Assisted dying: supporters and opponents of bill on hopes and fears ahead of crucial vote
Two cancer patients want choice to decide when to die but man re-diagnosed with non-terminal condition urges cautionEver since Pamela Fisher was diagnosed with terminal breast cancer, the fear of dying in pain and discomfort has been keeping her awake at night.“I don’t want to die, not now.I love life and I want to live.But that said, I live in terror at the prospect of how my final weeks of life could turn out,” the 64-year-old said.“I know that even with the best palliative care available, there are limits to what can be done.
It’s a dead weight of fear I carry around with me.”Fisher, a former academic and authorised Church of England preacher, is a strong supporter of the assisted dying bill that MPs will debate before a crucial vote on Friday.She hopes it will pass and come into force in enough time to give her the option of an assisted death when the moment comes.Although cancer has now spread to her bones and made walking difficult, she has travelled from her home in Huddersfield to join a planned demonstration outside parliament for the bill’s third reading.“Despite all my disabilities and pain, I’ll be there until the end, until the vote comes through,” she said.
“I’m hanging all my hopes on it,It would be quite devastating if it is defeated,”Her views have led to some tense exchanges with other members of the church, whose leaders have spoken out against the legislation,The bishop of London has said it may mean vulnerable people are compelled to hasten their death,Fisher said: “I can’t reconcile Christian compassion with the status quo that obliges people to a drawn-out process of dying in pain when this is against their will and they have the capacity to choose.
“People use this concept of the sanctity of life which is completely central to Christian teaching.But I reject the assumption that the sanctity of life requires telling terminally ill people to undergo a painful death when they don’t want to.”Most debates in her congregation about the subject had been civilised, she said, although she sometimes feels as if she is marginalised as a terminal cancer patient.“It’s like you’re not taken as seriously – people think ‘well she would say that, wouldn’t she?’,” she said.On the other side of the debate, there are people alarmed the legislation could lead to abuse, coercion or people dying earlier than needed, particularly in cases of misdiagnosis and inaccurate prognosis.
Peter Sefton-Williams, 72, was diagnosed with suspected motor neurone disease by two neurologists in January 2024 and joined Dignitas after deciding he wanted to opt for an assisted death.“I was so completely shocked.I did very much think about ending my life because I live on my own and I’m not married, and motor neurone disease is terrible, you can’t swallow, you can’t speak,” he said.His condition didn’t deteriorate and then, nine months later, his diagnosis was changed to a rare, non-terminal condition called multifocal motor neuropathy.“If assisted dying had been available to me, it’s quite possible I would have opted for that.
I mean, I had two of the country’s senior specialists confirm I had motor neurone disease,I was in a state of great despair,” he said,“People would have said, well, he died with dignity and so on,Except it would have been an error,It would have been a mistake.
I would have died needlessly.”Along with misdiagnoses, the all-party parliamentary group for terminal illness reported that the accuracy of predictions of how long someone has left to live can range from 78% to 23%, and in cases involving less understood conditions, such as motor neurone disease, it can be impossible.“There are lots and lots of cases where people have lived very fruitful, happy lives for much longer than they were expected to,” Sefton-Williams said.“I was completely traumatised by the whole experience, the misdiagnosis and the implications of that.People have to accept that there will be cases where doctors get it wrong.
And that needs to be discussed.”Shafaq Sikandar, 39, has stage 4 breast cancer and is a keen supporter of the bill.“It is not because I’m thinking about assisted dying,” she said.“I might not need it, but what I would like to know is that if and when that happens, that I have a choice.It’s a choice not to suffer, to be able to die at home with my loved ones.
”She is a professor of sensory neurophysiology, specialising in people’s experiences of chronic pain, so she knows more than most how pain works and the scientific limitations of measuring it.“We don’t currently have the appropriate tools to really assess someone’s comfort when they’re past the point of being able to articulate how they’re feeling,” she said.“I am particularly worried about experiencing pain at any point in my life, including at the end of it.Pain is often described as an erosion of dignity and it really does strip away everything that makes life worth living.”She said she understood the complexity of the bill, and the need to get the safeguarding right.
