County cricket’s restructure: what is being proposed and how will it work?

1 day ago

It feels symptomatic of English cricket’s dysfunctional nature that, having started the summer with five different options for a restructured County Championship, the 18 first-class chairs will conclude a tortuous process next week with a sixth on the table,International peace treaties have been negotiated quicker than talks over whether, and how, to cut a handful of playing days from a domestic calendar that, with four different competitions and formats to accommodate, is bursting at the seams,The tongue-in-cheek words of the England and Wales Cricket Board’s managing director of the professional game, Rob Andrew, when announcing the review in April have proved prophetic,“We have 18 counties that agree it’s not right, but 19 different versions of what the answer is,” he said,Unlike the previous attempt to remodel the English summer three years ago that was commissioned by the ECB and led by Andrew Strauss, the current review has been undertaken by the counties themselves under the aegis of the Professional Game Committee [PGC], chaired by Warwickshire’s Mark McCafferty.

Consequently, the emphasis has been on a widespread consultation that has resulted in seemingly ever-changing plans,The Strauss Review had a clear, single recommendation for the Championship: to be split into three divisions of six with a reduction from 14 to 10 matches in each,This, however, was comprehensively rejected by the counties,After a long summer, the most radical proposals have been dismissed, including three conferences of six, a single 18-team league with a Champions-League Swiss model fixture list, a mid-season split similar to that of the Scottish Premier League and several different variants of the current 10/8 divisional makeup,It has left two options on the table.

At a meeting at Lord’s next Tuesday the 18 county chairs will be asked to choose between keeping the status quo – 10 teams in Division One and eight in Division Two each playing 14 matches – or adopting a new structure that involves a 12-team County Championship being split into two pools of six, with the remaining six clubs in a second tier beneath this,A vote will follow the meeting later next week if the PGC judge there is a realistic prospect of it being passed, which is not guaranteed,With 12 votes required to alter the structure, Surrey, Yorkshire, Middlesex, Essex and Somerset have already stated they will oppose any reduction to the current 14-game season, with the voting intentions of Derbyshire, Sussex and Kent in the balance,The 10 other counties – an unlikely alliance of Test match grounds and Division Two sides such as Leicestershire and Northamptonshire – are broadly in favour but need two other clubs to come on side,“A small number of chairs have worked very hard to deliver the best solution for the game,” one advocate of the new structure told the Guardian.

“It would be a real shame if this opportunity is missed.”The selling point of the final compromise is the fact 14 of the 18 teams would play 13 matches each summer due to a series of September playoffs, on top of a 12-game regular season.The Championship would consist of each team playing 10 games home and away against the five opponents in their pool, plus two additional matches against sides in the other pool determined by seeding.At the end of the season, all the Championship teams would play a 13th game against the corresponding side in the other pool – first v first, second v second etc.While these matches were initially billed as playoffs for the title and wooden spoon, it is now envisaged that they would each be worth the standard 24 points and added to those in the regular season to determine final league positions.

Sign up to The SpinSubscribe to our cricket newsletter for our writers' thoughts on the biggest stories and a review of the week’s actionafter newsletter promotionAs a result, it is theoretically possible that the top-of-the-table clash could prove meaningless, if one of the sides has 24 points more than their opponent after 12 matches.Although this feels unsatisfactory to some and would remove the spectacle of a grand final at Lord’s, the proposed new structure would guarantee jeopardy at the wrong end of the top tier, with the bottom sides in each pool relegated.The winners of the second tier – Championship 2, consisting of 10 home-and-away games plus two additional loop fixtures – would be promoted automatically, with second facing third in a playoff for the right to join them in the top flight.The refuseniks are chiefly acting out the wishes of their vocal but relatively small memberships.Totalling about 70,000, of which Surrey contribute by far the most at just over 20,000, they vociferously oppose any reduction in championship matches.

