Fiscal recklessness aside, it’s the super-rich who’ll benefit from Reform UK policies | Richard Partington
For a politician who has done more than most to shape Britain’s current challenges, nothing seems to stick to Nigel Farage.Not the chaos of the post-Brexit referendum years; or the contradiction of his closed-border English nationalism combined with a fondness for courting nomad capitalists from Malaysia to Mar-a-Lago.This is, of course, because the Reform UK leader is the agitator-in-chief.He has prodded successive prime ministers into action, but has not been in the driving seat himself.Things though are changing.
When Keir Starmer turned his guns on Reform last week, blasting the party’s “fantasy economics”, he made clear that Farage is now Labour’s most serious rival.While Kemi Badenoch has led the Conservatives into increasing irrelevance, Reform has marched on to once traditional Labour ground on the economy, while keeping a rightwing stance on immigration and culture.It is clear that Farage sees an opening to peel support away from both traditional parties at once.It is no fantasy to suggest that Farage, riding high in opinion polls, could become prime minister.He should expect heightened scrutiny of his policies as a result, not least on economic policy, where there are serious questions marks over whether Reform’s tax and spending plans add up.
However, something is lost in the argument about Farageonomics.Not only are the party’s numbers hardly better than scribblings on the back of one of its leader’s umpteen fag packets, but there is a more fundamental problem: his plans would not help the communities that Reform claims to champion.Yes, scrapping the two-child limit on benefits, introduced by the Conservatives but maintained by Labour – something Farage promised he would do – would be welcome.At least 350,000 children would be lifted out of poverty overnight, at a cost of £2bn – barely a rounding error in the government’s more than £1tn of annual spending.Why Labour has not taken this step is a mystery.
There is the tight position of public finances, but perhaps also a political calculation that Reform-curious voters are among the majority of people who tell opinion pollsters that benefits eligibility is too lax.As is clear from recent weeks, Britain’s attitudes are not that simple to triangulate.Labour has made a grave political error in reckoning otherwise.Farage’s other policies remain straight from the rightwing, free-market libertarian playbook.They would help working-class families little, and the super-rich a lot.
Central to Reform’s election manifesto was a plan to cut £60bn from income tax.It would raise the personal allowance from £12,750 at present to £20,000 a year, while lifting the 40% higher-rate threshold from £50,271 to £70,000.Unspecified welfare cuts worth £15bn also feature – a sum three times larger than the savings Labour is pushing to find from the disability and incapacity support bill, which has provoked nationwide anger.Lifting more people out of tax altogether might sound beneficial for poorer households, and for many it would be.However, most of the gains from these vastly expensive policy changes would flow to the rich.
According to analysis by the IPPR thinktank, raising the personal allowance would come with a cost to the exchequer of at least £40bn a year, and hand the poorest 20% of households an extra £380 on average in annual household disposable income,However, the richest fifth would get a vast £2,400 extra,Changes to the higher-rate threshold would cost the exchequer about £18bn a year, and would benefit the poorest fifth of families by just £17,The richest, again, would get a much bigger boost, of £2,700,Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionTaken together, the top 10% of households would get 28p for every £1 of cash forgone by the exchequer, while the bottom 10% would receive only 2p.
Where in Britain would the winners and losers be from these vast distributive changes? For those with the biggest gains, look no further than London, home to 47 out of 50 local areas with the highest incomes before housing costs, according to the latest official figures, including Westminster, Kensington and Chelsea, Wandsworth and Camden.Of the 50 areas with the lowest incomes, more than half are in Yorkshire and the Humber, with a further quarter in the East Midlands, places where Reform has gained the most ground in the opinion polls.Those in Farage’s constituency of Clacton, where average earnings are £25,670 a year, would gain far less than in the leafy London commuter belt seat of Orpington, where the Reform leader has a £1m property and typical pay is £41,385 a year.In defence of Farage, something resembling an opposition to Labour’s vast parliamentary majority is not a bad thing.Starmer should not be surprised that the poorest communities in Britain are deserting Labour.
Promising “change”, then continuing as the Tories did, with high-profile benefit cuts, will do that.Starmer’s attack on Farage’s fiscally irresponsible stance may highlight Labour’s discipline but could also backfire.Voters are of course keen for the numbers to add up – nobody would relish another Liz Truss moment – but Labour’s attack is reminiscent of the ill-fated Project Fear, as opponents named the campaign to stay in the EU, and risks reinforcing a sense that the party has lost its purpose in the depths of a Treasury spreadsheet.Where the prime minister should focus is on using words and deeds to show the country’s poorest communities that Labour can change things for the better, in contrast to the cod working-class values of his shape-shifting opponent.
