Heraskevych’s ‘helmet of memory’ forces IOC into PR fiasco at Winter Olympics | Sean Ingle

A picture


Skeleton racer sacrificed his dream of winning a medal and succeeded in putting the horrors of the war in Ukraine back on the agendaTo be an Olympic-class skeleton racer requires extraordinary guts and impeccable nerve, as the corners loom and then whoosh past at frightening speed.So did anybody really believe that Ukraine’s Vladyslav Heraskevych would lose his when the world’s eyes were upon him?Not the International Olympic Committee, who flipped between threats of expulsion and sweet talk over the past fortnight, without coming close to changing his mind.And certainly not those of us who have spoken and messaged Heraskevych, and found a man utterly prepared to sacrifice his dream of winning a Winter Olympic medal for a higher purpose.In public and private his message was the same: he would not back down.And if the IOC barred from competing in his “helmet of memory”, which commemorates some of the 600 Ukrainian athletes and coaches killed by Russian bombs and bullets since 2022, he would accept his fate.

And when the moment came, shortly before 8.30am on Thursday, he met it with a powerful but resolute message: “This is price of our dignity,” alongside a photo of his helmet.For the IOC it must have been like watching a public relations car crash from the passenger seat.One that everyone knew was going to happen – and nothing could be done about it.Partly that was because Heraskevych’s messaging was so clever and precise.

He didn’t focus on statements about Russian aggression.Instead he spoke powerfully of wanting to honour his fallen friends.That allowed him to claim his message didn’t violate the IOC’s rules banning political expression on the field of play.Did everyone believe it? No.But it was a deft sidestep.

Heraskevych also cut through with his claims that the IOC was inconsistent in its application of its rules over athlete expression.At the opening ceremony, for instance, his fellow skeleton racer, Israel’s Jared Firestone, wore a commemorative kippah to remember the 11 victims of the Munich massacre at the 1972 Games, which said: “We remember.We endure.We rise.”This week the US skater Maxim Naumov, who lost his parents in the Potomac air collision last year, honoured them by holding up a photograph in their memory after he competed.

Why, Heraskevych pointed out, was his case any different?Finally, as he stated in his submission to the court of arbitration for sport in an attempt to overturn his ban on Thursday evening, was the IOC’s decision really proportionate?All that said, the IOC did try avert one of the most controversial moments of recent Olympics.Its president, Kirsty Coventry, went to Cortina in a last-ditch attempt to break the impasse.The fact that she did so, and was in tears afterwards, said a lot about her compassion and leadership style.However, allowing Heraskevych to use his helmet in practice and letting him wear a black armband in competition was never going to be enough to change his mind.This is not the IOC of her predecessor, Thomas Bach, who seemed to only smile in public when votes were needed at elections.

And this is certainly not the IOC of a generation or two ago.When Tommie Smith and John Carlos were kicked out for their black power salute at the 1968 Olympics it came at the urging of the then IOC president Avery Brundage – a man who repeatedly defended Nazi Germany before and after the 1936 Games when president of the US Olympic Committee.Brundage was at it again in 1972 in Munich when the American 400m athletes Vincent Matthews and Wayne Collett were given a lifetime ban from the Olympics after turning their backs to the US flag on the podium.“A disgusting display,” he called it.So times have changed.

But the problem the IOC has is that it clings to the old lie that sport and politics can be separated.Remember that it was only last week that the IOC – along with Fifa – was making noises about bringing Russia back into the sporting fold.This is the same Russia that tried to hack the Milano Cortina website before these Games.That launched a sophisticated cyber-attack at the Winter Olympics opening ceremony in Pyeongchang.And, most famously of all, corrupted the 2014 Winter Games in Sochi by doping its athletes – with a scheme that involved using a mousehole to swap steroid-riddled urine samples with clean ones.

Russia has, according to Ukraine, also destroyed more than 800 sports facilities, including over 20 Olympic, Paralympic and Deaflympic training centres.I am not convinced the IOC was doing Russia’s propaganda for them, as Heraskevych and the Global Athlete organisation has claimed.But it was certainly a terrible look to ban an athlete for wanting to pay homage to his friends, while his country is being hit with ballistic missiles and you have recently made cooing noises to Russia.The question is, could the IOC have done anything differently? Perhaps, but extending its rigid insistence that the field of play was sacrosanct and should be free of any political or social protest to include acts of bereavement made a compromise almost impossible.It is also the case that, as one insider put it to me, if the “helmet of memory” had been approved, the IOC could have potentially opened up Pandora’s box and set a precedent.

Could you imagine the furore if the Iranian government forced its athletes to mourn the head of the revolutionary guard, say, after he was assassinated?But perhaps there was a way,After all, if the IOC was able to set up an independent panel to decide whether Russians could compete as Authorised Neutral Athletes, why could they not have done the same for Heraskevych and other such cases? And maybe the IOC could have even looked the other way, and allowed him to compete,It would have made a ripple, for sure,But a day later we would have been on to the next ski jumping penisgate or biathlete cheating on his girlfriend story,That’s how fast the Olympics news cycle moves.

