What would happen if Thames Water is temporarily renationalised?
When the environment secretary, Steve Reed, stood up in parliament earlier this month his message for the owners of the struggling Thames Water appeared clear: there would be no leniency on fines for breaching environmental standards – despite the requests of creditors who control the company,Amid the standoff, Reed said the government had “stepped up our preparations” for the next stage: putting the company, a provider of water and sewage services to 16 million customers in London and south-east England, into temporary nationlisation, known as a special administration regime (SAR),Thames Water’s perilous position stems from years of mismanagement, during which it built up unsustainable debts of about £20bn,Over the past year its problems have come to a head, with the company scrambling through a court battle in February to secure emergency funding, and now finding new owners,Things have not gone smoothly.
The US investor KKR pulled out of its bid to buy Thames, leaving a group of about 100 creditors in line to take over the ownership.They include big institutional investors such as Aberdeen, BlackRock, Invesco and M&G, as well as US hedge funds such as Elliott Management and Silver Point Capital.So what would temporary nationalisation actually involve?Rather than selling off the business for parts, the special administrator’s first priority is maintaining the essential water service.Similar regimes are in place for other crucial institutions such as energy companies, the Post Office and banks.The creditors would have a claim on proceeds of an eventual sale after that objective has been achieved.
Senior class A bondholders would expect to receive some money back,The loans of class B creditors are likely to be worthless, and Thames’s official owners last year acknowledged that their shares were worth nothing,No water company has gone through special administration,But the energy company Bulb was nationalised temporarily in 2022 after surging energy prices forced it into insolvency,That process ended up making the government money when energy prices returned to normal.
Some of the most detailed cost estimates have come from consultants at Teneo hired by Thames Water.They said SAR would require as much as £4.1bn in funding from the UK government – seemingly a daunting addition to government debt.Yet the Teneo report and another prepared by consultants at Kroll make it clear they expect that burden to be temporary: even in the worst-case scenario, the government would eventually recover 100p in the pound.Dieter Helm, an Oxford University professor who has advised previous Labour and Conservative governments on energy and water policy, said: “Whatever way it’s done, it’s pretty much inconceivable the government will not recover its costs.
”Thames Water argued there would still be big extra costs of £51m a month as suppliers put pressure on and people leave the business – although many of these were forcefully disputed in court,Whatever the costs, they would be covered by the proceeds of an eventual sale out of SAR, with whatever is left shared out between the creditors,Such a sale does not seem impossible: the Hong Kong-based CK Infrastructure reportedly asked this month for its bid to be considered again,Helm has argued that the government should opt for SAR in order to prevent a free-for-all of special pleading from other water companies hoping to avoid fines,“Every regulatory regime has to have a procedure for handling failure,” Helm said.
“Currently nobody knows what happens if you get into trouble.Nobody knows what happens if you play with the finances.”Charlie Maynard, the Liberal Democrat MP who intervened in the February court case and is appealing to the supreme court, wants Thames to be mutually owned by its customers after an SAR process to cut its debts.Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotion“It’s clear from Thames Water’s own adviser that SAR will have a zero net cost so it is ridiculous that the government has not put the company into SAR already,” he said.“SAR is the only way that the company will end up with a balance sheet strong enough to manage the material spending required over the next 10 or so years to get Thames Water’s sewage system back in to shape and stop our rivers being filled with excrement.
”One person with knowledge of the Bulb administration process said: “Sorting out Thames Water in the public sector will be cheaper in the long run.The government definitely shouldn’t be afraid.”Thames Water and the main creditors are strongly opposed to SAR.A Thames spokesperson said: “An SAR doesn’t fix Thames Water’s problems.It will delay the delivery of improvement for our customers and the environment.
It will be disruptive, add risk and uncertainty, increase costs, hinder our operational turnaround, destabilise our stakeholders and colleagues, and will not fix the balance sheet.”Creditors also have a lot to lose if forced to write off debts beyond the £6.7bn – or about 20p of every pound initially lent – they have offered to reduce Thames’s financial burden.But under the worst-case scenario set out by Teneo, they could only receive 45p for every pound of debt.There are other arguments against SAR that the government may find compelling.
One of the most notable is that Thames’s operations are in need of a turnaround, so the prospect of the government owning every sewage overflow or flood may be unattractive,Trustees of the pension fund have also raised concerns,The Thames creditors also include some powerful investors who have told the government that imposing steep losses will make them much less willing to invest in Britain in the future,They argue that even if the government does not face any direct costs, the indirect cost will be much greater,On top of that, Thames and the creditors claim that any future owner will still require regulatory easements – leaving the government back where it started.
