‘It was soul destroying’: men on the struggle to get answers about infertility

A picture


After six years of trying for a baby and two failed rounds of IVF, Toby Trice found himself at his “lowest ebb”, feeling “lost, lonely and alienated from society”.“We were in this dark phase of not knowing where we were at.All our friends and family around us had children and we were constantly reminded we couldn’t.It was soul-destroying.“After the second round of IVF – and hope was ripped away from us – I had suicidal thoughts.

I didn’t want to be around any more,” he said.If a GP had tested Trice for the varicocele he was eventually diagnosed with, he might never have gone through such a painful process.A varicocele is a dilated vein in the scrotum that increases testicular temperatures and damages sperm.By some estimates it is present in 40% of cases of male infertility, yet it can be treated with routine surgery.“The basic thing was that I had some sperm, so all the focus and attention was on trying to find the problem with my wife, Katy,” he recalls.

“The clinic said we just need to keep trying through IVF and eventually we would have a baby.”Instead, it took a contact in a support group mentioning the possibility of male infertility and a visit to a private specialist clinic for Trice to get diagnosed and treated.Trice and his wife had a pot of money saved and faced a difficult crossroads: should they spend it on another round of IVF, or take a chance on the private clinic’s advice and pursue surgery for varicocele?“We were sat together one evening joking after the surgery – ‘Wouldn’t it be lovely to cancel our three-month check-up if we’ve fallen pregnant?’ – and I remember Katy laughing.Two weeks later, we tested positive for a natural pregnancy and that became our son, Oliver, so it was a whirlwind of a journey,” he said.Leading experts have spoken to the Guardian about what they say is a widespread lack of awareness of male infertility.

They have argued that couples are needlessly going through IVF because male infertility is under-researched, with the NHS too often failing to diagnose treatable causes.Martin Bowers has a similar story to Trice.It took eight years and four rounds of IVF for him and his wife to have a baby daughter, who is now 12 weeks old.The first three failed, but it was only after Bowers attended a private clinic that he was diagnosed with and treated for fragmented DNA in his sperm that the fourth worked.He was told to reduce his coffee intake and improve his diet, as well as taking medication to lower his oestrogen levels.

He recalls that one GP “didn’t seem to care” while another, when asked about how to improve the quality of his semen, replied: “There’s not a lot you can do.”Bowers struggled with feeling emasculated by the couple’s fertility issues, compounded by frequent questions from family members, colleagues and friends about when he was going to start a family.“I know it’s all good humour and joking, but when you hear comments like ‘You’re the one to deliver’, you feel like you’re not man enough to give your wife a baby,” he said.Sean Farrell got a semen test on the NHS and was told he had no sperm in his sample.He was then informed it would take over a year to see a urologist.

“At the time it felt far too long,” he recalled.The couple did not want to delay the process further since clinicians tell you that “age is really important” and their experience did not give them the confidence that they would “get the answers we needed”.He was surprised to see his local GP reading about his diagnosis of azoospermia off a screen.“We’d already done a lot of research and felt we knew more than she did.”Private testing gave him the diagnosis of rare Sertoli cell-only syndrome and they were told they would need to use donor sperm if they wanted to conceive with IVF.

Farrell and his fiancee wanted to choose a sperm donor external to the NHS clinic and were told this would not be funded.They have since spent almost £25,000 on gaining the diagnosis and surgery privately, plus one failed round of IVF.“I’m in my mid-30s now and I don’t think I’d really understood the true definition of being depressed or anxious before.I’d not experienced anything that caused me to feel low or as anxious or upset as I do now.The process is so all-consuming,” he said.

In the UK and Ireland, Samaritans can be contacted on freephone 116 123, or email jo@samaritans.org or jo@samaritans.ie.In the US, you can call or text the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988 or chat at 988lifeline.org.

In Australia, the crisis support service Lifeline is 13 11 14,Other international helplines can be found at befrienders,org This article was amended on 30 November 2025 to correct a reference to Sean Farrell’s diagnosis; he has azoospermia, not aspermia, which is a different condition,
trendingSee all
A picture

Bakery chain Gail’s plans to open 40 more outlets as sales soar

The upmarket bakery chain Gail’s is planning 40 more outlets after sales rose by a fifth last year as it opened 36 new bakeries and sales to supermarkets increased.The cafe and retailer, which currently has 185 sites, said sales rose to £278m in the year to the end of February but that pre-tax losses widened to £7.8m, from £7.4m a year before, as costs rose and it spent millions on opening new outlets, according to accounts filed at Companies House.Gail’s directors said staff and energy costs had risen, hitting profit margins, while it spent £51m on store pre-opening costs

A picture

Is gen Z’s love of fried chicken pushing Britain to ‘peak pizza’?

