Ascot’s bold move in turf war leaves racing fighting to avoid constitutional crisis

A picture


The racing industry is such a broad and varied collection of professions, venues and interests that at times it can feel like the Holy Roman empire: there is always a turf war or two going on somewhere, but never to such an extent that the whole thing falls apart.Ascot’s announcement on Monday that it will quit the Racecourse Association (RCA) at the end of the year, however, feels like more than just another localised dispute.The email dropped at 9am on a bank holiday, as if to underline that the king’s track means business, and where Ascot has led, others may follow, putting the future of a trade association that dates back to 1907 in serious doubt.The spark that lit the fuse, just two months ago, was Charles Allen’s departure as chair of the British Horseracing Authority (BHA), after a brief and ultimately fruitless attempt to impose a modern governance structure, including a fully independent board of directors, on Britain’s second-biggest spectator sport.Ascot, along with the Jockey Club, which operates major tracks including Cheltenham, Aintree, Epsom and Newmarket, and also three key “big independent” tracks – Newbury, York and Goodwood – subsequently wrote to the RCA calling for “a formal governance review” of the Association, to ensure “significant views from key racecourses can influence outcomes”.

The source of the major racecourses’ anger was plain: a belief – or rather a conviction – that the RCA’s one-track, one-vote structure hands too much power to smaller venues, and in particular, the 16 courses operated by Arena Racing Company (ARC), which has a quantity-over-quality business model to service the off-course betting market.Since the RCA gets to nominate two members of the BHA’s current board, Ascot and its co-signatories felt their views – including support for Lord Allen’s fully independent board – were not getting a fair hearing at the top of the sport.Chester 1.30 Adonius 2.05 Partisan Hero 2.

35 Amelia Earhart 3.05 Benvenuto Cellini 3.40 Ruby’s Angel 4.10 Arabian Desert 4.45 Miami Matrix (nb)Newton Abbot 1.

45 Centara 2.15 Name Me Nicely 2.45 Storminhome 3.15 Northern Air 3.50 Reel Orange 4.

20 JuggernautKelso 1,55 Dartmouth Castle 2,25 The Clonmel Kid 2,55 Starlyte 3,25 Fairly Fulling 4.

00 Maillot Blanc 4.32 Tanking Along 5.02 Whatdeawant 5.32 AllroadsleadtoromFontwell 5.42 Washington Singer 6.

12 La Cadalora 6,42 Land Girl’s Luck 7,12 Rapid Mission 7,42 Majestic Moment 8,12 Major DinoKempton 6.

00 Sceptic 6.30 Victory Ace 7.00 Brilliant Star 7.30 Venetian Gold 8.00 Ribenska (nap) 8.

30 Yehudi 9.00 Hint Of The JungleThe deadline set for an “acceptable proposal” for reform was the end of April, and Ascot wasted little time in submitting its resignation four days later.All eyes now are on the Jockey Club, British racing’s biggest commercial organisation, and while it has given the RCA an extension to its deadline, it is unlikely that an operator as sharp and well-connected as Felicity Barnard, Ascot’s CEO, would have led the charge without believing the Jockey Club would be next through the door.If or when the Jockey Club follow suit, the BHA will face a constitutional crisis, since the RCA’s two spots on the board depend on it being “the person most representative in Great Britain of the interests of owners of racecourses”.Without Ascot, the Jockey Club’s major tracks and the likes of Goodwood, York and Newbury, the RCA would not come close.

It is possible that, when faced with what is potentially an existential crisis, the RCA will come up with proposals for change that meet with the Jockey Club’s approval, and Wilf Walsh, the RCA’s chair, can draw on a wealth of experience both within racing and in industry in trying to strike a balance.But that would still mean a major shift of power towards the biggest tracks, and less influence for those further down the pecking order.In terms of what this may mean for punters and racegoers, it is tempting draw a parallel with the formation of the Premier League in the early 1990s, when England’s biggest clubs broke away from the Football League, to grab a much bigger slice of the sport’s TV revenues.Tempting, but arguably misleading, as the two sports have different structures, fanbases and revenue streams, not least income from off-course betting that means ARC can stage hundreds of meetings each year that attract a few hundred spectators at best.It is not a straightforward division either between the major tracks, with significant income from ticket sales, hospitality and, more recently, the Hong Kong-based World Pool in addition to their off-course media rights, and ARC’s heavily betting-dependent model.

There is also a cohort of smaller independent tracks, from Plumpton in the south to Kelso in the Scottish borders and dotted around in between.Chester, a member of the Large Independents group alongside Goodwood and York, stages its May festival this week, but also operates Bangor-on-Dee and Musselburgh.Nor is there any real scope for promotion or relegation.There is a more general argument, though, that while the formation of the Premier League was excellent news for the country’s most famous clubs, and made little difference to the old Division Three teams that were used to rubbing along with little cash and a loyal, local fanbase, the pinch was felt mostly keenly by some familiar names somewhere in between.Plumpton, in fact, quit the RCA two years ago, as Peter Savill, its owner and also a former chair of the British Horseracing Board, the BHA’s predecessor, felt the RCA’s representatives on the BHA board did not adequately represent the views of small independent tracks.

