Foreign states should not be co-owners of UK newspapers

Foreign states should not be co-owners of UK newspapers | Nils Pratley

1 day ago

‘We are fully upholding the need to safeguard our news media from foreign state control while recognising that news organisations must be able to raise vital funding,” said Lisa Nandy, the culture secretary, alighting on 15% as the limit for foreign state ownership of a UK newspaper company.She is obviously right that it is harder for companies to raise money if a pool of potential capital – state-controlled sovereign wealth funds and their like – are off-limits.No wonder some media owners lobbied for a percentage higher than the 5% that was being considered by the previous government as a tweak to last year’s legislation that set the cap at zero.But she is naive if she thinks 15% will ensure “minimal risk” of foreign state influence.That is not how the world works: 15% is a hefty foot in the door.

A shareholder with a stake of that size will sometimes (and, in the case of listed companies, very often) be the largest on the register.The chair of an organisation cannot simply refuse to take the phone call.If Nandy truly believes 15% is too small to make a meaningful difference, she should consider two recent examples from the world beyond state actors and sovereign funds.At BP, a mere 5% investor, the US hedge fund Elliott Management, plainly had a role in encouraging the board to perform strategic somersaults on green investment.Yes, BP’s independent board ultimately took the decision itself.

But Elliott, as we saw, tried to define expectations, set a mood and generally be influential.There is also a non-state example from media-land itself – one where the objective was to secure an editorial safeguard.When the Scott Trust, the owner of this newspaper, sold the Observer to Tortoise Media last year, it took a stake in the post-deal entity to “enshrine our values in the new ownership structure”.The stake deemed sufficient to achieve that aim was 9% – not even double digits – albeit with a boardroom seat on top.Under Nandy’s plan, the secretary of state will have powers to intervene if there are reasonable grounds to suspect a State Owned Investor, as they are referred to in secondary legislation, has acquired the ability to control or influence a newspaper’s policy, for example by being given rights to appoint or remove directors.

That is slippery territory,From the point of view of an autocratic regime seeking influence from the shadows, it only needs to use its shareholder access to encourage the board to smile upon the right candidate for director,Plausible deniability would be maintained; the secretary of state would struggle to pin down “reasonable grounds”,Nandy’s decision has come after the Abu Dhabi-backed Redbird IMI vehicle was blocked from acquiring the Telegraph last year,The IMI part, which would have provided the majority of the funding, is controlled by Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed al-Nahyan, a vice-president of the United Arab Emirates.

Now, if parliament passes the legislation, the state-sponsored UAE entity will be able to own 15% in its own right.The outcome would be extraordinary when you consider the uproar that would follow if the UK government owned even a 1% stake in the Telegraph or any national paper.Soon a foreign state – even one as low in the World Press Freedom index as the UAE – may be able to own 15%.It is also extraordinary, as argued here at the time, that the Redbird IMI affair generated so little outrage in left-of-centre circles that normally (and rightly) deplore the lack of diverse ownership of our media and how control can be held by foreign owners.Wake up: you may not care about the Telegraph, or may even enjoy how it has been in ownership limbo, but you ought to be alarmed by the very idea of foreign states or their controlled entities being 15% co-owners of a UK media organisation.

The definition of an acceptable state stake should be zero if one is serious about protecting press freedom.At a push, 5% might be a workable fudge if the government feels compelled to accommodate the cuddlier sort of passive state investor, such as Norway’s sovereign fund.But 15% should be a non-starter.MPs should block the proposal.

foodSee all

Rachel Roddy’s recipe for courgette, onion and chickpea flour bake, or scarpaccia | A kitchen in Rome

Like millions of people all over the world, ideas are often planted in my head by a couple called Alessandro Vitale and Iasmina P, whose fast-paced videos document recipes they have developed based on the vegetables they grow, with the objective of using absolutely everything. Edited for social media, their videos are designed not just to attract, but to trap attention in a TikTok spell, then communicate a rush of information in a matter of seconds. However, within the well-calculated rush of decisive movements and fishbowl close-ups, Alessandro (otherwise known as Spicy Moustache) is a hugely likable, calm and good teacher.For months now, his enthusiastic and entertaining approach to a vegetable or process has sent me into the kitchen to grate something and rub it with salt, to turn into a fritter or cake. “Such a vivid thing for us today,” is what Jane Grigson said about the ideas of Giacomo Castelvetro, the 16th-century proponent of vegetables and author of The Fruit, Herbs and Vegetables of Italy (1614), and I think the same can be said about Alessandro

