The Guide #195: How Reddit made nerds of us all

A picture


It only ended a few years ago, but Westworld already feels a bit of a TV footnote.A pricey mid-2010s remake of a 70s Yul Brynner movie few people remembered, HBO’s robot cowboy drama lumbered on for four lukewarm seasons before getting cancelled – with few people really noticing.Still, when it premiered, Westworld was big news.Here was a show well-placed to do a Game of Thrones, only for sci-fi.Its high production values were married to an eye-catching cast (Evan Rachel Wood, Ed Harris, Thandiwe Newton, Jeffrey Wright) and it was run by the crack team of Lisa Joy and Jonathan Nolan, who promised they had a playbook for how the whole show would shake out.

This, of course, was an important promise in that immediate post-Lost period, where everyone was terrified that they would be strung along by a show that was “making it up as they went along” (as a Lost defender, I have to say at this point that they weren’t “making it up as they went along”, but that’s an argument for another newsletter).But even the best laid plans, and the most tightly plotted of TV shows, have a way of unravelling.The first inkling I had that Westworld might not be TV’s next big series was when fans of the show on forum/social media hybrid Reddit started correctly guessing how plotlines would pan out.Twist after twist in the show’s first season were predicted, sometimes a week early or more, by Redditors well-versed in the rhythms and tropes of telly, or otherwise just willing to go above and beyond in the search for the most minuscule of clues.Things got so bad that, in the second season, Joy and Nolan were forced to rewrite the script to alter a plotline the Redditors had already rumbled.

It was a sign not just of Westworld’s fragility, but the strength of Reddit and its users, who were able to make even seasoned showrunners quake in their boots.Reddit has, of course, comfortably outlasted Westworld.This month, the site – immodestly self-described as “the front page of the internet” – celebrates its 20th birthday.It’s an anniversary that sits in the shadow of a more seismic 2005 web debut: YouTube, which celebrated its own birthday back in February.But Reddit’s impact on popular culture, though not at YouTube’s “we’ve replaced TV” levels, has been sizeable.

That Reddit’s arrival came in lockstep with an era of intense fandom and parasocial relationships doesn’t seem coincidental.Fan forums existed long before Reddit – from message boards for bands and solo artists to the acid-tipped TV show chat on the still-missed Television Without Pity – but Reddit organised and supercharged these communities.Suddenly, just about any enthusiasm big or small, Marvel movies to musical microgenres, could be discussed under one roof, freely and openly.Such freedom and openness come at a cost, and Reddit’s – misogyny, racism, conspiracy theories, threats of violence – have been widely documented.(Though, in contrast to so many social media platforms these days, Reddit has done a pretty decent job in cleaning up its act over the past decade).

Pop-culturally, it’s a place where fan enthusiasm can occasionally curdle into something more unpleasant (witness the long and messy history of the Rick and Morty subreddit).But too often discussion around Reddit has zeroed in on its less salubrious aspects and overlooked what a remarkable space it can be.Supported by some truly heroic moderation, it is one of the last outposts for that old internet – hobbyist, collaborative, more than a little eccentric.As this Atlantic defence puts it, Reddit is “simultaneously niche and expansive” – which means you can use it as superficially or deeply as you wish: whether you’re asking for a new TV recommendation, or getting detailed advice on building a hurdy-gurdy.In a sense, it has mainstreamed obsessiveness.

Where once these hyper-specific communities were hidden away from the wider world, now they’re accessible to anyone seeking them under one giant Reddit umbrella – almost 100 million people actively use the site every day.I’m not really one of them.At best, I’m a Reddit lurker – never bold enough to properly dive in and post – but, as someone who writes about pop culture, I find it endlessly useful.It’s where I go if I want to get to the bottom of a puzzling Severance plot point on the show’s endlessly insightful subreddit, or discover a lost 70s paranoid thriller on the extremely useful r/Movie Suggestions.And lord knows how many bands I’ve discovered on boards like the massive r/indieheads (3.

6 million members and growing).Fittingly, when I last looked in on r/indieheads, I was greeted with users marking Brian Wilson’s death by discussing his influence on the chillwave genre (with the song All I Wanna Do), exactly the sort of informed, spirited, geekish back and forth you’d hope for.Sign up to The GuideGet our weekly pop culture email, free in your inbox every Fridayafter newsletter promotionThat spirit seems to, for now, have held despite a stock market flotation that some justifiably worried would ruin the site.Perhaps that fear will one day come to pass.Or maybe not.

