Even more energy suppliers are short of capital. Ofgem needs to toughen up

A picture


When half the nation’s retail energy suppliers, including Bulb with 1.7 million customers, failed during the gas crisis of 2021-22, the embarrassed regulator, Ofgem, decided it should probably pay more attention to companies’ balance sheets.Better late than never.The cost of mopping up the corporate calamities added up to £2.7bn, or £94 on every household’s energy bill, calculated the National Audit Office.

The result was a new regime from March last year in which Ofgem set “capital targets” for each supplier to ensure financial resilience.And the secondary effect was an entertaining quarrel between Octopus Energy, which confessed to being one of three suppliers below its capital target, and British Gas-owning Centrica, whose chief executive argued it was “criminal” that the regulator was not applying its ultimate sanction of barring under-target firms from taking on new customers.So what’s today’s state of financial resilience? The question is timely because wholesale gas prices are again behaving wildly.The volatility is not to the same degree as in 2021-22, but cold weather in North America has affected the European market, the type of event that can upset UK suppliers’ hedging arrangements.The answer, found deep within an Ofgem report this week, is that even more suppliers failed to meet their capital targets at the latest measurement date.

From three last June, the tally was five at the end of September,There were only 23 suppliers at the time, so slightly more than a fifth of the supplier base was out of line,That is not a small proportion,“Where suppliers are below the target, we work proactively with them on their plan to meet this target in the shortest reasonable time,” says Ofgem’s report,But that’s about all it reveals.

The regulator doesn’t name the under-target firms (Octopus and Ovo volunteered their status last year) or say how far short they fell from the aim of having adjusted net assets of £115 per dual fuel equivalent customer.What is Ofgem’s definition of “the shortest reasonable time”.Are we talking six months, a year or longer? It is impossible to say because there is no statutory timeline and Ofgem treats each capital-improving plan as unique.And what does “working proactively” mean? Ofgem deems its measures too commercially sensitive to talk about.This is a strange version of a supposedly get-tough regime.

Over in banking-land, the Bank of England publishes its stress tests for each bank and the results are pored over by the City,Banks know the consequences would be severe even if they fell only close to regulatory minimums,The stakes are lower in the retail energy market, and the setup is newer,But the levels of transparency are poles apart,“Where a supplier is not meeting the Capital Target but has a credible and agreed plan in place they remain in compliance with our rules,” says Ofgem, reserving the right not to explain what it regards as credible.

One does not have to be in Centrica’s “ban ’em from accepting new customers immediately” camp to think the regulatory approach is far too weak.How much extra time will laggards – now increased in number – be given? Ofgem should be able to answer.The new rules are there for a reason.
trendingSee all
A picture

The Original Factory Shop calls in administrators, putting 1,200 jobs at risk

The Original Factory Shop homeware chain has called in administrators, putting 1,200 jobs at risk, putting the decision partly down to higher costs from government policies.Administrators from Interpath have been appointed at the 137-store discount retailer, which was bought by the private equity firm Modella Capital less than a year ago.On Wednesday, the video game chain Game Retail filed a notice of intention to appoint administrators, while the fashion chain LK Bennett was bought out of administration by a restructuring specialist.Administrators said the Original Factory Shop would continue to trade on high streets while they “assess options for the business”. Its website ceased taking new orders on Wednesday but orders placed before 28 January would be delivered as usual

A picture

SpaceX mulls $1.5tn IPO timed to ‘align with Musk’s birthday and the planets’

Elon Musk’s SpaceX is considering a flotation valuing the rocket company at $1.5tn (£1.1tn) that will reportedly be timed for early summer to coincide with a planetary alignment and the multibillionaire’s birthday.The world’s richest person is targeting a symbolic date of mid-June for the initial public offering, according to the Financial Times. This would be around the same time as Jupiter and Venus appear in close proximity to each other and shortly before Musk turns 55 on 28 June

A picture

YouTube criticised after pulling out of UK TV audience measurement

YouTube has been criticised by the TV and advertising industry after suspending its participation in a key measurement system that compares viewership on the social media site with other streamers such as Netflix and TV broadcasters.YouTube’s owner, Google, has sent “cease and desist” letters to Barb, which publishes audience figures that are used as the UK industry standard, and Kantar Media, its research partner in the service.The decision came months after YouTube started to allow viewership of 200 of its channels on TV sets to be included in viewer measurements alongside broadcasters including the BBC, Sky, ITV and Channel 4.Google sent the legal letters blocking access to data to attribute viewing sessions to specific content creators citing a breach of its terms of service, according to the Financial Times, which first reported the story.“It does seem odd that YouTube has spent so much effort trying to convince advertisers that they are TV, and so gain the benefits of that reputation, but the moment there’s some TV-like scrutiny they go legal to avoid it,” said Lindsey Clay, the chief executive of Thinkbox, the TV body owned by ITV, Sky, Channel 4 and UKTV

A picture

Amazon tells workers it will cut 16,000 jobs worldwide in second big wave of layoffs

Amazon has told workers it is cutting 16,000 jobs around the world to streamline its operations, hours after sending out a message to staff about the layoffs apparently in error.It is the second big wave of job cuts at the US online retail company, and comes just three months after the company said it was slashing 14,000 roles. Amazon employs about 1.5 million workers worldwide.Most job cuts are expected to be in the US, although some roles in the UK may also be affected

A picture

Are England missing a trick by not taking Joe Root to the T20 World Cup? | Taha Hashim

The final night was Harry Brook’s but Joe Root still took the series, as he usually does in Sri Lanka. It was here that he began his stratospheric run against the red ball, a double hundred at Galle in 2021 the first of 24 Test tons in the next five years. Go back to 2014, his first visit to the country with England, and there’s an unbeaten 50-over century in Pallekele, a trick he repeated on Tuesday in Colombo.As Root and Brook sat on the Premadasa outfield after England’s 53-run win in the deciding one-day international, it was the former’s shirt that one supporter repeatedly pleaded for from the stands, never mind what the captain had just done. Local admiration is expected when the 35-year-old has never left a tour of Sri Lanka without at least one match winning knock

A picture

Sinner set for ‘toughest challenge’ in semi-final against Djokovic after swatting Shelton

Jannik Sinner is under no illusion about the difficulty of his semi-final meeting with Novak Djokovic after defeating Ben Shelton on Wednesday. “It’s one of the toughest challenges we have in our sport,” he said. “It’s great to have Novak playing at this very, very high level. It’s a grand slam, it’s always very difficult against Novak. Let’s see what’s coming