The influence of this lobby group is a huge source of frustration to the Professional Cricketers’ Association, whose members want a cut in cricket on the grounds of player welfare and quality,In a last-minute attempt to win over floating voters the PGC is understood to have offered to add an extra fixture in the 50-over One Day Cup from next season to appease members and provide additional gate receipts, a proposal which will form part of the Championship vote,

politicsSee all

Police warn protesters not to travel to Epping after asylum hotel ruling – as it happened

The leader of Epping Forest district council has called for calm after the court of appeal ruled asylum seekers can stay at the Bell hotel in Essex.Councillor Chris Whitbread told Times Radio:I call for calm. There’s been peaceful protests and there’s been non peaceful protests outside the hotel.He added:We saw yesterday the government say that asylum seekers have more rights than my residents. I’m really cross with this ruling

1 day ago

Court orders seizure of counterfeit underwear seller’s £90m assets

A self-styled clothing tycoon who sold counterfeit socks and pants while operating an extensive fraud ring will have all his UK assets seized after the Crown Prosecution Service won a court order to confiscate up to £90m worth of property and luxury cars.Arif Patel, 57, from Preston, Lancashire, who has been on the run since 2011, will have homes and business premises he owned taken from him after a confiscation order granted by a judge at Chester crown court on Thursday.His Ferrari 575 Superamerica will be sold at auction, as will property in Morocco, the United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia and Turkey.Patel masterminded a gang that was convicted in 2023 of one of the UK’s biggest VAT tax frauds in HMRC’s history.In a sequence of trades known as carousel fraud, he moved goods between different companies, creating false export and import records that he used to claim back large sums from the tax authorities

1 day ago

Not monsters, but truly monstrous | Brief letters

All I learned from Nick Clegg’s interview (‘If the people who ran Facebook were monsters, I wouldn’t have worked there’: Nick Clegg on tech bros, Trump and leaving Silicon Valley, 23 August) is (a) his fawning homage to his former boss means that he is keeping his career options open and (b) he still doesn’t get why people despise him for his role in the coalition government. Zuckerberg, Cameron and Osborne may not be monsters, but the real harms they have wrought and their lack of any kind of accountability, responsibility or contrition are truly monstrous.Simon CollinYate, Gloucestershire A letter (22 August) perpetuates the claim that Angela Rayner is bent on selling off allotments for development. It isn’t true, as is clear from a close reading of your 5 August article, which unfortunately had the unhelpful headline “Jeremy Corbyn warns rules on council asset sales threaten allotments”. They don’t, they haven’t been changed, and sales have actually fallen slightly

1 day ago

How to tax the wealthy without a wealth tax | Letters

Faiza Shaheen is misguided in her advocacy of a wealth tax (Rachel Reeves needs to find cash fast. A wealth tax really is her only viable option, 22 August).There are far more practical policies available to tax wealth as part of the progressive narrative. These are based on the idea of taxing the income from wealth rather than taxing wealth directly.This is the approach of Prof Richard Murphy’s Taxing Wealth Report 2024, which estimated a tax yield of £90bn a year from its proposals

1 day ago

Reform UK council removes St George and union flags over safety fears

A Reform-led council has started to remove flags and bunting displaying the St George’s cross and the union flag after concerns were raised that they could cause accidents.Durham county council issued a statement on X on Friday saying that while the council “understand and respect the community’s desire to express national pride, celebration, or remembrance, it is important to ensure such expressions do not compromise public safety”.The council claimed it had been “left with no choice but to remove bunting” after a risk assessment found that “rope involved was so strong that, had a high-sided vehicle driven into it, the poles it was attached to could have been pulled down”.The statement said the council’s “priority remains ensuring the safety and integrity of the highway network, while being mindful of, and responsive to, the communities we serve”. It encouraged residents “to consider safer and more appropriate locations for flags or other displays that do not involve highway infrastructure and conform to all appropriate standards and regulations”

2 days ago

Starmer names former Bank deputy governor as his chief economic adviser

The former Bank of England deputy governor Minouche Shafik is set to join Keir Starmer’s team as chief economic adviser.In a boost to the prime minister’s office in the run-up to the autumn budget, Lady Shafik is expected to take on the role after a year heading a Foreign Office review of the government’s foreign aid spending.A member of the House of Lords, Shafik resigned last year as the president of Columbia University after criticism of the treatment of Jewish students during anti-Israel protests at the institution’s New York campus.Shafik was previously head of the London School of Economics, a deputy governor of the International Monetary Fund and the top civil servant at the now defunct Department for International Development. In 2019 she was touted as a possible contender to replace Mark Carney as the Bank of England’s governor

2 days ago

cultureSee all