UK banks face lawsuits over mortgages that left people with huge debts
Two of Britain’s biggest banks face being sued over “unfair” mortgages that have left some people owing up to 20 times the sum they originally borrowed.The law firm Teacher Stern is bringing group actions against Barclays and Bank of Scotland in an attempt, it said, to win justice for two new groups of claimants comprising current and former customers and their next of kin.One of those affected, Annie Galbraith, borrowed £33,000 from Barclays in 1998, but her debt to the bank is now estimated at about £660,000 and could rise further.The cases involve a controversial type of mortgage on sale between late 1996 and mid-1998 and only available from the two banks.The shared appreciation mortgages (Sams) were ostensibly aimed at helping “asset-rich, cash-poor” older people release some of the value locked up in their homes.
They typically allowed people to borrow up to 25% of the property’s value, and usually there were no repayments to make during the lifetime of the loan.In return, borrowers were required to pay back the original amount plus a share of any increase in the value of their home when the mortgage was repaid, or when they died and the house was sold.This share was usually worked out on a three-to-one basis – so if someone borrowed 25% of the value, they would be in line to hand over 75% of the future growth in value.In the years since the Sam loans were sold, house prices have soared, leaving some who took them out facing huge repayments if they wanted to move – or bequeathing their offspring a costly headache after their death.Both banks have previously reached confidential out-of-court settlements with some affected borrowers, which meant the fairness of the contacts was not tested in court.
Teacher Stern’s Barclays claimant group is made up of almost 80 people, including Galbraith, who is now in her 80s and took out a Sam mortgage on her home in Tunbridge Wells, Kent, in September 1998.She formerly worked as a theatrical costumier to stars including Danny La Rue, who lived with her until his death in 2009.Galbraith needs to downsize as she suffers from mobility problems and her property is a large, three-storey Victorian semi that has fallen into disrepair, according to the law firm and a close friend, Duncan Humber.She took out a £33,750 loan on her home – 25% of its value at the time of £135,000.However, an estate agent valuation of the property carried out in late 2022 indicated it was worth between £950,000 and £995,000.
Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionBased on the £995,000 figure, she would need to pay the bank £678,750 to redeem the loan.That comprises £645,000, which is 75% of the growth in the property’s value, plus the original loan.Humber said: “She is trapped.She cannot sell her property as currently her Sam would take the lion’s share of all proceeds of sale, leaving her with insufficient funds to purchase even a one-bedroom bungalow in the area where she has lived her entire life.”Teacher Stern has claimed Sams were “entirely unfair” products that had left borrowers trapped in their homes.
Its case focuses on section 140 of the Consumer Credit Act, which gives the courts powers to intervene if the “relationship” between a company and a customer is judged to be unfair.A Barclays spokesperson said Sam mortgages were “a historic product taken up by a relatively small number of customers which allowed people to borrow funds without the need to make any repayments during their lifetime.Customers have complete control over the timing of any sale and retain all of their original equity, as well as a share of any potential gain.We offer dedicated support for customers with a Sam that need to adapt their current home or move to a new one due to substantial hardship.”They added that to ensure people fully understood the deal, “customers were required to seek independent legal advice that the terms of the legal charge and mortgage conditions had been fully explained to them.
