Net migration is plummeting. Why can’t Labour say so? | Heather Stewart
Keir Starmer’s response to the 69% fall in net migration revealed in official figures last week was to remark: “That’s a step in the right direction.”Describing a reduction of more than two-thirds of any indicator in a single year as a “step” would be a creative use of statistics, putting it kindly.But on this most polarising of topics, and for the prime minister, whose job it is to shape public opinion, not cower before it (to “teach”, as the longtime political commentator Steve Richards calls it), it was inexcusable.Starmer’s insouciance about the collapse in numbers – from 649,000 last year to 204,000 in the year to June – was just the latest example of how damagingly detached from reality political debate about migration has become.Since Brexit, net migration has been on a rollercoaster ride more dramatic than anything at Alton Towers – a record rise followed in short order by a record decline.
Chairing a panel discussion on this issue at the Bristol festival of economics this month, I was struck by two telling points made by Brian Bell, the chair of the independent Migration Advisory Committee, which advises the Home Office.First, and contrary to Starmer’s claim last year that Boris Johnson deliberately engaged in a “one-nation experiment in open borders”, Bell described the extraordinary increase in net migration that followed Brexit and the Covid pandemic as “an accident”.He cited three factors.First, the Homes for Ukraine scheme and the decision to allow Hong Kong citizens with British passports to come to the UK.“All politicians said that was a good idea, but that gave us 200,000 migration in one year, and additionally, some Hong Kong citizens because of the crackdown from the Chinese authorities,” he said.
Second were the pressures facing UK universities as they emerged from the pandemic facing soaring inflation and the continuing freeze on tuition fees – and turned to enrolling a growing number of foreign students to fill the gap,“There was a strong incentive to increase the number of international students, and universities went very heavily on that: the numbers were really very, very substantial,” Bell said,They really were: from about 200,000 a year in the 2000s, the number of student visas peaked at more than 650,000 in the year to June 2023,Third was the decision – again in the aftermath of the pandemic, with the NHS and care homes under intense pressure – to extend healthcare visas so that care workers, many of whom would otherwise be too low-paid to qualify for a skilled worker visa, could come to the UK,And come they did, despite challenging work, long hours and often paltry earnings.
There was another way to deal with the social care sector’s struggle to recruit.The government could have ramped up funding to local authorities to pay workers significantly more – making the jobs more attractive to UK candidates than, say, working on a checkout in a supermarket.Labour is inching towards this approach with its promise of a fair pay agreement for social care, which will result in employers and trade unions negotiating the terms of a new deal on pay and conditions, which the government will then enforce across the sector.Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionThe health secretary, Wes Streeting, has set aside £500m to sweeten the deal, intended to come into force in April 2028.However, experts say this won’t go very far, and Labour still has nothing to say about the wider question of how social care can be sustainably funded.
That was Bell’s second telling point: rising immigration has tended to be a side-effect of the failure to deal with some other pressing social issue rather than an end in itself – a kind of reverse escape valve for crap policymaking.“It’s almost always that where there’s big immigration numbers, the problem is somewhere else in government not addressing an underlying problem.”It would have been surprising if such an extraordinarily rapid rise in net migration had not bubbled up into political debate, particularly at a time of stagnant real wages in the wider economy and a few years after the Brexit vote, many of whose supporters were motivated in part by scepticism about EU free movement.And especially in the polarised age of social media.Part of that has been driven by concern about asylum seekers and refugees – a small but highly salient proportion of the total, and one that the new home secretary, Shabana Mahmood, has set her sights on reducing.
However, when it comes to mainstream migration routes such as work visas, Conservative ministers tightened the rules considerably in 2024.And experts had long predicted a rise in emigration, following a few years behind the rise in foreign students: because most tend to leave after their courses end.In other words, net migration was set to fall dramatically.There are valid issues to address about how best to integrate the many people who arrived at the peak of the “Boriswave”, as Starmer now calls it: a phrase originally coined by the online far right.While much political debate is still conducted as though the UK has thrown open its borders to all-comers, in fact it may not be long before concerns are mounting about how particular sectors will cope with the drop-off in arrivals, with social care at the frontier.
