Ban on veggie ‘burgers’: plant-based products may lose meaty names in UK under EU law

A picture


Calling plant-based food veggie “burgers” or “sausages” may be banned in the UK under the new trade agreement with the EU, the Guardian understands.The Labour government secured a new sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement with the EU earlier this year, which allows British businesses to sell products including some burgers and sausages in the EU for the first time since Brexit.However, the deal ties the UK to some EU laws concerning food labelling, and the EU is set to vote this week on banning the use of “meaty” terms to describe vegetarian food after lobbying from the livestock industry.The European parliament voted for this ban last month, and this week the European Commission as well as the governments of the 27 member states will decide whether it becomes law.If it does, the UK government believes that the law will also apply to British businesses.

It is understood that the amendment would automatically come into force in the UK were it passed in the EU, and then it would be subject to negotiations, when a specific exemption could be carved out if it was in line with the agreement.The Food Standards Agency is understood to have told stakeholders that UK businesses would be subject to the new EU rules on plant-based labelling, if they were adopted.The “common understanding” between the UK and EU, which underpins the deal, states on labelling: “An exception could only be agreed if: (i) it does not lead to lower standards as compared to EU rules, (ii) it does not negatively affect EU goods being placed on the market in the UK.” Government sources said these clauses would be undermined if a labelling ban took place in the EU and was not adopted in the UK.A government spokesperson told the Guardian that ministers had made a choice to align in some areas where it made sense to do so in the national interest, but that details remained subject to negotiations.

Joel Scott-Halkes, the head of campaigns at WePlanet, said: “The only confusion over plant-based food labelling in Europe is exactly which shadowy livestock lobby is behind it.There’s no genuine, citizen-driven demand to ban veggie burgers or sausages – just a meat industry push to protect its profit margins from a rising tide of dietary change.”The proposed law change has been controversial in Europe.The supermarkets Aldi and Lidl, Burger King and the sausage producer Rügenwalder Mühle said in a joint open letter that banning “familiar terms” would make it “more difficult for consumers to make informed decisions”.The labelling ban has been supported by the French meat industry, and a similar proposal has been discussed by the Italian government.

The German chancellor, Friedrich Merz, has said: “A sausage is a sausage,Sausage is not vegan,”Sign up to Down to EarthThe planet's most important stories,Get all the week's environment news - the good, the bad and the essentialafter newsletter promotionThe French centre-right MEP Céline Imart drafted the amendment to legislation intended to strengthen the position of farmers in the food supply chain,Imart, who is also a cereals farmer in north-west France, said: “A steak, an escalope or a sausage are products from our livestock, not laboratory art nor plant products.

There is a need for transparency and clarity for the consumer and recognition for the work of our farmers.”Riley Jackson, the associate director of commercial at the cultivated meat company Ivy Farm Technologies, said: “Consumers today are savvy and capable of making informed choices.We’ve had black bean burgers and veggie sausages on shelves for decades – formats people know, love, and thus understand how to cook.“At a time when our farming communities are under immense pressure – with 51% of UK farmers considering leaving the industry – we should be welcoming solutions that could increase revenue streams to farmers, not blocking them with red tape that has nothing to do with safety or consumer awareness.Let’s focus on raising all boats by building a strong food system, not building barriers.

”A government spokesperson said: “We are focused on delivering an SPS deal that could add up to £5.1bn a year to our economy by cutting costs and reducing red tape for British growers, producers and retailers.We will not comment on hypothetical scenarios or speculation.”
societySee all
A picture

Pam Zinkin obituary

My mother, Pamela Zinkin, who has died aged 94, was a consultant paediatrician credited with saving the lives of children all over the world. She was also a lifelong campaigner for the NHS.In 1977, by then a single parent with two young sons, Pam moved to newly independent Mozambique to work as a senior paediatrician, then head of paediatrics, at Maputo central hospital. The country’s healthcare was in a precarious state, with 80% of its doctors having left after independence in 1975. Within five years, Pam and her team had reduced mortality among the 8,000 annual child admissions from 25% to 4%

A picture

I am the king of the common cold – and I can tell you how to avoid one | Adrian Chiles

This time last year, I was on a TV programme with three singers. There was a rapper of Ghanaian heritage, a big pop star, and a famous mezzo-soprano. It was deep midwinter. The night before, I’d been at an old friend’s 60th birthday, crammed into the function room of a pub somewhere in Surrey. It had been a good night, but now, just for something to say, I wondered how it was possible to avoid catching a cold when half the people at the party were players in a symphony of coughs, sneezes, snuffles and nose-blows

A picture

Are resident doctors right to strike over pay? | Letters

I totally support the resident doctors’ strike (Why the NHS doctors’ strikes look set to continue, 14 October). I am a retired consultant anaesthetist who worked in the NHS for 40 years. Throughout my career, I felt that I was totally underpaid for my work.As a junior doctor in the 1970s and up until my consultant appointment in 1991, I was paid a pittance for working excessive, unsafe hours – often 80 to 100 hours a week. Accommodation and catering were minimal

A picture

Labour is privatising the NHS in plain sight | Letter

Gaby Hinsliff is right to ask if the government’s reorganisation of the National Health Service will be the final nail in its coffin (Wes Streeting’s gamble with the NHS is greater than any play for Downing Street, 14 November). Such large‑scale redundancies are bound to create problems.There are other threats to the delivery of NHS services too. The privatisation of the NHS is happening in plain sight. Last month, the government proudly announced that “A total of 6

A picture

Krysty was diagnosed with breast cancer months after getting the all-clear. New Australian guidelines aim to help women like her

When Krysty Sullivan had a routine mammogram in 2019, she was given the all-clear.Eleven months later, she felt a lump.Doctors discovered two tumours, each more than 2cm in size. Sullivan, then 48 years old, was diagnosed with triple-negative breast cancer, a type that can be challenging to treat as the cancer cells do not respond to typical targeted treatments.“It’s always a shock to hear that you have breast cancer, but to learn that I had it months after I had a clear mammogram … it was like the Earth shifted,” Sullivan said

A picture

Mahmood and Lammy breached human rights law over segregation of prisoner, judge finds

Shabana Mahmood and David Lammy have been found to have breached a prohibition on inhuman or degrading treatment with respect to a prisoner who spent months segregated from other inmates, in what is believed to be a legal first.Sahayb Abu was confined to his cell at HMP Woodhill in Milton Keynes, for 22 hours a day and prevented from associating with other prisoners for more than four months after Hashem Abedi, the brother of the Manchester Arena bomber, allegedly attacked prison officers at HMP Frankland.Abu, a convicted terrorist serving a life sentence, was already being held in a separation centre for prisoners believed to be at risk or radicalising others, which has also been described as small group isolation, but was moved to even more restrictive conditions following the attack by Abedi in April.In what is believed to the the first instance of ministers being found in breach of article 3 of the European convention on human rights, Mr Justice Sheldon found that Lammy, the justice secretary, and Mahmood, his predecessor, should have considered Abu’s existing mental health issues before he was moved.In his written judgment, the judge said: “In the context of a prisoner who has a history of trauma and where there was a failure to obtain an assessment of his needs even though he was known to have mental health issues, and a failure to provide him with any therapeutic treatment to address his trauma, a contravention of article 3 is made out, notwithstanding the importance of the aim behind the segregation regime