Drastic Dave goes vague at Diageo | Nils Pratley
Diageo’s once high-flying share price was already back at 2012 levels,Now the dividend is there too,Sir Dave Lewis has cut it in half, chopping as drastically as the market feared he would,But that doesn’t quite explain Wednesday’s 13% fall in the shares,Rather, that was down to two factors.
First, the trading numbers continued the miserable run for the entire spirits sector – Diageo edged down its full-year forecasts again,The company is getting little help from the market, especially in the US and China,Second, and more importantly, Drastic Dave was vague about what shareholders can expect in terms of hard returns once he has administered his turnaround tonic,His diagnosis itself told investors little about Diageo that they not worked out themselves,It is hardly a revelation that the group’s spirits cabinet is overstuffed with brands, such as Don Julio and Casamigos in tequila, that sit at the top end of the price range.
In the important Latin American market, for example, Lewis said the entire collection was concentrated in the top 25%-30% price bracket,The deliberate upmarket brand construction worked beautifully in the era of gradually improving consumer incomes around the world,“Premiumisation”, or encouraging drinkers to drink more expensively, was a winner under the former boss Sir Ivan Menezes and, before him, Paul Walsh,The open question, though – the one Lewis has yet to answer – is how many price cuts Diageo will have to impose, and to how many mid-tier mass-market brands, to adapt to today’s harsher consumer climate,The good news, of a sort, is that Diageo ought to be skilled at such “price architecture” games.
Johnnie Walker’s red-to-blue whisky range is a model of how to finesse price-versus-volume tradeoffs.And a broad and deep portfolio, including Smirnoff vodka and Captain Morgan rum, ought to have the brands for the job.But until Diageo gets serious about laying out financial details of what Lewis called “the value premiumisation opportunity”, shareholders are in the dark.Come back in late summer for a worked-up strategy, as opposed to Lewis’s high-level thoughts after seven weeks in post.For investors, though, that’s a long wait.
They may happily accept that the old dividend was unsustainable and that reinvestment has to happen, but they also want to know if profit margins will be damaged by the necessary effort to regain a competitive edge,Similarly, everybody knew Lewis would see a chance to cut costs and find efficiencies,But they were hoping for a hint at the size of the prize, as opposed to some broad musings on resetting the “operational framework” and improving the availability of Guinness, the brand that is gloriously immune to the group’s struggles in spirits,In Lewis’s shoes, it was probably only sensible to keep it general at this stage,There is no point in offering hostages to fortune.
But for outsiders it all adds to the impression that turning around Diageo could be a long job.At Tesco, where Lewis earned his spurs as a turnaround merchant, he inherited a company that was still the market leader by a mile in its domestic market, even after its accounting scandal.Diageo is a more complex and more global beast.Still, the trading numbers, though weak, were not a disaster.Annual operating profits will either be flat or up a bit, if the latest projection is correct.
And, notably, the forecast for full-year cashflow was kept intact at $3bn (£2.2bn), which was a critical piece of guidance given the $21.7bn of net debt.But one was also left with the impression that Diageo should have started a proper self-help programme at least two years ago.Instead, the entire organisation seems to have suffered corporate shock after the sudden death of Menezes, the boardroom superstar, in June 2023.
His successor Debra Crew was propelled into the job early, issued a heavy profits warning, failed to deal with post-Covid hangovers and was decrewed last year by the new chair, Sir John Manzoni, a few months after his arrival.Now comes a reset under Lewis once he’s crunched the numbers.No doubt there is a “significant opportunity” ahead, as he says.But the opportunity would probably have been easier to grab had Diageo started sooner.You’d still bet on Lewis to succeed – but it may take longer than optimists had hoped.
