Lords examine new amendment to data bill to require AI firms declare use of copyrighted content
A new amendment to the data bill that would require artificial intelligence companies to disclose their use of copyright-protected content has been tabled, after MPs voted to remove an earlier version on Wednesday.The amendment by the cross-bench peer and former film director Beeban Kidron will be a fresh challenge to plans to let artificial intelligence firms use copyright-protected work without permission.It circumvents the financial privilege grounds – meaning there is no budget available for the regulation – on which its predecessor was rejected..The new wording states the government “may” make enforcement provisions rather than “must”, and gives no detail about how the government could enforce them.
It will be put to peers in the House of Lords for debate on 19 May after the earlier version of the amendment passed by 272 votes to 125 in a debate on Monday,Lady Kidron said: “We have accepted the speaker’s ruling on the Commons financial privilege and replaced the original amendment with another that would still offer transparency,“We very much hope that the government will accept it because it is in line with the review that they have proposed and the transparency that they have repeatedly said is a key to the outcome,But what it offers the creative industries and UK AI companies is a clear timeline, and a mechanism by which licensing and not stealing can become the norm,”Owen Meredith, chief executive of the News Media Association, said: “This new amendment removes any potential direct spending implications for enforcement – which was the Commons’ objection to the previous drafting – and would ensure copyright owners receive clear, relevant, accurate and accessible information about how their work is accessed and used, but gives the government flexibility over exactly how this is achieved.
“The entire creative industries, the voting public, and multiple parliamentary reports and debates have given a clear view to the government that action now to ensure rights holders are better equipped to enforce the existing law, with the proportionate application of transparency, is a progressive way forward,It’s time to act, not just ‘listen’,”In Wednesday’s debate, the data protection minister, Chris Bryant, told MPs that although he recognised that for many in the creative industries this “feels like an apocalyptic moment”, he did not think the transparency amendment delivered the required solutions, and he argued that changes needed to be completed “in the round and not just piecemeal”,He added that the sooner the data bill was passed, the quicker he would be able to make progress on updating copyright law,The government’s copyright proposals are the subject of a consultation due to report back this year, but opponents of the plans have used the data bill as a vehicle for registering their disapproval.
The main government proposal is to let AI firms use copyright-protected work to build their models without permission unless the copyright holders opt out – a solution that critics say is unworkable.
US PGA Championship 2025: second round – as it happened
Thanks for reading today. A few shots still to be played before everything is wrapped up but no television pictures so we’ll bid farewell.Scott Murray will guide you through all the weekend action. Can Rory McIlroy repeat history? Will Bryson DeChambeau fire? Is Scottie Scheffler going to land a third major championship victory? Or are we due a surprise? Join Scott tomorrow to find out!The Venezuela player holds a two-shot advantage over the field, but Scottie Scheffler will be the man whose shadow looms darkest for the pace-setter.-8: Vegas (F) -6: Pavon (F), Fitzpatrick (F), SW Kim (F) -5: Homa (F), Scheffler (F) -4: Stevens, (F), MacIntyre (F), Poston (F), Smalley (F), Fox (F), Bezuidenhout (F), Thorbjornsen (F), McCarthy (F), Gerard (F), Higgo (17)Catch up with the day’s action with Ewan Murray’s report
Tyrrell Hatton faces fine for US PGA outburst as Vegas leads the pack
Tyrrell Hatton’s love-hate relationship with his professional domain continues. The Englishman will inevitably be fined after a foul-mouthed tirade during his second round of the US PGA Championship was picked up on live television coverage.Hatton was within a shot of the lead when reaching the tee at the 18th, his 9th. Hatton’s drive found a water hazard. What happened next was rather typical for a player prone to tempestuous moments on golf courses
Brock Purdy reportedly agrees to $265m extension with San Francisco 49ers
The San Francisco 49ers and quarterback Brock Purdy have agreed to a five-year, $265m contract extension, ESPN’s Adam Schefter reported Friday. The deal includes $181m in guaranteed money, solidifying Purdy’s role as the franchise quarterback moving forward.Purdy, 25, was the final pick of the 2022 NFL draft – familiarly known as ‘Mr Irrelevant’ – but quickly defied expectations. After stepping in as the starter midway through his rookie season, Purdy led the 49ers to back-to-back playoff appearances, including a trip to the Super Bowl in February 2024. He was also named to the Pro Bowl and finished fourth in MVP voting that season
Jannik Sinner recovers to beat Paul and set up dream Rome final against Alcaraz
Four matches into his comeback at the Italian Open, the level displayed by Jannik Sinner had only underscored his status as the best tennis player in the world. He had marched past every challenge in his path, reaching the semi-finals without dropping a set.Consistent excellence in professional tennis, however, also means finding solutions when things aren’t going well. Sinner handled his first real challenge in Rome spectacularly well, recovering from heavily losing the first set to smother Tommy Paul of the United States 1-6, 6-0, 6-3. “These kind of matches I need,” said Sinner
In-form George Ford guides Sale to emphatic win over playoff rivals Bristol
This match was billed as a shootout for a playoff place, which was only a slight exaggeration, and Sale won emphatically to leapfrog Bristol and take a huge stride towards confirming a top-four finish.Alex Sanderson’s men are formidable on home soil and a bonus-point success, orchestrated by another masterly display from George Ford, gave them a 26th win from 29 Premiership games in Salford dating back to the start of the 2022- 23 campaign. It was no less than Sale deserved, such was the energy and effervescence of their display in running in five tries past one of their closest rivals, who claimed a potentially priceless losing bonus point late on.Sale travel to Exeter in their final game knowing a win will put them in the playoffs for the third consecutive season, while Bristol host Harlequins in a fortnight with their top-four hopes more in the balance.“I still have nightmares about going to Exeter three or four years ago when I first signed for Sale and being 19-0 up but ending up losing the game,” said Sanderson
Bairstow shines at the Oval, bees stop play at New Road: county cricket – as it happened
In Division One, a feisty Jonny Bairstow frisked 89 at a honey-warm Oval, where the Guardian football writer Jonathan Wilson and his stag do were among the 6,000 spectators. There were three wickets apiece for Surrey’s Jordan Clark and Tom Lawes and a gravity-defying catch by Ben Foakes, hanging in the air like an unvoiced memory. Adam Lyth added another fifty to his hefty season’s collection, but Yorkshire wilted after tea.The Nottinghamshire captain Haseeb Hameed was a sea of calm on a stormy scorecard at Chester-le-Street, carrying his bat for 206. Brydon Carse, playing in his first game for Durham this season after a toe injury, bowled through 14 overs, and grabbed three wickets
Anglian Water fined record £1.42m for contaminating water supply
UK Peppa Pig toy firm says trading ‘uncertain’ as US-China shipments on hold
She earned $20 doing laundry for a friend. Now this entrepreneur washes 7,000lb a month
King Charles’s wealth swells to match Rishi Sunak and Akshata Murty on UK rich list
Foreign states should not be co-owners of UK newspapers | Nils Pratley
Wealthy Britons avoiding more tax than previously thought, spending watchdog says