If Ascot’s decision to quit the RCA ultimately leads to a governance structure for racing in which the major tracks hold more sway, my guess would be that the less productive tracks in ARC’s portfolio could be particularly vulnerable.Its all-weather courses efficiently deliver a consistent stream of “product” for the betting industry.The turf tracks, not so much.With Ascot, the country’s premier track, leading the charge, racing’s governance structure may finally be set for long overdue reform.It promises to be a messy and painful process, however, with possible casualties among the current muster of 59 tracks If you have a particular favourite, now might be a good time to visit.

sportSee all
A picture

Mercedes may have won again but Miami upgrades have shaken up the F1 grid | Giles Richards

The improved form of McLaren and Red Bull in Florida suggests the 2026 title race is likely to run and runThere is a long old way to go but after Formula One emerged from its enforced early season break with an entertaining romp around the Hard Rock Stadium in Miami, it indicated that there may yet be a decent tale to be told this season. One where Mercedes do not have it all their own way.Regulation changes dominated the buildup – of which more later because honestly paragraph two is too early to subject readers to the increasingly soul-destroying phrase “energy management” – but what really mattered in Miami was the sporting imperative of upgrades making a competitive difference.Mercedes had looked ominously strong with three straight wins in the opening three rounds before the five-week break caused by the cancellation of the Bahrain and Saudi GPs. During that time there was no little beavering across the paddock on upgrades for Miami

A picture

RFU backs Steve Borthwick to lead England for 2027 World Cup after Six Nations review

Steve Borthwick and his coaching staff will remain in charge of England’s men despite the team’s worst Five or Six Nations for 50 years. The Rugby Football Union has opted to back Borthwick and his lieutenants through to the Rugby World Cup in Australia next year having completed what it described as “a detailed and robust review” of England’s latest campaign.Despite the team having lost four championship games in the same season for the first time since 1976, the RFU has chosen to keep faith with the Borthwick regime in the belief that things can only get better. The union has decided that sacking the head coach is not the optimal solution, having previously dispensed with Eddie Jones’s services nine months before the 2023 World Cup.“This has been a thorough and honest review, and it is clear that improvement will come from addressing several areas rather than chasing one simple answer,” said the RFU’s chief executive, Bill Sweeney, in a statement

A picture

The Breakdown | Rugby needs to stop the screen-obsessed, finger-pointing, hair-trigger arguments

Game is in danger of losing its integrity by howling about referees’ decisions and unedifying actions on the field under the notional banner of player welfareIt felt like a proper occasion in Bordeaux on Sunday. The trams were so jammed en route to the ground that the kick-off had to be delayed to allow spectators extra time to find their seats. For those who dismiss the notion of club rugby rivaling football for vibrant mass interest, here was a compelling counterpoint: a heaving 42,000-capacity stadium, off-the-scale passion, top-class sport in every respect.Later on, after the game was done, there was another revealing snapshot at the airport. As Bath’s beaten players headed for their flight home they were warmly applauded down to the gate by their travelling supporters

A picture

Carlton fined $75,000 for mishandling of Elijah Hollands’ mental health episode

The AFL has fined Carlton $75,000 for not removing Elijah Hollands from the field while he was experiencing a mental health episode during round six against Collingwood.Hollands appeared to be acting erratically during the match at the MCG, and was admitted to hospital for treatment several days later.The AFL found Carlton should have removed Hollands from the game earlier based on visual cues, performance data and the player’s previously disclosed mental health challenges, and that the club’s failure to do so brought the game into disrepute.The AFL’s chief executive, Andrew Dillon, said the “substantial sanction” was made against the club “collectively” rather than singling out any individuals.“What transpired during the game was something we haven’t seen before and while Elijah did undergo checks, he should not have been left on the field for that period of time,” Dillon said, adding that the incident had highlighted areas of improvement for the code

A picture

‘English cricketers don’t always have that fight’: Simon Harmer on lessons from a decade in county game

The Essex and South Africa spinner has taken more Championship wickets than anyone else since arriving in 2017 – but says 18 teams can reward mediocrityFor 10 seasons, few have earned the right to comment on English cricket more than Simon Harmer. Because for 10 seasons, no one has taken more County Championship wickets than the South African off-spinner who arrived at Essex in 2017 on a six-month contract, his international career stalled and his options narrowing fast.He has since become one of the great imports of the English game: 522 first-class wickets and counting for Essex, two County Championship titles, a Bob Willis Trophy, a return to South Africa’s Test side and, perhaps most importantly, contentment. “My journey has been bumpy,” Harmer says from a sun-drenched beer garden near the Oval. “I can say now that I’m at peace with it

A picture

These are the questions I would ask the Enhanced Games … if they would let me | Sean Ingle

The plan to fly to Las Vegas to cover what the Enhanced Games claims is the “next frontier of human performance” ended with a short email sent at 7.02pm on Friday. “After careful consideration, we are unable to approve your media credential request for this year’s event,” it said. “Due to the high volume of applications and limited media capacity, we could not accommodate all requests … thank you again for your interest and understanding.”Admittedly, the rejection didn’t come entirely out of the blue