Reeves wants to talk about the budget, but she’s taken a vow of white noise | John Crace

A picture


It’s this season’s fashion accessory for every politician.Outside election campaigns, press conferences usually signal major set piece events or a national emergency.Now you can’t move for them.Reform have had four inside a week with another one lined up for tomorrow.Even Kemi Badenoch has been at it with a bizarre outdoors show-and-tell last Thursday.

Blink and you would have missed it.Tuesday was Rachel Reeves’s turn.Her Lance Corporal Jones “Don’t Panic! Don’t Panic!” moment.Normally a chancellor takes a vow of silence in the weeks leading up to the budget.Locked away in the Treasury, head down over economic forecasts, anxious to give nothing away.

But not this year.Now Rachel wanted to give as many clues away as possible.Call it the budget performed in interpretative dance.Nothing actually spelled out but the message was clear.Not least in the timing.

A press conference that takes place at 8.10am in Downing Street and is broadcast on nearly every terrestrial channel screams: “Help! Things have gone seriously tits up!” Anyone watching would have been well advised to run for cover.You could see the bad news coming a mile away.This was Reeves trying to catch a break.Hoping to get in the bad headlines early so that, come 26 November, she will get an easier ride.

Let people imagine the worst and be pleasantly surprised when it turns out not to be so terrible as expected.We are rapidly approaching the point where words no longer have meaning.A speech that was delivered as code.Twenty minutes of white noise in which the thing she was trying to tell us was never actually mentioned.How to tell your audience you are going to raise income tax without actually telling them you are planning to raise income tax.

Something she and Keir Starmer have been practising relentlessly for the last couple of months.There can’t be many people left who aren’t preparing to be worse off.So you could call it job done.“I want to be honest with the country,” Reeves said.Really? It didn’t feel that way.

For a start, there was the inability to say the one thing that was on her mind,Around which everything else was just padding and self-justification,Then there were the more philosophical questions,If she was being honest now, how come she hadn’t been able to be honest with us previously? Was the manifesto pledge not to raise income tax, VAT and national insurance never meant to be taken seriously? Just some bullshit to win an election,And why repeat the promise to the CBI when she must have known she was unlikely to be able to keep it?Next we were into Schrödinger’s economy.

At last year’s budget, Reeves had fixed the foundations of the economy and yet somehow failed to fix the foundations of the economy.Everything was both tickety-boo – we were the fastest growing economy in the G7, borrowing costs were going down etc – and yet she somehow now had another hole in the public finances to fill that she hadn’t anticipated.Nor should we be too bothered by the forecasts of the Office for Budget Responsibility because their forecasts were not forecasts.They were forecasts that looked backwards.We’ll have to take her word for that.

Anyone would be facing these choices that could not be named, Rachel continued,And she was proud of what she had done,There would be no return to the austerity of the Tories,Reform had no solutions either,We all just had to bite the bullet and suck it up.

She just hadn’t anticipated quite how much damage Brexit and the Liz Truss budget had done to the economy.Basically, she was just being courteous and doing us all a favour.We should be happy to pay a bit more to protect our public services.Look at it this way, this was far more painful for her than it was for us.We are all so broke we won’t notice becoming even more broke.

“A brighter future is within our grasp,” Reeves concluded.At which point you could feel everyone’s heart sink.Politicians have been saying that repeatedly over the past 15 years and every time things have only got worse.It’s the reverse Midas touch.Understandably most of the questions cut straight to the chase.

Why couldn’t she just admit she was planning on raising taxes and why did she find it so hard to keep her promises? Rachel stonewalled.She had said all she had come to say.Now she just wanted to get the hell out of the room.It had been an excruciating 40 minutes for her.Still, at least almost no one was talking about her embarrassing rental faux pas.

Bank the small wins while you can.Reeves wasn’t the only one having a press conference.Kemi Badenoch was also up and about in front of the cameras.Only whereas the chancellor’s had some tangental purpose, Kemi’s had none whatsoever.Though the Tory leader has clearly got the taste for them.

Her very own echo chamber where she can stand up in front of a small gathering of her shadow ministers and say things that are totally irrelevant to the rest of us straight to camera.Gone and quickly forgotten.With four union jacks behind her, Kemi proceeded to deliver the director’s cut of the speech she had given last week.No one had listened then and no one was paying much attention now.Just an exercise in existential self-indulgence.

This time she droned on for twice as long.Sending twice as many people to sleep.Her theme was the familiar one.Like Nigel Farage, she is a broken record.The country is broken and only she could save it.

Primarily by cutting benefits and a return to austerity.She hasn’t yet realised that as much as people have doubts about Reeves’s ability to turn the country around, the last thing anyone wants is a lecture from the Tories.After all, it was the Conservatives who brought the country to its knees and there is no enthusiasm for their return.The kindest thing they could do is give us all a break and self-destruct in private.A year in Westminster: John Crace, Marina Hyde and Pippa Crerar.

