Does Labour’s spending review signal a return to austerity?
Rachel Reeves usually avoids any mention of the word “austerity” in connection with her fiscal policies, but on Wednesday, she decided to tackle the argument head on.“In this spending review, total departmental budgets will grow by 2.3% a year in real terms,” she told MPs as she announced the next stage of her spending review.“Compare that to the Conservatives’ choice of austerity … Austerity was a destructive choice for both the fabric of our society and our economy, choking off investment and demand and creating a lost decade for growth, wages and living standards.”The chancellor argues that her decision to lift departmental budgets by 2.
3% on average over the course of this parliament shows this cannot be compared with the coalition period, when spending fell by 2.9% on average.Some departments are faring particularly well.The Department of Health and Social Care will receive 2.8% more on average over the course of the parliament, taking its budget from £189bn in 2023-24 to £246bn by 2028-29.
But focusing only on this week’s announcement, which covers the three years from 2026-27, the settlement looks much tighter, with departmental budgets rising only 1,5% on average,Taking out certain big-ticket items of government spending, the situation looks tougher still,According to the Resolution Foundation, everything outside of health, defence, education and overseas aid will fall by 1,3% on average – a total of £2.
4bn in cuts.Some departments are being particularly badly hit, including the Home Office, which is facing 1.4% annual cuts over the next three years; and the environment department, the budget of which will drop 2.3% each year on average.Sharon Graham, the general secretary of the Unite union, said: “Spending cuts will be seen as austerity; those are the facts.
Labour needs to pick up the pace on change, otherwise it will be stuck in the political slow lane while other voices get louder.”The chancellor says that the significant rise in capital spending will help offset the impact of reduced day-to-day spending for some departments.Better technology and equipment will help make processes more efficient, for example in the NHS where new scanners and testing machines should help ease the burden on doctors and nurses.Economists also point out that the growth in day-to-day spending is still set to outstrip even the OBR’s relatively bullish growth forecasts.Paul Johnson, the director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, said: “This is not a period of austerity.
This is a long period during which spending will be growing faster than the economy which, given current OBR estimates – which are more optimistic than most – is set to grow by 1,5% a year,”Reeves faces two main problems, however, when persuading the public they are not experiencing austerity,One is that her plan mostly unpicks Conservative spending plans that were never realistic in the first place; without those there would have been significantly deeper cuts pencilled in,Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionAndy King, an economist and former chief of staff at the Office for Budget Responsibility, said the £400bn uplift outlined by Reeves was “basically the price tag for taking implausible out of the spending plans”.
He said: “Was it a spending spree? Not really,Was it austerity? Not really,It looks like a pretty conventional and sensible way of allocating the spending envelope,”The second is that unlike during the previous Labour government, Reeves is increasing overall departmental budgets after years of cuts,Local government, for example, will receive average real-terms rises of 1.
1% a year over the next three years.But at the end of that period its central government funding will be 50% lower than it was in 2010.For those on the left, those previous cuts are even more reason to open the spending taps now, even if it means raising taxes at the autumn budget to do so.Theo Harris, an economist at the New Economics Foundation, said: “To deliver the change people voted for, the government should free itself from its self-imposed fiscal rules, recognise the value of social spending and be willing to tax wealth fairly.This may not be austerity, but it doesn’t look like the start of a decade of renewal.
”Those close to Reeves, however, point out that she has already announced one of the biggest tax-hiking budgets in recent history to fund an immediate splurge in government spending – something Labour supporters have long called for.“In place of decline, I choose investment,” Reeves said on Wednesday.“These are Labour choices.”