2 days ago

How to turn old bread into a classic Portuguese soup – recipe

Today’s punchy and bright-green garlic and coriander soup is an intriguing Portuguese way to use up stale bread. The recipe is adapted from the traditional açorda of Alentejo, where it’s thought of as the region’s signature dish. Açorda is said to have been born from necessity, a waste-saving and resourceful soup that’s transformed by olive oil, plentiful herbs and rich egg. I find this take on it particularly interesting because, instead of simmering the coriander, garlic and egg in hot broth, they are instead put in a bowl and the broth is poured over them. This enhances the powerful flavours of the garlic and coriander, and the whole lot is then ladled over stale bread

3 days ago

Chilli oil udon and salmon salad: Justin Tsang’s speedy noodle recipes for one

At this time of year, I find myself swaying towards lighter meals and bolder flavours, and especially recipes that include a ton of herbs, citrus and spice. Noodles are my go-to theme in the warmer months, and for good reason: they’re super-versatile, can be eaten hot or cold, and they soak up flavours like a sponge. These recipes for one are also speedy, low-fuss and involve minimal cooking – perfect for maximising your time outdoors.These are inspired by my travels across China and its love for all things spicy noodles. A perfectly balanced sauce made with soy, vinegar and herbs means these salty, sweet, sour and spicy noodles are incredibly addictive

3 days ago

The cardamom conundrum: what’s the difference between green and black pods? | Kitchen aide

What’s the difference between green and black cardamom, and when should I use pods or ground? “Cardamom is my favourite spice,” says Cynthia Shanmugalingam, chef/proprietor of Rambutan in London. “It smells like childhood puddings and sweets.” That’s not to say the papery pods filled with black seeds aren’t versatile, mind. Yes, cardamom can bring a “piney, eucalyptus-like fragrance and warmth” to desserts, Shanmugalingam adds, but it also “adds depth” to savoury dishes, meaning you can take it in multiple directions.With its origins in southern India and a relative of ginger, cardamom pods commonly come in green and black (also known as brown) form, as well as red (used mainly in Chinese and Asian cuisines) and white, which are bleached green pods

4 days ago

Rukmini Iyer’s quick and easy recipe for soy and peanut trout with smashed cucumber, radishes and beans | Quick and easy

This is a lovely, light dinner, featuring honey- and soy-dressed peanut trout alongside a crunchy smashed cucumber and radish salad. With cannellini beans also tossed through the salad, you’ll be hard pressed to notice that this is also a low-carb meal.Salting the cucumber helps to get rid of the excess water, and improves the texture no end.Prep 15 min Cook 20 min Serves 22 trout fillets 30g peanuts, roughly chopped30ml soy sauce25g tsp honey 1 large cucumber, cut into 1⅓cm-thick rounds1 tsp sea salt flakes15ml sesame oil Juice of 1 lime (30ml)½ tsp chilli flakes Salt 150g radishes, trimmed and quartered400g tin cannellini beans, drainedHeat the oven to 180C (160C fan)/350F/gas 4. Put the trout fillets in a small, lined baking dish, ideally one small enough to hold them fairly snugly

5 days ago

Elly Curshen’s quick weeknight recipes for using up leftover greens, bread and vegetables

These are all about taking the spoils of the weekend, whether that’s leftovers from Sunday lunch, the bits you couldn’t finish from a takeaway or the last scraps from a party spread, and stretching them out to make joyous weekday lunches. I’m concentrating on ideas, rather than recipes as such, because using up the odds and ends from the fridge needs to be part of the flow of your cooking to avoid waste. Everything is quick, easy, involves minimal prep and, crucially, is endlessly open to adaptation. Prep 5 minCook 15 min Serves 11 medium egg Leftover naan or roti, or frozen paratha cooked from frozen in a dry frying pan for a couple of minutes1 spring onion and/or fresh herbs – coriander is perfect Chutney, such as mango, raita, mint, lime pickle Chilli crisp – I like LaoganmaBring a small pan of water to a boil, then add the egg and set a timer for six and a half minutes. (To save time, boil and peel a few eggs, then keep them in a sealed container in the fridge, where they’ll be fine for three days

5 days ago

sportSee all