A spokesperson for the creditors said Thames Water needed £5bn immediately and “SAR is the wrong answer with a viable market solution on the table”.They added: “Any exit from SAR will require regulatory support and SAR will only delay and increase the cost of the turnaround and leave customers and the taxpayer exposed to the continued risk of Thames Water’s worsening environmental performance.”Thames Water has enough money to make it to next year at least, but eventually the creditors will have to either move forward with the takeover or pull out if they are not granted regulatory easements such as exemption from fines and prosecution during the turnaround.Some people expect litigation from creditors if it gets to SAR.However, the process gives the government, in tandem with the appointed special administrator, a lot of power, according to a senior restructuring lawyer close to the situation.
“It is very challenging for the creditors,” the lawyer said,The preferred option for the government is still a private-sector owner without government intervention,But if no deal can be reached, temporary nationalisation may be the only option left,
My Glastonbury food odyssey: 10 of the best dishes – whether you’re feeling hungover or healthy
From vegan katsu curry to smoked barbecue brisket, the festival has an incredible array of street food. Here are the stalls worth queueing forThe food choices at Glastonbury can feel overwhelming – a smorgasbord of street food from around the world, which can trigger terrible choice paralysis when you’re operating with a hangover, on zero sleep, or both. Fear not. Here are some guaranteed Glastonbury food wins, whether you’re looking to stave off the mother of all hangovers or simply on the hunt for something green.South of the Pyramid stageA massaman curry served on brown rice (£14), this is loaded with nutritious ingredients, including greens, kimchi pickles and new potatoes
Benjamina Ebuehi’s recipe for bubble tea ice-cream sundaes | The sweet spot
I absolutely adore bubble tea: it’s such a fun drink. I find it impossible to be anywhere near Chinatown in London without ordering one, and the brown sugar milk tea flavour is my go-to. The “bubble” refers to the balls of tapioca that are cooked until chewy, a texture I find so pleasing; if you like mochi, this will be right up your street.You should be able to find quick-cook tapioca pearls in most large Asian supermarkets; I tend to avoid the plain white tapioca pearls because they can take more than an hour to cook.Prep 5 min Cook 20 min Serves 4150g quick-cook brown sugar tapioca 100g light brown sugar 2 English breakfast tea bags 100ml double cream ½ tsp flaky sea salt 8 scoops vanilla ice-cream Chocolate sprinkles or shavings, to serveBring a saucepan of water to a boil, add the tapioca pearls and cook for three to four minutes, until they’ve got a chew to them but are still a little firm
Summer calls for chilled red wine
Last week’s column was a casual toe-dip into the lido of summer-centric drinks writing. I write these columns just over two weeks in advance, so I need Met Office/clairvoyant weather prediction skills to work out what it is we’re likely to be drinking by the time the column comes out. But I’m going to go out on a limb here and declare that summer will be here when you read this. No, don’t look out of the window. Keep looking at your phone screen, and imagine the sun’s beating down outside
‘I don’t have rules’: cooks on making perfect porridge at home
The cookbook author Elizabeth Hewson cherishes her winter breakfast routine. She creeps downstairs before sunrise, while her husband and children are still sleeping, to make herself a bubbling pot of porridge.“It’s that small moment of peace before the day gets going,” she says. “The rhythm of standing at the stove stirring is one of those quiet rituals that I love.”She makes it with traditional oats, usually toasted dry then soaked in water overnight
How to turn the whole carrot, from leaf to root, into a Moroccan-spiced stew – recipe | Waste not
Today’s warming recipe makes a hero of the whole carrot from root to leaf, and sits somewhere between a roast and a stew. The lush green tops are turned into a punchy chermoula that is stirred into the sauce and used as a garnish.One image has stayed with me ever since a journey through a small Moroccan village near Taghazout, just west of Marrakech, all of 12 years ago. Bright orange carrots lay in vast heaps on contrasting blue tarpaulin spread across the ground. I was especially struck by how the vast majority of each pile was green with the feathery foliage that was still attached to the roots we love
Empanadas and stuffed piquillos: José Pizarro’s recipes for green peppers
Peppers are more than just staples of the Spanish kitchen, they are one of our culinary foundations. As with tomatoes, when Columbus returned from the Americas in the late 15th century, he presented peppers as a gift to Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand, and they very quickly became a key part of our cooking traditions. The pepper’s most iconic contribution to Spanish cuisine is surely pimentón de la Vera, or smoked paprika, which is an essential seasoning in a lot of Spanish cooking, adding exquisite depth to stews, rice dishes, seafood and, of course, chorizo. But we also celebrate fresh peppers in all their guises. Padrón peppers are, of course, a classic tapa, while pimientos rellenos (stuffed peppers) are filled every which way, from seafood and minced meat to creamy bechamel
Lindsey oil refinery owner Prax falls into administration as ministers urged to intervene
Speed restrictions imposed on two main train lines amid UK heatwave
WH Smith cuts sale price of high street business by £12m
UK households hit by squeeze on living standards despite fastest growth in G7
Number of new UK entry-level jobs has dived since ChatGPT launch – research
What would happen if Thames Water is temporarily renationalised?