Facebook and Instagram owner Meta to enable AI ad creation by end of next year
The owner of Facebook and Instagram is to help advertisers to fully create and target campaigns using artificial intelligence tools by the end of next year, in a move that sent shock waves through the traditional marketing industry.Mark Zuckerberg’s Meta, which also owns WhatsApp, aims to directly target brands’ marketing budgets, posing a threat to the advertising and media agencies that handle client campaigns and budgets.The AI tools under development, first reported by the Wall Street Journal, will allow brands using Meta’s advertising platform to create ads using a product image and a planned marketing spend.Meta’s platform already offers some AI tools that allow advertisers to tweak existing ads before they appear on Facebook and Instagram.However, the new tools could disintermediate the traditional advertising creation, planning and buying roles played by agencies, as well as open up a long tail of advertisers with small budgets that cannot afford to retain marketing services companies
‘Humanity deserves better’: iPhone designer on new partnership with OpenAI
The designer of the iPhone has promised his next artificial intelligence-enabled device will be driven by a sense that “humanity deserves better”, after admitting feeling “responsibility” for some of the negative consequences of modern technology.Sir Jony Ive said his new partnership with OpenAI, the company behind ChatGPT, would renew his optimism about technology, amid widespread concerns about the impact of smartphones and social media.In an interview with the Financial Times, London-born Ive declined to give details about the device he is developing with OpenAI, but indicated unease about people’s relationship with some tech products.“Many of us would say we have an uneasy relationship with technology at the moment,” he said. He added that the device’s design would be driven by “a sense of ‘we deserve better
More than 130 official suppliers willing to sell cloned UK number plates, experts find
More than 130 official suppliers of vehicle number plates in the UK are willing to sell cloned versions that could thwart police and avoid congestion charges, according to an investigation by government advisers.The alleged abuse of the system is described by the academics as a risk to law enforcement, road safety and the country’s critical national infrastructure.The expert group, which includes Dr Fraser Sampson, who was the government’s biometric surveillance camera commissioner until 2023, warns that the country is dependent on the “humble number plate”, but “anyone can become a DVLA-registered number plate scheme (RNPS) member on payment of £40.”They write: “There is no vetting, no trading history requirement and no monitoring of members’ practices.“To date we have found over 135 DVLA-registered RNPS members nationally who were prepared to make cloned plates … and there will undoubtedly be more
What is the most common mental health misinformation on TikTok?
Thousands of influencers peddle mental health misinformation on social media platforms – some out of a naive belief that their personal experience will help people, others because they want to boost their following or sell products.As part of a Guardian investigation, experts established clear themes to the misinformation contained in videos posted with a #mentalhealthtips hashtag on TikTok.Several videos about borderline personality disorder suggest symptoms that are everyday experiences – such as feeling anxiety when people change plans, experiencing mood swings, a fear of abandonment and mirroring people’s behaviour to be liked.Another video purports to show how depression manifests in the workplace as a lack of concentration, feeling tired, having low energy levels, a loss of appetite and irritability.“While some of the ‘symptoms’ overlap with depression, these can be attributed to a range of afflictions and struggles,” said Liam Modlin, a therapist and psychology researcher at King’s College London
Starmer says Farage would spook the City and give us Truss 2 – he could be right
The message Zia Yusuf wanted to send was clear. With a backdrop of the City of London behind him, from the 34th floor of the Shard, the Reform UK chair laid out an economic policy designed to show his party meant business.In a briefing over a full English breakfast for some of the nation’s journalists on Friday morning, Yusuf reiterated an announcement the Reform leader, Nigel Farage, had made overnight from another hotel 5,000 miles away in Las Vegas: the party would now accept donations in bitcoin, and if elected to power would make tax and regulatory changes to bolster Britain’s adoption of cryptocurrency.As far as settings go for a press conference, commanding views over St Paul’s Cathedral and the banks and asset managers of the Square Mile, it is straight out of the Westminster playbook, even if the policy idea is pure Donald Trump.However, the trouble with Yusuf’s message to the City was not the questionable credibility of crypto – viewed with unease at the Bank of England as the wild west of finance – but the party’s broader tax and spending policies
‘One day I overheard my boss saying: just put it in ChatGPT’: the workers who lost their jobs to AI
Mateusz Demski, 31, journalist, Kraków, PolandI’ve been a freelance journalist for 10 years, usually writing for magazines and websites about cinema. I presented a morning show on Radio Kraków twice a week for about two years. It was only one part of my work, but I really enjoyed it. It was about culture and cinema, and featured a range of people, from artists to activists. I remember interviewing Ukrainians about the Russian invasion for the first programme I presented, back in 2022
French Open: Musetti beats Tiafoe; Swiatek sets up Sabalenka semi – as it happened
Club rugby needs a radical fix – but is R360 breakaway league the cure to its ills? | Andy Bull
Rome’s taxi drivers outraged at claim they drive like F1’s Max Verstappen
England to face Fiji, South Africa and Argentina in inaugural Nations Championship games
Jack Draper must learn to play with a target on his back as Wimbledon looms | Tumaini Carayol
The Breakdown | The Premiership team of the 2024-25 season