“But it’s still a case of listening to the voice of patients and understanding they want to have a choice in their treatment,” she said,“When we think about death we also need to think about the meaning of life, and I think a lot of that boils down to living as well as you can until that very last breath,”
One in three across UK are overdue for cervical cancer screening
A third of people across the UK are overdue their cervical cancer screening, while in parts of England some are at greater risk of the disease than others due to a low uptake for the preventive vaccine, experts have warned.Since the coronavirus pandemic, cervical screening attendance rates for women and other people with cervixes have been steadily declining, from 72.2% in 2020 to 68.4% in 2024, NHS England data shows.A YouGov survey of 3,000 people across the UK eligible for cervical cancer screening, commissioned by Cancer Research UK, is in line with these findings, with 30% of respondents being overdue their screening
Jean Robinson obituary
Described as “a troublemaker of the very best kind”, the health activist Jean Robinson, who has died aged 95, championed the rights of patients, pregnant women and disadvantaged people for more than 50 years. She was chair of the Patients’ Association, president of Aims (the Association for Improvements in Maternity Services) and a lay member and outspoken critic of the doctors’ regulatory body the General Medical Council. In 1988 she wrote the explosive booklet A Patient Voice at the GMC, laying bare its inadequacies and contributing to its reform.Robinson’s activist career took off in 1966, when, living in Oxford and looking after her young son, she was invited to become a lay member of the regional health board. She was not prepared to be a rubber stamp appointment and said the board statistician nearly fell off his chair when “the token housewife” came to his office with detailed questions about perinatal mortality rates
Overseas-trained doctors ‘put off UK due to cost of living and low salaries’
Doctors are choosing not to come and work in the UK because they are put off by low salaries, the high cost of living and poor quality of life.Research by the General Medical Council (GMC) shows that doctors who shun the UK are opting to move instead to the United States, Australia and Canada to earn more and have a better life.Overall, 84% of doctors trained abroad surveyed by the GMC said that other countries were better than Britain at paying good salaries and only 5% felt the opposite was true.The UK was also seen as being very poor for the cost of living and quality of life, attracting scores of minus 44 and minus 43.Among doctors considering where to further their careers, the UK scored worse than competitor countries on 14 of the 15 issues the GMC asked them about
Two Leeds hospitals’ maternity services rated inadequate over safety risks
The care of women and babies at two Leeds hospitals presents a significant risk to their safety, the NHS regulator has said, after the preventable deaths of dozens of newborns.The Care Quality Commission (CQC) demanded urgent improvements to maternity services at Leeds general infirmary and St James’s hospital as it downgraded them to “inadequate”.A BBC investigation this year found that the deaths of at least 56 babies and two mothers may have been preventable at the two hospitals between January 2019 and July 2024.The hospitals, run by Leeds teaching hospitals NHS trust, are the latest to be engulfed by a maternity scandal that has revealed catastrophic failings in Nottingham, Shrewsbury and Telford, Morecambe Bay, east Kent and others.The downgrading of maternity and neonatal services in Leeds follows unannounced inspections by the CQC in December and January
UK ‘behind curve’ on assisted dying among progressive nations, says Kim Leadbeater
The UK is “behind the curve” among progressive nations, the assisted dying bill’s sponsor, Kim Leadbeater, has said on the eve of one of the most consequential votes for social change in England and Wales.The Labour MP said the circumstances may never be right again to pass such a bill, which would legalise assisted dying in England and Wales for terminally ill people with less than six months to live, subject to approval by two doctors and a panel of experts.Her intervention came amid more warnings about the safeguards in the bill, including from the Royal College of Psychiatrists and disability activists, who will protest outside parliament on Friday at the final vote in the Commons.Opponents believe the bill will not offer sufficient protection to those with mental illness or disability or those who might be coerced by abusers. On Thursday, another leading Labour MP, Dan Carden, said he would vote against the bill and the Conservative leader, Kemi Badenoch, urged her MPs to oppose it
Assisted dying: supporters and opponents of bill on hopes and fears ahead of crucial vote
Two cancer patients want choice to decide when to die but man re-diagnosed with non-terminal condition urges cautionEver since Pamela Fisher was diagnosed with terminal breast cancer, the fear of dying in pain and discomfort has been keeping her awake at night. “I don’t want to die, not now. I love life and I want to live. But that said, I live in terror at the prospect of how my final weeks of life could turn out,” the 64-year-old said.“I know that even with the best palliative care available, there are limits to what can be done
Garmin Forerunner 970 review: the new benchmark for running watches
Israel-linked group hacks Iranian cryptocurrency exchange in $90m heist
OpenAI boss accuses Meta of trying to poach staff with $100m sign-on bonuses
‘It’s terrifying’: WhatsApp AI helper mistakenly shares user’s number
Amazon boss tells staff AI means their jobs are at risk in coming years
Up to 70% of streams of AI-generated music on Deezer are fraudulent, says report