Humiliation upon humiliation for the Melster in front of half-full Tory crowd | John Crace

A picture


The unbearable lightness of the Tory party conference,A place where nothing ever happens,Where dreams come to die,Where the only joy to be found is in the possibility of forgetting,Oblivion is the hottest ticket on offer.

Above all else, a microverse of infinite sadness and suffering.The banners around the conference compound carry the catchy slogan “Stronger economy.Stronger borders”.They should say “Abandon hope, all ye who enter here”.A colleague asked the guard whether this was the media entrance.

He replied: “It’s anyone’s.It’s so quiet in there.I’ve been to busier dinner parties.” You can’t help feeling that the security is there to stop people leaving, rather than keeping the unwanted out.Inside the complex there is almost nothing going on.

The exhibitors’ hall a ghost town.All the Tories have to offer is some Winston Churchill and Margaret Thatcher tat.It’s like entering a time warp.Ask if there’s any Kemi Badenoch merchandise and you get a shrug of the head.“Nah, mate.

We’ve left that back at the warehouse,This is the only stuff that sells,”All around there is just bewilderment,No one seems quite sure exactly why they have come,Mostly out of habit or because they are in the shadow cabinet and are rather obliged to make an appearance.

Either way, it’s four days of misery for everyone concerned.They are all counting down the minutes till they can leave.The stench of decay is overpowering.An event dedicated to “young voters – under 50”.Nothing that happens here really matters.

During a fringe Spectator event, everyone was so bored that the interviewer asked Robert Jenrick if he would fight a horse-sized duck.It was by far the most interesting point of the day.No one embodies this sense of existential melancholy more than Mel Stride.A man who has been through so many political iterations that he had long since forgotten what he actually believes.If anything.

Mel is a natural-born follower.Someone who puts loyalty to the party above all else.The Melster can be relied on to say whatever he is told to say.Even when he suspects it’s all nonsense.There was something heartbreaking about him having been the last man standing to defend Rishi Sunak during last year’s election campaign.

No embarrassment is ever too much for Mel.He treads a fine line between decency and halfwittedness.And is all too often found on the wrong side.These days Mel is to be found as shadow chancellor.Not because he has any deep grounding in economics but because the Tories don’t really have anyone else.

He is the natural heir to the air-headed Jeremy Hunt,And not in a good way,But these days Kemi has to take what she can get, so the Melster was first up in the main hall on Monday morning,The audience had clearly come pre-warned as there barely was one,The seating capacity is already far smaller than in previous years and the room was barely half full.

It was like a fringe event for friends and family,He had to beg people to stay,But let’s be generous,Even if Mel had a decent story to tell, he’d have struggled to keep what passed for an audience awake,Put simply, he is no public speaker.

All the emphases come in the wrong place,It’s like he’s talking in a third or fourth language that he doesn’t properly understand,At one point he even felt the need to explain a joke as no one had laughed,No one had the heart to tell him that the silence was because it wasn’t funny,The Melster looked crestfallen.

He had chuckled himself to sleep with that one-liner the night before.That was just one of Mel’s tragedies.Humiliation heaped on humiliation.What made his speech an act of desperation was that it was both intellectually dishonest and completely irrelevant.“We need hope,” he said.

“We need a plan.” Unfortunately, Mel was offering neither.Least of all an explanation for the way successive Tory governments of which he had been part had left the country in such a desperate state.He seemed to think Labour had been given a wondrous economic inheritance.About as far from reality as you can get.

Mel ploughed on.A quick bit of backstory that he seemed to think made him more interesting.It didn’t.Then a whole load of promises.Keeping the two-child benefit cap.

Because why would you want to do the one thing that would make most difference to reducing child poverty? Cutting a whole load of benefits – though obviously not to pensioners,Got to protect the last remaining Tory core vote,He ignored the irony that he was proposing cutting the benefits that he had increased in one year as work and pensions secretary,By now the Melster was desperate,He was promising all these things and no one was clapping.

Because none of this was going to happen.Mel could have promised anything.Made any numbers up.It was just words to fill dead air.The audience was only here because they had nowhere better to be.

This was just a meta conference.A conference that only existed because someone had thought there needed to be a conference.His closing words came out as a shout.As if volume made them more real.“We can.

We will,” he said.He can’t.He won’t.You’d have thought we’d just hit rock bottom after that.But then you probably hadn’t banked on Claire Coutinho being up next.

Complete with slideshow that she hadn’t mastered.Quite how she has come to be shadow energy secretary is a mystery.Maybe she knows even less about other things than she does energy.Or maybe her role is just to make the Melster feel better about himself.Claire’s big suggestion that also isn’t going to happen is to get rid of the Climate Change Act, install air conditioning in every building and dent investor confidence in the energy market.

Brilliant,You can’t buy Claire’s level of stupidity,The morning ended with a desultory debate on the Online Safety Act in which no one was much interested,As if there was a prize for the last person left awake,Toby Young argued that the act needed to be abolished.

