Cabinet secretary apparently advised Starmer to wait for vetting before appointing Mandelson
The then cabinet secretary, Simon Case, appeared to advise Keir Starmer to complete security vetting for Peter Mandelson before announcing an appointment, documents reveal.The documents released last month by the Cabinet Office as part of the disclosures over the US ambassadorial appointment also show Mandelson was offered a “higher tiers” briefing before his vetting was finalised.The Guardian revealed last week that Mandelson failed his initial vetting by United Kingdom Security Vetting (UKSV) and that decision was then overruled by the Foreign Office.He was appointed as US ambassador but sacked in September after new disclosures about his friendship with the late child sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.In a letter written by Case to the prime minister, he is advised that in order to give the Washington role to a political appointee, the Foreign Office would “develop a plan for them to acquire the necessary security clearances and do due diligence on any potential conflicts of interest or other issues of which you should be aware before confirming your choice”.
The letter, sent on 11 November 2024, said the decision would then be formalised by the foreign secretary in a letter to the Foreign Office.Mandelson’s appointment was announced by No 10 just over a month later, on 20 December.The documents also show Mandelson was offered a “higher tiers” briefing on 6 January, before his developed vetting was confirmed on 29 January.This means he was offered highly classified briefing from the Foreign Office as US ambassador before he finished the formal vetting process, one he is now known to have failed before that outcome was overruled by the Foreign Office.Starmer will deliver a high-stakes statement to MPs on Monday where he will set out how Mandelson was able to take up his role as UK ambassador without the Foreign Office revealing it had overruled the decision to fail his vetting.
The scandal has already led to the sacking of the top civil servant at the Foreign Office, Olly Robbins, who is expected to appear before MPs on Tuesday in what could be another moment of grave peril for Starmer.In Case’s original letter to Starmer, he suggests political appointments are rare, giving examples of Ed Llewellyn, David Cameron’s former chief of staff who was appointed ambassador to France.Downing Street has strongly disputed claims by allies of Robbins that he was prevented by law from telling ministers Mandelson had failed vetting, arguing that there was a difference between being involved in the decision and being informed about it.It published an explanatory document that said: “No law stops civil servants sensibly flagging UK security vetting recommendations, while rightly protecting detailed sensitive vetting information, to allow ministers to make judgments on appointments or on explaining matters to parliament.”Asked whether it had been a mistake to not follow Case’s advice, Starmer’s official spokesperson said: “Well you’ve heard since this case, I think the chief secretary to the prime minister [Darren Jones] announced this as part of a formal review of the national security system, we’ve changed the process by which appointments can be made ahead of vetting.
”Pressed on why the prime minister had ignored the advice, he said external appointments to the civil service were normally “subject to obtaining security clearance”.Tom Fletcher, the UN undersecretary general for humanitarian affairs, a friend of Robbins, defended his actions on Monday.Speaking to Today on BBC Radio 4, he said: “This is a guy who has public service and integrity stitched into his DNA in a way I haven’t seen in any other single individual.And I’ve worked with so many people inside government.“So he has had an utterly rough few days.
He’s a pretty strong character.But I think he’s heartbroken.”Starmer told the Daily Mirror in an interview on Sunday he would not have appointed Mandelson had he known he had failed vetting.“The fact that I wasn’t told that Peter Mandelson had failed his security vetting when he was appointed is astonishing,” he said.“The fact that I wasn’t told when I said to parliament that due process had been followed is unforgivable, and that’s why I intend to set out in parliament on Monday the facts behind that, so there’s full transparency in relation to it.
