Commons to ask crown estate for details of Prince Andrew’s rent-free housing as inquiry moves closer – as it happened

A picture


Yesterday Keir Starmer told MPs that he favoured a parliamentary inquiry covering Prince Andrew’s housing arrangements at Royal Lodge – the mansion in Windsor which he leases from the crown estate on a deal that involves him paying no rent.Today the Commons public accounts committee (PAC) said it is going to be asking the crown estate for more details of Andrew’s lease arrangements – in what would be the first step towards a full investigation.Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, the Conservative MP who chairs the committee, said:The public accounts committee will be writing in the coming days to the crown estate commissioners and HM Treasury, seeking further information on the lease arrangements for Royal Lodge.In the correspondence, our cross-party committee will be raising a number of questions with the crown estate and HM Treasury.This forms part of our longstanding remit, on behalf of parliament and the British public, to examine the economy, efficiency and effectiveness of public spending, and ensure the taxpayer is receiving best value for money.

Our committee has a further opportunity in 2026 to consider the annual report and accounts for the crown estate, and will make a decision on whether to undertake any work on this in the normal way.We will review the response we receive to our forthcoming correspondence, and will consider at that time whether to seek further information.In the past the PAC has published reports looking at royal finances.But it has not taken evidence from members of the royal family directly, and Ed Davey, the Lib Dem leader, who wants to see Andrew summoned to parliament to face questions from MPs, is unlikely to get his wish granted any time soon.Clifton-Brown does not really need to write to the crown estate for details of the lease; they were published in the Times on Monday evening, after the crown estate responded to a Freedom of Information request.

Official bodies normally take weeks or months to respond to FoI requests.But George Greenwood, the journalist who broke the story, said he got a reply on the day – suggesting somone at the crown estate was not unhappy about the idea of this information appearing in the public domain.The paper said:The Times obtained a copy of the leasehold agreement for Royal Lodge, revealing the terms under which the prince lives on the 30-room estate.It states that, while the prince paid £1m for the lease plus at least £7.5 million for refurbishments completed in 2005, he has paid “one peppercorn (if demanded)” in rent per year, since 2003.

He and his family are entitled to live in the property until 2078,Keir Starmer has said he can’t express how much he disagrees with the Tory MP who wants mass deportations to make the UK more “culturally coherent”,In an interview at the weekend Katie Lam called for the deportation of large numbers of people who are settled in the UK lawfully,At first it was widely assumed that Lam was freelancing, but Lam was in fact describing the official party policy as set out in a bill tabled by Chris Philp, the shadow home secretary, earlier this year,(See 3.

09pm.) Lam said the deportations would leave “a mostly but not entirely culturally coherent group of people”.Asked what he thought of her comments, Starmer told ITV Meridian:I can’t tell you how much I disagree with her.I think that her approach, where people who are lawfully in this country, who have been working in our communities, perhaps in our schools, our hospitals, running businesses, our neighbours, people lawfully here, she wants to reach in and remove them from our country, for cultural reasons, she says.That is how far the Conservative party has sunk.

PM: "I can't tell you how much I disagree with her."Sir Keir Starmer hits back at @Katie_Lam_MP's suggestion that "multiculturalism has not succeeded in this country".The Weald of Kent MP made the comments this week on @itvpeston.@itvmeridian pic.twitter.

com/xFAheH5lYrConservative MPs have complained to party whips after Katie Lam’s comments.Ministers have confirmed plans to reduce affordable housing quotas in London as they try to reverse the recent collapse in housebuilding in the capital.The Commons public accounts committee has asked the crown estate for details of Prince Andrew’s lease, bringing the prospect of a parliamentary inquiry into his rent-free housing one step closer.(See 3.31pm.

)Five survivors invited on to the child sexual exploitation inquiry panel have written to Keir Starmer and Shabana Mahmood to say they will continue working with the investigation only if the safeguarding minister, Jess Phillips, remains in post,The only Black branch chair of Reform UK has left the rightwing populist party, saying the tone of Britain’s migration debate is “doing more harm than good”,Mark Sedwill’s prospects of becoming the UK’s ambassador in Washington have taken a blow after officials raised concerns about an article he wrote in 2021 praising Joe Biden and criticising Donald Trump,For a full list of all the stories covered on the blog today, do scroll through the list of key event headlines near the top of the blog,The use of artificial intelligence can boost trust in the state and tackle problems with the “bloated” public sector, David Lammy said.

