Wimbledon’s expansion plans heading for court of appeal after judge’s ruling

A picture


Wimbledon’s battle to build 39 new grass courts on a nearby golf course has taken a fresh twist after local residents were granted permission to take a judicial review case to the court of appeal.Last year the All England Club (AELTC) was given approval by Jules Pipe, the London deputy mayor for planning and regeneration, to build the courts on what used to be Wimbledon Park Golf Club – a decision that was then endorsed in the high court on 21 July.However, the Save Wimbledon Park pressure group challenged that verdict and on Monday it was announced that Lord Justice Holgate had granted a judicial review of the court’s decision.Explaining the reasons for granting the order, Holgate wrote that: “The grounds of appeal are arguable with a real prospect of success.The case law on scheme benefits, deliverability, relevance, material considerations and irrationality merits review.

”SWP maintains that the expansion plans will create a “tennis industrial complex”, which will damage the environment and has failed to properly listen to the community.It is also fighting its legal battle with the All England Club on two other fronts, including a separate court case in January, where a judge will consider the possibility that the golf course could be subject to a “statutory trust” and thus be reserved for public recreation.It is also considering whether to go to court to challenge a “restrictive covenant” given by the AELTC committee in 1993 in which it promised never to develop the land.“This is a David and Goliath struggle,” Save Wimbledon Park said in a statement.“The AELTC is a rich and well-connected corporate developer which has worked for decades to take over a substantial part of this highly protected public Park for its own purposes.

”Christopher Coombe, a local lawyer who opposes the plans, added: “SWP has never been anti-tennis.We believe that it is high time for the AELTC to recognise the raft of legal and principled problems with its proposals and sit down and talk constructively with SWP and the local community.”However, the All England Club remains confident that its expansion plans, which would triple the size of its grounds, will go ahead despite this latest stumbling block.In a statement, a spokesperson said: “We are confident that the court of appeal will ultimately judge that the high court made the correct decision in upholding the Greater London Authority’s grant of planning permission for a development that will enable us to deliver one of the greatest sporting transformations since the 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games.Sign up to The RecapThe best of our sports journalism from the past seven days and a heads-up on the weekend’s actionafter newsletter promotion“Our plans will create a permanent home for the Wimbledon qualifying competition but crucially they also deliver 27 acres of beautiful new parkland for local people to enjoy, providing the public access to green space that has been used as a private members golf club for more than 100 years.

societySee all
A picture

Labour is privatising the NHS in plain sight | Letter

Gaby Hinsliff is right to ask if the government’s reorganisation of the National Health Service will be the final nail in its coffin (Wes Streeting’s gamble with the NHS is greater than any play for Downing Street, 14 November). Such large‑scale redundancies are bound to create problems.There are other threats to the delivery of NHS services too. The privatisation of the NHS is happening in plain sight. Last month, the government proudly announced that “A total of 6

A picture

Krysty was diagnosed with breast cancer months after getting the all-clear. New Australian guidelines aim to help women like her

When Krysty Sullivan had a routine mammogram in 2019, she was given the all-clear.Eleven months later, she felt a lump.Doctors discovered two tumours, each more than 2cm in size. Sullivan, then 48 years old, was diagnosed with triple-negative breast cancer, a type that can be challenging to treat as the cancer cells do not respond to typical targeted treatments.“It’s always a shock to hear that you have breast cancer, but to learn that I had it months after I had a clear mammogram … it was like the Earth shifted,” Sullivan said

A picture

Mahmood and Lammy breached human rights law over segregation of prisoner, judge finds

Shabana Mahmood and David Lammy have been found to have breached a prohibition on inhuman or degrading treatment with respect to a prisoner who spent months segregated from other inmates, in what is believed to be a legal first.Sahayb Abu was confined to his cell at HMP Woodhill in Milton Keynes, for 22 hours a day and prevented from associating with other prisoners for more than four months after Hashem Abedi, the brother of the Manchester Arena bomber, allegedly attacked prison officers at HMP Frankland.Abu, a convicted terrorist serving a life sentence, was already being held in a separation centre for prisoners believed to be at risk or radicalising others, which has also been described as small group isolation, but was moved to even more restrictive conditions following the attack by Abedi in April.In what is believed to the the first instance of ministers being found in breach of article 3 of the European convention on human rights, Mr Justice Sheldon found that Lammy, the justice secretary, and Mahmood, his predecessor, should have considered Abu’s existing mental health issues before he was moved.In his written judgment, the judge said: “In the context of a prisoner who has a history of trauma and where there was a failure to obtain an assessment of his needs even though he was known to have mental health issues, and a failure to provide him with any therapeutic treatment to address his trauma, a contravention of article 3 is made out, notwithstanding the importance of the aim behind the segregation regime

A picture

Coroners’ advice on maternal deaths in England and Wales routinely ignored, study finds

The advice given by coroners in England and Wales to help prevent maternal deaths is not being acted upon, research suggests.Academics at King’s College London looked at prevention of future deaths (PFD) reports issued by coroners in cases of pregnant women and new mothers who died between 2013 and 2023. They found these reports were not being “systematically used nationally”.The study, published in the BMJ Gynecology and Obstetrics Clinical Medicine, identified 29 PFDs involving maternal deaths, but found that nearly two-thirds of these reports were ignored.Two-thirds of deaths occurred in hospitals, with more than half of the women dying after giving birth

A picture

NHS failing to cut waiting times as promised in recovery plan, report warns

The NHS has failed to cut waiting times as promised in its recovery plan despite billions of pounds in investment, the public accounts committee (PAC) has warned.The influential parliamentary committee’s verdict raises serious doubts over whether Labour can fulfil its key pledge to voters to “fix the NHS” by ensuring that patients can once again get hospital care within 18 weeks by 2029.In a scathing report, the cross-party PAC warns that improvements in providing faster tests and treatment have “stalled”. And it criticises Keir Starmer and the health secretary, Wes Streeting, for ordering a costly, unplanned reorganisation of the NHS in England. It said this could damage care and was reminiscent of the shambles surrounding the HS2 rail project

A picture

Lack of planning has hit Labour’s efforts to fix public services, says thinktank

Keir Starmer is failing to make major improvements to public services partly because he did not plan properly while in opposition, according to a report from the Institute for Government (IfG).The prime minister went into government without a clear idea about how to achieve his targets, the IfG found, resulting in haphazard attempts to reform various sectors, from the health service to the courts.The annual report provides a damaging overview of an occasionally chaotic first year in government for Labour, during which the party and Starmer have slumped in the polls.Nick Davies, a programme director at the IfG and one of the authors of the report, said: “Starmer went into government with a set of missions, but no clear idea about how to achieve them or how those targets fit together in any meaningful way.“He has not been properly engaged with this process