On Tuesday 2 December, join Crace, Hyde and Crerar as they look back with special guests at another extraordinary year, live at the Barbican in London and livestreamed globally.Book tickets hereThe Bonfire of the Insanities by John Crace (Guardian Faber Publishing, £16.99).To support the Guardian, order your copy at guardianbookshop.com.

Delivery charges may apply,
trendingSee all
A picture

Drax power plant to go on earning ‘over £1m a day’ from burning wood pellets

Britain’s biggest power plant will continue to earn more than £1m a day from burning wood pellets under a new government subsidy contract designed to halve its financial support, according to analysts.The Drax power plant in North Yorkshire is in line to earn £458.6m a year between 2027 and 2031 after the government agreed to extend its subsidies beyond 2026, according to analysts at Ember, a climate thinktank.The earnings are well below the £869m in subsidies handed to the Drax power plant last year for generating about 5% of the UK’s electricity from burning biomass after the government promised to curb the use of biomass in Britain’s power system.Under the contract, Drax will be paid to run just over a quarter of the time, down sharply from almost two-thirds of time currently

A picture

European markets down and Asian chipmakers tumble in global stock sell-off amid worries over AI bubble – as it happened

Jim Reid, analyst at Deutsche Bank, said there is talk of whether we are “on the verge of an equity correction”.The last 24 hours have brought a clear risk-off move, as concerns over lofty tech valuations have hit investor sentiment. Markets compounded these losses in the early hours of Asian trading but have been rallying back in the couple of hours prior to going to print with US futures clawing back towards flat with the Kospi rallying back a couple of percentage points from early -5% plus losses.On Wall Street yesterday, the S&P 500 closed down 1.17%, losing ground because of sharp losses among tech stocks, and there was a big slump for Palantir (-7

A picture

Elon Musk’s $1tn Tesla pay deal to be rejected by huge Norway wealth fund

Norway’s sovereign wealth fund has said it will vote against a $1tn (£765bn) pay package for the Tesla chief executive, Elon Musk.The fund, which is the biggest national wealth fund in the world, said that while it appreciated the “the significant value created under Mr Musk’s visionary role” it would vote against his performance award.“We are concerned about the total size of the award, dilution and lack of mitigation of key person risk – consistent with our views on executive compensation,” it said. “We will continue to seek constructive dialogue with Tesla on this and other topics.”The warning from Norges Bank, which is the seventh biggest single shareholder in Tesla with a stake worth $17bn, comes two days before the carmaker hosts its annual shareholder meeting

A picture

Apple Watch SE 3 review: the bargain smartwatch for iPhone

Apple’s entry level Watch SE has been updated with almost everything from its excellent mid-range Series 11 but costs about 40% less, making it the bargain of iPhone smartwatches.The Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.The new Watch SE 3 costs from £219 (€269/$249/A$399), making it one of the cheapest brand-new fully fledged smartwatches available for the iPhone and undercutting the £369 Series 11 and the top-of-the-line £749 Apple Watch Ultra 3

A picture

Who is Joe Marler? From hair-raising rugby antics to breakout star of Celebrity Traitors

Viewers have been won over by the quick-witted and quirky former England international. But do they all know about the groin-grabbing and that ‘horse’ of his?It’s difficult to know where to begin with a not-so-quick guide to Celebrity Traitors’ breakout star, Joe Marler. The BBC series has introduced a wider public to the tattooed, 18-stone-plus former England rugby union player – fans won over by his quick-witted humour, allied to a direct, confrontational form of questioning and an uncanny knack for detective work.Not all viewers, though, will be au fait with his backstory; the 35-year-old dungaree-wearing ex-prop forward admitted he was mistaken for a sound technician by his fellow celebrities when first on set, and then asked whether he played rugby league when he revealed his previous 15-year career. For those who know rugby union, however, Marler’s style on the show has come as little surprise, save it being slightly toned down for a wider public audience

A picture

Fast-rising Fiji carry a nation’s pride in redemption match with England | Luke McLaughlin

True, they are the lowest-ranked team England will play this month, but it would be highly dangerous to underestimate Fiji. Coming between an opening victory against Australia and a box‑office encounter with the All Blacks, it might be easy to regard the Twickenham game on Saturday as a relatively straightforward assignment. Easy, but foolish.You don’t have to go back far – two years or so, to an autumn afternoon in Marseille and England’s 2023 Rugby World Cup quarter-final – to remember how potent Fiji can be.Picture the scene: with 10 minutes to play at Stade Vélodrome, Vilimoni Botitu’s attractive try has levelled the score at 24-24