Far better that teenagers watched unlimited porn so long as rightwing activists had a platform to say whatever they liked,Julia Lopez excitedly announced the meaningless results of the online audience poll,Toby had won by 12 votes to eight,In current Tory circles, that counts as a landslide,A year in Westminster: John Crace, Marina Hyde and Pippa Crerar.

On Tuesday 2 December, join Crace, Hyde and Crerar as they look back with special guests at another extraordinary year, live at the Barbican in London and livestreamed globally,Book tickets here,The Bonfire of the Insanities by John Crace (Guardian Faber Publishing, £16,99),To support the Guardian, order your copy at guardianbookshop.

com.Delivery charges may apply.
societySee all
A picture

Hampstead Heath swimming ponds considering limiting transgender users’ access

A consultation has been launched on transgender swimmers’ access to Hampstead Heath ponds, which could result in them being banned from using the pools for the gender they identify as.The Kenwood Ladies’ and Highgate Men’s ponds are gender-segregated, with trans people currently able to swim in whichever they feel most appropriate, or use the heath’s mixed-gender pond instead.The consultation, by the City of London Corporation (CLC), is now presenting six options for gender inclusivity in the historic institution, one of which would ban trans people from using their preferred ponds.It comes amid a battle between groups who swim in the natural pools, with a protest in 2018 in the men’s pond by women wearing fake moustaches and beards to draw attention to the organisation’s refusal to ban trans women from the ladies’ pond.While this was unsuccessful, the Kenwood Ladies’ Pond Association (KLPA) rejecting a motion among its 200 members last year that “only those born female in sex can use the pond”, pressure has since mounted after the supreme court ruled earlier this year that trans women were not legally defined as women

A picture

Stalin, Putin and an enduring obsession with immortality | Letter

Like Vladimir Putin, Joseph Stalin was interested in immortality (‘To them, ageing is a technical problem that can, and will, be fixed’: how the rich and powerful plan to live for ever, 28 September). In 1939 he read Prolonging Life, a pamphlet promising a lifespan of 150 years, by Aleksandr Bogomolets, a haematologist famous for his rapid-healing serums and blood transfusion methods.Bogomolets promised to prolong life with cytotoxic proteins, herbs and transfusions of young blood. Stalin made him a Hero of Socialist Labour and gave him generous research funding, but was dismayed when he died aged 64 in 1946 (this was hardly Bogomolets’s fault – as a boy in Tsarist times, he visited his mother, a revolutionary serving a sentence of hard labour in a Siberian prison, and caught tuberculosis).Donald RayfieldEmeritus professor, Queen Mary University of London Aleks Krotoski says dictators and US techno-billionaires are striving for immortality

A picture

More than 60,000 cancer patients in England ‘not getting necessary radiotherapy’

More than 60,000 cancer patients a year in England are not getting the radiotherapy they need at all, while some face waits of up to six months to begin the treatment, research has found.The situation is so dire that nearly 100 heads of radiotherapy and oncology – three-quarters of England’s radiotherapy leaders – have warned in an open letter that the government is failing patients.International experts agree that more than half (53%) of all cancer patients will typically need radiotherapy, but exclusive analysis of the latest NHS data in England shows only 35% actually receive it. The study by the charity Radiotherapy UK found 181,023 cancer patients should have received radiotherapy but only 120,569 did, leaving 60,455 patients a year without any radiotherapy at all.Regional inequalities are rife

A picture

Advantages of online GP booking systems | Letters

GPs in England are missing a trick (GPs in England threaten action over online appointment booking plan, 29 September). The point about non-urgent GP appointments is that they do not need triage – if a patient wants to see a primary care clinician for a routine concern, they can do so, whatever the issue.The number of routine slots available remains the same, and allowing people to book them online will reduce, not increase, workload by freeing up reception staff for other admin tasks, and making it easier to get through on the phone for urgent appointments. It’s urgent requests, not routine ones, that need triage.The big problem in primary care is the mismatch between demand and capacity, not how appointments are booked

A picture

Landmark study shows 1.4m Britons have a gambling problem

An estimated 1.4 million adults in Britain have a gambling problem, according to landmark figures released days after the chancellor hinted at plans to increase taxes on the £11.5bn betting and gaming industry.The Gambling Commission’s annual survey found that 2.7% of adults scored 8 or above on the problem gambling severity index, a widely accepted measure analysing negative consequences of betting

A picture

UK woman who refused cancer drugs was influenced by mother, inquest finds

A woman who died after refusing chemotherapy doctors believed would have given her a strong chance of recovery was “adversely influenced” by her conspiracy theorist mother, a coroner has said.Paloma Shemirani died aged 23 in July 2024 after refusing conventional treatment for non-Hodgkin lymphoma. On Thursday, the coroner in her inquest said the influence of her parents, Kay and Faramarz Shemirani, “more than minimally” contributed to her death.“It seems that if Paloma had been supported and encouraged to accept her diagnosis and considered chemotherapy with an open mind she probably would have followed that course,” Catherine Wood told a hearing at Kent and Medway coroner’s court in Maidstone.She said Kay Shemirani “took a leading role in advising Paloma in respect of and facilitating access to alternative treatments”