright-protected content.The government stripped the transparency amendment, which was backed by peers in the bill’s reading in the House of Lords last week, out of the draft text by invoking financial privilege, meaning there is no budget available for new regulations, during a Commons debate on Wednesday afternoon.The amendment, which would have required tech companies to reveal which copyrighted material is used in their models, was tabled by the crossbench peer Beeban Kidron and was passed by 272 votes to 125 in a Lords debate last week.There were 297 MPs who voted in favour of removing the amendment, while 168 opposed.The data protection minister, Chris Bryant, told MPs that although he recognised that for many in the creative industries this “feels like an apocalyptic moment”, he did not think the transparency amendment delivered the required solutions, and he argued that changes needed to be completed “in the round and not just piecemeal”.

The sooner the data bill was passed, the quicker he would be able to make progress on updating copyright law, Bryant said.Lady Kidron said: “The government failed to answer its own backbenchers who repeatedly asked ‘if not now then when?’ and the minister replied with roundtable reviews and spurious problems about technical solutions.It is for government to set the laws and incentivise companies to obey it not run roundtables trying to work out technical solutions that they are not fit to provide.“It is astonishing that a Labour government would abandon the labour force of an entire sector.My inbox is filled with individual artists and global companies who are bewildered that the government would allow theft at scale and cosy up to those who are thieving.

There is another way, but this government have chosen to ignore it.“Across the creative and business community, across parliament, people are gobsmacked that the government is playing parliamentary chess with their livelihoods.”Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotionKidron will table a rephrased amendment before the bill’s return to the Lords next week, setting the scene for another confrontation.This could include removing the reference to regulation, or omitting a timeframe for it to be implemented.Owen Meredith, the chief executive of the News Media Association, said: “It is extremely disappointing that the government has failed to listen to the deep concerns of the creative industries, including news publishers who are so fundamental to uploading our democratic values, by rejecting the House of Lords amendments that would have given a workable and proportionate level of transparency to creators over the use of their works by AI.

“Instead, the government has used parliamentary procedure to dismiss industry concerns, rather than taking this timely opportunity to introduce the transparency that will drive a dynamic licensing market for the UK’s immensely valuable creative content.There is still time for parliament to back our great British creative industries, while supporting AI firms’ access to high-quality data, as the bill heads back to the Lords.The government must recognise the urgent need to take the necessary powers now.”Last week, hundreds of artists and organisations including Paul McCartney, Jeanette Winterson, Dua Lipa and the Royal Shakespeare Company urged the prime minister not to “give our work away at the behest of a handful of powerful overseas tech companies”.The government’s copyright proposals are the subject of a consultation due to report back this year, but opponents of the plans have used the data bill as a vehicle for registering their disapproval.

The main government proposal is to let AI firms use copyright-protected work to build their models without permission unless the copyright holders opt out – a solution that critics say is unworkable.The government insists that the creative and tech sectors are being held back and this needs to be resolved through new legislation.It has already tabled one concession in the data bill by committing to an economic impact assessment of its proposals.A Department for Science, Innovation and Technology spokesperson said: “We want our creative industries and AI companies to flourish, which is why we have been separately consulting on a package of measures that we hope will work for both sectors.We have always been clear that we will not rush into any decisions or bring forward any legislation until we are confident that we have a practical plan which delivers on each of our objectives.

businessSee all
A picture

Anglian Water fined record £1.42m for contaminating water supply

Anglian Water has been fined a record £1.42m for contaminating the water supply.The company, which covers the east of England, received the fine at Northampton crown court after a prosecution brought by the Drinking Water Inspectorate (DWI) for failures that affected 1.3 million people.An investigation found that between June and December 2021 the company used unapproved materials in five drinking water tanks at four sites across its network

A picture

UK Peppa Pig toy firm says trading ‘uncertain’ as US-China shipments on hold

A British manufacturer that makes Peppa Pig and Fireman Sam toys has said trading with the US remains “uncertain” after it paused shipping Chinese-made products to the country because of Donald Trump’s tariffs.London-listed Character Group said on Friday that it had put shipments from China to the US “on hold” in April after the White House announced hefty levies for imports of Chinese-made goods.The company also withdrew its guidance for the current financial year last month, as a result of the introduction of tariffs by the US.Sales of Character’s products in the US, including stretchy action figures in the Heroes of Goo Jit Zu collection, represented 20% of the group’s revenues in the last financial year, which ended on 31 August 2024. The company said “substantially all” of its products sold in the US were manufactured in China

A picture

She earned $20 doing laundry for a friend. Now this entrepreneur washes 7,000lb a month

The first time Hyacinth Tucker did someone else’s laundry, she earned $20. “I didn’t think of it as a business. This was just another side hustle,” she said. It was 2022 and the Maryland-based army veteran needed money.She was going through a divorce, and Covid had staunched the flow of income from the event facilities she owned, so she had taken to driving for Uber and pet-sitting

A picture

King Charles’s wealth swells to match Rishi Sunak and Akshata Murty on UK rich list

King Charles’s personal fortune increased to £640m in the past year, making him as wealthy as the former prime minister Rishi Sunak and his wife, Akshata Murty, according to the Sunday Times rich list.The 76-year-old monarch, who acceded to the throne in 2022, recorded a £30m increase in wealth and ranks joint 238th on the list of the UK’s wealthiest people and families.The estimate of the king’s wealth is based on personal assets, including the investment portfolio he inherited from his late mother and private estates at Sandringham and Balmoral, and does not include the crown estate.Charles is now estimated to be worth considerably more than the late Queen Elizabeth II, whose wealth was put at £370m in 2022.However, an investigation by the Guardian in 2023 estimated that King Charles’s fortune could be almost £2bn

A picture

Foreign states should not be co-owners of UK newspapers | Nils Pratley

‘We are fully upholding the need to safeguard our news media from foreign state control while recognising that news organisations must be able to raise vital funding,” said Lisa Nandy, the culture secretary, alighting on 15% as the limit for foreign state ownership of a UK newspaper company.She is obviously right that it is harder for companies to raise money if a pool of potential capital – state-controlled sovereign wealth funds and their like – are off-limits. No wonder some media owners lobbied for a percentage higher than the 5% that was being considered by the previous government as a tweak to last year’s legislation that set the cap at zero.But she is naive if she thinks 15% will ensure “minimal risk” of foreign state influence. That is not how the world works: 15% is a hefty foot in the door

A picture

Wealthy Britons avoiding more tax than previously thought, spending watchdog says

Wealthy individuals in Britain could be avoiding more tax than had been thought, the government’s spending watchdog has said, after a dramatic fall in the number of penalties being issued to the super-rich.In a report urging ministers to redouble their efforts to secure more of the money owed by wealthy people to the exchequer, the National Audit Office (NAO) said billions of pounds was going unpaid each year.It said that HMRC had greatly increased the additional tax revenue it was collecting from wealthy individuals by tackling non-compliance, but that additional steps were required to ensure rich people paid their fair share.It comes as Rachel Reeves, the chancellor, faces renewed pressure to find extra money for public services and defence, amid warnings that she could be forced to raise taxes in the autumn budget.Nick Williams, an ex-No 10 senior economic adviser, who left his post last month, said on Thursday Reeves’s spending plans were “not credible” and needed to be reassessed