Arts funding in England must be protected from politics, Hodge report urges

about 12 hours ago

Arts Council England must ensure funding is protected from politicisation and simplify its application process in order to regain trust, a damaging report has found,The investigation into the national body for arts funding found there had been a “loss of respect and trust” for ACE among those it backed, in part because of “perceived political interference in decision-making”,The report was written by the Labour peer Margaret Hodge, who recommended that ACE be retained but with the arm’s-length principle strengthened at all levels of government “to ensure that arts funding is protected from politicisation”,She said: “There have been attempts to exert more political control over ACE decisions in recent years and this has to stop,The Arts Council must remain free from political interference.

This matters.It ensures that artistic freedom is protected, that creativity is not stifled and that public trust is maintained.Political interference, even by those with the best of intentions, could lead to political bias, or even censorship.”ACE is a non-departmental public body of the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) that distributes public funds to arts organisations ranging from national institutions to community-based ventures.Lady Hodge’s report calls for red tape to be minimised by simplifying the funder’s application process and by replacing its Let’s Create strategy – a set of investment principles and delivery plans – which was supposed to be in place until the end of the decade.

Those who gave evidence said Let’s Create was “a straitjacket … stifling artistic innovation and creativity”; Hodge called for it to be replaced with “a new, less prescriptive” model.Earlier this year, Wigmore Hall voluntarily withdrew from ACE funding, with the London concert venue’s director, John Gilhooly, criticising Let’s Create, saying ACE had “lost its way”.On Tuesday, Gilhooly said the foregrounding of ACE’s “crippling red tape” vindicated what he and other arts leaders had been telling the funding body privately for years.“We hope the government will implement every recommendation of this report, and that ACE abandons its current role as the enforcer and regulator of the arts and becomes our greatest champion, delivering great arts and culture to every citizen,” he said.A straining in relations between ACE and the bodies it gives money to was a theme throughout Hodge’s report.

“People viewed ACE as a command-and-control funding body, rather than a leader and facilitator in the cultural landscape,” it said.Shortly before the report was originally commissioned in March 2024 by the then culture secretary, Nadine Dorries, ACE was forced to amend “reputational risk” guidance that suggested “overtly political or activist” work could break funding agreements.One of the key missions highlighted in the review was the need to reduce bureaucracy, including by “radically” reforming ACE’s application and reporting requirements.It said ACE should reduce the number of its funding streams.It also recommended lengthening the national portfolio organisations (NPO) cycle from three to five years, having a rolling programme of applications, and assuring certain organisations that they would receive at least 80% of their funding in the next round.

It said the government “can and must” find innovative ways of responding urgently to the underfunding that had undermined the arts over the last decade.These include amending theatre tax relief and orchestra tax relief to include the additional costs of touring, which have been exacerbated by Brexit.The report suggested that ACE could meanwhile offer a wide range of financing options by having a trading arm.It also recommended a new mechanism to bring money back to ACE when an NPO has produced a show that is a strong commercial success – either by a return through royalties, or a percentage of profits or a fee.The report said that while decisions about funding for arts organisations of national and international significance should be made by a national panel, other funding should be handed out by new local and regional decision-making boards.

Hodge said ACE was “a vital national body” whose role in “promoting and ensuring access to excellence” was fundamental to its work,The culture secretary, Lisa Nandy, stressed the necessity of access to the arts,She said the review highlighted the strengths of ACE’s work, “but it also challenges us to do better,It sets out recommendations to strengthen support for artists, reach communities more effectively, and ensure that creativity is accessible to all,”ACE said it was heartened to read of the “overwhelming” backing for its principles.

But it said it had also “heard clearly” that the organisation had been too “prescriptive” in how it implemented its Let’s Create strategy.It vowed to give artists and organisations more space to articulate their ambitions and reduce the administrative burden placed on them.The ACE chair, Nicholas Serota, said the report “offers us an opportunity to listen, learn, and improve – so that we can continue to nurture ambition, excellence, and access to excellence in the artists and organisations that we support”.The ACE chief executive, Darren Henley, added: “We want people to spend less time on our paperwork and more time on their creative work.Our mission over the months to come is to roll up our sleeves and make that happen.

