AFL State of Origin return was no kick and giggle but spectre of injury hangs over its future | Jonathan Horn

A picture


Even for the most sceptical, there was never any question that the quality of skill in the State of Origin’s return game would be exceptional.There were three Brownlow medallists, two Coleman medallists, 29 All-Australians and 19 premiership players.Patrick Dangerfield and Max Gawn had 16 All-Australian blazers between them, more than the entire Western Australian squad combined.The doubt lay in how hard the players would go, and how seriously they would take it.How much would they be willing to risk? And how far down the well – in the middle of a Perth summer and with no serious game time in the legs for nearly five months – were they prepared to go?The game was heavily marketed, and backed with a lot of money from the WA government.

Indeed, Channel 7 did a preview show on Thursday night, which was basically an infomercial spruiking the majesty and magnificence of all things Western Australia.The only thing missing was Basil Zempilas shucking an oyster.It’s important that sceptics like myself acknowledge what a success this game was.I thought it would be an exhibition game.But this was no kick and giggle.

The players asked for it.They said all the right words.And they backed it up.The evidence was in all the little things you look for in a normal home and away season.It was the way defenders hurled themselves back into packs.

It was the ferocity in which midfielders attacked contests,It was the way exhausted and cramping players were still mowing down their opponents in the final term,Nick Daicos was booed every time he touched the ball, which was a bit rough for a bloke who’d been shilling for Tourism WA for the past three days,But Lachie Ash, probably the most anonymous of the Victorian players, was a good choice as the EJ Whitten medallist,The announcement of Ash’s honour was met with bewilderment online and inside Optus Stadium, but his long kicks opened up the Sandgropers all night.

Besides, the voting panel of Chris Scott, Sam Mitchell and Garry Lyon was reasonably well placed to determine who their most influential player was.And it was good, for a change, that the player with the most touches didn’t automatically win a medal.It was a terrific contest.But the game was always going to be loaded with risk.The vision of a chalk-white Mark Keane slapping his leg back together would have been in the back of every player’s mind.

Even worse was the serious knee injury to GWS midfielder Tom Green just 24 hours earlier.Lyon, in his ambassadorial role, said injuries can happen anywhere, at any time.Look at Will Day, he said.But the Hawthorn star injured himself in a club program, with a long-term goal in mind, and every Hawks supporter understood that.Carlton fans probably took a little more convincing when Jacob Weitering was in a neck brace.

He injured himself in an act that personified the intensity of Saturday’s game, lunging a little bit more desperately than he would have in an intraclub game, and feeling the full tonnage of two large men.“That’ll squeeze the juice out of you,” commentator Brian Taylor squawked.Taylor has considerable history when it comes to misdiagnosis and every time he said “it’s just precautionary”, I added another month to the amount of time Weitering would be missing.Indeed, there was plenty to be precautionary about – the neck, the brain, the spine, the shoulder, the ribs.There was a lot of footballing flash on display on Saturday night but there’s nothing flashy about Weitering.

In terms of structure and basic competence, he’s just about the Blues’ most important player,And there’s not a lot of Geoff Southbys, Bruce Doulls and Stephen Silvagnis waiting to replace him,The question now is what the AFL will do with this format,South Australians will certainly embrace it,Perth deserves another crack as soon as possible.

The locals came out in droves, the same way they packed the stadium for the Big Bash League final, and the same way they provided the best atmosphere of the season in last year’s elimination final.But the spectre of injury will always hang over the fixture.It’s a game that supporters, coaches and high performance managers will watch with their hearts in their mouths.Weitering has been cleared of any neck, spinal or major internal injuries, with further investigations required to assess soreness he is still experiencing in his chest.Like 49 other players, he knew the stakes and he rolled the dice.

But when things go wrong, it’s his club that pays the price.
societySee all
A picture

More than 60 children infected in north London measles outbreak

More than 60 children have been infected by a measles outbreak in north London, it has been reported.Seven schools and a nursery in Enfield reported the cases, with some children treated in hospital, according to the Sunday Times.There are concerns the outbreak is linked to low levels of MMR vaccination in the capital. For every one infected person, measles can spread to up to 18 unvaccinated people.Dudu Sher-Arami, Enfield’s director of public health who is writing to every parent in the area, said the outbreak posed a serious threat to the wider capital and there was the potential to cause a “much greater and bigger pan-London outbreak” because residents travel across the city

A picture

Vaping in cars carrying children to be banned in England

Vaping in cars carrying anyone under 18 will be banned in England under government plans to reduce the harm caused by smoking and e-cigarettes.The move is included in the tobacco and vapes bill, which will also outlaw smoking, vaping and using heated tobacco in playgrounds and outside schools and hospitals.Smoking in cars containing children and young people up to the age of 18 has been illegal in England since 2015. The new legislation will extend that prohibition to the use of vapes and heated tobacco.“No child in a playground or hospital patient should suffer because someone else chooses to smoke,” said Wes Streeting, the health secretary

A picture

When it comes to mental health labels, we need to tread lightly | Letters

Thank you, Gavin Francis, for your long read (‘What I see in clinic is never a set of labels’: are we in danger of overdiagnosing mental illness?, 10 February). It powerfully captures some of the traps modern psychiatry finds itself in and beautifully describes the all-important – and indeed, threatened – relationship at the heart of any good doctor’s practice. I have been a psychiatrist and psychotherapist for over 40 years and would like to make two points about the “epidemic” of mental illness now upon us.First, there is a mass of evidence that shows mental ill-being, suffering and disturbance, at all degrees of severity, are affected by the level of inequality in society and by social hardship such as poverty, violence and discrimination. Between them, this explains some of the increase we are seeing

A picture

Can we make a plea for 'thank yous' | Letters

I do not agree with Sangeeta Pillai (The hill I will die on: Britons love saying thank you – I think we should ban the phrase, 7 February). I do not like sarcastic or passive aggressive “thank yous”, but what is wrong with thanking people in the service industry for the service they give? I do not believe that it is overworked or meaningless. I love to thank baristas, shop assistants, bus drivers or other people because they more often than not provide a very good service. They work hard and are not paid a lot of money. They are often people doing jobs that are difficult for one reason or another

A picture

All men have a responsibility to challenge misogyny | Letter

The Buckingham Palace statement (King Charles ‘ready to support’ police over claims about Andrew, 9 February) should be welcomed, but should have come sooner, acknowledging as it does the responsibility we have for the acts of others, not only for our own.Male violence against women and girls is not the preserve of the rich and powerful. It is evident in every strata of society: behind closed doors in domestic abuse, in the spiked drinks in clubs and pubs, in the trafficking and rape of girls by grooming gangs of every ethnicity, in the offices of the Metropolitan police, in the genital mutilation of hundreds of thousands of women across the globe. I could go on.In every iteration, it is an expression of power: of power over women, of power over other men, or of power created and shored up between men

A picture

Criminals exploit ‘stigma and embarrassment’ to sell fake erectile dysfunction drugs

Men have been warned against buying illegal erectile dysfunction pills online after nearly 20m pills – enough to fill two doubledecker buses – were seized in the last five years.The “stigma and embarrassment” of erectile dysfunction is being “exploited by criminals”, according to the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA).Between 2021 and 2025, the MHRA’s criminal enforcement unit, working closely with Border Force to intercept shipments, seized about 19.5m doses of erectile dysfunction medicines, equivalent to a single dose for three in every four adult men in the UK. Many of the pills seized contained no active ingredient, the wrong dose, hidden drugs or toxic ingredients, the MHRA said