In a speech at OpenAI’s Frontiers conference in London this morning, the deputy PM said that the public sector had become “too expensive” and that productivity was still lagging behind pre-pandemic levels, but that AI had the potential to change that,He said:Governments and corporations who seize AI faster and more robustly will surge ahead and those that hesitate will fall very quickly behind,I’m also convinced that if used well – emphasis on used well – AI can help to rebuild trust in the state, badly needed trust in our politics, delivering what people really want: shorter waits, fewer errors, lower costs and better outcomes,He also said:Parts of our bureaucracy have become bloated, they have become too expensive, they have become too unproductive, to the point that too often they fail to meet the needs of the people that they’re meant to serve,And, let’s be frank, public sector productivity is still lagging, certainly behind pre-pandemic levels, and that’s not good for anybody.

It’s certainly not good for the people of our country …If we get this right, if we embed AI across government, across every system, across every service, I believe that we can rejuvenate 150 years of British state enterprise in the next 15 years, possibly even sooner.Voting has closed in the Labour deputy leadership contest.The result will be announced on Saturday.LabourList and Survation do regular polls of Labour members (they survey LabourList members who say they are party members, and weight the results according to what is known the composition of the Labour membership) and they have published their final deputy leadership one.It suggests Lucy Powell will beat Bridget Phillipson by 57% to 40%.

Conservative MPs have complained to party whips after Katie Lam said many legally settled people should be deported to make the UK “culturally coherent”, the Guardian has learned.Eleni Courea and Peter Walker have the story.As expected, the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government has confirmed that it will allow builders to qualify for fast-track planning approval if their developments contain 20% affordable housing – rather than 35%, the current minimum.MHCLG said this was housing building in Londo “has faced significant challenges over recent years due to a combination of the legacy of the previous government, impact of the Covid-19 pandemic, high interest rates, spiralling construction costs, regulatory blockers and wider economic conditions”.In its news release, MHCLG said:Time-limited, emergency measures, which are subject to consultation, will unlock development by making sites more viable and incentivise developers to get spades in the ground through a fast-tracked planning process for sites with at least 20 per cent affordable housing.

Targeted measures will tackle squeezed viability, including the removal of design guidance that constrains density and temporary relief from development levies for schemes able to start promptly and guarantee affordable homes for Londoners.Today’s package will mean that more homes – including affordable homes and those for social rent – can be built and built faster.This ‘use it or lose it’ route will come with strict conditions to speed up the delivery of new homes, which if not met will require developers to share their profits with local boroughs to deliver more affordable homes.Unusually, the announcement has been welcomed by thinktanks on the left and the right.This is from Ben Cooper, head of the Fabian Housing Centre, the housing wing of the Labour thinktank, the Fabian Society.

The collapse of housebuilding in London is the legacy of the previous government, piling up costs on housebuilders and failing to ensure quick planning decisions.Unless this is tackled swiftly, London’s housing crisis will continue to devastate families and communities – leaving thousands trapped in temporary accommodation and many more struggling with the cost of rent or unable to buy.That is why this package is critical to kickstart building in London over the next two years.Additional powers for the mayor will ensure that every part of London is making its contribution to tackling the housing crisis and meeting the 1.5m new homes target.

The temporary reduction in the affordable housing target is a regrettable necessity, to ensure that we don’t see the delivery of affordable and social housing grind to a halt in London.And this is from Ben Hopkinson, head of housing and infrastracture at the Centre for Policy Studies, a Conservative thinktank.The government’s support for housebuilding in London is welcome, and the new policy paper contains some encouraging elements.The removal of costly regulations like those requiring dual aspect and the changes to high affordability requirements, as the CPS has repeatedly called for, are especially good news.The Centre for London also welcomed the news.

Its CEO, Antonia Jennings, said:The 35% affordable homes target for new developments is admirable, and it’s one London should strive for in the long-term,The reality is, however, that 35% of nothing, is nothing,When no new developments are being built, there will be no new social homes,The Labour MP Lloyd Hatton, who has been among those pushing for a fuller inquiry into Prince Andrew, welcomeed the announcement from the public accounts committee,(See 3.

31pm.)He said:It’s good news the public accounts committee is beginning to take a much closer look at this pressing matter.We must scrutinise any taxpayers’ money that may be linked to the Royal Lodge.The public rightly expect parliament to get to the bottom of this.The food minister has faced calls to explain the “ocean-going madness” of spending less than 8% of a new fishing fund on Scotland, PA Media reports.

PA says:During a Commns urgent question this morning Orkney and Shetland MP Alistair Carmichael pressed Angela Eagle to say when she planned to look again at Scotland’s £28m allocation from the £360m UK-wide package.Scotland lands the most fish by quantity and value out of the four UK nations, according to the Government, and the Scottish fishing fleet has landed more than three-quarters of UK quota species, such as cod, haddock and herring, over recent years.The government earlier this year set out its intention to back coastal communities with funding when negotiators struck a 12-year agreement with the EU, granting British fishing access and rights with no increase in the amount which EU vessels can catch in UK waters.“We are working closely with our fishing and seafood sectors to ensure that they’re vibrant, profitable and sustainable alongside a healthy and productive marine environment,” Eagle told the Commons.She said the Fishing and Coastal Growth Fund will “support the next generation of fishers and breathe new life into our coastal communities”.