”The government will publish a response to the review in the new year, when Serota is expected to be replaced as chair,The Royal Ballet and Opera, which receives the largest single grant from ACE for its core funding, was among the arts organisations that responded to the report on Tuesday,Alex Beard, its chief executive, said Hodge’s proposals had the “potential to be transformative for performing arts organisations”,

cultureSee all

My cultural awakening: The Lehman Trilogy helped me to live with my sight loss

I began to notice my sight deteriorating in my 40s, but not just in the way that you expect it to with age. I had night blindness and blind spots in my field of view. At 44, I was diagnosed with retinitis pigmentosa, a genetic eye condition that causes the retina cells to die. I had always been a very visually oriented person: I was a practising architect, and someone who loved to read, draw, go to the cinema and visit art exhibitions. So when black text disappeared on a glaring white page, films became impossible to follow and artworks only took shape once explained to me, I questioned who I would be without my vision

4 days ago

The Guide #221: Endless ticket queues, AI slop and ALL CAPS agony

It’s time for a big old moan. Next week’s newsletter will be a roundup of our favourite culture of the year, a bit of an annual Guide tradition by now, and something that’s great fun to put together.But do you know what’s even more fun? Complaining about things. So, this week’s Guide is devoted to cultural gripes, big and small, of 2025. Here’s what had us seething this year

4 days ago

From Eleanor the Great to Emily in Paris: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead

Eleanor the GreatOut nowJune Squibb stars in Scarlett Johansson’s directorial debut, which premiered at Cannes and tells the tale of the eponymous Eleanor, a senior citizen recently relocated to New York, who strikes up a friendship with a 19-year old – and then stumbles her way into pretending to be a Holocaust survivor.LurkerOut nowA hit at Sundance, this is the story of a lowly retail employee who happens to strike up a friendship with a rising pop star, becoming the Boswell to his Johnson, if Boswell was part of a pop star’s entourage. But the path of friendship with a famous person never did run smooth, and the uneven power dynamic soon prompts some desperate manoeuvring in this psychological thriller.Ella McCayOut nowEmma Mackey stars in the latest from James L Brooks (his first since 2010), a political comedy about an idealistic thirtysomething working in government and preparing to step into the shoes of her mentor, Governor Bill (Albert Brooks). Jamie Lee Curtis co-stars as Ella’s aunt

4 days ago

Stephen Colbert on Trump’s ‘gold card’: ‘Pay-to-play program for rich foreigners’

Late-night hosts tore into Donald Trump’s new “gold card” immigration program and his many weird tangents about grocery prices.Stephen Colbert opened Thursday’s Late Show with a new Christmas jingle about the president: “He’s making a list, checking it twice, then handing that list to the people at ICE. Donald Trump … ruins everything he touches,” he sang. “And lately he’s been pretty handsy, slapping his face on anything in sight.”On Wednesday, Trump put his face on what Colbert called “his long-promised pay-to-play program for rich foreigners”

5 days ago

‘Like lipstick on a fabulous gorilla’: the Barbican’s many gaudy glow-ups and the one to top them all

The brutalist arts-and-towers complex, where even great explorers get lost, is showing its age. Let’s hope the 50th anniversary upgrade is better than the ‘pointillist stippling’ tried in the 1990sThe Barbican is aptly named. From the Old French barbacane, it historically means a fortified gateway forming the outer line of defence to a city or castle. London’s Barbican marks the site of a medieval structure that would have defended an important access point. Its architecture was designed to repel

5 days ago

Barbican to close its doors for a year for multimillion-pound renovation

The Barbican will close its doors for 12 months from June 2028 as it undergoes a multimillion-pound renovation that its leaders say will secure its future.The arts organisation’s Beech Street cinemas will remain open but its theatre, music venue, conservatory and visual arts galleries are set to shutter as the overhaul of the 43-year-old building begins in the lead-up to its 50th anniversary in 2032.The main Barbican site will close its doors in June 2028 and reopen in June 2029, but some disruption will happen before that as the foyer, lakeside area and internal control room are all renovated.The conservatory, which is open only for a few hours at the weekend and currently has netting to stop falling glass, will close earlier, in 2027.Philippa Simpson, the director of buildings and renewal at the Barbican, said the work could not be completed while the site was open to the public as it would be too dangerous, but that it was essential to secure the site’s future

6 days ago

technologySee all