Starmer and Reeves should consider wealth tax, says former shadow chancellor

A picture


The Treasury should consider a wealth tax to close the growing gap in the public finances, according to a Labour former shadow chancellor.Anneliese Dodds, who held the role under Keir Starmer in opposition, said ministers must have a “full and frank discussion” with the public about the “really big decisions” they had to take at this autumn’s budget.With Rachel Reeves aiming to fill a financial hole that economists say could exceed £20bn, the senior Labour MP said there was “no silver bullet” to funding big-ticket items such as defence but the chancellor should consider tax rises.Dodds quit her post as international development minister in February over a decision to slash the aid budget to pay for increased defence spending – a move she said was a mistake that would have a big impact on global security.With Russia and China already stepping into the gap to boost their own global influence, she said now was not the time for the UK to be “walking back” from using soft power.

In her first interview since standing down, Dodds told the Guardian: “It’s important that we have a longer-term approach.That does mean asking and confronting difficult questions around our fiscal position, around taxation.But if we’re open and honest about the nature of the challenge that we face, we cannot duck that.“Now is a time when we’re seeing forces outside our country’s control impacting on our security.It’s important to have an open conversation with the public and say that means we will need to change when it comes to tax.

That needs to be done in a way where those with the broadest shoulders take more responsibility,”While she did not set out exactly where wealth taxes might fall, Dodds urged the Treasury to “look carefully” at the work of economist Arun Advani, whose wealth tax commission in 2020 recommended a one-off levy on millionaire households as a better way of raising revenue than increasing taxes on workers or consumers,She joins a growing chorus of Labour MPs, not all from the left of the party, calling for further wealth taxes this autumn,However, proposals for an annual 2% tax on assets over £10m have been denounced as “daft” by the business secretary, Jonathan Reynolds,Government insiders have questioned whether it would raise any funds.

Dodds acknowledged there would be consequences from any new wealth tax and said she did not underestimate the challenges involved.However, she played down suggestions the policy would automatically lead to a reduction in the tax base as people moved assets overseas.She added: “There’s no silver bullet here, and I’ve been quite cautious about claims in the past that there’s one single change to tax that could suddenly, immediately inject enormous amounts of money into the government coffers without any further implications.That’s simply not the case.There will be consequences.

”Dodds also suggested that Reeves should look again at her fiscal rules to help deliver an increase in defence spending, rather than through further cuts to aid.The government has pledged to spend 2.5% of GDP on defence from 2027, with an ambition to reach 3% in the next parliament.It has not said how this would be paid for.She said it would be very difficult for the UK to change its fiscal rules to borrow more to invest in defence, as Germany – which was in a stronger economic position – did when it loosened its “debt brake” in March.

But she added: “There’s no route forward without some risk and without some cost.”Forecasts twice a year from the Office for Budget Responsibility have ended up driving fiscal policy, injecting more uncertainty into the system, she said.The IMF has suggested the government should consider having the public finances formally assessed only once a year instead.Dodds said she had little doubt the government would have to further increase defence spending.But she said this could not come from further cuts to the aid budget without an impact on global security and migration patterns.

Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotion“I believe the public know that also,” she said.“We need to have a really full and frank discussion now nationally about how we will deliver that more secure country, but also about the challenges of doing that at the same time as getting our public services up off their knees.“We did see a reduction in our soft power, and we saw a reduction in what makes our country stronger.Especially now with the rise of China, Russia, becoming far more involved in the continent of Africa, and many other geopolitical pressures, now isn’t the time to be walking back from those commitments.“We will also see the impact on global security.

We also see the impact of it in population movements,It’s no surprise that the number of people seeking asylum in the UK from Sudan, for example, has increased,There is eventually that knock-on impact,There’s no question about that,”Dodds said there was “no magic wand” to bring down the number of asylum hotels, which have been funded from the aid budget.

Suggestions that the government could make big savings from quick closures were “just not credible”.She did not criticise Starmer directly for his “island of strangers” remarks, which the prime minister has since said he regretted, and said it was “right to acknowledge people’s concerns” about small boat crossings but she urged ministers “to be clear that we are talking ultimately about human beings”.As a former Labour chair, Dodds suggested the party had to do more to explain what it stood for to take on the rise of Nigel Farage’s Reform UK.She said: “What I find time and again when I speak with people who are considering Reform is that they want politicians to say what they think.They want politicians who are upfront about what they believe and who act on their beliefs.

”She described Jeremy Corbyn’s new movement as “a bit like the People’s Front of Judea” from Monty Python’s Life of Brian but warned that it could end up splitting the vote: “We have seen in some other countries, a splintering of the left, and centre-left parties doing very badly,”The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know,If you have something to share on this subject you can contact us confidentially using the following methods,Secure Messaging in the Guardian appThe Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories,Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs.