US Open golf 2025: Sam Burns keeps hold of lead at Oakmont – as it happened
Moving Day took a while to get going, but once it did, it produced some exciting golf. Plenty of players are still in with a shout, so hopefully you’ll join us for the final round tomorrow. Thanks for reading this report!-4: Sam Burns -3: Adam Scott, JJ Spaun -1: Viktor Hovland E: Carlos Ortiz +1: Tyrrell Hatton, Thriston Lawrence +2: Rasmus Neergaard-Petersen +3: Robert MacIntyre, Cameron YoungThe final stroke of the day is made by Sam Burns. He makes his par putt, he remains one of just two players yet to three-putt this week – Ryan Fox is the other – and he’s got sole ownership of the lead going into the final round. A 69 for Burns, which is exactly what his playing partner JJ Spaun shot as well
Caitlin Clark spectacular in return from injury as Fever hand Liberty first loss
Caitlin Clark totaled 32 points, nine assists and eight rebounds in a spectacular return from a left quad injury on Saturday leading the Indiana Fever to a 102-88 victory over the New York Liberty, snapping their season-opening nine-game winning streak.After missing five games, Clark scored 25 points in the first half to help Indiana (5-5) rally from an early 11-point deficit. Clark made 11-of-20 shots and tied a career high by hitting seven threees, including several from well beyond the arc.Clark finished with the second-most points in her career and three shy of her career-high (35) set on 15 September against the Dallas Wings. Clark scored 14 in the first quarter, including three 3s in the final 86 seconds after the Fever trailed by 11
Rory McIlroy says he ‘didn’t really care’ about making US Open cut at Oakmont
Rory McIlroy admitted he was in two minds over whether he wanted to make the US Open cut, in the latest nod to the Northern Irishman’s psychological struggles since winning the Masters in April.McIlroy made birdie on two of his last four holes on Friday evening to survive for the closing 36 holes at Oakmont. Until that point, he was heading for an early exit. McIlroy returned to the course to post 74 on Saturday, leaving him 10 over for the week, before addressing the media for the first time since Tuesday. McIlroy’s body language suggested he would rather be elsewhere
Formula One: Mercedes’ Russell snatches pole for Canadian grand prix – as it happened
Wow! Russell has done it on the medium tyre! After Piastri went ahead Verstappen reclaim the top spot before Russell beat them all with a final surge. That is back-to-back poles for Russell in Montreal.That is all from me today. Join us tomorrow for live updates from Circuit Gilles Villeneuve for the Canadian Grand Prix. Au revoir!George Russell, Mercedes, 1:10
‘Tennis repairs you’: the 101-year-old fuelled by iced coffee who still plays competitively | Jo Khan
Henry Young is proud to have played on centre court during the Australian Open but does not want to be seen as remarkable just for playing at allHenry Young doesn’t mind being asked about his secret to a long, active life – it comes with the territory when you’re a 101-year-old competitive tennis player. It has its perks, like getting to play on centre court during the Australian Open, but what he does mind is that it’s considered so remarkable that he is playing at all. That he is seen as extraordinary and there must be some magic trick that keeps him going.“What bugs me is that people give up their tennis when they have some kind of injury,” Young says. “I’m a monument to the medical profession because I’ve had so many injuries and I just persevere, and then tennis repairs you
Leicester coach Cheika hits out at Cole yellow card after final defeat by Bath
Michael Cheika, the Leicester head coach, took issue with the officiating after his side’s playoff final defeat by Bath, describing the late yellow card shown to Dan Cole after an aerial collision with Finn Russell as “embarrassing for the game” and “hardly even a penalty”.The Australian was also less than impressed with how the scrum was refereed. “I’ve never seen it before in my life, dominating like that and getting nothing, zero. In fact, getting penalised against.“That was a strategical point for us to try and dominate there and in mauls as well
Disney and Universal sue AI image creator Midjourney, alleging copyright infringement
‘They went too far’: Musk says he regrets some of his posts about Trump
Meta to announce $15bn investment in bid to achieve computerised ‘superintelligence’
UK students and staff: tell us your experiences with AI at university
As big tech grows more involved in Gaza, Muslim workers are wrestling with a spiritual crisis
AI can ‘level up’ opportunities for dyslexic children, says UK tech secretary