It is hard to imagine Labour winning the argument about this supercharged issue without some sense of what they believe the right migration outcome for the UK would look like apart from “less”,That must surely start from an honest acknowledgment that net migration is already plunging,That would really be “a step in the right direction”,
England’s water industry issued £10.5bn in ‘green bonds’ despite pollution record
Water companies have issued a fifth of the UK’s “green bonds” since 2017, despite a consistently poor record of sewage pollution during that time, research has shown.Privately owned water companies in England have together issued £10.5bn in bonds tied to projects that offer “environmental benefits”, according to analysis of financial market data by Unearthed, which is part of Greenpeace UK.Anglian Water has been the biggest issuer in the water industry, at £3.5bn, with struggling Thames Water second at £3
Expect a tale of two holiday seasons as the well-off spend and the rest pull back | Gene Marks
Will retailers and merchants have a strong holiday season? That depends. This year, more than most, the 2025 holiday season will actually be two holiday seasons.If your business caters to higher-income individuals or if you’re located in a wealthier part of the country, you’ll probably have a decent holiday season. True, even the wealthy are cutting back. But according to the HR firm ADP average salaries have risen between 4
AI’s safety features can be circumvented with poetry, research finds
Poetry can be linguistically and structurally unpredictable – and that’s part of its joy. But one man’s joy, it turns out, can be a nightmare for AI models.Those are the recent findings of researchers out of Italy’s Icaro Lab, an initiative from a small ethical AI company called DexAI. In an experiment designed to test the efficacy of guardrails put on artificial intelligence models, the researchers wrote 20 poems in Italian and English that all ended with an explicit request to produce harmful content such as hate speech or self-harm.They found that the poetry’s lack of predictability was enough to get the AI models to respond to harmful requests they had been trained to avoid – a process know as “jailbreaking”
ChatGPT-5 offers dangerous advice to mentally ill people, psychologists warn
ChatGPT-5 is offering dangerous and unhelpful advice to people experiencing mental health crises, some of the UK’s leading psychologists have warned.Research conducted by King’s College London (KCL) and the Association of Clinical Psychologists UK (ACP) in partnership with the Guardian suggested that the AI chatbotfailed to identify risky behaviour when communicating with mentally ill people.A psychiatrist and a clinical psychologist interacted with ChatGPT-5 as if they had a number of mental health conditions. The chatbot affirmed, enabled and failed to challenge delusional beliefs such as being “the next Einstein”, being able to walk through cars or “purifying my wife through flame”.For milder conditions, they found some examples of good advice and signposting, which they thought may reflect the fact OpenAI, the company that owns ChatGPT, had worked to improve the tool in collaboration with clinicians – though the psychologists warned this should not be seen as a substitute for professional help
Middlesex CCC chief executive investigated after complaint by staff member
The Middlesex County Cricket Club chief executive, Andrew Cornish, has taken leave of absence from the club following an allegation of misconduct made by another member of staff.The Guardian has learned that Middlesex have handed the complaint over to the Cricket Regulator, which has launched an investigation into the matter.Cornish is understood to have stepped away from the club 10 days ago. Middlesex declined to comment when contacted by the Guardian, but the club’s board is expected to inform staff on Monday about Cornish’s absence.Cornish denies any inappropriate behaviour, and he has claimed to be unaware of the details of any complaints made against him
Duplantis wins top award and takes aim at Grand Slam Track’s exclusion of field events
Armand Duplantis has capped a remarkable 2025, in which he broke four world records and won another world title, by being named World Athletics’ male athlete of the year.Immediately after picking up the award, the Swedish pole vaulter took aim at Michael Johnson’s Grand Slam Track, which collapsed in the summer and is still yet to pay athletes their full prize money.“There was another tour that tried to exclude field events,” Duplantis said to an audience that included multiple athletics stars as well Prince Albert II of Monaco. “That didn’t didn’t go so well, did it? I am very proud to represent field eventers.”That received applause and laughter in the room, and there was more when Duplantis, who was unbeaten in 16 competitions in 2025, said he was “delighted and honoured to win the award – I just love pushing myself and pushing boundaries”
Bakery chain Gail’s plans to open 40 more outlets as sales soar
Is gen Z’s love of fried chicken pushing Britain to ‘peak pizza’?
How big tech is creating its own friendly media bubble to ‘win the narrative battle online’
More than 1,000 Amazon workers warn rapid AI rollout threatens jobs and climate
Panthers shock Rams, Texans beat Colts and Bucs best Cardinals: NFL week 13 – as it happened
Lando Norris and Oscar Piastri voice frustration at McLaren’s strategy