The Hodge report into Arts Council England: ‘Not exactly a ringing endorsement’
The arts in England are underfunded, and were dealt a blow by Covid from which many organisations have not yet recovered.But that has been only part of the story.The sheer weight of required form-filling, the endless bureaucracy, the impracticable length of time it takes to simply be funded by Arts Council England (ACE) have caused universal frustration among those working in the arts.There is much talk of exhaustion and burnout.Many organisations have felt frustrated, too, by the strictures of ACE’s flagship strategy, Let’s Create, which, though admirable in principle, with its focus on participation in the arts, is perhaps tilted too far from recognising the expertise and individuality of artists and arts institutions.
Especially in classical music and opera – where ACE has made crude interventions into the direction of the art form – the body has been widely condemned for overreach of its powers.As with many things in life, though, opinion depends on your perspective.Funding has been diverted to underserved areas, and grassroots organisations, outside the south-east.Unsurprisingly, those who have received support for the first time are better disposed to ACE than those who have had their funding reduced or cut off.The report on Arts Council England by Margaret Hodge, Labour peer and former arts minister, urges a bonfire of red tape.
That will be welcomed.More controversially, she also recommends binning Let’s Create, the 10-year strategy designed to take ACE all the way to 2030, in favour of a simpler strategy that allows organisations to apply based on their own strengths, rather than endlessly banging square pegs into round holes.With Hodge’s language of “excellence and access to excellence”, those with long memories might remember Brian McMaster’s report of 2008, Supporting Excellence in the Arts, which similarly urged an end to box-ticking and a revival of trust in artists and arts organisations.Those with even longer memories might recall regional arts boards, which were abolished in 2001 in order to streamline the Arts Council’s operations.Hodge is proposing to revive a version of these bodies – once condemned as wasteful – in order to strengthen regional decision-making, though without, importantly, handing off powers to the political control of metro mayors.
(Nationally and internationally important bodies, on the other hand, would stay within the purview of the central ACE operation, which could cause some friction.)There is often a sense with the Arts Council that it trundles off in one direction for a few years, only to be pulled back in the opposite direction, before the entire cycle begins all over again.Another revival of an old hit is a recommendation to reboot something like the old Creative Partnerships programme, which, between 2002 and 2011, put local artists into schools.The report has some sensible ideas to help plug the funding void in the arts, without simply demanding more money be coughed up from the Treasury, which in the current climate is unlikely to happen.These include extending existing tax breaks for touring (arts organisations like these tax breaks – they are straightforward and simply incentivise making things and performing them without adding all sorts of extra prescriptions).
Ideas on encouraging philanthropy include increasing tax breaks for givers outside London (the vast majority of giving to the arts is in the south-east of the nation),The report is not exactly a ringing endorsement of Arts Council England as it stands: banish your bureaucracy! Strangle your strategy! And still, England has not addressed the single most calamitous cause of funding reduction in the arts, which is the collapse of local authority support,(Though the report does recommend mandating local authorities to at least have a cultural strategy,) But Hodge does insist that Arts Council England is the right body to deliver public funding to the arts and should continue to exist,And she strongly reasserts its most central and fundamental principle, that it should be at arm’s length from government, protected from political interference.
Thames Water defers controversial £2.5m in bonuses to bosses
Thames Water has deferred awarding bosses retention payments totalling £2.5m, avoiding a potentially damaging pre-Christmas row as the heavily indebted utility scrambles to agree a multibillion-pound rescue deal.Sources at the UK’s biggest water company confirmed the controversial retention payment package for 21 senior executives, which had been due to go out this month, would remain on hold until the new year.The bonuses were put on pause earlier this year after the Guardian revealed the chair of the company wrongly told parliament that creditors had “insisted” on the payments.Sir Adrian Montague admitted he “may have misspoken” after he incorrectly told the environment, food and rural affairs (Efra) select committee that the lenders had insisted that “very substantial” bonuses of up to 50% of salary should be paid to executives to help retain important staff
Jim Chalmers won’t have good news in Myefo. Instead, he’ll be trying to sell Labor’s good intentions
A penny-pinching Jim Chalmers will reveal a multibillion-dollar improvement in the federal budget that will still see the deficit nearly quadruple to $36.8bn in this financial year.The treasurer is the master of expectations management, and this week’s midyear economic and fiscal outlook (Myefo) will be an exercise in selling the Albanese government’s fiscal rectitude: Chalmers and Katy Gallagher gamely battling the rising tide of spending pressures.“Despite all the pressures we’ve had to accommodate in the budget, the bottom line is better in every year over the forwards thanks to our efforts,” the treasurer said in a statement as he revealed the latest budget figures.The newly estimated deficit is $5
Roasted! Morrisons loses £17m VAT battle over rotisserie chickens
The UK supermarket chain Morrisons faces a £17m tax bill after losing a lengthy court battle against HMRC over the charging of value added tax (VAT) on rotisserie chicken.The high court has ruled that whole cooked cool-down chickens should be subject to the standard 20% VAT rate for hot food.The dispute relates to changes introduced by the then chancellor George Osborne’s controversial “pasty tax” of 2012, when the Treasury imposed VAT on all hot takeaway food sold by bakeries and supermarkets, such as Cornish pasties, pies and sausage rolls. This prompted a public outcry, forcing the Treasury to partially row back.The Treasury initially said that food sold above “ambient temperature” should be subject to VAT
UK unemployment rose to four-year high of 5.1% before budget
The rate of UK unemployment rose to a four-year high of 5.1% in the three months to October, as the labour market showed signs of further weakening before last month’s budget.The Office for National Statistics said the jobless rate was the highest since January 2021 – but with the pandemic era stripped out, it was the highest since early 2016.Analysts said the rise in the jobless rate made it almost certain that the Bank of England would cut interest rates when policymakers meet on Thursday.The central bank has said it wanted wages growth to fall further before reducing the cost of borrowing again this year
Young people hit hard as UK unemployment marches upwards
When Labour came to power, it set a “long-term ambition” of increasing the employment rate – the share of the working age population with a job – to 80%. The latest data suggest things are moving in the wrong direction.The employment rate in the three months to October was 74.9%, according to the Office for National Statistics (ONS), down 0.3 percentage points on the quarter
‘Squeezed from every direction’: pubs voice fury at Reeves’s business rates changes
Emma Harrison has begun to wonder how her business will survive in recent weeks. The managing director of the Three Hills pub in Bartlow, Cambridgeshire, is struggling to see how she will make a profit after examining the impact of her rising tax bill.“I’m really terrified about this coming year,” Harrison says. “We’re a well-run pub, we’ve won lots of awards, but this is going to be really hard.”Harrison is not alone
Alan Milburn launches major UK review into rising inactivity among young people
Officials fear NHS will be hit hard after resident doctors reject latest offer
The slow death of social housing – and its original purpose | Letters
Children need mental health care provided by humans, not chatbots | Letter
Resident doctors in England vote to go ahead with strike
Tell us: have you ever had an allergic reaction caused by your clothes?