Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind was never a love story. It was a warning

A picture


Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind is a film about the gap between what we think we can control and what happens when reality hits.Over the years, many critics and fans have celebrated Michel Gondry’s film as a tender-hearted love story.But a rewatch might reveal that Gondry’s second collaboration with postmodern American screenwriter Charlie Kaufman is much closer to another, twistier genre: hard sci-fi.By now, the story of Eternal Sunshine is familiar.Depressed introvert Joel (Jim Carrey) meets Clementine (Kate Winslet), whose box-dyed hair colour and moods change as often as the weather.

A mismatch made in heaven.The troubled couple eventually find a fix for their rocky, codependent relationship: a service provided by a sketchy medical company called Lacuna Inc that offers to erase their memories of each other.Clementine goes first.Out of spite, Joel follows.Early on in the film, a nervous Joel asks about the risks of brain damage before committing to the procedure.

Dr Mierzwiak (Tom Wilkinson), Lacuna Inc’s founder and chief technician, says matter-of-factly: “Technically speaking, the procedure is brain damage.It’s on par with a night of heavy drinking.Nothing you’ll miss.”Joel’s fears are soothed, but mid-procedure, something shifts.Trapped inside his own consciousness, Joel realises he doesn’t want to lose Clementine.

In an attempt to outsmart the Lacuna Inc technicians, he tries to conceal her in his oldest, deepest, most buried memories – childhood moments she was never part of.Hiding under the kitchen table from his mother.Being bullied.Moments that the technicians haven’t mapped out yet on their clunky equipment.Typically, sci-fi films are about what can happen when technology works too well, and the characters can’t handle the ensuing moral and psychological consequences.

Eternal Sunshine, on the other hand, is about technology failing – from the very start,Joel interferes with his own procedure,The Lacuna Inc technicians are hilariously unprofessional,The company founder is sleeping with patients,Everyone’s sloppy, human, compromised.

Most sci-fi aims to demonstrate what happens when you solve the problem,Eternal Sunshine is about what happens when the problem was never solvable in the first place,The film keeps undercutting its own romantic moments with genuinely uncomfortable reality,In flashbacks, Joel calls Clementine “selfish” and “pathetic”,She’s mean to him at parties, dismissive of his interests, gets drunk and embarrassing.

He’s passive-aggressive, judgmental and withdrawn.These aren’t quirky flaws – they’re the day-to-day of two incompatible people hurting each other.Their relationship is doomed from the beginning.Eternal Sunshine, then, is far from a love story – but rather a warning about how technology can’t really fix all our romantic mishaps.In 2004, the idea of erasing someone required literal brain damage.

Now we have a softer, more insidious version: you can curate someone out of existence digitally,Block, unfollow, mute, delete, untag and archive entire text threads,We’ve built the infrastructure for memory erasure into our daily lives,In 2004, scrubbing someone out of our life on purpose was a thought experiment,In 2026, we’re discovering, like Joel, that erasure doesn’t actually work.

We may mute an ex, but their account still exists.We block their number but remember the texts.We archive photos but actually deleting feels too permanent.We’re never fully erasing, never fully remembering.We’re constantly trying to move on without fully committing.

Like the existential terror of time travel narratives like Back to the Future – or even the Sundance-approved cult puzzler Primer – Eternal Sunshine unravels in gloriously non-linear fashion.Scenes interrupt each other.Time scrambles.We are immersed inside Joel’s consciousness, watching memories break apart and warp.As Clementine starts to disappear from Joel’s memories, they have conversations they could never have in linear time.

In one flashback, the couple talks at a beach party, sitting far away from everyone else,“This is it, Joel,I’m going to be gone soon,” Clementine says, knowing they’re existing only briefly in a reconstructed memory,“What do we do?” Rather than scheming, Joel gives up: “Enjoy it,”That’s not romantic in the traditional sense.

Because the version of love that the film believes in isn’t about erasing or curating or controlling, but accepting the whole mess in front of us and choosing it anyway, knowing exactly what we’re signing up for.This is a sci-fi film that argues for accepting our imperfect selves against the illusion of technological perfection.We try to delete.We try to refresh.But really, the best we can do is hope that things can be different this time around.

