Actors, musicians and writers welcome UK U-turn on AI use of copyrighted work

A picture


Actors, musicians and writers have welcomed the UK government’s decision to backtrack on plans to let AI firms use copyright-protected work without permission.Technology secretary Liz Kendall said it no longer had a “preferred option” on copyright reform, having previously supported a proposal allowing tech companies to take copyrighted work – unless rights holders opted out of the process.“We have listened,” said Kendall on Wednesday, “we have engaged extensively with creatives, AI firms, industry bodies, unions, academics and AI adopters, and that engagement has shaped our approach.This is why we can confirm today that the government no longer has a preferred option.”The proposal had triggered a backlash from Elton John, who called the government “absolute losers” over the plans.

Dua Lipa, Abba’s Björn Ulvaeus, the actor Julianne Moore and the Radiohead singer Thom Yorke are among thousands of artists who voiced their concerns over the potential legal overhaul,Creative industry organisations welcomed the new government stance,Equity, the actors’ trade union, said the move was “recognition that selling out the UK’s creative industries to benefit US tech companies would’ve been an act of national self-sabotage”,UK Music, a trade body representing the UK music industry including the Musicians’ Union, said it was “delighted” but urged the government to rule out the proposal altogether,The Society of Authors said the announcement was a “hard-won” moment for writers and creators, while the News Media Association – whose members include the Guardian – said giving away the UK’s “goldmine” of creative content was not the way to drive economic growth.

Intellectual property has become a key battleground in the development of AI because the technology requires vast amounts of data, including copyright-protected work taken from the open web, to develop tools such as chatbots and image generators.Ed Newton-Rex, a composer and campaigner for protecting artists’ copyright, said the creative industries should not celebrate too soon.“Virtually everything is still on the table, including the opt-out,” he said.“It’s just kicking the can down the road.”Kendall’s announcement came as the government published an update on its proposals, including an economic impact assessment – although it did not provide a “monetised” economic cost for each of its four copyright proposals.

Along with the former preferred option, a government consultation is considering: leaving the situation unchanged; forcing AI companies to seek licences for using copyrighted work; or allowing AI firms to use copyrighted work with no opt-out for creative companies and individuals.Beeban Kidron, a cross-bench peer who led opposition to the proposals in the House of Lords, said there was “nothing but political will” standing in the way of letting artists see how and where their work is being used by AI firms – which would pave the way for them to be compensated.Kendall also announced the establishment of a taskforce to examine proposals to label AI content; a consultation on protecting someone’s likeness from being used in deepfakes; a working group to support smaller creative organisations in licensing their content; and a review of how creators can monitor use of their work by AI firms.Antony Walker, deputy chief executive at techUK, a tech industry trade body, said the announcement must be used as an opportunity to “reset and find a way forward” on copyright.The economic impact assessments said leaving copyright law unchanged could benefit creative firms by growing the market for licensing content to AI firms, but could prevent the development of cutting-edge AI models in the UK.

Requiring licensing could result in some AI tools being withdrawn from the UK, the government added, although it could be a “net positive” for the creative sector,Waiving copyright for AI firms could put at risk a “globally competitive” creative sector but would lower costs for tech firms, it said, while the controversial opt-out option could affect both sides if it is not implemented efficiently,
A picture

Peter Smith obituary

My father, Peter Smith, who has died aged 97, set up a pioneering health food store in the unlikely setting of Scunthorpe, Lincolnshire, in the late 1950s, at a time when the pursuit of vegetarianism and healthy eating was a fringe interest.He ran the shop until the mid-1960s before spending a number of years living and teaching in Japan and then opening up another health food outlet in Surrey in the early 70s, guiding it successfully into the late 90s, by which time his advocacy of healthy diets had become much more mainstream.Born in Cottam, on the Nottinghamshire-Lincolnshire border, to Jack and Doris (nee Womble), Peter was raised in the lively setting of their pub, the Railway Inn in Leverton, where he flourished. As a child he showed a talent for snooker, touring local halls to play in charity matches and displaying the confidence that would mark his later life.After leaving Scunthorpe technical high school he did three years of national service from 1946 to 1949 with the Royal Air Force as an engineer and was posted to Iraq, an experience that sparked a fascination with foreign cultures, food and travel