This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said,If you don't already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu,Select ‘Secure Messaging’,SecureDrop, instant messengers, email, telephone and postSee our guide at theguardian,com/tips for alternative methods and the pros and cons of each.

societySee all
A picture

Staff fear to speak up at NHS hospital trust under police investigation, report says

Staff at a hospital trust where police are investigating at least 90 deaths say they face reprisals and ridicule from bosses if they raise concerns, according to a damning report.Asked to review University Hospitals Sussex, the report’s authors said they “repeatedly heard concerning examples of staff, often at a senior level, being ignored, dismissed and sometimes ridiculed when speaking up”.The report by Niche Health and Social Care Consulting said this fear of reprisals from whistleblowing could be harming patient safety. It also highlighted complaints of misogyny and failures to deal with “unwanted romantic advances”.The review team noted a number of challenges facing the trust, including an investigation by Sussex police into possible corporate and individual manslaughter charges over allegations of medical negligence and cover-up in the general surgery and neurosurgery departments

A picture

World’s ‘oldest baby’ born from embryo frozen in 1994

The world’s “oldest baby” has been born in the US from an embryo that was frozen in 1994, it has been reported.Thaddeus Daniel Pierce was born on 26 July in Ohio to Lindsey and Tim Pierce, using an “adopted” embryo from Linda Archerd, 62, from more than 30 years ago.In the early 1990s, Archerd and her then husband decided to try in vitro fertilisation (IVF) after struggling to become pregnant. In 1994 four embryos resulted: one was transferred to Archerd and resulted in the birth of a daughter, who is now 30 and mother to a 10-year-old. The other embryos were cryopreserved and stored

A picture

Mother’s instinct not addressed, report on death of boy sent home from Rotherham A&E says

A report into the death of a five-year-old Rotherham boy sent home from A&E has called for national guidance to take into account parents’ intuition that “something feels very wrong” about their child.Yusuf Mahmud Nazir died of pneumonia and sepsis at Sheffield children’s hospital on 23 November 2022, almost a week after his parents first raised concerns that he was unwell.He was seen by numerous clinicians who failed to listen to the concerns of his mother, Soniya Ahmed, that something was seriously wrong with Yusuf, instead relying solely on data that suggested he was not seriously ill.The independent patient safety investigation (IPSI) report, commissioned by NHS England in response to significant concerns raised by Yusuf’s family, recommended that caregivers’ concerns be taken more seriously when assessing children.The report asked healthcare organisations to consider treating parental intuition as a “legitimate and vital form of evidence” and asked: “What becomes possible when the instinct of a mother is given the same attention as a monitor reading?”The report, written by Dr Peter Carter, an independent healthcare consultant and former chief executive and general secretary of the Royal College of Nursing, stated: “The system is not designed to capture ‘something feels very wrong’ as an input, and thus a gap opens between family and clinicians

A picture

First NHS AI-run physio clinic in England halves back-pain waiting list

The first NHS AI-run physiotherapy clinic has halved the waiting list for back pain and musculoskeletal services, according to the NHS trust where the pilot has taken place.More than 2,500 patients living in Cambridgeshire and Peterborough were able to access Flok Health, a physiotherapy platform run by AI, over a 12-week period starting in February.The platform, which was created using video footage of a human physiotherapist, provides same-day automated video appointments with a digital physiotherapist via an app that responds to information given by a patient in real time.When the clinic was first launched in Cambridgeshire, waiting times for elective community musculoskeletal (MSK) services in the region were about 18 weeks.The waiting times for all MSK conditions decreased by 44% over the course of the 12-week period due to the use of Flok combined with other initiatives such as community assessment days, according to Cambridgeshire Community Services NHS trust (CCS), which deployed the services in those areas of England

A picture

The care sector needs migrant workers. Labour’s visa crackdown is a cynical move | Letter

You are right to highlight, in your editorial, the folly of the government’s decision to make it harder for migrant workers to find work as carers in the UK (The Guardian view on Labour’s visa crackdown in social care: another problem for an overstretched system, 22 July).It’s a cynical political move aimed at spiking Reform UK’s guns on immigration, rather than alleviating pressure on the much-maligned care sector. Migrant workers are indispensable in filling roles that have been undervalued, underpaid and unwanted for too long.With thousands more care professionals needed to look after our ageing population, the government needs a joined-up approach if the crisis-ridden sector is to be transformed.While the government’s fair pay agreement is the first step in turning care around, ministers must think again on their approach to foreign help – and, closer to home, announce the funding to make the fair pay agreement a reality

A picture

Green burials – the biodegradable alternative | Letter

For those who find the idea of burning their deceased friend’s body distasteful (‘The delivery man arrived with the ashes in a gift bag’ – why are so many people opting out of traditional funerals?, 23 July), an alternative to direct cremation is a green burial, which costs more but not excessively so. Here, the grave is not permanent, and everything that goes in it has to be biodegradable – this rules out embalming. Coffins must be made of cardboard or untreated wood – woven willow is becoming very popular. No permanent memorial is allowed, but usually a wooden plaque can be added, which will last for several years if oiled. Natural wildflowers can often be planted, but vases cannot be used