Eagle continued: “This fund recognises the vital contribution that fishing and coastal communities make to our economy, local communities and national heritage.Designing this fund with stakeholders is paramount to its success, and we want to work with industry and communities to get their views on how to maximise value, and target investment for maximum local impact.”The minister added the fund “would be devolved, providing devolved governments with full discretion of how to allocate funding and reaffirming this Government’s commitment to devolution”, with the allocations for Holyrood, Cardiff Bay and Stormont based on the Barnett Formula.Carmichael, who chairs the Commons’ environment committee, told MPs: “Let’s not forget that this fund was created because the prime minister went and rolled over for 12 years the catastrophically bad deal that Boris Johnson gave us for five.“If the minister is sincere when she says that the aim of the government is to maximise local investment, then to use the Barnett Formula to distribute this is ocean-going madness.

”Brendan O’Hara described the allocation as a “kick in the teeth to those fishing communities” in his Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber constituency,Mairi Gougeon, the Scottish government’s rural affairs secretary, has previously written to Eagle, describing the allocation as “wholly unacceptable”,Wales’s Fishing and Coastal Growth Fund allocation was £18m, with Northern Ireland set to receive £10m,Yesterday Keir Starmer told MPs that he favoured a parliamentary inquiry covering Prince Andrew’s housing arrangements at Royal Lodge – the mansion in Windsor which he leases from the crown estate on a deal that involves him paying no rent,Today the Commons public accounts committee (PAC) said it is going to be asking the crown estate for more details of Andrew’s lease arrangements – in what would be the first step towards a full investigation.

Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, the Conservative MP who chairs the committee, said:The public accounts committee will be writing in the coming days to the crown estate commissioners and HM Treasury, seeking further information on the lease arrangements for Royal Lodge,In the correspondence, our cross-party committee will be raising a number of questions with the crown estate and HM Treasury,This forms part of our longstanding remit, on behalf of parliament and the British public, to examine the economy, efficiency and effectiveness of public spending, and ensure the taxpayer is receiving best value for money,Our committee has a further opportunity in 2026 to consider the annual report and accounts for the crown estate, and will make a decision on whether to undertake any work on this in the normal way,We will review the response we receive to our forthcoming correspondence, and will consider at that time whether to seek further information.

In the past the PAC has published reports looking at royal finances.But it has not taken evidence from members of the royal family directly, and Ed Davey, the Lib Dem leader, who wants to see Andrew summoned to parliament to face questions from MPs, is unlikely to get his wish granted any time soon.Clifton-Brown does not really need to write to the crown estate for details of the lease; they were published in the Times on Monday evening, after the crown estate responded to a Freedom of Information request.Official bodies normally take weeks or months to respond to FoI requests.But George Greenwood, the journalist who broke the story, said he got a reply on the day – suggesting somone at the crown estate was not unhappy about the idea of this information appearing in the public domain.

The paper said:The Times obtained a copy of the leasehold agreement for Royal Lodge, revealing the terms under which the prince lives on the 30-room estate.It states that, while the prince paid £1m for the lease plus at least £7.5 million for refurbishments completed in 2005, he has paid “one peppercorn (if demanded)” in rent per year, since 2003.He and his family are entitled to live in the property until 2078.Five survivors invited on to the child sexual exploitation inquiry panel have written to Keir Starmer and Shabana Mahmood to say they will continue working with the investigation only if the safeguarding minister Jess Phillips remains in post, Geraldine McKelvie reports.

James Cleverly is probably not the only senior Tory who is not aware of the full details of the party’s plan to revoke indefinite leave to remain from many people, including people who have been in receipt of benefits and people earning less than £38,700 a year.(See 12.27pm.) The proposal is so extreme that it is safe to assume that it did not get proper scrutiny before Chris Philp, the shadow home secretary, published it in a private member’s bill.In a column for the Financial Times, Stephen Bush says this could lead to 5% of the UK’s legal population being deported.