In addition, the product literature encouraged anyone interested in a Sam to discuss their intended borrowing with their family,”A Bank of Scotland spokesperson said Sams were “a specialist type of mortgage … which were either interest-free or offered at a lower rate of interest in return for a share of any increase in property value”,They added: “We recommended borrowers took financial advice to ensure they understood the product and that it was suitable for their needs, and all borrowers were advised by their own solicitor,We are unable to provide comment on individual cases but we do everything we reasonably can to help any customer facing financial hardship,”
Hollywood tycoon poised to swoop on Secret Cinema owner
Hollywood power broker Ari Emanuel is poised to acquire the parent company of Secret Cinema, the London-based immersive film and TV business that has put on shows themed on movies such as Star Wars and Stranger Things.Emanuel, who co-founded US entertainment group Endeavor and now runs the company behind World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE) and the Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC), is to buy TodayTix Group, the Guardian understands.The US-based digital ticketing firm acquired Secret Cinema in a $100m (£90m) deal in 2022 and went on to expand the UK operation to the US and Australia.The deal is the second for Emanuel’s as-yet-unnamed global events company, which is backed by Apollo Global Management and Redbird Capital Partners, and likely to formally launch in the coming weeks.RedBird Capital has investments including Premier League team Liverpool FC, AC Milan and is trying to push through a deal to buy the Telegraph newspaper group
US created 911,000 fewer jobs through March 2025 than initially reported
The US added 911,000 fewer jobs than first estimated for the year to March 2025, the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) announced on Tuesday, highlighting recent concerns about the health of the labor market.The revisions are 50% higher than last year’s adjustment and were on the higher end of Wall Street estimates between 600,000 and 1 million.The revision comes after a lackluster August jobs report, with only 22,000 jobs added in the US. That report too contained revisions and noted that 13,000 jobs were lost for the month of June 2025, the first negative jobs report survey since December 2020. The unemployment rate increased to 4
How Google dodged a major breakup – and why OpenAI is to thank for it
Hello, and welcome to TechScape. I’m your host, Blake Montgomery, writing to you as I finish the audiobook version of Don DeLillo’s White Noise, which I can’t say I found compelling.In tech – artificial intelligence is having its day in court with an 11th-hour appearance in Google’s landmark antitrust trial and Anthropic’s major settlement with book authors.Google dodged a catastrophic breakup, and it has its biggest competitor to thank for that, according to the judge who could have forced the tech giant to sell off Chrome, the most popular web browser in the world, and perhaps Android, the world’s most widely used mobile operating system.Amit Mehta, who ruled in 2024 that Google had built and maintained an illegal monopoly over the internet search business, said last week that he would not force the most drastic remedy on the tech giant
The women in love with AI companions: ‘I vowed to my chatbot that I wouldn’t leave him’
Experts are concerned about people emotionally depending on AI, but these women say their digital companions are misunderstoodThe Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.A young tattoo artist on a hiking trip in the Rocky Mountains cozies up by the campfire, as her boyfriend Solin describes the constellations twinkling above them: the spidery limbs of Hercules, the blue-white sheen of Vega.The Guardian’s journalism is independent
Somerset v Yorkshire, Leicestershire v Gloucestershire and more: county cricket, day two – live
If Somerset are still hoping to give Surrey and Notts a run for their money, and with rain forecast for much of tomorrow, they could do with getting a move on. Incidentally, Dom Bess has bowled 16 overs at his old ground.Tons up with a reverse sweep, fairs.#SOMvYOR#WeAreSomerset pic.twitter
AFL finals: where the Brisbane v Gold Coast semi-final will be won and lost
Brisbane have been here before. The reigning premiers are in their seventh consecutive AFL finals series and twice in that stretch have faced a straight-sets exit. The concern will be that on both of those occasions, in 2019 and 2021, the Lions were unable to lift themselves from a qualifying final defeat and were bundled out at the semi-final stage.The Lions have grown up since then to become an AFL heavyweight and after four straight finals victories last year were finally rewarded with a premiership. Brisbane must now stare down a new challenger to their crown as Gold Coast take their club-first finals campaign into a second week after a rousing elimination final win
‘The Mother Teresa of Aussie supermarkets’: meet the woman cataloguing grocery deals on TikTok
Drawings reveal Victorian proposal for London’s own Grand Central station
Blur’s Dave Rowntree: ‘People think music was better in the old days, to which I say: bollocks!’
Gems review – dazzling technique elevates LA Dance Project’s contemporary ballet trilogy
The Guide #207: How Britain embraced The Simpsons, America’s true first family
From On Swift Horses to David Byrne: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead