Foreign states should not be co-owners of UK newspapers | Nils Pratley
‘We are fully upholding the need to safeguard our news media from foreign state control while recognising that news organisations must be able to raise vital funding,” said Lisa Nandy, the culture secretary, alighting on 15% as the limit for foreign state ownership of a UK newspaper company.She is obviously right that it is harder for companies to raise money if a pool of potential capital – state-controlled sovereign wealth funds and their like – are off-limits.No wonder some media owners lobbied for a percentage higher than the 5% that was being considered by the previous government as a tweak to last year’s legislation that set the cap at zero.But she is naive if she thinks 15% will ensure “minimal risk” of foreign state influence.That is not how the world works: 15% is a hefty foot in the door.
A shareholder with a stake of that size will sometimes (and, in the case of listed companies, very often) be the largest on the register,The chair of an organisation cannot simply refuse to take the phone call,If Nandy truly believes 15% is too small to make a meaningful difference, she should consider two recent examples from the world beyond state actors and sovereign funds,At BP, a mere 5% investor, the US hedge fund Elliott Management, plainly had a role in encouraging the board to perform strategic somersaults on green investment,Yes, BP’s independent board ultimately took the decision itself.
But Elliott, as we saw, tried to define expectations, set a mood and generally be influential.There is also a non-state example from media-land itself – one where the objective was to secure an editorial safeguard.When the Scott Trust, the owner of this newspaper, sold the Observer to Tortoise Media last year, it took a stake in the post-deal entity to “enshrine our values in the new ownership structure”.The stake deemed sufficient to achieve that aim was 9% – not even double digits – albeit with a boardroom seat on top.Under Nandy’s plan, the secretary of state will have powers to intervene if there are reasonable grounds to suspect a State Owned Investor, as they are referred to in secondary legislation, has acquired the ability to control or influence a newspaper’s policy, for example by being given rights to appoint or remove directors.
That is slippery territory.From the point of view of an autocratic regime seeking influence from the shadows, it only needs to use its shareholder access to encourage the board to smile upon the right candidate for director.Plausible deniability would be maintained; the secretary of state would struggle to pin down “reasonable grounds”.Nandy’s decision has come after the Abu Dhabi-backed Redbird IMI vehicle was blocked from acquiring the Telegraph last year.The IMI part, which would have provided the majority of the funding, is controlled by Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed al-Nahyan, a vice-president of the United Arab Emirates.
Now, if parliament passes the legislation, the state-sponsored UAE entity will be able to own 15% in its own right.The outcome would be extraordinary when you consider the uproar that would follow if the UK government owned even a 1% stake in the Telegraph or any national paper.Soon a foreign state – even one as low in the World Press Freedom index as the UAE – may be able to own 15%.It is also extraordinary, as argued here at the time, that the Redbird IMI affair generated so little outrage in left-of-centre circles that normally (and rightly) deplore the lack of diverse ownership of our media and how control can be held by foreign owners.Wake up: you may not care about the Telegraph, or may even enjoy how it has been in ownership limbo, but you ought to be alarmed by the very idea of foreign states or their controlled entities being 15% co-owners of a UK media organisation.
The definition of an acceptable state stake should be zero if one is serious about protecting press freedom.At a push, 5% might be a workable fudge if the government feels compelled to accommodate the cuddlier sort of passive state investor, such as Norway’s sovereign fund.But 15% should be a non-starter.MPs should block the proposal.
Families of victims appalled as Boeing seems likely to avoid prosecution over 737 Max crashes
Boeing is set to avoid prosecution in a fraud case sparked by two fatal crashes of its bestselling 737 Max jet that killed 346 people, according to sources familiar with the matter.The US Department of Justice is considering a non-prosecution agreement, relatives of the victims were told on Friday, through which the US aerospace giant would not be required to plead guilty.Representatives of the crash victims’ families expressed outrage, describing the proposal as “morally repugnant” after a tense call with senior justice department officials.Boeing declined to comment. The justice department did not immediately respond to a request for comment
US consumer sentiment falls as tariffs drive up inflation fears; Number of UK billionaires drops – as it happened
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of business, the financial markets and the world economy.The number of British billionaires has fallen, as the super-rich are hit by stock market turbulence and the end of tax breaks for non-doms.The Sunday Times’s annual totting-up of Britain’s richest people, just published shows that the number of billionaires slid to 156 this year from 165 in 2024. That’s the sharpest decline in the Rich List’s 37-year-history.The Sunday Times reports that “falling fortunes” have led many to drop off the list, while others are no longer eligible, having “fled Britain after Labour’s non-dom crackdown”
Scattered Spider hackers in UK are ‘facilitating’ cyber-attacks, says Google
UK-based members of the Scattered Spider hacking community are actively “facilitating” cyber-attacks, according to Google, as disruption to British retailers spreads to the US.A group of hackers labelled “Scattered Spider” have been linked with attacks on UK retailers Marks & Spencer, the Co-op and Harrods, with Google cybersecurity experts warning this week that unnamed retailers across the Atlantic are being targeted as well.Charles Carmakal, the chief technology officer at Google’s Mandiant cybersecurity unit, said that the threat had moved to the US in a pattern typical of Scattered Spider assailants.“They tend to focus on a particular industry sector and geography for a few weeks and then they move on to something else,” he said. “And right now they’re focused on retail organisations
Elon Musk’s AI firm blames unauthorised change for chatbot’s rant about ‘white genocide’
Elon Musk’s artificial intelligence company has blamed an “unauthorised modification” for a glitch in its Grok chatbot that resulted in the tool ranting about “white genocide” in South Africa.In a post on Musk’s X platform, xAI said new measures would be brought in to ensure its employees cannot modify the bot’s behaviour without extra oversight.The Grok bot repeatedly referred to a white genocide in South Africa – a discredited claim promoted by Donald Trump among other US populist figures – this week in responses to unrelated queries.One user of Musk’s X platform, which also hosts Grok, asked the bot to identify the location of a photo of a walking path, triggering a non sequitur swerve into “South Africa’s farm attack debate”.xAI, the Musk-owned company that developed the chatbot, said in a post on X that the bot’s erratic behaviour was due to an unauthorised change made to the Grok bot’s system prompt, which guides a chatbot’s responses and actions
Rampant Knicks blow out Celtics to advance to first East finals since 2000
It didn’t take long for the New York Knicks to turn their biggest game in a quarter-century into a complete laugher on Friday night.Jalen Brunson and OG Anunoby scored 23 points apiece as the Knicks eliminated the defending champion Boston Celtics with a 119-81 beatdown in Game 6 of their Eastern Conference semi-final series, propelling New York into the last four of the NBA playoffs for the first time since 2000.The Knicks advance to meet the Indiana Pacers, the same team they faced in each of their previous three trips to the East finals in 1994, 1999 and 2000. Game 1 is Wednesday night in Manhattan.New York overcame a sloppy opening quarter to lead by as many as 41 points during a non-competitive second half in front of a rollicking, celebrity-flecked crowd that included Timothée Chalamet, Ben Stiller, Bad Bunny and Lenny Kravitz
US PGA Championship 2025: second round – as it happened
Thanks for reading today. A few shots still to be played before everything is wrapped up but no television pictures so we’ll bid farewell.Scott Murray will guide you through all the weekend action. Can Rory McIlroy repeat history? Will Bryson DeChambeau fire? Is Scottie Scheffler going to land a third major championship victory? Or are we due a surprise? Join Scott tomorrow to find out!The Venezuela player holds a two-shot advantage over the field, but Scottie Scheffler will be the man whose shadow looms darkest for the pace-setter.-8: Vegas (F) -6: Pavon (F), Fitzpatrick (F), SW Kim (F) -5: Homa (F), Scheffler (F) -4: Stevens, (F), MacIntyre (F), Poston (F), Smalley (F), Fox (F), Bezuidenhout (F), Thorbjornsen (F), McCarthy (F), Gerard (F), Higgo (17)Catch up with the day’s action with Ewan Murray’s report
Anglian Water fined record £1.42m for contaminating water supply
UK Peppa Pig toy firm says trading ‘uncertain’ as US-China shipments on hold
Lords examine new amendment to data bill to require AI firms declare use of copyrighted content
Australian girl, 11, sexually abused by stranger after adding him to get Snapchat points
Tyrrell Hatton faces fine for US PGA outburst as Vegas leads the pack
Brock Purdy reportedly agrees to $265m extension with San Francisco 49ers