He says;[The proposal] essentially means that almost anyone who works in the UK for most of their working life is not going to be able to retire in the UK — which if you are in any way integrated to the country is going to be a huge wrench for you, your friends, neighbours and at least some of your family members.In scale, these proposals would mean deporting greater numbers and a greater proportion of the population than former Ugandan President Idi Amin’s deportation of Ugandan Asians.This scale of population movement is comparable to that which happened with the partition of India and Pakistan and the foundation of the state of Israel …Politically, the big winner here is Nigel Farage.That the Conservative party increasingly holds positions that are further from mainstream British public opinion than Reform, and does so while being blamed by the public for many of the UK’s problems today, is a gift to him in his quest to first become the dominant force on the British right and then to win an election.My colleague Rafael Behr says he has heard suggestions that the Tories published their bill before Kemi Badenoch had even read it
A picture

Rachel Roddy’s recipe for leftover polenta biscuits | A kitchen in Rome

This, then, was the situation: it was Friday night after a long week, and having met a friend on the way home for a glass of wine, which arrived with crisps, taralli, dry roasted peanuts and enough salt that we needed another glass, it seemed a good idea to go home and cook polenta – the long-stir sort as opposed to the instant variety, although I always have that in the cupboard, too. Another good idea, which came to me as I pulled a new packet from the back of the dresser and ignored the flutter of tiny wings, was to make more than enough polenta and pour the extra into a Pyrex dish while it was still hot, so it could set into a block to be cut into slices and grilled the next day.I’ve written about polenta before; how the word is ancient and generic – referring to any mushy dish made from cereal flour and water – and how, after its arrival in Europe in the 1600s, it became synonymous with ground maize. There exists a world of different grades and milling, but, broadly speaking, when you buy ground maize (cornmeal) for polenta, you will have two options: finely ground (which might also be white) for a soft, thin polenta, and coarsely ground, which will have glassy-looking grains and makes an excellent body scrub and a harder, tastier polenta. The latter also takes much longer to cook, anything from 40 minutes to several hours, depending on who (or which packet) you consult, although in my experience an hour is almost always enough, and anything beyond that is more a way of deepening the flavour

A picture

Don’t chuck your parmesan rind – it is an excellent stock cube – recipe | Waste not

Parmesan rinds are the ultimate zero-waste hack – like a cheesy stock cube, they enrich stews, sauces and all sorts, and add pure deliciousness in the form of umami depth and creamy texture. Stored in the fridge or freezer, they keep almost indefinitely. This week’s recipe uses them in a thrifty, creamy corn orzo that transforms a few simple ingredients into comforting autumn fare.This dish was a happy accident, and left me and my family drooling for more. I was planning a classic tomato orzo to use up that half-bag in the cupboard left over from making a pasta salad, but wanted something more seasonal

A picture

No waste, all taste: Max La Manna’s comfort food pantry-raid recipes

Cooking with little to no waste isn’t about rules; it’s about rethinking old habits. Take inventory of the food you already have (I like taking a photo of my fridge and pantry before I go shopping), stick to your list and buy only what you need. Make sure you store it properly, too, so it lasts longer, and don’t forget to cook with a bit of curiosity: that bendy carrot, yesterday’s rice, the broccoli stem you’d normally bin – they all have potential. Start small, and trust me: you’ll notice the wins in no time, saving money, time and food from the bin. For me, low-waste cooking isn’t restrictive, it’s liberation

A picture

If you like piña coladas: how to make slushies at home without a machine

It promises icy, refreshing drinks, and for a cool $179, this slushie maker is yours – if you can find one.Australian TikTok users have become fixated on a Kmart slushie machine, apparently a budget version of the equally viral Ninja slushie machine (RRP A$499), with users posting videos and reviews of their frosty, fruity extrusions. One Australian video has racked up 2.7m views, and the appliance has sold out online. But with Kmart supply chains under scrutiny and the knowledge that culinary trends and the very specific appliances needed to make them are passing fads, not everyone wants to – or has to – buy a machine to make slushies this summer

A picture

Pickle power: how to make your first ferments | Kitchen aide

I love ferments and want to start making my own to save money. Where should I start? Ben, by email“Maybe with some carrots, onions, cucumber or beetroot – anything Ben has an excess of,” says Connor Wilson, head chef at The Kirkstyle Inn in Slaggyford, Northumberland. “Fermentation is a great way of preserving produce, but it won’t give new life to things that are past their best.”That said, tired-looking carrots would be perfect for Olia Hercules’ go-to for newbie fermenters: “If they look dehydrated but without any rotting, they’re amazing to ferment,” says the author of Strong Roots. “The sugars concentrate and you get this bright carrot flavour

A picture

Georgina Hayden’s recipe for parmesan and sage jacket potato gnocchi | Quick and easy

If I’m going to the effort of making jacket potatoes (and by effort I mean putting them in the oven for an hour), I will almost always pop in a few extra spuds to make gnocchi for a later meal. The difference between shop-bought and homemade gnocchi is vast, especially the vac-packed, long-life kind, which are dense and can be heavy. Freshly made gnocchi, with fluffy baked potatoes, however, are light as air, pillowy and silky. If that sounds intimidating, let me reassure you that this recipe is really forgiving, and much easier than making fresh sheet pasta. I love them served simply, as here, with a slightly nutty sage butter and lots of parmesan