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind is available to rent in Australia and available to stream on Mubi in the UK and Hulu in the US.For more recommendations of what to stream in Australia, click here
cultureSee all
A picture

Jon Stewart calls Maga backlash to Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl show ‘actually pathetic’

Late-night hosts addressed the performative Maga outrage over Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl half-time show.Jon Stewart returned to his Monday night Daily Show post fired up about the Super Bowl, and particularly the outrage from conservative pundits such as Megyn Kelly and Benny Johnson over Bad Bunny’s half-time show, which he performed, as usual entirely in Spanish.Stewart played numerous clips of Fox News hosts et al complaining that they couldn’t understand the Spanish, then cut to a clip of Turning Point USA “All-American Halftime Show” headliner, Kid Rock, singing his hit Bawitdaba, with its gibberish chorus.The host then tore into the rightwing talking point that Bad Bunny’s half-time show, whose overarching theme was pan-American unity, was not “unifying” because it was in Spanish. “Why the fuck is it the Super Bowl Halftime entertainer’s job to unify the country? Is that their job?” he fumed

A picture

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind was never a love story. It was a warning

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind is a film about the gap between what we think we can control and what happens when reality hits. Over the years, many critics and fans have celebrated Michel Gondry’s film as a tender-hearted love story. But a rewatch might reveal that Gondry’s second collaboration with postmodern American screenwriter Charlie Kaufman is much closer to another, twistier genre: hard sci-fi.By now, the story of Eternal Sunshine is familiar. Depressed introvert Joel (Jim Carrey) meets Clementine (Kate Winslet), whose box-dyed hair colour and moods change as often as the weather

A picture

Actor Catherine O’Hara died of a blood clot in her lungs, death certificate says

Catherine O’Hara, the Emmy-winning actor and beloved star of the series Schitt’s Creek and the 1990 hit movie Home Alone, died from a blood clot in her lungs, her death certificate revealed Monday.The death certificate released by the Los Angeles county medical examiner’s office also listed rectal cancer as an underlying cause.The Canadian-born performer was rushed to the hospital on 30 January after having difficulty breathing at her home in the ritzy Brentwood neighborhood of Los Angeles.The 71-year-old, who starred in Beetlejuice and more recently in Apple TV’s Hollywood satire show The Studio, was declared dead a short time later.The actor’s death sent shock waves through Hollywood with tributes pouring in from past co-stars – including Schitt’s Creek creators Eugene and Dan Levy, Beetlejuice’s Michael Keaton and Home Alone’s Macaulay Culkin

A picture

‘We recorded it in a kitchen!’ How China Crisis made Black Man Ray

Ed and I had just come off a long tour of Europe and North America supporting Simple Minds and needed a break. I immersed myself in music-making with a synth, drum machine and a four-track Tascam Portastudio. I was very inspired by Brian Eno. I’d seen the words “found sounds” on his album credits. The notion that any sound could be included in a recording struck me as magical

A picture

Super Bowl: Bad Bunny, the ads and everything but the football – as it happened

Well, I could not tell you a thing about that game – I’ve heard that it was a boring outcome for a boring match-up – but it does not matter: the real winner tonight was Bad Bunny, who delivered a raucous, intricate and wildly ambitious half-time show that exceeded already sky-high expectations. With the world watching and many in the US government actively rooting against him (you can guess who took to Truth Social already), the Puerto Rican artist born Benito Antonio Martínez Ocasio thoroughly stomped on the haters with an exuberant 13-minute show that both honored his roots and championed an expansive view of American unity.It’s hard to overstate how much pressure Bad Bunny was under, as the first all Spanish-language half-time performer at a time when the US government is profiling Spanish speakers for its brutal immigration enforcement campaign. But Benito made the whole affair feel light as a feather, from the sugar cane fields to the bodegas to the rollicking casita party to a full-on real wedding (and surprise duet with Latino pop trailblazer Ricky Martin). Truly, this set was exquisite

A picture

Perth festival 2026: Swan River bursts to life with a stunning trail of stories and light

From dazzling light installations to unexpected conversations on pop-up phones, Perth festival has opened with a timely celebration of culture and communityGet our weekend culture and lifestyle emailAs families gather for sunset at Perth’s Kings Park, a giant golden orb glows on the horizon, shooting ribbons of light into the night sky.“It looks like an upside down jellyfish!” a child shouts gleefully, gazing up at this mysterious beacon. Others watch from park benches or drift slowly around its base, as a gentle wash of sound spills from its centre. The work is called Karla Bidi, translating to “fire trail” in Noongar: a light and sound installation that draws on the ancient practice of lighting campfires along the Derbarl Yerrigan (Swan River), which marks the opening of this year’s Perth festival.Featuring 11 installations stretching from Mandoon (Guildford) to Walyalup (Fremantle), Karla Bidi lights a path between communities along the river – a trail of gathering places that recalls how these banks have always been a place for story and connection