Starmer’s ‘five-point plan’ was not a plan | Nils Pratley
‘We have a five-point plan for the immediate crisis,” declared the prime minister during his remarks from Downing Street on Wednesday.Really? Two of his five points were measures on energy bills that pre-date the Iran war.One was a description of support for a sub-set of consumers but dodged the key question of who else could get help.Another stated the government’s longstanding energy strategy in unchanged terms.The last was a diplomatic policy, presumably shoehorned into the cost-of-living passage because a five-point plan sounds better than a four-point one.
Let’s take them in order.First: “We’re cutting energy bills by over £100 per household today.” That, very obviously, is not a response to “the immediate crisis”.The chancellor announced in her budget last November that some green levies would be switched into general taxation for three years.At the time, Rachel Reeves claimed a £150 cut, ignoring the awkward reality that energy bills contain many moving parts, such as rising charges for maintaining and upgrading the electricity and gas grids.
Those charges duly trimmed the cut to £117 for an average dual-fuel household.So, unfortunately for political-messaging purposes, consumers have merely been shown that a supposedly decisive £150 can morph into “over £100” three months later.Second: “We’ve extended the cut in fuel duty until September, and we are monitoring that situation daily.” Again, Reeves announced the cut in November.It’s not new.
Virtually nobody believes the 1p a litre increase scheduled for September will happen – or the 2p increases due in December and next March.But, until Starmer or Reeves say so, the government can’t claim to have acted on fuel duty in response to the Middle East conflict.Third: “We’re supporting people exposed to heating oil rises – setting aside £53m.” Yes, that one counts as a response to the immediate crisis.But the big unknown is who could be covered by any “targeted” support on gas and electricity bills when the impact is felt from October.
Other questions include when assistance would take effect, how it could be delivered and how “cliff-edge” cases would be treated.One can’t blame the government for vagueness at this point because it doesn’t know the size of the challenge.But £53m will be a rounding error if the chancellor ends up having to find billions.Fourth: “We’re taking back control of our energy security, by investing in clean British energy.” Come on, the Clean Power 2030 plan cannot be accelerated in response to the war.
It is a five-year £200bn infrastructure project.Nuclear power stations take at least a decade to build.The windfarms commissioned this year will start spinning in 2028 and 2029.They all help necessary energy transition, but most energy analysts project that savings for consumers from a cleaner system only start to arrive around 2040, assuming the government continues to load the bulk of costs and levies on to bills.And, by the way, gas-fired generation will still be needed as back-up to intermittent wind and solar, so the fossil fuel “rollercoaster”, in the over-used political metaphor, is not wholly escapable.
Starmer’s final point was “to continue to push for de-escalation in the Middle East”.That is uncontentious and, yes, the timing of a return to “normal” oil and gas prices will, to a large degree, determine the size of the hit to the UK economy and consumers.But we knew that already.The real debate is about what happens if an energy price shock turns into a supply shock, possibly meaning rationing of some form.That would be when a proper five-point plan would be needed, and also be the moment when Reeves would have to decide how much of her fiscal headroom she’s prepared to allow to disappear.
As with previous energy shocks, the decisions aren’t easy,But repeating measures taken in last November’s budget is not a plan,
Stellantis recalls 44,000 UK vehicles over fault that could cause fires
The European carmaker Stellantis has issued a recall for 44,000 UK vehicles after discovering a fault that could result in its cars catching fire.The fault has been found in certain models across its Peugeot, Citroën, DS Automobiles, Vauxhall, Lancia, Alfa Romeo, Jeep and Fiat brands, produced between 2023 and 2026. Key vehicles affected by the recall include the Citroën C3, Peugeot 208 and Vauxhall Mokka.The manufacturer said the issue related to a lack of clearance between the gas filter pipe and a component of the belt starter generator, which could cause water to leak into the engine bay during wet driving conditions. That created a “potential risk of fire” in the engine, in the worst-case scenario
UK firms expect to raise prices more quickly as Iran war pushes up costs
Companies in the UK expect to raise their prices more rapidly over the coming months as the war in the Middle East drives up costs, Bank of England research shows.The Bank’s regular survey of more than 2,000 chief financial officers conducted last month, after the Iran conflict began, shows they now expect to raise their prices by 3.7% over the coming year.That was a rise from 3.4% in February, while the bosses’ expectation of inflation across the economy has risen from 3% to 3
Claude’s code: Anthropic leaks source code for AI software engineering tool
Anthropic accidentally released part of the internal source code for its AI-powered coding assistant, Claude Code, due to “human error”, the company said on Tuesday.An internal-use file mistakenly included in a software update pointed to an archive containing nearly 2,000 files and 500,000 lines of code, which were quickly copied to developer platform GitHub. A post on X sharing a link to the leaked code had more than 29m views early on Wednesday, and a rewritten version of the source code quickly became GitHub’s fastest-ever downloaded repository. Anthropic issued copyright takedown requests to try to contain the code’s spread. Within the code, users spotted blueprints for a Tamagotchi-esque coding assistant and an always-on AI agent, per the Verge
SpaceX confidentially files to go public at $1.75tn, reports say
SpaceX has confidentially filed for an initial public offering on the US stock market, according to reports from Bloomberg and the Wall Street Journal. The IPO is set to be one of the most closely watched and highly valued listings in market history.Elon Musk’s company, which has become a dominant power in both space travel and satellite communications, could potentially seek a valuation upwards of $1.75tn. The confidential filing will give regulators a period to review and discuss the company’s financial disclosures before investors and the public are able to view them
Rams star Puka Nacua in rehab amid claims of antisemitic remark and biting incident
Los Angeles Rams star Puka Nacua is in rehab and was there before he was sued by a woman who says he made an antisemitic statement and bit her on the shoulder, according to his attorney. “He was in [rehab] a substantial period of time before any of these allegations broke ... and he’s scheduled to be there for a while longer,” Levi McCathern told The California Post
‘From the ground up’ – How Black Country volunteers are tackling the highest levels of inactivity in England
“Being in nature and among the trees, getting some nice air and oxygen and exercise, that’s what clears the mind,” says Kelvin Gilkes, the human dynamo behind the Pendeford Community Bike Hub.A place where he fixes old and abandoned bicycles and helps people ride them, Kelvin also hopes his hub can expand horizons. “I’ve got one lady who has ADHD and she’s a big woman,” he says. “When she comes back from a ride, she’s so tired, she’s like: ‘Oh, my legs hurt.’ But she also says: ‘Oh, I slept really good
Oil price jumps and markets slide after Trump warning to Iran
US crude oil hits $110 a barrel and markets drop as Trump dashes Iran de-escalation hopes – as it happened
Goodbye mrbrightside416: Google allows users to alter quirky Gmail addresses
Pupils in England are losing their thinking skills because of AI, survey suggests
‘World is his oyster’: new Derbyshire home and mentor offer Shoaib Bashir fresh start
Weakened Leicester show why away sides need Champions Cup miracles