Tony Blair’s oil lobbying is a misleading rehash of fossil fuel industry spin
Ex-PM’s thinktank urges more drilling and fewer renewables, ignoring evidence that clean energy is cheaper and better for billsA thinktank with close ties to Saudi Arabia and substantial funding from a Donald Trump ally needs to present a particularly robust analysis to earn the right to be listened to on the climate crisis,On that measure, Tony Blair’s latest report fails on almost every point,The Tony Blair Institute for Global Change (TBI) received money from the Saudi government, has advised the United Arab Emirates petrostate, and counts as a main donor Larry Ellison, the founder of Oracle, friend of Trump and advocate of AI,The latest TBI report calls for an expansion of oil and gas production in the North Sea, despite the additional greenhouse gas emissions this would generate, and abandoning the UK government’s target to largely decarbonise the electricity sector by 2030, arguing that doing so is necessary to power AI datacentres,The report claims renewable energy is too expensive.
Yet this overlooks the fact that it is significantly cheaper than building the gas-fired power stations that would be needed instead.New onshore wind has been agreed at a price of £72/MWh and new solar at £65MWh – both less than half the £147/MWh cost of building and operating new gas power stations.New offshore wind, at £91/MWh, is about 40% cheaper than new gas.According to the analyst firm Aurora Energy Research, offshore wind priced below £94/MWh lowers consumer bills.By contrast, nuclear power – on which the TBI is keen – is likely to cost more than £133/MWh and would take many more years to build.
The report also cavils at the cost of electricity grid upgrades needed to support renewable energy, without acknowledging that grid improvements will be required in any scenario.It also ignores the conclusion of the network system operators, NESO, that a clean power system for the UK by 2030 is achievable “without increasing costs to consumers”.Draining the last drops of oil and gas from the North Sea lies at the heart of the TBI advice, projecting a £165bn industry as a result.Yet the North Sea is a rapidly declining basin where the remaining reserves are increasingly expensive to extract.Accordingly, says the TBI, oil and gas companies should receive substantial tax cuts.
Since 2020, the energy industry has made £125bn in profits in the UK, with oil and gas companies enjoying windfalls while vulnerable people struggled to heat their homes.Shell made $40bn in 2022 alone, BP $30bn the same year.Although profits have come down from their peaks, persistently high gas prices are keeping fossil fuel companies buoyant.Simon Francis, a coordinator at the End Fuel Poverty Coalition, said: “To call for the windfall tax to be scrapped, while energy giants post extraordinary profits and millions live in cold damp homes is staggering.“That tax exists because companies benefited from a crisis that devastated household finances.
Removing the windfall tax would reward profiteering and shift the burden back on to households that are still paying the price of Britain’s overreliance on gas,”Numerous analyses have shown that further North Sea production would make little difference to the UK’s energy security and would not reduce energy bills,Bob Ward, a policy director of the Grantham Research Institute at the London School of Economics and Political Science, said: “More North Sea production would have no significant impact on the wholesale price of electricity and would not reduce prices for British households and businesses,”Gas is traded on international markets, which determine the price,Even if the North Sea were drilled to exhaustion, the UK is likely to be reliant on imports for at least two-thirds of its gas within five years, and potentially all of it by 2050.
Mike Childs, the head of science at Friends of the Earth, said: “If we’re to bring down bills for good and protect people from future gas price volatility, then we must accelerate the development of renewable energy.”The report’s claim that renewable energy will be costly – despite price falls of 50-90% in recent years – also overlooks the fact that wind energy cut wholesale prices of electricity by about a third last year, with further reductions likely as new offshore windfarms come online.Shaun Spiers, the executive director of the Green Alliance thinktank, said: “We don’t need to rethink a clean power plan that’s working – the UK generated record-breaking amounts of renewable energy last year.”Consumers have yet to feel the full benefit, largely because the structure of the UK’s privatised energy market means electricity prices remain mostly dependent on the price of gas.The TBI report, Spiers added, “gives few suggestions for how to do this”.
Although TBI maintains that the UK’s target of reaching net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 should remain, it does not explain how slowing the rollout of renewables is compatible with that goal,What matters to the climate is not emissions in 2050 but the accumulation of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere,Maintaining fossil fuel production, as TBI advocates, might still allow net zero to be reached by mid-century, but would result in higher emissions in the interim, undermining the purpose of the target,According to Angharad Hopkinson, a political campaigner for Greenpeace UK: “The assertion that abandoning strategies to reduce emissions will somehow reduce emissions, and choosing more expensive energy will somehow reduce costs, is ludicrous,”Elsewhere in the report, the TBI rehashes the argument that the UK is responsible for just 1% of global greenhouse gas emissions, implying that the actions of larger emitters such as China will make more of an impact.