But there is one thing we can say for certain: Heraskevych has got the horrors of the war in Ukraine back on the agenda, which was his aim all along.The Russian team will be back at the Winter Paralympics later this month.And last week there were suggestions that the Olympic team would be reinstated this year.The latter decision has surely been pushed back now.So while Heraskevych has lost his battle to compete – at least until Cas rules – he has taken a stand that will live long in the memory, and certainly won the public relations war.

societySee all
A picture

Youth work ‘black holes’ in half of all council areas in England, study finds

Almost half of all council areas in England have youth work “black holes” with few or no services despite high levels of deprivation and antisocial behaviour, analysis shows.The first mapping in decades of youth centres across the country has revealed a nationwide crisis in youth support and significant inequality. Poorer areas in the north of England are shown to have been the worst affected by cuts to youth services since 2010.The research, produced by the charity funder Social Investment Business (SIB) and the University of Leeds, plotted youth services against the needs of the local population for the first time and found “a consistent picture of youth work black holes” across the country.Bethia McNeil, the director of quality and impact at the YMCA, the country’s largest youth charity, said: “Having this data is critical – we haven’t had anything like this in a very long time, probably since 2010, and youth provision has changed dramatically since then

A picture

One in 14 children who die in England have closely related parents, study finds

One in 14 children who died in England in a four-year period had parents who were close relatives, according to “stark” figures revealed by the first study of its kind.The figures, published by the National Child Mortality Database (NCMD), based at the University of Bristol, analysed all 13,045 child deaths in England between 2019 and 2023. Of these, 926 (7%) were found to be of children born to consanguineous parents, meaning the mother and father are close blood relatives, such as first cousins.Although the exact number of children with consanguineous parents across England is unclear, the data clearly shows their overrepresentation within mortality statistics and requires “urgent action”, according to researchers.The largest geographical estimate of consanguinity currently available is from a large study following the lives of 13,000 babies born in Bradford

A picture

Parents of children taken in to care should get more help, say experts after Victoria Marten death

Parents whose children are taken into care should receive trauma-informed support to reduce the risk of harm to any further babies they have, according to child protection experts.A national child safeguarding review, launched after the death of baby Victoria Marten, said that if “destructive cycles of harm are to be interrupted” there needed to be more focus on parents, as well as their vulnerable baby or unborn infant.Victoria died in January 2023 after her parents, Constance Marten and her convicted rapist partner, Mark Gordon, took her to live in a tent in wintry conditions to evade social services. The child’s decomposed remains were found by police officers in March that year.The pair, who were jailed last September for 14 years for killing their newborn baby, had fled authorities to prevent Victoria being taken into care, as four older siblings had been previously, their Old Bailey case heard

A picture

Reading and writing can lower dementia risk by almost 40%, study finds

Reading, writing and learning a language or two can lower your risk of dementia by almost 40%, according to a study that suggests millions of people could prevent or delay the condition.Dementia is one of the world’s biggest health threats. The number of people living with the condition is forecast to triple to more than 150 million globally by 2050, and experts say it presents a big and rapidly growing threat to future health and social care systems in every community, country and continent.US researchers found that engaging in intellectually stimulating activities throughout life, such as reading, writing or learning a new language, was associated with a lower risk of Alzheimer’s disease, the most common form of dementia, and slower cognitive decline.The study author Andrea Zammit, of Rush University Medical Center in Chicago, said the discovery suggested cognitive health in later life was “strongly influenced” by lifelong exposure to intellectually stimulating environments

A picture

Psychiatric drugs aren’t always the answer | Letter

Yes, there has been a shocking lack of progress in developing transformative psychiatric medicine (We need new drugs for mental ill-health, 5 February), but this may be because in mental health, drugs are not always the answer (see, for example, Richard P Bentall’s Doctoring the Mind).Huge progress has been made in the effectiveness of talking therapies – for example, free effective treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is available to all UK army veterans through the charity PTSD Resolution.What is lacking is rollout of the effective methods that now exist. This is an area where the UK is genuinely world leading. The Human Givens Institute is at the forefront of the development of effective, solution-focused, science-based therapies

A picture

Exercise can be ‘frontline treatment’ for mild depression, researchers say

Aerobic exercise such as running, swimming or dancing can be considered a frontline treatment for mild depression and anxiety, according to research that suggests working out with others brings the most benefits.Scientists analysed published reviews on exercise and mental health and found that some of the greatest improvements were observed in young adults and new mothers – groups that are considered particularly vulnerable to mental health problems.While aerobic group exercise emerged as the most effective physical activity for reducing depression and anxiety, low-intensity programmes that lasted only a couple of months may be best for anxiety, the researchers said.“Exercise can have a similar effect, and sometimes a stronger impact, than traditional treatments,” said Neil Munro, a psychologist at James Cook University in Queensland, Australia. “Getting moving, in whatever shape or form works best for each person, can help mitigate depression and anxiety symptoms