Maybe Reddit is too big, too singular, too defiantly peculiar to be blandified by big business.Let’s hope we’re still celebrating it in another 20 years’ time, as it topples another pedestrianly plotted TV show.If you want to read the complete version of this newsletter please subscribe to receive The Guide in your inbox every Friday
politicsSee all
A picture

Civil service is ‘too remote’ from people’s lives across UK, says minister

The Whitehall civil service is too remote from people’s lives and needs to be “turned inside out” as part of plans to drive three of Keir Starmer’s missions from outside London, a Cabinet Office minister has said.Georgia Gould, a former leader of Camden council who had a meteoric rise after her election as a Labour MP last year, said the government’s plan to move thousands more civil service jobs out of London was not about just “having offices in places” – and Whitehall civil servants needed to be more familiar with the day-to-day problems in frontline services from health centres to family hubs.She said her job was to help close the “big gap between those doing the frontline operational roles and those who are making policies” by helping them to work together, share data and come up with new ideas about how to improve people’s lives – especially those who “fall through the cracks” of different public services.Gould told the Guardian that Whitehall working would be “turned inside out”, as the Cabinet Office announced Starmer’s health mission would be based in Leeds, its opportunity mission in Sheffield and its growth mission in Darlington, with civil servants working with local government and frontline workers to pioneer new approaches.The Cabinet Office announced in May that major Whitehall government buildings were to be shut by ministers as they seek to shed 12,000 civil servant jobs in London, while moving thousands of roles to cities across the UK

A picture

Ministers step up efforts to quell growing rebellion over UK welfare bill

The government is intensifying efforts to quell a growing rebellion over welfare cuts, with whips stepping up contact with MPs and strategists drawing up plans for a cabinet reshuffle in case of resignations.Ministers are taking a carrot-and-stick approach by laying out extra support for people who face losing their benefits, while also warning mutinous MPs of the consequences of voting against the plans.Several MPs said that whips were strengthening efforts to bring them into line after Liz Kendall, the work and pensions secretary, sought to ease concerns by promising extra protections for vulnerable people.Some MPs say there have been suggestions that the vote on cuts could be treated as a confidence issue, with those rebelling facing suspension from the whip or even deselection. No 10 and government sources strongly denied this

A picture

Russia adviser Fiona Hill’s alarming conclusion | Letter

Fiona Hill’s assessment of the Russian threat to Britain is a classic example of how a seemingly rational argument based on a false premise and scanty evidence can lead to a mad conclusion (Russia is at war with Britain and US is no longer a reliable ally, UK adviser says, 6 June). It is especially alarming that this conclusion was reached by one of the three principal authors of the recent strategic defence review.The false premise is that Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine is the first step to make Russia “a dominant military power in all of Europe”. Evidence that Britain is already under attack is provided by “the poisonings, assassinations, sabotage operations … cyber-attacks and influence operations .

A picture

Ministers to offer olive branch on welfare plans to avert Labour rebellion

Ministers are to offer mutinous Labour MPs an olive branch on the government’s welfare plans to help avert a major rebellion in a crucial vote early next month.Liz Kendall, the welfare secretary, wants to reassure angry MPs who have threatened to rebel over fears that sick and disabled people will be hardest hit.The Guardian has been told she will put “non-negotiable” protections for the most vulnerable benefits recipients on the face of the welfare reform bill when it is published next week, providing additional support to those with the most severe conditions who will never work.But with Rachel Reeves, the chancellor, ruling out a U-turn on disability benefit cuts and government aides insisting there will be no substantial change to the bill, it is unclear whether the tweaks will be enough to prevent a rebellion that could even risk a defeat.Labour MPs are demanding big changes to the proposals first put forward in March in the welfare green paper, including a rethink on eligibility for personal independence payments (Pip) for disabled people and benefits for carers

A picture

Does Labour’s spending review signal a return to austerity?

Rachel Reeves usually avoids any mention of the word “austerity” in connection with her fiscal policies, but on Wednesday, she decided to tackle the argument head on.“In this spending review, total departmental budgets will grow by 2.3% a year in real terms,” she told MPs as she announced the next stage of her spending review.“Compare that to the Conservatives’ choice of austerity … Austerity was a destructive choice for both the fabric of our society and our economy, choking off investment and demand and creating a lost decade for growth, wages and living standards.”The chancellor argues that her decision to lift departmental budgets by 2

A picture

Sadiq Khan warns ministers not to ‘pit our towns and cities against each other’

Ministers must not “stumble into the trap of pitting our towns and cities against each other”, Sadiq Khan will say, as he delivers a blistering attack on the Treasury’s decision to sideline London in this week’s spending review.In a state of London address, the capital’s mayor will urge ministers to stop treating investment as a zero-sum game between north and south – arguing that some of the worst deprivation in the country is within London’s borders.“I’ve seen first-hand how parts of our city suffer from some of the worst poverty and deprivation in the country,” he will say. “As someone who grew up on a London council estate, I know help for our communities should be based on need not geography.“A child blighted by a lack of support and opportunity in Newham or Lewisham is just as deserving as a child born into similar circumstances in Newcastle or Leeds