While technically accurate, this fails to acknowledge that roughly a quarter of global greenhouse gas emissions come from countries that each account for about 1% of emissions.If all of them abandoned net zero efforts, global temperatures would rise far beyond the 1.5C limit of safe heating.
Cocktails and crepes in bed? Ravinder Bhogal’s recipes for Valentine’s Day breakfast
Give me breakfast in bed over a bunch of limp supermarket roses any day. Nothing says “I love you” more genuinely than a decadent tray of delicious things to savour between the sheets. Because V-Day falls on a weekend this year, you can do better than just buttered toast and an unbidden cup of tea. Whether it’s sweet or savoury (or even a cheeky cocktail), I’ve got you!These French crepes are given the Midas touch with a pinch of saffron. Use your favourite fish – mackerel and salmon also work well here
‘Boy kibble’: why are young men turning to dog food for meal inspiration?
The dried food, traditionally for pets, has become an unlikely influence for meal preppers. Some commenters have even claimed the trend could be an antidote to toxic masculinity Name: Boy kibble.Age: It’s new.Appearance: Like a dog’s dinner.Isn’t that what kibble is? Traditionally, yes, kibble is dried food for pets in pellet form, made of grains, vegetables and meat
Frothing over: the coffee foams and ‘indulgent’ drinks keeping Australian cafes afloat
Cold brews and matcha lattes with airy, dessert-like layers are everywhere. What’s driving the trend for blockbuster toppings?Get our weekend culture and lifestyle emailCoffee brimming with lemon myrtle cream. Matcha banked with strawberry-lychee foam. Cold brew with choc-orange froth thick enough to stuff a pillow. Every caffeinated drink I’ve ordered in Sydney recently has the appearance of a generously frosted cake
What is fibremaxxing – and how much is too much? | Kitchen aide
Why is everyone talking about fibremaxxing?Chris, by emailTikTok-born trends rarely go hand in hand with sage health advice, but that’s not to say upping our fibre – an often-forgotten part of our diets – is a bad idea. “Fibre needed its moment, so this is a good thing,” says dietitian Priya Tew. The non-digestible carbohydrate has two main functions: “There’s insoluble fibre, which is found in things such as whole grains, brown rice or vegetable skins, and I think about it like a broom,” Tew says, “in that it brushes the system out.” Then there’s soluble fibre (oats, beans, lentils), which she likens to a sponge: “It turns into this gel in your gut, and aids digestion and keeps us regular.” But that’s only part of the story, because fibre can also help lower cholesterol and stabilise blood sugar
Moroccan lamb filo pie and rhubarb panna cotta: Thomasina Miers’ Sunday best recipes
There is little as pleasing to cook in the depths of the winter as a pot of enticingly fragrant, slow-braised meat. A shoulder of lamb is one of my favourite cuts; you, or a friendly butcher, will need to trim away its excess fat, a job that will reward you with an exquisite flavour that marries beautifully with bold spicing. Here, we travel to Morocco, with sweetly aromatic ginger, turmeric and cinnamon, and follow that with cardamom, cream and rhubarb for pudding. A sumptuous, colourful feast to stave off any February blues.Many elements of this dish, with its falling apart, richly seasoned lamb and carrots encased in crisp, golden pastry, can be made the day before
Georgina Hayden’s quick and easy recipe for creamy chicken and mustard fricassee | Quick and easy
This is a one-pan dinner at its finest: elegant and full of flavour, something that feels as if it has taken more effort and time than it actually has, and versatile in its finish – serve with creamy mash, fluffy rice, boiled potatoes; even hunks of fresh baguette would be wonderful for mopping up the creamy mustard sauce. I use whatever veg is in season: purple sprouting broccoli is at its best right now, but you could add stalks of rainbow chard, shredded cavolo nero, even halved baby carrots. Play around with whatever veg you have and love.If you can’t find mustard powder, feel free to use your mustard of choice – wholegrain would work well here.Prep 5 min Cook 30 min Serves 44 skin-on chicken breasts (about 160g each)Sea salt and black pepper 2 tsp English mustard powder 1 tbsp olive oil 200g purple sprouting broccoli 30g unsalted butter 4 garlic cloves, peeled and finely sliced1 tsp dried oregano 1 tsp aleppo pepper 2½ tbsp plain flour 125ml dry white wine 500ml chicken stock 200ml single creamPut the chicken breasts on a deep plate and season generously
Jon Stewart calls Maga backlash to Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl show ‘actually pathetic’
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind was never a love story. It was a warning
Actor Catherine O’Hara died of a blood clot in her lungs, death certificate says
‘We recorded it in a kitchen!’ How China Crisis made Black Man Ray
Super Bowl: Bad Bunny, the ads and everything but the football – as it happened
Perth festival 2026: Swan River bursts to life with a stunning trail of stories and light