A picture

Rukmini Iyer’s quick and easy reccipe for crispy baked gnocchi puttanesca | Quick and easy

Puttanesca purists, look away now. This dish takes the classic elements of a puttanesca – that is, anchovies, capers, olives, tomatoes – and combines them into a rich sauce for gnocchi, which are then covered in mozzarella, breadcrumbs and parmesan, and flashed under the grill. It’s exactly what you want on a rainy night. In fact, my sauce-averse toddler thought it smelled so good that she stole half of my plate – a win all round. (Although her pretty decent suggestion was that next time I use it as a pizza sauce, rather than on pasta or gnocchi

A picture

How to make Irish stew – recipe | Felicity Cloake's Masterclass

The first time I dared to write a recipe for Irish stew, I was invited on to the national broadcaster, RTÉ, to discuss my choices live on air. And, to my considerable relief, it was eventually decided that I had not dishonoured the memory of my ancestors. It’s tempting for modern cooks to meddle with such resolutely plain classics. Do not! It’s delicious just as it is.Prep 20 min Cook 2 hr Serves 63 large onions 2 tbsp oil, or lamb fat10-12 very floury potatoes, depending on size and hunger1 neck of lamb, or hogget or mutton, cut into thick slices (see steps 1 and 2)2 sprigs fresh thyme Salt and pepper 6 carrots, or, if you like, substitute some for chopped turnip, swede or leekChopped parsley, or chives, to serve (optional)Traditionally, an older, less productive animal would have been used here – and the slow cooking time reflects this – but modern recipes tend to favour lamb

A picture

DakaDaka, London W1: ‘Like a 2am lock-in on a Tbilisi back street’ – restaurant review | Grace Dent on restaurants

DakaDaka, a rowdy paean to Georgian cuisine, has arrived on Heddon Street in the West End of London. Heddon Street has always been synonymous with rowdiness, regardless of the fact that the mature, semi-elegant likes of Sabor, Piccolino and Heddon Street Kitchen are quite the opposite. But anyone who ever found themselves staggering out of Strawberry Moons in the 1990s having lost a shoe and with a love bite or from the basement club at Momo will know that this little nook tucked away behind Regent Street is where a good time is meant to be had.And now there’s DakaDaka, which certainly does not market itself as a nightclub, because, well, virtually nowhere does any more. What DakaDaka does do, though, is play Georgian dance music very loudly and with endless enthusiasm right through your badrijani (grilled aubergines), imeruli (cheese-filled flatbread) and kababi (lamb skewers)

A picture

Fallouts and financial woes: inside Heston Blumenthal’s sinking empire

Dinner by Heston was once one of the world’s most revered restaurants, known for its decadent and unusual dishes such as the “meat fruit”.But Heston Blumenthal announced this week that he is winding down operations at the two Michelin-star restaurant at the Mandarin Oriental hotel in Knightsbridge, London, saying it was because the tenancy had “finished”.However, current and former workers at Dinner claim the restaurant has been going downhill for years after Blumenthal fell out with his right-hand man, Ashley Palmer-Watts, who created the menu and ran the restaurant day to day before he left the business.“Closing the restaurant was not Heston’s choice whatsoever,” a senior source from the Mandarin Oriental told the Guardian. “The hotel chose not to renew the lease

A picture

Mother’s Day UK recipes: three delicious ideas to make for your mum from Ravinder Bhogal

Few things say “I love you” more than an unbidden cup of tea, but if you want to show true appreciation to the maternal figure in your life this Mother’s Day, there’s nothing better than a few indulgent snacks to go with it. I love the British tradition of afternoon tea, but I find finger sandwiches in hotel lobbies a little too fussy. I would much rather a fortifying savoury sandwich, a slab of good, old-fashioned cake and buttery biscuits that crumble into a million sweet crumbs.This very simple cake can be baked in a regular cake tin, but cooking it in a bundt tin makes it much more of a showstopper. If you want to forgo the icing, serve with a dollop of creme fraiche and berries instead