Drastic Dave goes vague at Diageo | Nils Pratley
Diageo’s once high-flying share price was already back at 2012 levels. Now the dividend is there too. Sir Dave Lewis has cut it in half, chopping as drastically as the market feared he would.But that doesn’t quite explain Wednesday’s 13% fall in the shares. Rather, that was down to two factors
John Lewis scraps £500m deal to build 1,000 rental homes
The John Lewis Partnership is pulling out of a £500m deal to build almost 1,000 residential rental homes for rent in Bromley, Reading and West Ealing amid a “cautious property market”.The retailer, which owns Waitrose supermarkets and John Lewis department stores, blamed a “fundamental shift in the economic conditions”, which it said had made it difficult for its financial partner, Aberdeen, to raise funds for the venture, first launched in 2020.Aberdeen said its difficulties with fundraising “reflect the realities of the environment” and a “challenging UK market” between 2022 and 2025.A spokesperson said the investment firm still planned to increase its presence in UK homes through existing partnerships.“We have high conviction in build-to-rent in the UK and globally,” they said
Diageo slashes dividend and vows to address Guinness shortage in London
Diageo has slashed its dividend and cut its annual sales and profit forecast for the second time in four months, as the maker of Guinness warned of capacity constraints affecting drinkers of “the black stuff” in London pubs.The world’s largest spirits maker – which owns brands including Smirnoff vodka, Johnnie Walker whisky and Don Julio tequila – lost more than £5bn of its market value on Wednesday as it reported weak demand in the US and China in the first results released under the new chief executive, Sir Dave Lewis.The former Tesco chief executive, who earned the nickname “Drastic Dave” as a result of his cost-cutting during almost three decades at the conglomerate Unilever, took the reins at Diageo in January and wasted no time in cutting the company’s shareholder dividend in his attempt to turn around the drinks maker.Describing his first seven weeks in the role as “pretty intense”, Lewis said in a results webcast it had not been a simple choice to reduce the dividend, halving it to 20 cents a share, down from 40.5 cents a year ago
HSBC bankers to share $3.9bn bonus pot, the highest in more than a decade
Bankers at HSBC are to share a bonus pot worth $3.9bn (£2.9bn), the highest in more than a decade, after Europe’s largest lender reported better-than-expected annual results.The bonus pool for staff is 10% higher than a year earlier and the bank said it had determined it “based on a review of our performance against financial and non-financial metrics”, while the bank’s chief executive’s pay also rose.Georges Elhedery, who took over as the CEO in 2024, signalled that his sweeping turnaround of the lender was drawing to a close
Starmer says ‘more to do’ on cost of living despite £117 fall in energy bills from April - as it happened
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of business, the financial markets and the world economy.Energy bills in Great Britain will fall by £117 to a typical annual bill of £1,641 from April, the regulator Ofgem announced this morning.It announced a 7% reduction of the energy price cap for the period covering 1 April to 30 June.This change amounts to a reduction of about £10 a month for the average household using both electricity and gas, Ofgem said. This is more than £200 lower than a year ago
Ineos said to be in talks to sell parts of business to tackle rising debt
The chemicals empire owned by the billionaire Jim Ratcliffe is in talks to sell parts of the business in the hope of raising hundreds of millions of pounds to tackle its rising debts, according to a report.The talks are at an early stage but have focused on selling assets from Ratcliffe’s vinyls business, Ineos Inovyn, the Financial Times said, citing people familiar with the matter.Ineos group is scrambling to cut costs and reduce its debts amid a prolonged downturn in the global chemicals industry. Ratcliffe, who is the UK’s seventh richest person, has described this as “unsurvivable” for chemical plants in Europe owing to “rising carbon costs and weak trade defence”.The two largest companies in his empire, Ineos Group Holdings and Ineos Quattro Holdings, together had more than £18bn of borrowings at the end of last year, an increase of almost £3bn on the year before
Breakaway union stands behind Tara Moore’s $20m legal battle against WTA
Constitution Hill out of Champion Hurdle and ready for next chapter on the Flat
MPs back UK broadcasters in push to expand sport’s free-to-air ‘crown jewels’
The US men’s hockey team at the State of the Union showed proximity to Trump is never neutral
Among the gangsters, gamblers and high rollers: a master bookie’s life in Las Vegas
The Spin | Zimbabwean breakout at T20 World Cup has fans rejoicing renaissance