Competition intensifies as former chief of Domino’s says days of ‘massive growth’ are overPizza has become ubiquitous on British dinner plates, with chains such as Pizza Express, Franco Manca, Domino’s and Goodfella’s dominating the market – but is its popularity starting to cool?Domino’s Pizza Group announced this week that its chief executive of two years had stepped down with immediate effect, less than two weeks after he appeared to suggest the UK may be approaching “peak pizza”.Andrew Rennie – who worked for Domino’s for more than two decades and in the top job for just two – told the Financial Times this month there was not “massive growth” left in the UK’s pizza market.Given the fast-growing demand for fried chicken, he said it was “pretty obvious” the group should broaden its menu.Rennie’s calculations are borne out by the shrinking presence of pizza restaurants on UK high streets after a period of rapid expansion more than a decade ago.The number of chain pizza restaurants has fallen from 5,000 in 2015 to 3,750 today, according to the restaurant analysts CGA, with companies such as Pizza Express, Pizza Hut and Papa Johns closing outlets in recent years

A picture

How big tech is creating its own friendly media bubble to ‘win the narrative battle online’

At a time when distrust of big tech is high, Silicon Valley is embracing an alternative ecosystem where every CEO is a starA montage of Palantir’s CEO, Alex Karp, and waving US flags set to a remix of AC/DC’s Thunderstruck blasts out as the intro for the tech billionaire’s interview with Sourcery, a YouTube show presented by the digital finance platform Brex. Over the course of a friendly walk through the company offices, Karp fields no questions about Palantir’s controversial ties to ICE but instead extolls the company’s virtues, brandishes a sword and discusses how he exhumed the remains of his childhood dog Rosita to rebury them near his current home.“That’s really sweet,” host Molly O’Shea tells Karp.If you are looking to hear from some of tech’s most powerful people, you will increasingly find them on a constellation of shows and podcasts like Sourcery that provide a safe space for an industry that is wary, if not openly hostile, towards critical media outlets. Some of the new media outlets are created by the companies themselves

A picture

More than 1,000 Amazon workers warn rapid AI rollout threatens jobs and climate

More than 1,000 Amazon employees have signed an open letter expressing “serious concerns” about AI development, saying that the company’s “all-costs justified, warp speed” approach to the powerful technology will cause damage to “democracy, to our jobs, and to the earth.”The letter, published on Wednesday, was signed by the Amazon workers anonymously, and comes a month after Amazon announced mass layoff plans as it increases adoption of AI in its operations.Among the signatories are staffers in a range of positions, including engineers, product managers and warehouse associates.Reflecting broader AI concerns across the industry, the letter was also supported by more than 2,400 workers from companies including Meta, Google, Apple and Microsoft.The letter contains a range of demands for Amazon, concerning its impact on the workplace and the environment

A picture

Panthers shock Rams, Texans beat Colts and Bucs best Cardinals: NFL week 13 – as it happened

(7-6) Carolina Panthers 31-28 Los Angeles Rams (9-3)(3-9) Cleveland Browns 8-26 San Francisco 49ers (9-4)(8-4) Indianapolis Colts 16-20 Houston Texans (7-5)(5-7) Miami Dolphins 21-17 New Orleans Saints (2-10)(3-9) New York Jets 27-24 Atlanta Falcons (4-8)(7-5) Tampa Bay Buccaneers 20-17 Arizona Cardinals (3-9)(1-11) Tennessee Titans 3-25 Jacksonville Jaguars (8-4)And that’s the end of that chapter. I’m really glad we got another upset after all the shocks midweek. The Panthers couldn’t look like more of a different team than the rabble that flopped against the 49ers on Monday. Nice to see Bryce Young pull off a huge win, maybe we might start seeing a few more of them as he continues to develop. Enjoy the rest of night’s action if you are staying locked in, goodnight! I’ll just leave you with another view of that frankly ridiculous Puka Nacua catch

A picture

Lando Norris and Oscar Piastri voice frustration at McLaren’s strategy

Lando Norris, the championship leader, has decried the McLaren team strategy error at the Qatar Grand Prix that allowed Max Verstappen right back into the fight and forced a three-way battle at next Sunday’s title-deciding finale in Abu Dhabi.Verstappen won the race in Doha after McLaren chose not to pit their drivers under a safety car early in the race. It was a costly error that gave Verstappen the lead and the win. Norris could finish only fourth and his teammate Oscar Piastri, who was equally unhappy with the team, was second.Norris had been 24 points ahead of both Piastri and Verstappen going into the weekend but now leads Verstappen by only 12 points and Piastri by 16