“But am I furious that I wasn’t told? Yes, I am,Am I furious that other ministers weren’t told? Yes, I am,I should have been told, and I wasn’t told,”
European stock markets fall and oil and gas prices jump as strait of Hormuz ‘chaos’ worries investors – as it happened
European stock markets have dropped at the start of trading, as last Friday’s optimism about a Middle East peace deal evaporates.In London, the FTSE 100 has dropped by 42 points, or 0.4%, to 10,626 points, away from a six-week high at the end of last week.Germany’s DAX has fallen by 1.3%, and Italy’s FTSE Mib is down 1
Victoria Beckham ties up with Gap as retailer hopes luxe push will drive comeback
From the 80s through to the early noughties it was the go-to high street store for casual hoodies and jeans, before falling out of favour. Now almost 30 years after its heyday, Gap is hoping to turn things around. Key to its comeback strategy? A pivot to more premium fashion.On Friday the retailer will unveil a collection with the luxury fashion designer Victoria Beckham. The collaboration is the next step in the luxification of Gap being led by Richard Dickson, who joined Gap Inc as its president and chief executive from Mattel, the US toymaker, in 2023
How a fiery attack on Sam Altman’s home unfolded
In the early hours of 10 April, a man approached the gate of OpenAI CEO Sam Altman’s house in San Francisco and hurled a molotov cocktail at the building before fleeing. The suspect, 20-year-old Daniel Moreno-Gama, was arrested less than two hours later while allegedly attempting to break into the headquarters of OpenAI with a jug of kerosene, a lighter and an anti-AI manifesto.Federal and California state authorities have charged Moreno-Gama with a range of crimes including attempted arson and attempted murder. His parents issued a statement this week saying that their son had recently suffered a mental health crisis. Moreno-Gama, who has not yet entered a plea, faces up to life in prison if convicted
Kenyan firm sacks more than 1,000 workers after losing Meta contract
More than 1,000 low-paid workers in Kenya have been abruptly sacked by an outsourcing company contracted by Meta, in what activists said was a shocking move exposing the precariousness of tech jobs in the global south.Sama, a company based in Nairobi to which Meta outsourced content moderation and AI training work, announced on Thursday that the workers were being laid off after Meta terminated a contract.Last month reports said some Kenyan workers involved in data annotation were asked to view content filmed using Meta’s AI smart glasses showing wearers using the toilet or having sex.The sacked workers, many involved in AI training, have been given six days’ notice, according to the Oversight Lab, an organisation that advocates for fair regulation and deployment of technology across Africa. It said it was advising the workers on legal options
Why time is not on big-spending Joorabchian’s side in make-or-break season
There was an unexpected, jarring moment in the winner’s enclosure at Newmarket last week as Kevin Philippart de Foy, the principal trainer for the football super-agent Kia Joorabchian’s Amo Racing operation, prepared to discuss his win with Sovereign Spell in the opening race on Craven Stakes day.The familiar “huddle” of reporters was ready to hear what might come next for the three-year-old, but first, the trainer had a question of his own: was anyone there to report for the Racing Post? Amo Racing and the British turf’s trade paper, it seems, are not currently on speaking terms, for reasons best known to themselves.Welcome back to the latest run of the compelling and highly unpredictable docudrama in which Joorabchian attempts to buy his way to racing’s top table. What better moment to catch up on some of the twists and turns in the story arc so far?Back in 2024, long-time viewers will recall, Joorabchian launched a full-frontal assault on the Book 1 sale at Tattersalls in October, going toe-to-toe with the biggest beasts in the game to recruit 22.9m gns (£24m) of yearlings to race in Amo’s purple colours
Brian McDermott to be named new England rugby league head coach this week
The former Leeds Rhinos coach Brian McDermott will be named as Shaun Wane’s successor as head coach of the England men’s national team later this week.McDermott, the most successful coach in Super League history having guided Leeds Rhinos to eight major honours during his time with the club, has seen off interest from the likes of Sam Burgess and the current Rhinos coach, Brad Arthur, to land the honour of taking England to this autumn’s Rugby League World Cup in Australia.The 56-year-old is currently working in the NRL as an assistant coach at Newcastle Knights. However, he has been identified by the Rugby Football League (RFL) as the ideal man to succeed Wane, who parted company with the national team at the start of this year after a series whitewash at the hands of the Kangaroos in last year’s Ashes.McDermott was on a five-man shortlist who were interviewed for the role last week by the governing body
Starmer says it ‘beggars belief’ he wasn’t told about Mandelson vetting failure as he faces down the Commons – UK politics as it happened
What Starmer said, and didn’t say, in the Commons about the Mandelson saga
Starmer the Incurious asks no questions and sees no Mandy-shaped red flags
Is Richard Tice’s picture AI-manipulated? Here are five giveaways
Mandelson vetting saga reveals flaws in Starmer’s judgment, not process | Letters
Starmer orders inquiry into any security concerns over Mandelson’s tenure in US