Starmer’s disability benefit concessions are not enough, says rebel Labour whip
The Labour whip who resigned in protest against disability benefit cuts has said Keir Starmer’s concessions do not yet go far enough to win her over, as No 10 launched a fresh attempt to stem the revolt against its welfare bill.Vicky Foxcroft, who quit her frontbench role over the welfare bill a little more than a week ago, urged the government to work jointly on the changes with disabled people and to publish the review of the system before bringing in cuts.In an interview with the Guardian, Foxcroft said she had not made up her mind how to vote on Tuesday but would need assurances about further improvements.“I would hope that actually we start to ensure we listen to disabled people and their organisations right across government.This isn’t just about warm words.
This is about making sure we get policy right,” she said.Starmer is facing a challenging 48 hours as No 10 battles to persuade Labour MPs to back the welfare bill now that the government has promised that current claimants of personal independence payment (Pip) will not be subject to proposed cuts.It also pledged that the health element of universal credit will rise at least in line with inflation.The Department for Work and Pensions will on Monday publish the terms of reference for a review of personal independence payment (Pip) to be undertaken by a minister, Stephen Timms, which the government says will be “co-produced” with disabled people.It will set out £300m of employment support to be brought forward over the next three years, and publish draft regulations on the “right to try” – allowing disabled people to try work without risking their financial support.
Liz Kendall, the work and pensions secretary, said: “This is about delivering a fairer, more compassionate system as part of our plan for change which supports people to thrive, whatever their circumstances.”However, critics of the welfare cuts will be looking carefully at the timetable for the Timms review, as many want to see it published before the reduction in Pip due in November next year.Alternatively, they want to see the cuts delayed until after the review of the system is published.Dozens of Labour MPs appear yet to be convinced, with estimates that 50 to 60 would like to see further changes, although one of the leading original critics, Louise Haigh, the former transport secretary, said she was now likely to back the legislation.Meg Hillier, the Treasury committee chair, has also switched to say she will back the bill, but many others are waiting to see further details.
In her first interview since quitting, Foxcroft said it was “good to hear that people won’t be losing their benefits who are currently on them” but said there were “areas where I still think there’s need for movement”,The MP said one of the biggest issues was the need for co-production with disabled people and disability groups, and that should have happened “absolutely from the start”,“This is the problem,And this is why a lot of people have said, ‘Can we delay this? Can we pause this until we ensure that we properly get it right?’ Right now, we’re kind of tinkering in terms of things to make it the least worst situation we can, and we need to learn lessons from that and make sure that we get these things right going forward,” she said,The former shadow minister for disabled people said she would also like to see the Pathways to Work review by Timms published before the implementation of the bill that would bring in cuts.
The 12-week consultation period began on 7 April.Foxcroft said she did not see herself as a rebel and had not wanted to resign but felt welfare bill plans would hurt the most vulnerable and she knew she could not whip or vote for something she did not believe in.She said the whips had been “raising … for months” that Labour MPs were not happy with the disability cuts and that potentially part of the problem for Downing Street had been “maybe ensuring that you listen to what the chief whip says”.But she said it was important that the prime minister “appreciates he needs to be in listening mode more … and I think you’ve got to really respect it when somebody does come out and say that”.Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotionStarmer acknowledged in an interview with the Sunday Times that he did not get a grip on the Labour rebellion over disability benefits earlier because he was focused on foreign affairs.
The prime minister acknowledged he had not got it right, and said he would have wanted to make the concessions earlier.“I’d have liked to get to a better position with colleagues sooner than we did,” Starmer said.“I’m putting this as context rather than an excuse.”Foxcroft is one of dozens of Labour MPs who remain worried about the changes, despite concessions made by Kendall in a midnight email on Thursday.Marie Tidball, a Labour MP who has a disability and chairs two all-party groups on autism and disability, wrote in the Guardian on Sunday that she wanted the bill to be produced along with disabled people, to promise more consultation over the summer, and to do better on enabling more people to work.
“Fundamentally, I will be looking for further reassurances that the detail will fulfil Labour’s manifesto commitments to disabled people,” she said,Olivia Blake, one of the few Labour MPs with a disclosed disability, also accused the government of creating an “unethical two-tier system” by its welfare bill concessions – and urged rebels to stand firm,The Disability Labour-affiliated group is also asking all MPs to oppose the legislation,In another development, a legal opinion commissioned by the union Equity and given by Jamie Burton KC of Doughty Street Chambers, concluded that “the aggressive measures set out in the government’s proposals will inevitably result in very serious breaches of the UK’s obligations under the UN convention on the rights of persons with disabilities and the international covenant on economic, social and cultural rights,”He added: “They are likely to be condemned by the treaty-monitoring bodies, who have become all too familiar with very similar reforms designed to cut the welfare bill and promote work, but which ultimately result in yet further and longstanding human rights violations for disabled people.
