Equalities watchdog submits formal guidance after UK supreme court transgender ruling

A picture


The equalities watchdog has submitted its formal guidance about how institutions should respond to the landmark supreme court ruling on transgender people’s rights, with its chair admitting it would be “difficult” for many to shape workable policies.The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has handed the guidance to Bridget Phillipson, the minister for women and equalities as well as the education secretary, who must now decide whether to accept it.One EHRC source said that while the decision-making on the guidance was restricted to a small group of people around the group’s outgoing chair, Kishwer Falkner, the expectation was that it would closely reflect interim advice released by the watchdog in April.This alarmed transgender groups, who said its guidance that the supreme court’s ruling that the legal definition of a woman was based just on biological sex meant transgender people should not be allowed to use toilets of the gender they live as, and that in some cases they could not use toilets of their birth sex, would effectively exclude transgender people from much of the public realm.It also said that organisations such as sports clubs or hospitals could ask to see someone’s birth certificate if there was “genuine concern” about what biological sex they are.

Speaking on Friday morning, Falkner, who departs the role in December, said she accepted it would not necessarily be easy for public bodies to turn the guidance into practical rules and guidelines.“I think it’s going to be difficult for duty bearers, service providers, to adapt a ruling which is quite black and white into practical steps according to their own circumstances and their own organisation, which is why we’ve always emphasised they should take their own advice as well as adhering to our code,” she told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme.Falkner, a crossbench peer, said of the advice, which has a statutory basis: “Everybody I speak to, every institution I speak to, says: ‘Can you tell us what we’re supposed to do?’ That’s wrong … they should have been doing it anyway.”The guidance follows a consultation in which more than 50,000 responses were gathered over a period lasting six weeks – extended from an initial two weeks after MPs expressed worries about what they said was a rushed timetable.Deciding on whether and how to accept the guidance will be a hugely complex and sensitive issue for Phillipson’s office, with no timetable set for when it will happen.

The document was described by one official as “hugely complicated”.When the supreme court ruling was published in April, Keir Starmer praised it for offering “real clarity” on a vexed issue, saying organisations and institutions would now be able to turn this into practical guidelines.But a number of Labour MPs, as well as campaign groups, have expressed alarm that what they fear could be an overly fast and literal interpretation of the ruling could have major consequences for how transgender people live their lives.Jude Guaitamacchi, the founder of the Trans+ Solidarity Alliance, said the EHRC had “rushed” the consultation and was proposing what could end up being “a trans bathroom ban”.They said: “It’s up to the government what happens next.

Bridget Phillipson could fix this mess tomorrow,Waving this through would be Labour’s Section 28 moment and define their legacy on LGBT+ rights,”
recentSee all
A picture

Shein UK accused of moving ‘vast bulk of income’ to Singapore to cut British tax

Shein’s UK arm has been accused of transferring the “vast bulk of income” to its Singaporean parent in order to cut its British tax bill.The company, which had been considering a £50bn float on the London Stock Exchange but is expected to list in Hong Kong, paid just £9.6m in corporation tax despite taking £2bn in sales last year.The payment is equivalent to 25% of the £38.2m in pre-tax profits it made in the UK in 2024, according to accounts filed at Companies House, in line with the UK corporation tax rate

A picture

UK phone retailers lock shop doors while trading to tackle rising thefts

Mobile phone retailers are locking their doors during trading hours and considering using “kill switches” to disable stolen devices, as incidents of theft increase more than ninefold in some high streets due to organised crime.VodafoneThree, which operates the largest retail network with 650 stores across the UK, has experienced a 967% increase in theft incidents in the first half of this year compared with the same period in 2024.“In recent months, the telecoms sector has seen an alarming surge in aggressive robberies and attempted robberies in stores, particularly across London and the south-east of England,” said a spokesperson for the company. “VodafoneThree has seen a nine-times increase in these types of incidents.”In response, the company has introduced measures including a locked door policy in some stores, which requires security guards to open the store’s doors to customers during trading hours, rather than them remaining open at all times

A picture

Tesla offers Elon Musk a trillion-dollar pay package

Elon Musk could become the world’s first trillionaire if he hits targets set by Tesla, under a scheme disclosed by the electric car company he runs and in which he is the largest shareholder.Tesla outlined the terms of the incentive package, unprecedented in corporate history, in a section of its latest stock market update that began: “Yes, you read that correctly.”Musk, the company said, will have to increase the value of Tesla from just over $1tn now to $8.5tn over 10 years.If he presides over growth on that scale, the 54-year-old will receive new shares that would push his stake in the company from nearly 16% to well beyond 25%, increasing the fortunes of the world’s richest man to more than $2tn

A picture

Trump hosts US tech leaders at White House dinner – minus Elon Musk

As Donald Trump hosted leaders from the biggest US tech companies at a lavish White House state dining room dinner on Thursday night, there was one notable absence. Elon Musk, once inseparable from Trump and a constant, contentious presence in the White House, was not in attendance.The dinner, which included Meta’s Mark Zuckerberg, Microsoft’s Bill Gates, Apple’s Tim Cook and OpenAI’s Sam Altman, was exactly the type of event where Musk would have sat at Trump’s right hand only a few months ago. Instead, the Tesla CEO stated on his social media platform X that he had been invited but could not make it. He said he planned to send a representative and spent the day on X posting a familiar stream of attacks on immigration and trans people

A picture

US Open tennis 2025: Aryna Sabalenka beats Amanda Anisimova in women’s singles final – as it happened

Right, it’s time for me to take my leave, but we’ll have Tumaini’s match report on the site shortly. And then Daniel will be here for Alcaraz v Sinner tomorrow, the lucky chap. Many thanks as always for joining us. Bye!Sabalenka seems unsure whether to go for the cheque or the trophy. I think I’d dive for the cheque, given it’s for $5m, but she opts for the trophy

A picture

Aryna Sabalenka sweeps aside Amanda Anisimova to retain US Open title

After such a bittersweet season filled with near-misses and heartbreak at the final hurdle, Aryna Sabalenka returned to the US Open final with one final chance to win the grand slam title she felt she was owed.Such an occasion could have been the source of more anxiety and stress, another reason for her to fall apart, but Sabalenka’s increasingly legendary career has been driven by her ability to learn from her losses, no matter how painful they are. This time, the No 1’s nerves perfectly held up under pressure as she maintained her composure during a late surge from Amanda Anisimova before closing her US Open title defence with a 6-3, 7-6 (3) win.As the best player in the world at the peak of her powers, Sabalenka continues to establish herself as one of the greatest players of the 21st century. She has now won four grand slam titles, drawing level with Kim Clijsters, Arantxa Sánchez Vicario, Naomi Osaka and Hana Mandlikova