”A DWP spokesperson said: “The secretary of state has carefully considered, and will continue to consider, all her legal obligations and is satisfied that these reforms are lawful,” This article was amended on 30 June 2025,Labour’s proposed cuts to personal independence payments are due to be implemented in November 2026, not this year as a previous version said,
My cultural awakening: Buffy gave me the courage to escape my conservative Pakistani upbringing
I was 10, cross-legged on the floor of my parents’ living room in Newcastle, bathed in the blue light of a TV. The volume was set to near-silence – my dad, asleep in another room, had schizophrenia and frontal lobe syndrome, and I didn’t want to wake him. Then, like some divine interruption to the endless blur of news and repeats, I stumbled across Buffy the Vampire Slayer. The show may have been barely audible, but it hit me like a lightning bolt.Before Buffy, life was like a pressure cooker
Your front-row pass to who the performers will be watching at Glastonbury
Hello from Worthy Farm, home to Glastonbury festival! As is tradition, this newsletter is coming to you from a sparsely apportioned cabin behind the festival’s legendary Pyramid stage, which this weekend will feature headline sets from The 1975, Neil Young and Olivia Rodrigo.The festival proper is kicking off right about now, though really it has been whirring away for two days already. The official opening was on Wednesday night: a circus spectacular on the Pyramid stage featuring jugglers, drummers, fire-flinging dancers and a bloke doing handstands on a fairy-light-strewn bike suspended above the audience. The extravaganza came courtesy of the talented folk from Glastonbury’s theatre and circus fields, who were tasked with opening the festival for the first time since the early 90s.(Incidentally, the Theatre and Circus Fields have a pretty remarkable origin story: in 1971 Winston Churchill’s granddaughter Arabella was being relentlessly hounded by the paparazzi in London, having created a bit of a stink by daring to speak out against the Vietnam war
‘Joyous, immersive’ Beamish wins Art Fund museum of the year award
Beamish, the Living Museum of the North, has won the prestigious Art Fund museum of the year award, the largest such prize in the world.Awarding it the £120,000 prize, judges called Beamish a “joyous, immersive and unique place shaped by the stories and experiences of its community”.The open-air museum in County Durham, which is celebrating its 55th anniversary, brings north-east England’s Georgian, Edwardian, 1940s and 1950s history to life through immersive exhibits.Visitors engage with costumed staff and volunteers and experience regional stories of everyday life. The museum has a longstanding commitment to preserving local heritage
Seth Meyers on Trump’s new Nato nickname: ‘Why is anyone calling him daddy?’
Late-night hosts discussed Donald Trump’s belief that he should win a Nobel peace prize and the bizarre new name given to him by the Nato chief.On Late Night, Seth Meyers said that Trump’s insistence that he deserves the Nobel peace prize for inserting himself into the Iran-Israel conflict is “obviously insane” but “at best we can trick him” by offering him a “Babybel piece of cheese on a lanyard”.He added that “no president should get a Nobel peace prize” and played footage of Trump listing all of the things he has done that deserve one. “This idiot thinks it’s the Nathan’s hotdog contest,” he said.Meyers said that Trump is thirsty for praise “for stopping an illegal war he started” and is now “absolutely livid” that the ceasefire was violated
Stephen Colbert on Ice: ‘Constantly devising new terrible ways to treat immigrants’
Late-night hosts talked about US involvement in the Israel-Iran conflict and how the situation at home should be higher on the priority list.On The Late Show, Stephen Colbert spoke about the “tenuous ceasefire” that Donald Trump has been taking credit for after getting involved in the situation between Israel and Iran.The president’s controversial decision to bomb Iran has led some of his most ardent loyalists to claim he deserves the Nobel peace prize.Colbert said he is “not sure if they give an award for bombing people into submission” and anyway, they “kept bombing each other” despite an alleged ceasefire.The ongoing conflict led Trump to lose his cool with press, telling reporters that Israel and Iran “don’t know what the fuck they’re doing”
‘She killed three husbands with this teapot’: Prue Leith, Huw Stephens and more pick their favourite museum
From a stray meteorite to an immersive coal pit, via the chance to sit on a ‘feeding chair’, famous fans tell us how they fell in love with the UK’s Museum of the Year finalistsIt’s rare to hear someone getting this excited over a teapot. But as Terry Deary tells me, with exactly the kind of relish you’d expect from the author of Horrible Histories, this particular drinks vessel belonged to the Victorian-era mass murderer Mary Ann Cotton. Believed to have killed 12 of her children, not to mention three husbands, she was finally caught after poisoning her stepson in 1872 with an arsenic-laced brew. “And in Beamish they’ve got the teapot!” says Deary. “I was blown away to hold it!”He’s talking about Beamish, the Living Museum of the North, an open-air site based in County Durham (just like Cotton herself, who was eventually hanged in Durham Gaol)
Lindsey oil refinery owner Prax falls into administration as ministers urged to intervene
Speed restrictions imposed on two main train lines amid UK heatwave
WH Smith cuts sale price of high street business by £12m
UK households hit by squeeze on living standards despite fastest growth in G7
Number of new UK entry-level jobs has dived since ChatGPT launch – research
What would happen if Thames Water is temporarily renationalised?